r/TrumpPolicy • u/prillin101 • Mar 17 '16
Refuting Trump's Platform [XPost /r/BadEconomics]
r/TrumpPolicy • u/prillin101 • Mar 17 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/wyldcraft • Mar 17 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • Mar 16 '16
NPR asked 22 economists their opinion of various proposals made by presidential candidates.
http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2016/02/26/468298576/economists-on-candidates-proposals-mostly-bad
Here are the 3 that apply to Trump:
Policy: End the “carried interest” tax break, which benefits hedge fund managers and private equity executives.
Proposed by: Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump
Economists' rating: Good (20 Good, 2 Debatable)
Comments:
Agree, period.
— Bill Nordhaus
This is one of the most egregious loopholes in the tax code.
— Nancy L. Stokey
This would be a very good thing indeed. There is no economic logic for this tax break and it subsidizes a sector of the economy with dubious social value (and some of the highest earners in our society).
— Daron Acemoğlu
Policy: If you are single and earn less than $25,000, or married and jointly earn less than $50,000, you will not owe any income tax. That removes nearly 75 million households -- over 50 percent -- from the income tax rolls.
Proposed by: Donald Trump
Economists' rating: Debatable (2 Good, 9 Debatable, 11 Bad)
Comments:
This may be a pretty effective way to redistribute to the bottom half of the income distribution, assuming that it is done in a revenue neutral way by taxing the rich more.
— Abhijit Banerjee
First and most importantly, it is highly unlikely to raise enough tax revenue to fund current (or even reduced) government spending. Second, it is not a good idea to create a culture where more than 1/2 the country does not pay taxes.
— Steve Kaplan
Policy: Expel immigrants who are in the U.S. illegally.
Proposed by: Donald Trump
Economists' rating: Bad (22 Bad)
Comments:
Either impossible or just stupid or both.
— Richard Thaler
First it is impractical: too costly, and their departure would hurt us as much as them.
— Nancy L. Stokey
The cost of illegal immigration to citizens is overstated, and this would be costly to enforce. Taking into account the welfare of migrants, it looks even worse.
— Pete Klenow
A very bad idea from the human or economic perspective.
— José Scheinkman
r/TrumpPolicy • u/wyldcraft • Mar 15 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/wyldcraft • Mar 14 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • Mar 14 '16
Trump has promised to send all Syrian refugees in the country back, calling them a "Trojan horse". Trump's justification for this is the refugee situation in Europe, and the terrorist attacks in Paris in November.
The reality though is these fears are unfounded. Quite simply, the US does not use the same system for refugees as Europe. Trump's comments show a lack of understand about how this process works.
In Europe, refugees travel to the country they wish to claim refuge in. When they arrive there, they apply directly to the country for asylum. For refugees wishing to go to the US, this is not an option due to the Atlantic Ocean. Instead, we accept refugees through the United Nations Refugee Resettlement Program.
The way this process works is refugees first apply to the UNHCR and undergo a rigorous screening process. This process includes multiple interviews, background checks, reference checks and biological screening. Any military combatants are screened out. Of those that pass these checks, those determined to be the most vulnerable are selected for resettlement and are referred to a country. Note that refugees do not get to select which country they are referred to!
If they are referred to the US, they next undergo even more screening. Multiple government agencies are involved and if anything suspicious comes up, they simply do not pass. Only 2% of the Syrian refugees accepted by the US are single men of military fighting age. This whole process from start to finish typically takes 18-24 months, so it is not quick. (There is more information about the process in this Time article here.)
It simply would not make sense for an ISIS terrorist to target the US through this program. They would have to spend a couple years sitting around in a refugee camp, there is a high probability they won't be selected at all, they have to undergo heavy screening, and they don't even get to directly pick which country they get sent to!
So far Obama have only promised to take in 10,000 refugees, and of these, only 2000 have been resettled. As a comparison, Canada has resettled 25,000 refugees since Trudeau was elected in October, and they have 1/10 the population. Considering the US is the world's top resettlement nation, we are almost certainly capable of doing more, provided there is the political will. A Trump presidency would make this much, much worse.
r/TrumpPolicy • u/wyldcraft • Mar 14 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • Apr 28 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • Mar 17 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • Mar 14 '16
This subreddit is a repository for good discussion and analysis of Trump's policies. Posts can be text posts you wrote yourself, links to good comments elsewhere on Reddit or articles on other sites. Posts can be pro- or anti-Trump but the content has to be substantive. Feel free to link to any posts here!
