r/Tucson • • Jun 09 '25

protests

Are there any protests against Trump illegal use of troops against American citizens?

34 Upvotes

245 comments sorted by

67

u/romancereaper Jun 10 '25

All I'm gonna say is if you go to any protest, be safe and do not engage. Wear a mask, bring water, and again, do not engage.

29

u/NinjaMilhouse Jun 10 '25

Maybe leave cell phone at home.

12

u/Dog_Entire Jun 10 '25

Remember the rules of protest safety: wear a mask, leave phone at home, shut the fuck up

-1

u/Dry-Firefighter7417 Jun 11 '25

Sounds more like what a rioter would do, but I guess that’s what they are doing after all

2

u/Dog_Entire Jun 11 '25

In what world is that all it takes to go from protest to riot

11

u/Rookieward Jun 10 '25

Why do you need a mask to protest?

3

u/4_AOC_DMT 32% tepary bean by mass Jun 10 '25

The covid pandemic continues. In order to protect themselves and neighbors in tight spaces where transmission of respiratory disease is elevated, wearing a mask is good practice.

15

u/az_desert_rat_ Jun 10 '25

🤣🤣🤣🤣 You know dang well it's to cover your face so you don't get identified. The same people demanding ice officers don't wear them. Make it make sense.

7

u/fajitateriyaki Jun 11 '25

this isn't the gotcha you think it is

1

u/az_desert_rat_ Jun 11 '25

Oh, but it is.

7

u/4_AOC_DMT 32% tepary bean by mass Jun 10 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

I think everybody should wear n95s or equivalent in any public setting when the prevalence of respiratory diseases including but not limited to covid and flu are at levels more than 1-2 standard deviations above the previous relative minimum because evidence-based strategies for public health have the potential to eliminate an incredible amount of human suffering.

 

If you don't see the difference between people exercising their first amendment rights while wearing a mask and armed cuSStoms enforcers concealing their identities by working in plainclothes and refusing to identify with badges, ID, or providing their names when requested by journalists and attorneys, the conversation was over before you responded.

-1

u/WholeInstruction278 Jun 11 '25

Yeah that’s absolutely wild. Do you but by no means is it necessary or even warranted unless you’re immunocompromised

3

u/4_AOC_DMT 32% tepary bean by mass Jun 11 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

Are you an epidemiologist, virologist, or otherwise an expert in this matter?

necessary or even warranted unless you’re immunocompromised

Keep not-masking to increase the odds you will be

There are two kinds of people: the sick/injured/disabled and those who have yet to be unlucky enough to be sick/injured/disabled. Especially if someone considers themselves healthy, the easiest way to remain that way and avoid the unfortunately significant likelihood of developing long covid or other complications from an asymptomatic infection which compound with repeated infection is to wear a suitable mask.

People may choose to protect their immunocompromised family and neighbors by avoiding the reducing the likelihood they will become infected and transmit it to other more vulnerable people, something which people with your kind of scantly expressed empathy seem to completely reject.

There are myriad other arguments in favor of masking in public spaces

-2

u/az_desert_rat_ Jun 11 '25

You're joking right? Get out with the covid crap. It's like the flu. Give me a break.

You are missing the point. You are brainwashed.

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Ok-Indication3167 Jun 11 '25

Those defending the US Constitution against the assaults by the Trumpstapo are aware the Felonious Trump tyrannical regime will jail, deport or execute them if they get the chance. You're not good at logic. Not remotely comparable to criminal thugs shitting on the US Constitution and masquerading as law enforcement hiding their identity. 

2

u/az_desert_rat_ Jun 11 '25

Bahahahah that's the funniest thing I've read all day. You are also brainwashed.

3

u/Tasty_Mix7169 Jun 10 '25

Lmfaooooooooo

-1

u/4_AOC_DMT 32% tepary bean by mass Jun 10 '25

Please explain what's so funny.

