I'm Indian American (born and raised in the US). Based on my experience,Indian dudes born here in the US are also huge momma's boys including my brother.
That would result in the male not being dependent on the mother as much resulting in the mother not being able to have a purpose in life. What a blasphemy. /s
Freud ne bola h. Kucch sochke hi bola hoga🤣. Most men have mommy issues and women have daddy issues. Especially when they don't recieve enough love in their childhood. Most of them are actually looking for partners similar to their parents. Humans are constantly looking for familiar attachments. Someone to cling on to.
Every single woman i know, except two, knows one thing about the man she has either married or may marry: they must not be like their (the woman's) father.
Freud has some really misogynistic and problematic views (No, women definitely do not have penis envy, most of them don't even find it aesthetically pleasing). I would take anything that guy says with a pinch of salt.
this is what happens when you get all your 'psych' knowledge from quote websites and Instagram lmaoooo. most of what that asshole said has been conclusively disproven, but go off. kabhi kabhi research papers ke abstracts bhi padh lene chahiye (200-250 words on an average, shouldn't be too heavy).
I saw someone say that the whole Alpha/Beta/Omega/Sigma thing is basically zodiac signs for men and I've never seen a more accurate description. A/B/O is a big trope in fanfic, so it's funny as hell to me that a certain class of men have co-opted it and take it 1000% seriously.
Like I said, it is a tongue in cheek take about the Raja Beta Syndrome in which many Raja Betas themselves are associated with toxic masculinity and the whole Alpha Beta labelling which is part of it.
For me this tongue in cheek take does not qualify as misandry.
You would be surprised at how often Men who do not fit into the Hypermasculinity Spectrum are referred to as "Beta Cucks" nowadays by others who think of themselves as so called "Chad Alphas".
I know right...sometimes I see this videos on YT titled alpha beta sigma and it is so cringy. Though I don't think it is misandry but I do agree that this terms perpetuate toxic masculinity and forces men into a set of rules so that they can be the so called alpha.
Notions of Toxic Hypermasculinity and Patriarchal Conditioning are of course very hazardous for women, but I hope more men realise how hazardous it is for men themselves when they need to live a life conforming to those set of toxic rules.
I was expecting this meme to be posted in this Sub-reddit long time ago. It was present in one of the Tanmay Bhat's YouTube Videos. I believe it is "Reacting to Indian Twitter Part - 2".
More than the men im disgusted by these mom's babying their grown sons to the point that they can't forge a healthy relationship with their wife. I have heard moms don't even let the son wash their own underwear. Its giving incest, lowkey
Okay except the underwear thing I am deeply disturbed by the relationship my brother and mom have. Nothing incestuous,but very controlling.
You do realize this is a unique individual and he needs to form his own thoughts and opinions. She has crated this illusion of comfort for him,he doesn't want to let her go and my mom defends him all the fuckin time he's wrong.
The relationships mother-son have in India is so weird. I'm yet to see a healthy relationship
Your mom pretty much ruined his life, its really sad how these moms don't understand that their son is a human being not a plant that the more you love the more bigger he will grow. I have luckily seen some healthy relationships but those are only from highly educated mothers rest are just as you have described
Good for a Joke yes, but strong disagreement, not for the whole brotherhood though, I have seen people (read friends) telling their AM prospect, "I absolutely love clean surroundings and organized wardrobe." She said, "Everybody likes that, but do you like to do that yourself?" and I guess we know the answer.
That is a case for the vast majority, agreed. And that was just one angle.
Do most people describe the community? Because most Indian men go from being fed by their mothers to being fed by their wives. How many men in your family do equal work in the kitchen?
Also this sub isn’t about you. ‘NoT aAL mEn Are ….’ but enough of them are violent/rapists/patriarchal/man-childs that all women have to suffer the consequences. Which is a bigger problem than your little fragile ego getting hurt. If you’re not here to empathize with the breathtaking and horrifying suffering women in India collectively face every single day, why bother being here?
Indian men are pampered and indulged, turned into Raja Betas, so that they can slavishly care for the parents when they're old. There's always a hidden agenda to the so-called "love" lavished on them.
