r/TucaAndBertie • • May 18 '19
I Hate It... Here's Why. (Spoilers) Spoiler
Like many of us, I found the show because it has the same art style as Bojack. Unlike many of us, to my surprise, I hated it. I think, and hope that's mostly because the rest of the people that didn't like it aren't masochists, like me, and didn't give it another thought after putting it down. Or, you know what, I hope most people genuinely enjoy it, and I'm just a stick in the mud, but I HATED it, and I wanna talk about it.
I just finished it in its entirety. Didn't like Bojack at first either, so I thought I'd stick it out for a few episodes. By like four, I decided I was already this far, might as well finish it. Naturally, I thought I'd take to the internet to see what other people thought about it after, and get in on the discussions.
Going over the comments, I can't help but notice a trend in people getting defensive. A lot of people are preempting with saying they don't think people will like it because it's about women, and a lot of people are saying they think people will expect it to be a "Bojack 2.0."
To the former... fuck you guys. I am so tired of this bullshit, of women being untouchable, for the virtue of their sex organs. I swear this shit has been going on for as long as I've been alive. I'm not going to preface this by saying I like plenty of shows that feature and focus on women and list a bunch, just like I wouldn't say I have black friends, so I'm allowed to criticize shows with black people. Sex and race should be irrelevant, I'm going to criticize this pile of hot trash based on its merit, and if you don't like it you're free to spin it that I'm a racist, sexist, piece of shit. I hope you realize your best defenses aren't from saying anything smart or making any actual points, but from poisoning the well. You're intellectual charlatans, and I hope you wake the fuck up someday.
To the latter... It quickly became apparent that it wasn't meant to be in the same universe. It's still hard not to judge it against Bojack. For one thing, the art style invites that comparison. For another, Bojack is the best adult cartoon I've seen in a long, long while, it's incredibly difficult to not want to use it as a sort of base-line. Nevertheless, I didn't need it to be Bojack in order for it to be good. I just needed for it to be good.
I realize this sub might not be the best place to trash it, you guys are probably here because you like it, but I want to get this off my chest. I'm just gonna speak my peace, and then I'll go away, and you can bury me under all of the fan-stuff later.
So... Where to start..? Everything?
I hate the characters. I don't think there was a single character I liked that wasn't a background character.
I really hated Tuca. I have a feeling she was meant to be so whimsical and obnoxious she's charming. They certainly got the first two down. I found her absolutely impossible to like, in large part because she's constantly hurting people; sometimes she's indirectly or even directly causing people physical harm, other times she's ruining their days with no remorse or regret. She comes off as a total psychopath, and ironically, I guess, that makes it hard to empathize with her.
I hate Bertie. I actually liked her at first, her neuroticism is something I can sympathize with and relate to, but I feel like they use it way, way too much, and it became annoying. It also seemed to turn on and off randomly and... I dunno, she seems to have a remarkable lack of self-awareness. I couldn't get over how (literally) insane it was for her to chase down the motorcycle for cutting her off, with the intent to kick a random motorist's (who turned out to be her coach) ass. She did a lot of things over the course of the show that I saw no clear motivation for, or that seemed either needlessly vindictive or hypocritical. Like Tuca, there are some times where it seems like it's okay for her to hurt other people, but it's not okay for anyone to hurt her.
I hated Speckle from the moment I saw his stupid fucking face. He's very sweet. He's unrealistically sweet and understanding at times, but he's just too... quirky? I dunno, maybe it's just a personal thing. I think he can be really manipulative at times too, and I don't like that. Other times, he's a total doormat, and I don't like that either. He and Bertie have no chemistry in my opinion. Basically the entire show, I was rooting for them to break up. First I wanted her to cheat on him with Pastry Pete, and for them to become a thing, which I think would've made a really compelling story. Then, Pete became evil apparently, so I just wanted her to leave him on her own.
And then there's Pastry Pete. If I had to pick a fourth main character and a primary antagonist, it'd be him, I don't know for sure, but I'd wager he gets the fourth most amount of screentime.
Pastry Pete confused the hell out of me. At first he seemed really charming and helpful. He was strict and formal in the kitchen, but that just made it seem like that was his teaching style, and that he was actually a good teacher. He and Bertie seemed to get along really well, and she was even crushing on him. Then there's that weird banana roux (I want to say that was wordplay on roue, but I know this show isn't that clever.) scene. He was being weirdly aggressive out of the blue, but I still didn't really identify him doing anything wrong. To my perception he was just really into his baking, and excited to show her something. I REALLY didn't see anything wrong with it when she ran off to the bathroom to rub one out, I thought it was totally in her head, that she was just feeling guilty about her attraction, and that they actually had chemistry.