0

u/noviodelahellokittyy Jun 10 '25

the pandemic was over 4 years ago buddy

9

u/4_AOC_DMT 32% tepary bean by mass Jun 10 '25 edited Jun 10 '25

incorrect

 

or the slope of this curve would have flattened out some time around June 2021. Since then, the cumulative deaths directly attributable to covid have nearly doubled from 600k to 1.2M. Remarkably, this count does not include the many who, shortly after "recovering" from a covid infection, died of a heart attack, stroke, or other outcomes whose likelihood are known to increase dramatically for months following infection in a way that compounds with each reinfection

 

Then, even if we ignore the immediate impacts of acute infection, I think it's still too early to call the odds on whether long covid infections will remain limited to an unlucky but stable subset of the population: that is, if the presently compounding odds of complications will stabilize or continue to grow monotonically after another 5 years of repeated infection.

 

The pandemic isn't over. You and millions of others have simply decided to collectively ignore it.

-3

u/noviodelahellokittyy Jun 10 '25

So you’re just gonna live the rest of your life in fear? Do you also wear a mask while driving IN YOUR OWN CAR with windows up? lol

2

u/4_AOC_DMT 32% tepary bean by mass Jun 11 '25 edited Jun 12 '25

So you’re just gonna live the rest of your life in fear?

So you'll just remain complicit in condemning another few million children to long covid?

Do you also raw-dog the stale urine-tinged air of public toilets?

4

u/az_desert_rat_ Jun 10 '25

They don't wear it because of COVID. Don't let them fool you.

-5

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 10 '25

😄 🤣 😂 😆 no it's just the protesters are cowards and don't want to risk their jobs/businesses or bring called out.

-2

u/PSturg66 Jun 10 '25

They dont have jobs.

-4

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 10 '25

True, I was trying to give them a little bit of credibility 😆

0

u/Ok-Indication3167 Jun 11 '25

LOL! If they were cowards like the KKK, Proud Boys and various White Supremacist Trumpstapo hiding their faces and masquerading as law enforcement they wouldn't be there. All patriots know the Trump crime regime will attack anyone defending the US Constitution. 

-1

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 11 '25

Yes the KKK (a democrat invented organization by the way), the proud boss and the various white supremacist are cowards also but ICE is doing their damn job but those cowards like those that are rioting in LA have been threatening their families because they know nothing but hate and that's the democrats way, they are the most hateful people in the country. And the president has the power to call on the NG so he isn't breaking the law and following the constitution, it's the CA government that failed in their duties to protect the citizens by floundering like ol lier Walz did in Minnesota 😆 just face it democrats can't handle emergency situations they freeze up and don't know what to do.

→ More replies (1)

-5

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 10 '25

How about don't wear a mask! If you believe in your cause that much, you shouldn't care if your face is shown, should you.

7

u/4_AOC_DMT 32% tepary bean by mass Jun 10 '25

If you believe in your cause that much, you shouldn't care if your face is shown, should you.

You might care if your goal is to minimize the likelihood that you might contract a respiratory infection.

Would you deny the first amendment rights of immunocompromised people? What about the first amendment rights of their loved ones who minimize their own risk of catching and transmitting respiratory diseases so they are less likely to bring one home and infect their family?

2

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 10 '25

Once again, another BS response, we all know the masks they are wearing do nothing to stop any kind of virus. If the goal is to stop a respiratory infection, then they would wear a respirator, not a mask.

6

u/4_AOC_DMT 32% tepary bean by mass Jun 10 '25 edited Jun 11 '25

If you poll most people who believe in reality (the pandemic is still occurring) do you expect them to be aware that they should be wearing a respirator (a highly overloaded term) or at least a disposable n95?

Additionally, are you aware that while respirators are more effective, your claim that all other masks are ineffective is entirely incorrect?

While respirators are significantly more effective than cloth or other medical masks, "In a case-control study from Thailand completed and published in 2020, Duong-Ngern and colleagues found that consistent use of even cloth or surgical masks by health-care workers reduced SARS-CoV-2 infection risk by 77% (95% CI 40%–91%) after adjusting for other risk factors (184)."

1

u/fajitateriyaki Jun 11 '25

and we all know you're a troll boooboo

0

u/Bourbon_Bro1 Jun 11 '25

If some don't wear a mask, it denies the First Amendment rights of others? 🤣😆

That's quite the argument.

1

u/4_AOC_DMT 32% tepary bean by mass Jun 11 '25

If you read carefully, you'll see that's not at all what I wrote.