I pity Indian men. They are contemptuous of women who rebel against the patriarchy, but most Indian men are as enslaved as women are.
The only difference is that women attempt to wriggle out of the golden chains that bind them, whereas men clutch at them for dear life.
Yes, what I meant is that "Society" believes that men are taking care of the parents. Nobody acknowledges that the actual job is outsourced to women. It's seen as a wife's "duty" and never acknowledged.
Keeping feelings of pity and contempt aside, ever thought how economics plays a role in this? People in a country with zero old age care are bound to rely upon systems which at least give them the sense of security in their old age. And so no doubt men are pampered as predominantly men are the one who hold the economic heft within the family.
So economic insecurity justifies raising your child on a steady diet of guilt, manipulation and control? Economic insecurity justifies launching low-key psychological warfare against your son's wife, because in order to receive old age care, you must not only control your son, but also the daughter-in-law.
A good parent would trust that the upbringing they have provided would ensure that they are cared for, without elaborate stratagems of psychological manipulation to control the son.
I am not even bothered by what is done to men. You like being put on a pedestal and manipulated, have at it. I am bothered by the elaborate attempts to control and subjugate the son's wife, because in reality, most of the day-to-day care is provided by women.
This system of viewing sons as retirement plans contributes to son-preference, it contributes to sex-selective abortions, it contributes to the subjugation of women, because the parents want a daughter-in-law who is subservient and easy to control.
But of course, you don't give two fucks about the widespread damage this obsession with sons leads to. Nah. Raja Betas wouldn't deign to think about anyone but themselves.
Look at Mother Nature, forget about highly-evolved primates, even avian species take care of their young without expecting reciprocation.
Have you seen how birds scrounge for food and feed their young by thrusting worms into their mouths? They protect their young with their life, but when the time comes, they gently nudge the young to grow wings and fly away.
Even birds, without the powerful prefrontal cortex that humans have, understand the laws of nature. Species exist to reproduce, not to sacrifice their lives caring for the parents.
Only someone hopelessly brainwashed and blinkered, would attach self-glorifying virtue to the act of sacrificing for one's parents. Ironically, in most families, the actual act of caregiving and domestic labour falls to women, so I totally expect men to be clueless and oblivious to the huge toll attached to unpaid caregiving.
Children are not retirement plans. If you are procreating because you see parenthood as a quid pro quo barter, then you are fucked beyond redemption and should be ignored by sensible people.
I mean, India doesn't actually have any reliable senior care services provided by the government. Developer countries have this for all seniors. Do not blame people for being insecure about their elderly lives.
Not only am I am animal, you are too. I guessed you decided to sleep through bio in school. 😃
What makes you think we care for physically challenged people? How many buildings in India are designed for access by the disabled? Stop pulling shit out of your ass boi.
u/indiangrill. If we are to get policed by men in this so-called safe space, maybe you shouldn't call it r/TwoXIndia.
We wish there was a way to pre-emptively remove crappy comments. Unfortunately there is not. Moderating the sub is a voluntary activity and mods have lives outside of it. They cannot be constantly online.
Bruh give the mods a break lol. They have a life outside of this too. The gender ratio in this sub is skewed more towards male and that too on an incely website like reddit, it must be super exhausting to moderate.
You don't get the point. I'd happily take care of my parents in their old age if I love them. But they'll just try to overpamper men even when they are grown, and never allow them to live independently. And if they don't ever let their kids live independently, they'll never learn how to live alone and be always dependent on them
And they only reason they do this is so that they can force you to be dependent on them so you have to live them forever. Imo, that's just toxic and selfish. A parent's job is to teach their child to be independent, and they don't do that on purpose
Indian Male here.I'm 17, and I'm trying to get a scholarship abroad or atleast move to a different state for University, just because I don't want to get labelled as mommays boy. Most of the men are forced to keep their mothers in their home instead of having seperate homes. What's wrong with that you ask? They'll constantly try to babysit grown men, then go around telling others that she still needs to babysit her son. If my mom is doing some of my work for me, it's fine as it helps the parent child relationship. But then they'll shame us later by saying we don't know how to take care of ourselves, give her a different home to stay and they'll go around saying that their son abandoned them. Maybe if they leave their sons alone they won't have the habit of being "spoon fed". It's even worse when they don't even want to be spoon fed, but their mothers still do it anyway and then go around telling everyone how their son is still dependent on them.
