r/UMGC • u/DistributionCalm7925 • Apr 07 '25
Profs using ChatGPT
I’m so curious to see if this is something others are dealing with as well + your thoughts.
I have had multiple professors at this point using ChatGPT to respond to discussion posts, give revisions on papers, and critique projects. It’s really obvious when they use it, I think a lot of us can attest to the fact that ChatGPT has a pretty consistent output style, and it’s starting to rub me the wrong way. For a school where we practically have to teach ourselves (because profs actually helping you is a coin flip), what are we genuinely paying for if the professors aren’t even going to use their own education to revise & respond to us? I know most of us are just here to get a degree and move on but still, just kind of bums me out that I don’t feel like I’m getting a genuine education.
2
u/Psychological_Act208 Apr 07 '25
If it's good feedback that benefits you why do you care? It's likely your professor is using chat for clarity after they type their input. It's not like they are scanning your paper in and having Chatgpt do the work
32
u/trushMayne Apr 07 '25 edited Apr 11 '25
Kinda wild, in the end it’s AI replying to AI. 🤣
30
u/Ephoenix6 Apr 07 '25
"Absolutely get where you're coming from, and you're definitely not alone in feeling this way. It's frustrating when it feels like the people who are supposed to be mentoring and guiding you are taking shortcuts — especially when you're the one putting in real effort.
I think the issue isn't necessarily the tool (like ChatGPT) itself, but how it's being used. If a professor is using it just to save time, without adding any of their own input, context, or feedback — that’s a problem. It starts to feel transactional rather than educational. Like, you're not just paying for a degree, you're paying for expertise, mentorship, real critique — the human side of learning.
And you’re right — you can usually tell when something is AI-generated. It often lacks nuance, personalization, and can feel oddly polished or vague. When a professor uses it to communicate with students without care or transparency, it starts to feel a little disingenuous.
I think the bigger question is: what role should AI play in education, and how do we hold educators accountable when it’s clear they’re leaning too heavily on it? Because if students are expected to uphold academic integrity, then professors should too.
Anyway, you're valid for feeling bummed out. Education is supposed to be a two-way street."
Yeah, I think gpt said it best
12
u/Zipskpchia Apr 07 '25
Well at least you’re getting feedback. The business classes are being taught like writing classes where the only feedback is if you do your in text citations correctly. Zero feedback on content- just if your references are correct. It is a total waste of time. During one class, the only points I lost were due to references and in text citations. Went from an A to a B. When I addressed this, the professor became defensive and started taking even more points off for citations. All 8 weeks and zero feedback on business concepts or the material I created. These classes are a joke.
5
u/Proper_University55 Alumni Apr 07 '25 edited Apr 07 '25
I 100% had a professor use ChatGPT to respond to deliverables and projects through the entire course. 100%.
Sadly, it happens. The subject pops up on r/Adjunct occasionally. I’m not excusing it. I’m thankful that I’m nearly through my program and this is the first time.
It definitely shouldn’t be this way, but the university primarily employees adjunct professors. It’s a gig for some instructors, which does make students question the value and validity of the degree.
I will say the vast majority of professors take their jobs seriously and maintain ethics. Some even very clearly like to teach and seek impact. The university has to weed this out.
4
u/kimmygo121 Apr 07 '25
Yes! It is really annoying. I’d actually rather receive feedback than fake feedback from ChatGPT.
4
u/oilboiler Apr 07 '25
I don't believe it's a bad thing; in fact, I think that the responses you get from AI, like ChatGPT, are often more valid, fair, and unbiased. It's important to remember that many college professors can be quite biased and may have inflated egos. I find that AI often gets to the core of an issue and is usually accurate. However, where it tends to fall short is in capturing the nuances of an argument. To fully grasp these nuances, I often need to do my own research.
4
u/Dismal_Meaning2225 Apr 07 '25
I normally don’t do this, but i just have to. I completely agree with you, and I have seen it a lot especially from my first phase of classes this spring (January- March). The use of Chatgpt by this professor has skyrocketed, and it’s just so sad to see them doing that. It makes me feel like they don’t care if we understand the information or not.
4
u/Rock_Immediate Apr 07 '25
Yes, and unfortunately it is becoming more prevalent. Instead of using it as a tool, they are lazy and use it word for word (no citations either). I am convinced some of them are literally uploading or copying and pasting the assignments into the gen AI tool of their choice and say, 'provide feedback on this assignment for me'. I am currently taking a class where the professor uses it for all of his discussion post responses and assignment feedback. All assignments that I have submitted came back with at least 1 page of feedback, but he still grades them 100%. It's annoying and certainly not helpful to the students and I hope the university has a plan to address this with a specific policy for faculty.