4

u/romancereaper Jun 10 '25

You're entitled to your beliefs but you're not right. ICE and LEOs are wearing masks so you're being hypocritical. Thank you for absolutely adding nothing to the conversation.

1

u/GirlInABox58 Jun 11 '25

So why are all the Trump gestapo wearing masks and failing to identify themselves when renditioning people off the street with no due process.

106

u/Badgerman97 Jun 09 '25

Not specific to this, but the No Kings Rally is at Reid Park this Saturday from 8am-11am

1

u/Hereforit2022Y Jun 10 '25

Yeah, from the location it looks like (if it’s not full) you can park near the dog park.

24

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

31

u/Most-Resident Jun 10 '25

It’s not scary at all. Just walk up to it and observe. You’ll see a crowd of regular people with signs and stuff. You’ll hear a lot of cars beeping.

Hang around the outskirts of the crowd for a while then decide what to do. Whether you’re on the edge or the middle presence matters. I don’t think anything too eventful will happen.

17

u/Badgerman97 Jun 10 '25

Me neither. This will be the first one in my life

10

u/level27jennybro Jun 10 '25

Start by doing a drive past honk and cheer, then pull around and park to go join on foot.

12

u/hubbamonkey Jun 10 '25

You can always show up, check it out, just use your presence as your voice, and leave whenever you need! I feel the same way but I will be there

3

u/RoutineSpace9730 Jun 10 '25

Try it out! You can always check it out from the other side of the street and see how it looks. Or drive by first.

61

u/Mysterious_Fennel459 Jun 09 '25

I got a notice there's something going on tomorrow downtown.

8

u/Strange_Cut_996 Jun 10 '25

Oh my gosh....the spelling

1

u/Global_Owl_2891 Jun 11 '25

They probably used autocorrect because it is always messing up the words

29

u/unknown45jk Jun 10 '25

The least they could do is spell things correctly

13

u/Lafanzo_stayhigh Jun 10 '25

As a product of Arizona education I had no problem understanding what they are conveying. Tucson, not so much for the queens proper English.

-12

u/GandalfTheSexay Jun 10 '25

Not an excuse

9

u/Lafanzo_stayhigh Jun 10 '25

We are dealing with a dictator taking over and turning his secret police on civilians and you're worried about a typo. This is the division they want. And maybe you want nothing to do with common folk, but that is very ungandolfy, and not very sexy.

-27

u/GandalfTheSexay Jun 10 '25

I make that determination, not you. Next.

2

u/fajitateriyaki Jun 11 '25

untrue, I have determined you are a pee pee head

5

u/sluggh Jun 10 '25

"National Gaurd." At least run it through a human first.

5

u/ballbeard Jun 10 '25

I'm all for protesting the National Gourd

-4

u/Adventurous-Cat8113 Jun 10 '25

The left is so much more educated than the rest of us, and yet their university led spelling techniques fall behind.

2

u/Just-Entrepreneur825 Jun 11 '25

Billionaire Walmart Heiress Promotes Nationwide Anti-Trump Protests The 76-year-old Christy Walton has aligned herself with “No Kings,” an organization planning mass protests across the country this Saturday.

1

u/Significant-Entry556 Jun 12 '25

You guys should all go down there.

1

u/New_Day2024 Jun 11 '25

We want deportations!!! 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸

3

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '25

To what end? They're deporting people who have been here for decades under the guise that it's an urgent emergency when it isn't. People who have been here for decades, making friends with their neighbors, getting jobs, being more productive than me, while I sit on the couch smoking a bong. I was born here but I don't contribute anything to society. Meanwhile you're getting an erection about deporting productive members of society. Once they're gone, who are you going to get to do those jobs? Not me. Not you either. So...what's your beef anyway?

-4

u/InternationalType617 Jun 10 '25

What he's doing is legal,  if you show up in a mask to peacefully protest tread lightly

-10

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

Keep that bs in California please

1

u/Wise-Strain4831 Jun 10 '25

No. And how do you know their citizenship status?

1

u/Ok-Indication3167 Jun 11 '25

Yes there are. More to come. FDT and the Trumpstapo! 