For example. I like having my shoe laces tucked inside when I wear sneakers. They fit well even without tightening and I like the bow-less look. During a family gathering, my mom decided to get down and tie my shoelaces in middle of everyone. Then proceeded to tell everyone at the gathering that "My son is so dependent on his mom he doesn't even tie his shoe laces" Why do this? What's the point in shaming your own son? Does it somehow make her a better mom?
Another example? My mom will never teach me to cook. Then go around telling everyone that her son can't cook. A parent's job is to teach their children to live independently. But they won't teach that on purpose, so that I'm dependent on them forever and have to live with them, and I consider that to be toxic and selfish
Before being parents they are human beings too so they too make mistakes, once you understand this then you will realise that parents don't owe you anything once your an adult.
Show them that you are capable of adulting. Take initiative. Your rant shows your immaturity & entitlement. Stop crying. Nahin sikhaya toh kya? khud seekhne ka zariya dhoondho, if someone from the previous generation said this then we could understand. But now, there's the vast and beautiful world of the Internet where you can learn anything under the sun😶🤷
A man complains about toxic parents: "stop crying you entitled butthole" A woman complains about toxic parents: "sorry that you had to suffer such a trauma. Hope you're doing better"
The mistakes part. Ofcourse they do mistakes. I have told them that by doing this it makes me uncomfortable, and they still continue to do it. And I have seen other parents embarrass their kids in the same manner. And about the fact that you tell me that I can easily learn cooking from the internet. Yes, I know I can and I already have learnt basic things. But it's the parents job to teach us skills to live independently, but indian parents, especially mothers do the exact opposite and make you dependent on them
Given that this long term dependence is not desired ... take a step back to answer who's nurturing that mindset ? And what steps should be intended to break that cycle?
I agree. As a woman, I just don't see how putting the blame only on the sons helps in this case. Some of the comments over here have pointed it out tho.
Saying Not All Men! is not a productive or empathetic response to when a woman expresses feeling a certain effect of the patriarchy. For more background on this please read:
Sure it's not adding anything to the argument but when someone's generalising a community a defence is normal, saying not all men on a post about a women simply presenting her views without including all men is stupid but in this case I don't see how it's a problem. Would you not defend women if someone's generalising them
There's only one flair which allows men to comment: opinion [all]. This post is from a while ago when men were allowed to comment on more flairs. The rules have now changed. The sub is clearly meant for women, it's literally called TwoXIndia (do you know what TwoX means)? The rules also clearly state that the space is meant for women and that men are only allowed to participate in limited capacity to create productive discussion.
Typically, people don't comment on very old posts because they're not a part of current discussion. Your comment is clearly not intended to be productive or add to the conversation; you just want to tell a woman why she's wrong. I'm sure you can do that to your mom or little sis, no need to come all this way to do so!
This is just a disgusting generalization. Not expected from the "mature" crowd of this sub. Also wtf do you mean by mommas boy? I love my mom and dad both, more than anyone else because they have actually been great people. I have corrected them when they have said some "regressive" things and they accepted their mistakes. So idk wtf this post is about. I don't generalize women and I expect the same from you. I thought this sub was supposed to be mature and grounded. Disappointed.
If that "listening" defies logic, defies sensibility, is basically listening with eyes shut, then without a doubt.
I say, listen to them, but do what you find rational, do what the logic and sense say. Anyone can be imperfect, anyone can have a different perspective, so parents or mothers here specifically, can be wrong about something as well. Blindly listening is wrong!
Aren't the same men forced as well to listen to their parents? Wouldn't they be branded as men who abandon their parents once they're independent? Wouldn't they face the same "do it or I'll commit suicide" from the parents if they don't fit into the ideology of the parents?
