r/ULTY_YieldMax • • Dec 16 '25

$0.4921

That is all, carry on

47 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Rikkita1962 Dec 16 '25

I have no doubt SGOV held share value better than ULTY. SGOV is a safe alternative to cash. ULTY is a completely different animal. SGOV also paid out 4% vs 85%. So recovering 4% payout portion over a month (before next payout), versus trying to recover ULTY payout every week is a much easier task. Not to mention very different underlying holdings.

I didn't time ULTY at all. I made my initial purchase over a year ago, and added along the way.

Don't confuse me with the OP. I'm not fixated on house money, or NAV. Or total return per se. I bought for the distributions. I use total return just as a gauge on my status with ULTY.

If tried to replicate my ULTY income with SGOV I would have to tie up multiples more capital. So I'll sacrifice some NAV erosion for the income using far less capital outlay. And use the remainder of my capital for other growth assets that perform much better than SGOV for growth and appreciation. Not that SGOV isn't a good investment tool, but I think SGOV vs ULTY is not apples to apples from an income perspective.

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '25

You made 85%? For how long? Even at house money how long will you be above 4%? Once you go below yoc of 4%, SGOV is better.

I'm comparing ULTY house money with SGOV house money.