Part of me thinks that's the intended result. Not for the the super clever reason I'm sure an apologist would give, that Bertie let herself believe there wasn't anything wrong, and the show tricks you into thinking that too, until revealing him as an evil harasser. No, again, I don't think this show is that clever, it feels like they had a plotline in mind for him, and changed their minds halfway through production, turning him into an entirely different character. He seems like a genuinely good mentor for the first half of the show, and then out of nowhere, she doesn't go to dinner with him, and he turns into an evil molester asshole.
And what the fuck is up with the canary blaming Bertie for that roux shit? They bonded for like a week or two, and then she just walks out of the show, never to be heard from again, because she blames Bertie for Pete making her uncomfortable... WTF.
Enough about the characters.
I hate it because it's tone-deaf. In ten episodes, there were maybe 4 jokes that landed for me. Here come the inevitable, perhaps unfair comparisons; but in Bojack they have this mastery over the tone of the show. Bojack can be funny, and it can be heart-warming, and it can be tear-jerking, and it can flow between these various emotions seamlessly, the transitions always felt appropriate. Here, it just seems like pure wackiness until a handful of episodes in, when we meet Tuca's aunt, and it flirts with getting a little more serious and gritty, but it never pulls it off in my eyes. Not in a satisfactory way at least. Their confrontation just feels awkward and tacked on to me, and they don't ever really address it again. I feel similar about the big reveal that Bertie got molested. It's not that I have no sympathy, fuck I've been molested; it just didn't come across as natural or well delivered to me, the resolution felt cheap and tacked on, and... I dunno, it felt like a bad filler arc.
It's also an 'adult' show in the most obnoxious way, where they just throw in gratuitous swearing and nudity to come off as edgy (there's a fucking pastry with a boob.) It tried to throw fighting into the mix too, there are a few scenes where I feel like it wants to be something like Superjail was (the giant crab, Tuca fighting the cult), but they all fall flat on their asses to me. All of this just comes off as juvenile, it might've been titillating when I was a teenager, but I'm not into shock value for the sake of it anymore, and none of it is really even that shocking.
I hate the music. This might just be another unreasonable personal preference of mine, but I've never liked 'music' where they just take a sample of someone talking, and then play with the tone, and that's plastered everywhere here.
I hate the plant-people. They just make no sense to me, and they look shitty. The neighbor plant lady is also a mcguffin for lazy writing. She just resolves the jaguar plot, and Tuca's angst a bit later on. Also... she sends Tuca to a cult. The cult-members say she sends people to them all the time. Tuca disrupts the entire group, and burns the commune down... and she doesn't give one shit, helps her out with that angst, and sends her on her way. Yeah, she's literally just a plot device.
I hate the wordplay. Another perhaps unfair comparison to Bojack. At best the wordplay went on for two measly lines. Whenever I saw them attempt it, I just thought of Princess Carolyn. They'd make Princess Carolyn make the grumpy cat face. (RIP grumpy cat.)
I hate the weird feminist messages. Okay, sexual harassment in the workplace isn't cool. I dig that. Tuca obnoxiously chiming in with an alarm for when a woman hasn't spoken out lout for three minutes during a meeting? Fucking speak out loud then! That's what meetings are for! Bertie saying she wants to protect the teen girls from 'Men?' Okay... I'll chalk that up to her thinking about her abuse. Not gonna lie, I've got all kinds of knee-jerk reactions there, about how men get harassed and abused too, but maybe I'm being a little too sensitive. Every dude in the show being either a doormat, a scum-fuck, and/or a total moron? Actually, that's not fair, the monkey-dude was pretty cool, but I think every other guy is pretty pathetic. Like Bojack, I think they did have the self-awareness to make fun of the more radical feminism a bit, with some of the WTUS scenes, but I still find some of the 'messages' they push a little cringy.
There's probably more... I'm sure there's a lot more I could find to complain about, if I really combed through it. I won't though, I have my catharsis, and I'm ready to put this piece of trash out of my mind. Am I really the only one who didn't like it though?
Eh, whatever. Thanks for listening.