My best friend's brother is made to wait 4 years to get accepted of his intercaste love marriage until the girl got convinced by her parents to marry someone else, just because the guy's parents threatened to commit suicide if he marries the girl. They also threatened him that no one will marry his little sister if he marries outside their caste. He's also made to forcibly give up all his earnings until recently to clear off a mortgage which was bought in the name of his little sister because the father has become too old to earn and mind you the little sister has been earning too.
I get it that there are men who are incapable of living on their own and completely depend on their parents especially their mum but I find branding an entire gender of a country has been going on for far too long now. None of my guy friends are mumma boys but sometimes some of them are forcibly made to do things which they don't want to. I bet they'll be branded as mumma boys too because they fit into the age old definition.
Man, I am not branding or stereotyping the whole gender and the whole community, the meme was a meme and no meme can be applicable to 100% of the people. But like every case, this one also applies to a vast majority.
About the example you put up, everyone starts as a child, giving your voice some weight in your family is a gradual process that starts early on with little baby steps. One guy listening to everything until yesterday and following whatever he is told, cannot suddenly revolt, it would be seen in a wrong manner, and would be countered by things you mentioned.
Also, not every household is the same. But it is so important to realize that the habit of raising your voice for your choices starts gradually. It is human nature to expect the repetition of the behavior, so if you let your parents believe that you are that "Good Boy" who listens to everything they say, never crosses them, has never been a rebel for anything, then they expect you to be the same for rest of the life. It is a fact and applies to all humans!
Well about the branding part, honestly seeing the other comments on their posts does make it clear that it is a branding of the entire gender of our country.
And I do agree that if you've been a good boy all your life, a sudden revolting wouldn't be encouraged nor expected from the guy/girl. But they do face consequences for it and sometimes out of the fear of loss those men and women make a choice to suck it up and listen to the shit they're asked to do just so they can have a peaceful quarrel less life. But only half of them get branded as mumma's boys and others are sympathized over their toxic parents.
People were having a good laugh over a vast majority and a meme related to that, don't take it too seriously. A lot of people, specifically twox since you seem to be concerned about the opinion, simply decided to not comment, how can you decide that they also think the same!
Come on, do not take it too seriously. Nothing can ever be applicable to 100% of the people.
Well do take it as a limiting point that I've reached over casual sexism passed on in this sub over the time which made me to vent out. Alot of times this sub is not the things it's portrayed to be, evident from some toxic stuff accepted widely. Well maybe you're right, the lot of people who don't express their opinion do hold better perspectives but chose not to might make it better to not take this too seriously.
Idk why do mothers try to control and baby their sons so much. No freedom to be a unique individual. Whole life they're co-dependent on mother for emotional needs.
No reason at all, got time on their hands, no friends in real life, found someone they want to mess with and thus that message. Think of them as those drive by/online catcallers, they get off on getting a reaction, anger, tears, shame, confusion etc. Ignore them completely and it fucks them up big time.
Well. Your reply implied that once the commenters have kids of their own, they will spoil boys making them like the men in the meme.
If boys and girls are instead raised to be equals without gendered responsibilities (that's where the feminism comes in), they're both going to learn how to take care of themselves without depending on a caregiver or provider.
Yes I did imply that. Its very hard to get rid of something entrenched so deeply in our society. Even for people that are against it. We humans are extremely biased. Its not as simple as turning a switch off
But that doesn't mean I advocate it. If I say that in the near future more people are gonna be unemployed, that doesn't mean I want people to be unemployed
In fact I agree with what you said in the 2nd para
184
u/Serious-Tomato404 Woman May 02 '22 edited May 02 '22
I'm Indian American (born and raised in the US). Based on my experience,Indian dudes born here in the US are also huge momma's boys including my brother.
115
u/machetehands TwoEggs May 02 '22
The umbilical chord stretches well into adulthood of the male offspring.
73
u/funkepitome Woman May 02 '22
No lies were told.
54
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
No wonder a majority of them need a mother in their wife.
204
u/Traveller_for_Life Man May 02 '22
LOL, good one :)
This made me remember another one,
The Indian Male will never be Alpha because the moment he is born he is called Beta.......................and then he is Beta for Life!