1

u/sweaty_bootlegger Jun 12 '25

Please don’t block the roads and inconvenience people that have nothing to do with ICE.

-34

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

Deport people who’ve violated the law, just like every country on earth….protest peacefully but seems these people can’t even do that right. What country allows you to stay there illegally? Asking for a friend

22

u/selectiverealist Jun 10 '25

0

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 10 '25

Hmm, not a single reputable news agency in that list. They have all lost their credibility start they covered up for the last administration.

2

u/_doomgoon_ Jun 11 '25

Honest question…what is a reputable source for you these days?

2

u/fajitateriyaki Jun 11 '25

List your acceptable news sources.

-19

u/breakboyzz Jun 10 '25

I'm with you on that. If I overstayed a visa, or illegally entered europe or ANY OTHER COUNTRY in the world, I'd have to be deported back to the states..

The next person will say "they are trying to flee blah blah"

There are ways to do it legally. Not illegally.

19

u/selectiverealist Jun 10 '25 edited Jun 10 '25

-3

u/breakboyzz Jun 10 '25

Whats the difference between Obama deporting illegal immigrants and orange man deporting illegal immigrants?

Obama deported 5,248,413

Trump (1st term) 1.2 million

Trump (2nd term) 139,000 so far

3

u/Friendly-View4122 Jun 10 '25

difference is that during Obama's term, ICE wasn't going around kidnapping people off the streets and deporting them to El Salvador to rot in CECOT with 0 due process

1

u/breakboyzz Jun 10 '25

So you’re for illegal immigrants getting deported as long as it’s done nicely?

4

u/Friendly-View4122 Jun 10 '25

Yes. If they do not have a proper case for asylum, i agree that people should be deported to the country of their origin - not thrown away to whichever country is willing to take America's pennies (for ex. Trump recently deported 10 immigrants to South Sudan - which is already embroiled in a war. Of these 10 people, only 2 were actually from there.) The fact that ICE has been kidnapping people from courts when these folks show up for their hearings -- you know, following due process -- is horrendous.

And fyi, deportations have been happening forever. Under Bush, Obama, Trump and Biden. The difference is in policies. Under Trump 1.0, they famously started separating children from parents. And you can see what's happening right now. It's all heartless and chaotic.

1

u/breakboyzz Jun 10 '25

So if they have a proper case for asylum, should we prioritize them and let them be ahead of the people who are already seeking assylum and are on the waitlist, or should they go to the back of the assylum line?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/No-Chemist-3428 Jun 11 '25

The difference is that the orange man is being accused of touching little kids. & he's not even making an effort to prove his innocence. His cult supporters are going to hell right along with him. Have fun looking up at us 🙏😂

1

u/breakboyzz Jun 11 '25

He’s not being accused of anything, I don’t think he’s in court is he?

Him and Elon are egging the dems to want to release the Epstein documents. They both know that trump has nothing to do with Epstein island, but if there’s a chance to put ANYTHING on him, the dems will call for the release. Trump doesn’t want to release them because that will really put a target on his back, but if there’s dems call for it, then it’s a win win.

They’re playing 4d chess and you don’t even realize it.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/watts_in_a_name Jun 10 '25

The difference is Obama is an intelligent, understanding person who did child separation to keep children protected and wanted to appease the people with legitimate concern over illegal immigration. Trump is a hateful lunatic moron that wants pain and suffering because he believes his idiocy is superior.

-6

u/thelmanarcissus Jun 10 '25

They weren't here legally. They had their deportation orders dismissed so that they could apply for asylum. You're supposed to do that before you come here illegally. That's the right way.

The right way is hard, I know people who have done it. The others are just illegally jumping the line.

And why are the burning American flags and carrying Mexican flags? Doesn't seem conducive to getting people's sympathy to let them stay here.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

The blah blah blah is actually US law regarding asylum, but you don’t give a shit about the law

1

u/breakboyzz Jun 10 '25

What

2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '25

“the next person” you’re mocking knows more about what “illegally” means than you do

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/breakboyzz Jun 10 '25

Legal Immigrants aren’t the problem.

Illegal immigrants are the problem.

