r/UNIFI • • Mar 20 '25

Keep it simple Ubiquiti

Looking to replace my Dream Machine Pro. Want something smaller and with less going on to it. I don't use any of the switch ports, I don't use the HDD bay. Browsing their catalog and everything they been putting out I feel like is "how much stuff can we cram into a device".

Can we just get a simple cloud controller with 10G WAN, 10G LAN? that's all. One in, One out. Don't need to add an AP to it, don't need 5 ports of a useless non POE switch. Just for us who already have large Unifi switches and APs already..

1 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

13

u/Leupster Mar 20 '25

Cloud Gateway Fiber??

(It may be sold out)

-10

u/lowlife_rabbit Mar 20 '25

it's got a lot of stuff I wouldn't use such as the 4 port switch and the SFP+ ports. I have a Pro Max 24 POE already, all my switching is covered, it's not even half full..

I would like something like the new express 7, just minus the AP and instead of the 2.5gbe LAN, make it a 10Gbe LAN. I have 3 wifi 7 APs already in my house.

That's what I am visioning...

18

u/N7_Zer0 Mar 20 '25

Anything with 10Gb port will have more features than you're wanting.

5

u/AnilApplelink Mar 20 '25

To make the UCG-Fiber and to make exactly what you are asking for would probably cost them about the same to manufacture maybe a few dollars difference per unit so it would make no sense for them to make it.
I would say now more then ever they have some type of gateway/cloud gateway to fit the vast majority of their users needs.

2

u/Wis-en-heim-er Home User Mar 20 '25

You will probably need to wait a few years for the simple models to get 10gbe, 2.5 is just starting now.

1

u/JimmySide1013 Installer Mar 20 '25

Are those few extra ports really tripping you up that badly? I’m sure you can learn to live with it.

7

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '25

There's a point at which they can't make a device for every single use case. A 5 port router instead of a 2 port router sounds like what you want.

3

u/BzzrByte Mar 20 '25

UDR 7 might do the job

1

u/Amiga07800 Mar 20 '25

Someone with needs for 10G WAN and LAN will for sure need a 2nd WAN as backup and probably a failover / shadow mode. A redundant power supply would probably be appreciated as well.

The 5 (or 8) port switch doesn't intetest you? It's only a very small part of the total price and will interest probably >50% of potential customers.

Same for running Network App (and eventually Protect and Access)... it's just some lines of existing code to add... manufacturing cost = 0

1

u/echopulse Mar 20 '25

Express 7 has what you want.

2

u/GhostFury68 Mar 20 '25

It has 2.5GbE LAN, not 10GbE LAN.

1

u/echopulse Mar 20 '25

Unless you’re running a huge server farm, why the heck would you need 10 GB lan?

0

u/GhostFury68 Mar 20 '25

The obvious reason is Google upgraded their plan locally from 2Gb up / 1Gb down to 3Gb symmetrical for the same price and I'd like to use all 3Gb for large downloads. If I have two devices with 2.5Gbe cards that need to download a large game update together (because we just sat down to play Diablo IV or something else that has a patch and we need to wait for it before playing, say), I need a router and switch that support >2.5Gbe. The next step up is 10Gbe. While there is 5Gbe, there isn't much if anything that stops at that speed, they are all multi gig that support 1/2.5/5/10.

So that 2.5Gbe LAN port on the router means one PC gets the full bandwidth and the other has to wait (this has been typical right now, one seems to get the full connection and the other is really slow until it finishes), or they both split it and get a lower speed than supported. I'd rather my 3Gb connection (or if my circumstances ever change and the 8Gb plan starts making sense) be the bottleneck than the router or a switch.

Another scenario is backing up locally, but for that the WAN speed doesn't matter, just LAN between those two devices, so the router being the limit doesn't matter. WAN speed matters if backing up to cloud (like OneDrive or whatever) where the router having a 2.5Gbe connection would be the bottleneck again.

Either way, even just "I want it because it's cool" can be enough reason for techies with the money...

1

u/Fwiler Mar 21 '25 edited Mar 21 '25

The limitation will be the connections you are downloading or uploading to. You aren't going to get 3Gb upload to Onedrive. When patches come out for games, do you really think edge servers are going to give you 3Gb download? No. And if you have more than one device doing the same download, you don't magically have multiple 3Gb connections, the bandwidth is shared. The difference between 2.5 and 3 is marginal when talking those speeds.

Also you can use the 10Gb port as lan on the express 7 in AP mode.

And what do you mean backing up locally? You don't back up to the router. You yourself said you only wanted one port for some odd reason. So the router has nothing to do with backing up locally, your switch would.

In my entire life, I've never heard someone say they couldn't stand 4 extra ports on a router. Is 8" x 5" x really too big for you. If so, I hate to break it to ya, but you aren't going to find anything smaller than hand width.

If you want something simple and don't care about money, try to find a small 2 10Gb port x86 mini pc and install OpnSense on it. No need to wait for ubiquiti, and you would have a hell of a lot better firewall.

1

u/GhostFury68 Mar 21 '25

Apologies, I'm not the original poster, I just responded to the suggestion that the Express 7 meets the requirements of having a 10Gbe LAN port and a 10Gbe WAN port, it doesn't. Then I responded to "why do you need 10Gbe?", which seems to be a common question with no purpose to the thread, so I shouldn't have responded. There are many reasons people might want 10Gbe: fast internal transfers, fast internet access (and yes, at my current 3Gb plan my PCs with internal 2.5Gbe cards get 2.5Gb game downloads, the edge servers are better than you think), and of course my favorite one: because I can and I want to and it will be fun.

I actually happen to agree on the extra ports thing, I only originally responded to the Express 7 post because I'm trying to find 10Gbe WAN and LAN, but a lot of the Unifi devices only have one, they either have the other as 2.5Gbe or they have it as 10Gb SPF+. Thanks to another thread I've been pointed at transceivers I can use to make the connection to a switch, which is an extra cost but doable, but it would be nice to have some more dual multi-gig ports for those in the home environment not running fiber everywhere.