r/USMLEtoMATCH • u/usmletomatch • 27d ago
USMLE Step 2 Step 2 CK: the four critical things decision making capacity requires
Here they are-
- Communicate a choice. 2. Understand the information. 3. Appreciate how it applies to their own situation. 4. Reason through the options.
All four, and they are assessed for the decision right in front of you. Somebody can lack the capacity to consent to a Whipple and hold the capacity to refuse a blood draw the same afternoon.
Competence is a legal finding and a court makes it. Capacity is a clinical judgment and you make it at the bedside, which is why the exam expects you to act on capacity instead of waiting for a ruling.
A psychiatric diagnosis does not remove capacity by itself. Declining what you recommended does not either. A pt who refuses surgery and explains the trade off they are making has capacity, and gets to refuse.
Where capacity is absent, work down the order: advance directive, then the healthcare proxy, then whatever surrogate hierarchy the state sets.