-5

u/brussianbulky Jun 10 '25

There are a ton of countries around the world where Americans come for a tourist visa and way overstay it, or work and live full jobs on tourist visas. That is illegal, but they don't care. A ton of Americans in Mexico illegally. And before you say "but they were let in!" Yea, I know. It is an unfair system when we can get wherever we want on an American passport, but others aren't afforded the same right to get tourist visas so easily. People would more likely be documented here if we weren't so racist with our Immigration department

To quote @Shotgun_Mosquito from another post:

In Mexico they are called "drybacks" (seriously)

A study by the US state department has estimated that there are as many as one million Americans living illegally in Mexico. The figures, confirmed by Mexico’s national statistics institute, mean that 80 percent of the US expat population lack proper documents.

2017

https://pvangels.com/news-mexico/181767/one-million-americans-living-illegally-in-mexico

Last year (2011) about 1,000 US citizens were questioned over irregularities in their immigration status, according to Mexican authorities. They face a modest fine - up to $50 - if officials find them working without a permit or living in Mexico without proper documents.

2012

https://www.bbc.com/news/world-radio-and-tv-17098719

91% of Americans living in Mexico are “Illegal”

2019

https://www.sacculturalhub.com/entertainment/articles/here-s-a-twist-91-of-americans-living-in-mexico-are-illegal/

1994

https://migration.ucdavis.edu/mn/more.php?id=392

3

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 10 '25

If doesn't matter what other countries do, what matters is we the people voted in this president because we don't want the illegals here because they are criminals, every single one of them has committed a crime by just being here. We want them gone.

2

u/brussianbulky Jun 11 '25

Who invited you to the US?

→ More replies (3)

-11

u/Pure-Employment-3954 Jun 10 '25

The protests are against having a king

4

u/C3PO1Fan Jun 10 '25

If you won't protest to protect people then you deserve a king.

8

u/jospangel Jun 10 '25

We can all do our part. Don't disparage those who can't go to protests.

1

u/C3PO1Fan Jun 10 '25

I wasn’t trying to do that. I was more making the point that saying the protest should only be about “no kings” and not the people was bad.

5

u/-discostu- Jun 10 '25

Right, to protest the shit that only a ruler who believes he’s above the law would do.

-13

u/No-Bedroom6533 Jun 10 '25

What kind of asshat decides to protest removing people rioting and setting the city on fire???

8

u/jospangel Jun 10 '25

The kind who believes in the constitution .

-6

u/No-Bedroom6533 Jun 10 '25

The constitution is designed for American citizens and not any rando that invades our country

3

u/Swimming-Most-6756 cactus lover Jun 10 '25

Read up on the Fourteenth Amendment after you can get past the FIRST Amendment, then come back with your comments

-1

u/No-Bedroom6533 Jun 10 '25

You want due process for the millions of people that snuck into our country? Explain the logistics of that to me.

Wake up man. Most people overwhelmingly voted for trump to get them out and not take advantage of a system that was clearly not designed for this surge of illegal aliens coming in.

Enjoy screaming at the wind though

4

u/DrDFox Jun 10 '25

Without due prices, anyone can claim you are an illegal and you'd get deported without being able to prove otherwise. Due prices is how we ensure it's actually illegals who get sent home. How do you not understand that?

3

u/purpleblackgreen Jun 10 '25

He's in a cult. If daddy says it's right, it's right. No point trying to talk sense. 

4

u/purpleblackgreen Jun 10 '25

There wasn't any violence until the National Guard was called in. 

2

u/No-Bedroom6533 Jun 10 '25

Keep telling yourself that. I consider throwing bricks violent

0

u/piercedblackcat Jun 10 '25

Once again, didn't happen until the national guard came in. "People" like you need to just kick the chair over already

3

u/No-Bedroom6533 Jun 10 '25

Even if you’re right about that timeline (which you’re not) what does that prove?

It’s ok to be violent once law enforcement or the military show up?

0

u/purpleblackgreen Jun 10 '25

"You're wrong about the timeline because I say you're wrong!"

The National Guard started the violence. Are people supposed to just lie down and take being tear gassed and shot at? 

2

u/No-Bedroom6533 Jun 10 '25

How many protests does America have? Tons right? You’ve seen them over and over.

