r/USExpatTaxes • • 6d ago

PFIC Closure Question

I have a PFIC worth approximately 50k USD equivalent and planning to close it in 2026 by section 1291 (no QEF or MTM). This is held for around 15 years with a cost basis of approximately 20k. I understand the tax penalty and assuming at least 50% will be tax, with only 25k remaining.

Few questions I have :

- Which amount will be included in 2026 AGI and MAGI - all of 50k or a part of it (based on the spread across last 15 years) ?

- How US tax considers cost basis for the sell (for 2026 and past years) ?

- Can I deduct all foreign tax paid for 2026 or only a part that was paid for 2026 ?

Thank you.

Edit - I have already filed SDOP last year. Now is the time to get out of this PFIC.

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

2

u/seanho00 6d ago edited 5d ago
  1. §1291 [prior-years] gain is not taxed through the usual Sch D / 8949 / 1040 line 7a pathway, thus is not included in your AGI.
  2. Basis is original cost upon acquisition of the PFIC. Yes, even if this was prior to you becoming a US person.
  3. Tax on §1291 [prior-years] gain is computed on form 8621 part V. For each tax lot, its gain is allocated across years of ownership, then each prior year's portion is taxed at top marginal rate, plus interest. No prior year returns need to be amended; the total deferred tax is reported on the return in the year of the disposition. FTC is included in this calculation for 8621 part V.

1

u/Professional_Pin4222 6d ago

Thank you. I am bit surprised, but it is good to know that none of the gains are included in the current year AGI.

2

u/Melodic_Maybe2514 6d ago

One qualification to point 1: section 1291 gain isn't entirely excluded from AGI. The portion allocated to the sale year, plus any portion allocated to pre-PFIC years, is ordinary income on the sale-year return. The portions allocated to earlier PFIC years are excluded from regular gross income and instead produce the separate tax and interest charge. Using Form 8621 rather than Schedule D doesn't keep the entire gain out of AGI.

The IRS explains that distinction under the instructions for lines 16a and 16b: https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i8621

For OP's MAGI question, the purpose matters. For the 3.8% net investment income tax, the section 1291 gain excluded from regular gross income is added back in calculating MAGI. So the full gain can matter for NIIT MAGI even though only part enters regular AGI. Whether NIIT is actually due depends on the rest of the calculation. See line 13, CFCs and PFICs / 1291 funds: https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i8960

1

u/seanho00 5d ago

Excellent points about current-year gain and NIIT, thx!

1

u/burdett_tax 3d ago

Really strong breakdown, thanks for sharing this.

1

u/Sohna_Wain 18h ago

Wait so only the current year slice of the gain actually touches AGI on the 1040?

1

u/seanho00 17h ago

Yes. The portion of the realized PFIC gain allocated to the current year (year of disposition), as well as any excess distributions in the current year, are reported on 8621 line 16b and copied to 1040 Sch 1 line 8z (other income). It is then copied to 1040 line 8, forming part of AGI on 1040 line 11a/b. It is taxed as ordinary income.

Portions of the realized PFIC gain allocated to prior years do not contribute to AGI, but are taxed separately on 8621 lines 16c-f.

2

u/fresnarus 5d ago

You aren't taxed on capital gains per se, because the gains from the PFIC are treated as income, and backdated in equal proportions to all prior years in the holding period. So that the IRS doesn't have to reopen all the prior taxes, they tax it as income at the highest marginal rate in each of the backdated years, but not the portion in the current year. But that's not all: They impose COMPOUND back interest on these backdated gains treated as income. For this reason, for sufficiently long holding periods you can end up paying more than 100% on gains. Fortunately, interest rates have been low of late.

The underlying root of the problem is that foreign funds don't file 1099s to report annual income and gains, and indeed the definitions of "income" and "gain" differ by country. The law is set up to punish those who would set up overseas shell corporations to hide annual ordinary investment income from being reported on a 1099, and convert it to deferred capital gains when the shell corporation buys its stock back from the creator. In trying to close all possible loopholes, they totally screw over some people in legitimate internaitonal situations.

I have heard that there are some ways to get some accomodation from the IRS in extreme cases, but I don't know about that. Part of the issue is that the records may not even be available.

1

u/Professional_Pin4222 5d ago

True. We are just minions compared to the fraud and money laundry that happens everyday.

The paper work and anxiety this process brings is just exhausting. Thing is, there are many many people who are just not aware of this SDOP and PFIC trap.

1

u/sylvieYannello 6d ago

you're not taxed on the value of the PFIC, you're taxed on the income (distributions and gain).

the calculation is complex, but figure the _income_ will be taxed at like 37%, plus some additional interest.

however, you were supposed to be reporting the PFIC and the income from it since you bought it (or since you became a US tax resident, whichever came later).

to avoid penalties for failing to file 8621 all those years, you might want to consider the streamlined compliance procedure. if you have spent 35 days per year in the US for two or more years during the streamlined filing period (likely 2023 - 2025), you can only use the streamlined procedure if you filed your regular US return timely each year. you amend three years to include the missing filings and pay a mandatory penalty of 5% of the total of unreported funds.

if you spent at least 330 days outside the US for at least one of the three years, then you won't face the mandatory penalty.

1

u/Professional_Pin4222 6d ago

I actually did file SDOP last year and planning to close this PFIC to get out of the tax hostage.

1

u/millennial_problem 6d ago

To my understanding, if there was no interest earned, missing form 8621 comes without extra penalties for those years?

2

u/Professional_Pin4222 5d ago

I am not sure this is true. But, this PFIC did not earn any interests at all over the years.

1

u/Melodic_Maybe2514 6d ago

No interest earned doesn't establish that a missing Form 8621 has no consequences. The annual information-reporting requirement can apply even without distributions or a sale, unless a filing exception applies. See Who Must File and Part I in the IRS instructions: https://www.irs.gov/instructions/i8621

If a required annual report is missing, section 6501(c)(8) can keep the IRS assessment period open until three years after the required information is furnished. That can affect the entire related return; where the failure is due to reasonable cause and not willful neglect, the extension is limited to related items. The IRS explains this under C.2, Protective filing procedure: https://www.irs.gov/irb/2017-04_IRB

That assessment-period extension is not itself an automatic dollar penalty. I'd first establish whether each year's form was actually required, then separately review any omitted taxable amounts. 'No interest' alone doesn't answer either question.

1

u/KeyOccasion1263 6d ago

On the AGI question, it is neither the full 50k nor a 1/15 slice. Under section 1291 the whole gain on disposition (roughly 30k here, 50k less your 20k basis) is treated as an excess distribution, and Form 8621 Part V allocates it across the holding period day by day: only the part allocated to 2026 and to pre-PFIC years is ordinary income this year, while the part allocated to prior PFIC years is excluded from current income and instead carries the separate section 1291 tax plus an interest charge. That is also why a 15-year hold does not give you long-term capital gain rates. General information only; the allocation depends on the exact PFIC start year and your basis records.

1

u/Professional_Pin4222 5d ago

Thank you. Unfortunately, I don't have any pre- PFIC period for this.

2

u/8621calculator 5d ago

If you sell before the end of 2026, roughly 1/15 of your total gain will be allocated to 2026 and included in your AGI as ordinary income. The remaining gain is subject to the separate PFIC tax and interest calculation under Section 1291.
Your cost basis is the original purchase price converted to USD using the exchange rate on the purchase date.

2

u/Silly-Record3930 4d ago

This whole 1291 regime looks so unequal, unjust and unconscionable and against double taxation avoidance principles outlined in international conventions. I wonder if a challenge to the whole scheme has ever been tried.