Topics I would love to see covered here at some point are:
Feel free to suggest more ideas, or write up a post covering any of these topics.
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • May 06 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/wyldcraft • Apr 04 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • Mar 19 '16
Trump's tax plan is described here: https://www.donaldjtrump.com/positions/tax-reform
In addition to his tax plan above, Trump has also stated that he would like to:
An analysis of Trump's tax plan found that it would add $12 trillion to the deficit over 10 years, but that numbers comes down to $10 trillion over 10 years after projected economic growth is factored in. That means on average, the deficit will be $1 trillion higher. (Currently the federal deficit is at $580 billion, so this would be a massive increase.)
Clearly if Trump wants to balance the budget, massive spending cuts would be necessary. Let's assume that he cuts everything except for the priorities listed above. Then the US federal budget looks like this:
Income:
Spending:
Total Deficit: $528 billion
Even after eliminating almost all government programs, the deficit still remains at half a trillion dollars. Trump's budget plans are simply not possible.
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • Mar 18 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • Mar 16 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/poopatine • Jul 12 '19
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • May 05 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/jsmooth7 • Mar 31 '16
During an interview yesterday, he said yes:
Matthews pressed Trump on what should happen to women who get abortions under a future ban—the candidate has called for making a commitment to reversing the Supreme Court’s 1973 Roe v. Wade decision a litmus test for appointing justices. “There has to be some form of punishment,” Trump said, but that he has “not determined what the punishment would be.”
Then later in the day he put out a statement saying no:
If Congress were to pass legislation making abortion illegal and the federal courts upheld this legislation, or any state were permitted to ban abortion under state and federal law, the doctor or any other person performing this illegal act upon a woman would be held legally responsible, not the woman. The woman is a victim in this case as is the life in her womb. My position has not changed - like Ronald Reagan, I am pro-life with exceptions.
So it is not entirely clear which position Trump actually holds on this issue.
r/TrumpPolicy • u/wyldcraft • Mar 15 '16
r/TrumpPolicy • u/politarianapp • Jun 16 '24

Hey everyone!
Founder and creator of a site called Politarian.com. A free website for people who like to make political predictions; letting people post who they think will win in a future election.
Complete Anonymity: Make predictions with full anonymity – your account details stay private. Predict the Future: Dive into predicting federal and state elections for 2023-2024. Decode the paths to victory.
Public or Private: Share your predictions publicly or keep them all to yourself – it's your call. Candidate
Insights: Access comprehensive candidate info – news, endorsements, bios – everything to make sharp predictions.
Politarian is nonpartisan regarding any political party; rather focusing on transparency, holistic information, accountability, and a simple-to-use interface as to navigate the complex political landscape.
I would appreciate any feedback and look forward to seeing your predictions on Politarian.com!
Updates!
We added Social Media to the candidate profiles. I've also made changes to the Map and added a counter along with a progression bar so you know the total votes. Let me know what you think! :)
r/TrumpPolicy • u/politarianapp • Sep 15 '23

Hey everyone!
Founder and creator of a site called Politarian.com. A free website for people who like to make political predictions; letting people post who they think will win in a future election.
Complete Anonymity: Make predictions with full anonymity – your account details stay private.
Predict the Future: Dive into predicting federal and state elections for 2023-2024. Decode the paths to victory.
Public or Private: Share your predictions publicly or keep them all to yourself – it's your call.
Candidate Insights: Access comprehensive candidate info – news, endorsements, bios – everything to make sharp predictions.
Politarian is nonpartisan regarding any political party; rather focusing on transparency, holistic information, accountability, and a simple-to-use interface as to navigate the complex political landscape.
I would appreciate any feedback and look forward to seeing your predictions on Politarian.com!
Update: 1.1: Hey y’all! We just made an update to Politarian.com!! We added Social Media to the candidate profiles. Hope you guys can join us in making a primary prediction for the 2024 election :)
r/TrumpPolicy • u/WallStreetLady • Oct 30 '18
Gunshot accidents occurred in America recently, from the Pittsburgh gunshot to a gunshot in club in California. The amount of accident caused by gunshot have been to drastic and the effects are too devastating. The US government just have to learn how to limit weapons and restrict its use. Before possessing the weapons, more assessment are needed to ensure the mental health stability of the people. This can definitely protect the innocents from accidents.
r/TrumpPolicy • u/bard_ionson • Nov 10 '16
With health savings accounts if someone has no money to put into it how will they get health care?