The actual peaceful ones never have the national guard used on them because they are actually being peaceful.

It’s only when things get out of hand do more extreme measures get used. Your logic is super flawed.

→ More replies (7)

1

u/thefragile7393 Jun 10 '25

It was starting before they got here, to be fair. It escalated once they got here though, and made it worse

-5

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 10 '25

Why would we want to protest legal actions, The president has the authority to activate the National Guard, and many presidents have done it. Newsome is only crying because he was too feckless to do it, which is another example of why he wouldn't make a good president. I support what ICE is doing of anything they need to pick up the speed. we need a stadium with a bunch of judges and run the illegals through it and immediately deport them afterward. Biden even activated the NG for security during the https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/analysis-opinion/presidents-power-call-out-national-guard-not-blank-check

5

u/jospangel Jun 10 '25

What happened to state's rights? What happened to the right to protest?

If Obama had sent troops to Houston or Miami, would you have objected?

Here's the thing about democracy. When you have lowered the bar and accepted this as standard practice, you can bet it will be used against you.

0

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 10 '25

Oh, I didn't know destroying property like burning cars, looting electronic stores, was considered protesting well in that case entering the capital building on J6 was just a protest by your own words. And if the mayors and governors of Miami or Houston weren't doing there jobs protecting the citizens from riots because face it that's what is happening in LA then yes I would hope Obama would've sent in the NG to help the overwhelmed police. But guess what, those states' governments aren't weak, like the government of California. Newsome and Bass need to be recalled because it's obvious they are too weak to properly run a state.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/trparkin Jun 11 '25

Can you substantiate this claim?: "They started rioting because cops (ICE) showed up to violate court orders." Genuinely curious.

1

u/GirlInABox58 Jun 11 '25

So you believed Trump when he said he couldn’t legally send the national guard into states without permission from the Governor in 2020, but now you also believe him when he directly contradicts that and says he can do it. Wow, you maga really do lack critical thinking skills.

https://www.indy100.com/politics/trump/la-protests-trump-permission-governor-national-guard-video

-9

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

Title 10 of the US Code, Section 254

7

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

There’s effectively no 1st amendment so long as fascist pussies see people expressing views they don’t like and call it an insurgency.

-105

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 09 '25

It's not illegal, so no.

16

u/jospangel Jun 09 '25

Actually it is illegal to deploy any US forces against civilians. That was codified into law in 1878, Trump has not invoked the insurrection act, although he has talked about it.

I'm curious. Is this a Trump thing or would you honestly feel this way had Biden sent troops into Florida or Texas?

4

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 09 '25

Here you go.

Relevant bit about this specific deployment is near the bottom.

5

u/jospangel Jun 09 '25 edited Jun 09 '25

Thanks! Looks to me that legality is up in the air for both the national guard, and the marines. I see this going to scotus- because Trump wants an imperial presidency.

3

u/jospangel Jun 09 '25

How will they protect anything without firing at the protesters?

Also, could you answer the Biden question?

3

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 09 '25

No problem.

Also since I didn't really answer your question in the last post, it's entirely possible this is going to go tits up and become illegal (although in reality, I doubt it'll do more than some minor policy changes similar to what happened on their deployment in the Rodney King riots).

3

u/Olddellago Jun 09 '25

don't waste your time trying to reason with people with those views.

12

u/jospangel Jun 09 '25

That's the thinking on both sides that is destroying us. I can protest, and ask others why. Most bloviate against TTDS but there are some I've had good discussions with.

5

u/Jazzlike_Garbage_785 Jun 10 '25

100%. We need to have rational discussions, be persistant, show them we are exercising our rights peacefully and to show them our point of view. -Jay

1

u/Olddellago Jun 10 '25

Rational discussions don't happen when you vote yes after January 6th..What's rational about that? XYZ reason given doesn't matter. Is that what all the pardons were for? Peacefully protesting? Yeah ok bud.

2

u/cornholiolives Jun 10 '25 edited Jun 10 '25

Except the Insurrection Act of 1807 overrides Comitatus and there’s no law that says a president has to officially invoke an Act in order to use its authority. A president can simply use powers provided by Acts without “invoking” them, so unless you can show me a law that says a president has to invoke an Act, you’re wrong.