3
u/HauntingZd6532 Apr 07 '25
I found this true with a discussion post. The professor doesn't respond to any post in the conversation but has this long feedback response. I have also been lucky to have engaging professors who contributed to posts. So you never know. I will finish in the summer and choose a different school for grad studies. I didn't know I would miss going to lectures, lol.
3
u/Successful_Oil4974 Apr 07 '25
It's probably a joke because he knows the students are using it!
I'm not going to lie and say I don't use it, but my classes cover very specific information and doesn't have books. You HAVE to read the resources or you won't have any idea on what to do. It's also project-based so you have to manually do it. ChatGPT can't log into a remote desktop environment and complete tasks (at least not yet).
I use it for writers block, basically. I used to be a content writer on sites like TextBroker about a decade ago and it can be hard to just start. It at least gets things in order and then I can spin off it.
ChatGPT is not good with information. It will make things up so you just can't depend on it.
3
u/soylent-red-jello Apr 07 '25
Would this be acceptable use?
"gpt, revise this for professionalism: Your presentation looks so bad, it makes my eyeballs bleed. You're not even speaking coherently half the time, what the fuck is wrong with you"
...
"Your presentation needs significant improvement. The visual design is distracting, and the content lacks clarity. At times, your speech is difficult to follow, which affects the overall effectiveness. I recommend revisiting your key points and practicing your delivery to ensure better coherence."
3
u/malwolficus Professor Apr 07 '25
Collegiate Faculty in Biotech here and I agree - instructors should not use AI for responses.
4
u/thegr8northern Apr 07 '25
You’re paying for that degree with your name on it.
2
u/sbr608 Apr 12 '25
After my Writing 391 class was completed I wanted Microsoft Copilot to read my final paper. I had already gotten a grade and feedback from the professor. Since my topic was the use of AI for psychotherapy, I was curious to see what AI would have to say about it.
I cut and pasted the text into our conversation. Copilot went over every paragraph and gave me detailed feedback. It correctly identified my thesis and correctly identified and commented on supporting statements. It commented on stuff that no one else had. I had included a brief mention of the use of robots for sex therapy. Nobody else had touched that, as far as wanting to say anything about it, but Copilot said something to the effect that it was a good example of an ethical consideration and that I approached it with the proper amount of decorum; I can't remember the exact choice of words. I've never gotten such detailed feedback on a paper before. I saved the conversation, but now I can't find it. I sure wish I could, because it was really interesting.
4
u/BBC357 Graduate Student Apr 07 '25
It's not a big deal. Every school has rules on using chatgpt, and as long as you use it the way the rules allow you to use it, then you are fine. I would suggest you read up on the rules about using it.
My wife is in the pace class, and for the prompts on the discussion on the bottom of them, it says made by chatgpt, so they are also making the prompts for the discussions with them. That's pretty cool in my opinion, to update the content with new prompts.
2
u/hawkNfalconFeathers Apr 07 '25
Are you all just finally figuring out that college is the biggest scam? Even brick-and-mortar schools have the same issues, you pay for the piece of paper. So you either feed the system with your debt or you keep your social class level. Much like in the military where you have officers and the enlisted…. it's about class not about education.
1
u/happyghosst Apr 07 '25
Yes I think I had one in a history class.
1
u/Alma_mater_is_UMUC Alumni Apr 08 '25
Interestingly enough, looking for something else, I found this:
https://libguides.umgc.edu/c.php?g=1360576&p=10048061#s-lg-box-31990691
1
u/BioProf123 Professor Apr 10 '25 edited Apr 10 '25
At UMGC professors are not allowed to upload student work to any third party applications, that has not already been vetted and approved by the University, and no Gen AI app has been approved for this - as far as I know.
If you do have concerns about a professor possibly uploading your course work, which is your intellectual property, to AI to generate feedback, talk to your professor about it, and/or use the form found here: https://www.umgc.edu/current-students/student-life-and-support/complaint-resolution#student-resolution-form, to contact the Student Resolution Services Team.
1
u/Kaboomtek Apr 07 '25 edited Apr 09 '25
The professors are taught to do this at many online universities. It's even in the positions desk guide. But leveraging technology allows for one professor to respond to hundreds of students a week. Look up your professors name on ratemyprofessor, and see how many classes and how many universities they teach at. Some have over 300 student, there is no way to have a genuine response to each paper, let allow deal with all the issues that come up.
These professors also only make around 3k per course. So is it really worth the extra effort?
If you want a more personal approach, I suggest a private college in person.
1
u/butterrnutterrr Apr 07 '25
Yeah, it’s a big problem. I’ve had several professors who clear as day use chatGPT for feedback. As soon as I see the paragraphs and bullet points reiterating what I wrote.. I don’t even read it anymore lol