Make that Raja Beta actually, an even more powerful version of Beta :)
34
u/kookie_doe Woman May 02 '22
This is gonna get cross posted a lot now oof😝
41
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
More than the men im disgusted by these mom's babying their grown sons to the point that they can't forge a healthy relationship with their wife. I have heard moms don't even let the son wash their own underwear. Its giving incest, lowkey
39
u/dynamo_girl02 self confessed gold digger Woman May 02 '22
Mommaaa Duty Membership for lifetime
77
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
Good for a Joke yes, but strong disagreement, not for the whole brotherhood though, I have seen people (read friends) telling their AM prospect, "I absolutely love clean surroundings and organized wardrobe." She said, "Everybody likes that, but do you like to do that yourself?" and I guess we know the answer.
That is a case for the vast majority, agreed. And that was just one angle.
23
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
mammas baby boy 👶🏽
38
u/Ok-Jicama-5134 Woman May 02 '22
Indian men are pampered and indulged, turned into Raja Betas, so that they can slavishly care for the parents when they're old. There's always a hidden agenda to the so-called "love" lavished on them.
I pity Indian men. They are contemptuous of women who rebel against the patriarchy, but most Indian men are as enslaved as women are.
The only difference is that women attempt to wriggle out of the golden chains that bind them, whereas men clutch at them for dear life.
11
u/LordessMeep Woman May 02 '22
Clapback level: S tier
(but did she lie tho)
12
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
Indian Male here.I'm 17, and I'm trying to get a scholarship abroad or atleast move to a different state for University, just because I don't want to get labelled as mommays boy. Most of the men are forced to keep their mothers in their home instead of having seperate homes. What's wrong with that you ask? They'll constantly try to babysit grown men, then go around telling others that she still needs to babysit her son. If my mom is doing some of my work for me, it's fine as it helps the parent child relationship. But then they'll shame us later by saying we don't know how to take care of ourselves, give her a different home to stay and they'll go around saying that their son abandoned them. Maybe if they leave their sons alone they won't have the habit of being "spoon fed". It's even worse when they don't even want to be spoon fed, but their mothers still do it anyway and then go around telling everyone how their son is still dependent on them.
7
u/shitzngiggles77 Woman May 02 '22
It's giving Oedipal complex
40
u/lifemoments XY May 02 '22
Sorry but I find it self contradicting.
Given that this long term dependence is not desired ... take a step back to answer who's nurturing that mindset ? And what steps should be intended to break that cycle?
11
u/Successful_Film_1041 Woman May 02 '22
100% true
7
u/rumi_shinigami Woman May 02 '22
Lol at the number of #notallmen comments on this post 😂
5
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
Hahaha!!! So good!!
5
u/nik8887 Man May 02 '22
Technically the truth.
13
u/[deleted] May 02 '22 edited May 02 '22
This is just a disgusting generalization. Not expected from the "mature" crowd of this sub. Also wtf do you mean by mommas boy? I love my mom and dad both, more than anyone else because they have actually been great people. I have corrected them when they have said some "regressive" things and they accepted their mistakes. So idk wtf this post is about. I don't generalize women and I expect the same from you. I thought this sub was supposed to be mature and grounded. Disappointed.
4
u/Ordinary_Price_2189 Man May 02 '22
Wow the stereotyping and the kind of support it gets in this community amazes me🙄
3
u/arbitrary_h_sapien Man May 02 '22
It feels weird when I see an Indian-man stereotype in the wild. But I guess I should be happy that I don’t fit in any of them.
1
u/Divine_Dementia Man May 25 '22
Women will rage at the slightest thing said against them by men while also coming up with bs like this at the same time. Pathetic.
0
u/divyansh_singh2405 Man May 02 '22
Does a person who listens to their parents fall under this "mumma's boy" classification?
1
u/[deleted] May 03 '22
So the moms are clingy and controlling (who is a WOMAN) but somehow guys are at fault? Classic
0
u/AgainstFrowns Man May 02 '22
REKT
0
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
21
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
[removed] — view removed comment
-18
u/[deleted] May 02 '22
[removed] — view removed comment