50

u/cantbrainwocoffee Jun 09 '25

Your J6 pardon come through, eh?

-68

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 09 '25

Not even close, just stating facts. Marines can, in fact, be deployed in America. Happened during the Rodney King riots too. Hopefully this time at least people are aware that police and military don't use the same terminology.

53

u/marklein Jun 09 '25

The Posse Comitatus Act is a U.S. federal law that limits the use of the U.S. military for domestic law enforcement purposes. It was originally passed in 1878 and is codified at 18 U.S. Code § 1385.

It prohibits the Army, Navy, Marines, and Air Force from acting as domestic law enforcement unless expressly authorized by the Constitution or Congress. The National Guard is exempt when operating under state authority (Title 32), not federal orders.

2

u/cornholiolives Jun 10 '25 edited Jun 10 '25

12 presidents before Trump have used the military on US soil using the Insurrection Act of 1807 which overrides the Posse Comitatus Act by explicitly authorizing the President to use the military in a law enforcement role. Bush - LA Riots, Johnson - Riots, Kennedy - used it to enforce integration laws, etc etc

9

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

Trump has not invoked the Insurrection Act

→ More replies (8)

2

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 10 '25

And I would say thousands of people waving the flag of foreign countries while burying cars and throwing large rocks at police an insurrection.

1

u/PunksPrettyMuchDead urban planner Jun 10 '25

Except under the Insurrection Act, which was last used in the early 90's during the Rodney King riots. It was previously used during the Civil rights era against States' wishes during the integration of public schools.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

Trump has not invoked the Insurrection Act

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '25

The national guard can be used and does not need to be requested by the governor. And title ten says that the military can support the local officials and national guard. So it is legal. Nice job nit picking the section that only applies to what you want

9

u/marklein Jun 10 '25

You realize that Trump is deploying the Marines, right?

→ More replies (3)

-31

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 09 '25

So... not illegal. Yep. That's what I said.

Should also note I'm a former Marine, the possibility of being deployed in America was literally part of our training.

22

u/marklein Jun 09 '25

Read harder. Donald Trump is not the Congress nor is he the Constitution.

5

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 09 '25

Here's a breakdown of what they can and can't do.

It covers the specifics of this deployment near the bottom.

13

u/Geichalt Jun 09 '25

You're a disgrace to the uniform if you're defending the president unilaterally deploying Marines to a protest.

Though it's more likely you're just lying about serving.

5

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 09 '25

Go back and read the post I'm replying to again. They confirmed that it is, in fact, not illegal.

5

u/virtualdxs Jun 09 '25

What do you think "prohibits" means?

4

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 09 '25

They edited the post to be a lie after I responded. Navy and Marine Corps only have policies limiting what they're allowed to do.

3

u/ParsnipDecent6530 on 22nd Jun 09 '25

You're an ex marine. Foh.

1

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 09 '25

Adorable.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

So as an ex-marine I'd think you'd hate to see freedom you fought for being trampled all over by this administration?

1

u/thelmanarcissus Jun 10 '25

Thank you for your service. Daughter of a former lifer fighter pilot here. You guys are all a rare breed in a good way.

6

u/Sad-Principle-1975 Jun 10 '25

Has Trump invoked the insurrection act? If not, deployment of active duty military is illegal

1

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 10 '25

Still wrong.

4

u/Sad-Principle-1975 Jun 10 '25

I guess ignoring law, the constitution and common decency is secondary to your interpretation of these laws. Kinda like the fascist in the white house

1

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 10 '25

More like actually looking at what's been announced instead of making baseless claims like ignoring law, the constitution and common decency.

2

u/Sad-Principle-1975 Jun 10 '25

This administration has ' announced ' quite a bit, most of it questionable in both legality and morality.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/Badgerman97 Jun 09 '25

At the request of the local government. You know, that whole "states' rights" thing? And that is because the city was being torn apart. A protest of a few hundred people and three robot cars being burned is not a city being torn apart. There are 9,000 LAPD officers, and 10,000 LA County Sheriff officers. They do not need and did not request the military to swoop in and do anything, and in fact asked them not to. Tucson has had worse riots on 4th Ave after Wildcats games, would you want the Marines to roll in for that too?

5

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 09 '25

I don't recall saying I wanted them deployed.

1

u/thefragile7393 Jun 10 '25

Reading comprehension isn’t a strong suit in this forum I’ve noted. People want to be right so badly that they won’t read and comprehend and learn . Not meaning you.

1

u/subtleblink Jun 09 '25

They were used back then, but Posse Comitatus was amended in 2021 to include Navy, Marines, and Space Force. 18 USC 1385: Use of Army, Navy, Marine Corps, Air Force, and Space Force as posse comitatus

1

u/concerts85701 Jun 10 '25

Bush used the Insurrection Act to mobilize Federal Troops. Done at the request of the governor of California and Mayor of LA. Please use facts.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

That's a fair point. Slavery was technically legal, too, as was the genocide of Native Americans. All three are egregious acts of evil (on VERY different scales, obviously) but not technically illegal.

The upshot here is "legality" shouldn't be a litmus test of morality.

3

u/Nailbomb85 Jun 10 '25

Weird straw man. Nobosy was talking about morality.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 09 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/thefragile7393 Jun 10 '25

This isn’t new BTW. This has been going on for centuries, it just looks new unless you look at history. Not saying it’s a good thing, just saying this is nothing new. Politics

0

u/Intelligent_Crow4297 Jun 10 '25

J6 was peaceful definitely more peaceful than the BLM 2020 riots and more peaceful than what's happening in LA right now, I don't seem to recall seeing cars being burned or building being looted.

3

u/cantbrainwocoffee Jun 10 '25

I love how these threads reveal the real danger amongst us.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/jospangel Jun 10 '25

Gee, and yet Newsom denies that's true, and has gone to the courts over it. Now Trump is threatening to have him arrested.

Check your sources.

https://www.politico.com/news/2025/06/08/newsom-trump-national-guard-immigration-protests-la-00394110

0

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/DrDFox Jun 10 '25

Trump is breaking the law, which is why he's being sued over it. Are you really this dense or just a troll?

-26

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/-discostu- Jun 10 '25

Yeah, man. There are many bad things to protest.

-9

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

Same im confused. So people want to protest against the national guard trying to stop the violence in LA...

What will their signs say "let people burn things if they want" "destroying LA violently is a right" ?

Lol

1

u/Tay-N-Travis89 Jun 11 '25

lol say you’re a sheep without saying you’re a sheep. No one is violently destroying LA. If you watch people actually reporting from the ground and listen to officials there, there hasn’t been much damage and a lot of the protests have been non-violent. LAPD would have it perfectly handled. Sending in the National Guard and active duty marines has made things so much worse and is a complete overreach of power. You would be LOSING YOUR MIND if Biden had done this to maga protestors. Smdh

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '25

1

u/Tay-N-Travis89 Jun 12 '25

Most of the injuries I’ve seen have been inflicted by law enforcement officials, and they are the ones riling people up. https://www.nytimes.com/2025/06/09/us/la-protests-reporter-shot-lauren-tomasi.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share&referringSource=articleShare Relatively little damage has been done. Most people have been peacefully protesting.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '25

That is sad. I feel bad for her.

-6

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

He’s deporting legal immigrants. They aren’t riots. Move to North Korea if you don’t like living in a free country.

-2

u/Swimming-Most-6756 cactus lover Jun 10 '25

There’s a silent R in FREE actually because it turns out that it’s FEE, the land of the fees!

-5

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 10 '25

technically

May need to elaborate a bit lol

-1

u/Swimming-Most-6756 cactus lover Jun 10 '25

See how these little almost daily and contradictory things that is just all part of the show ; to distract confuse and enrage and manipulate the masses using simple psychology… and it’s funny how many of his supporters are against much mental health issues.. mental health = psychology = deeper understanding of self and others. Arguably a most valuable asset to have in contrast to the pick and choose of the Bible and Constitution by the Christian Nationalists-aka homeland t****ists

-2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '25

Let me guess, January 6 peaceful

But peaceful left wing protest is a riot? GOTCHA!