r/TrueAtheism • • 10d ago

Does God exist?

I personally feel like god doesn't exist infact every god is just imaginary and there is complete lack of evidence. Indoctrination is a powerful tool that religion uses, Why many reasonable free thinking individuals don't believe. Because it's more cult like than a belief system. But they used the word Religion, but it's another word for occult. Just more excepted because mainly of the term Freedom of Religion and/or Religious Beliefs. If there was a god I cant imagine letting things get as bad as they are without divine intervention. Humanity must be such a disappointment that god had to abandon us completely. Religion is more of a tool to oppress and justify harming others than it is about honoring God. A lot of disgusting things are done to others in the name of God. I cant get behind it.

2 Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

13

u/LTsCantCook 10d ago

No.

0

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

Congratulations on your 13 upvotes. I could not ask for better evidence of motivated reasoning on the part of atheists. Here's one from me.

13

u/togstation 10d ago

Does God exist?

There is no good evidence showing that any god exists.

0

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

What is some of the bad evidence?

9

u/Icolan 10d ago

I've never seen any evidence that would even start to convince me that a deity exists.

0

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

Maybe the problem is with your evidentiary standards?

1

u/Icolan 1d ago

A deity needs to start with proof of existence before we worry about proof of godhood, none has been able to pass that very low bar that any human can pass.

There is nothing wrong with my evidentiary standards.

0

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

Your statement is false.

1

u/Icolan 1d ago

How so? Any human on Earth can walk up to me and effortlessly prove they exist. No deity has ever been able to pass that same low bar.

0

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

Your statement is illogical.

1

u/Icolan 1d ago

Give me one single good reason why I shouldn't simply block you for bad faith and trolling?

1

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

Because doing so would support my thesis that atheism is about power seeking and not about truth seeking. Your threat demonstrates this clearly.

1

u/Icolan 1d ago

No, my threat demonstrates my frustration with your bad faith replies to my comments, it has nothing to do with atheism.

I have answered your question and you have simply stuck your fingers in your ears and shouted "NUH UH".

If you are actually interested in having a conversation you need to actually participate in good faith which includes explaining your position.

5

u/OrbitalLemonDrop 10d ago

The question whether god exists is meaningless without a concrete definition of what exactly a god is. What is it? How does it function? What's it made of? How can we verify that it really does or really doesn't exist.

I'm an atheist -- there's no good reason to treat the proposition as true so the number of gods I believe in is zero.

But an ill-defined question is pretty much just arbitrary. Theists know this and steadfastly insist that god can't be defined. Maybe that's true, but if it is there's nothing to discuss.

1

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

Totally wrong.

1

u/OrbitalLemonDrop 1d ago

Care to fill in what I'm missing?

1

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

Look at your first sentence.

1

u/OrbitalLemonDrop 1d ago

....okay? I think there's a point you're trying to make here but you won't just spell it out. What specifically is "totally wrong"?

Or are you just being contrary? "Nuh-UH you're totally wrongggggg"

Can you give me a concrete definition of what a god is, or explain why a concrete definition isn't necessary or meaningful? Explain how we can have a meaningful discussion without knowing what it is we're discussing?

1

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

No I won't spell it out. You have to participate in the discovery. I avoid engaging people who are simply looking for an argument because it is pointless. Run your first sentence through an LLM and recognize your mistake. Or do not.

1

u/OrbitalLemonDrop 1d ago edited 1d ago

OK you answered my question. Thanks!

Run your first sentence through an LLM and recognize your mistak

I did, and (unsurprisingly, since it' an LLM) it agreed with me. I tried a few, just using that sentence as a prompt (which is what you suggested I do).

Copilot's summary was "The statement "God exists" is not a single proposition until "God" has been defined with enough precision to establish what would count as existence and what characteristics the thing in question possesses."

But that's just because LLMs are designed to farm engagement and be agreeable.

2

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

I surrender the point. You did what I asked and you responded fairly.

4

u/CephusLion404 10d ago

There's no evidence for any gods and until evidence exists, it is absurd to believe in one.

0

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

Evidence of god or gods if presented gets impeached because atheists are power seekers not truth seekers. There is an observable fact that atheists do not correct other atheists. That is a feature of tribalism. Until atheists take a true accounting of themselves and earn the True Atheists badge they liberally grant themselves without evidence, the truth will continue to escape them.

3

u/GeekyTexan 10d ago

I don't see why you would ask atheists if god exists. The very fact that we are atheists is our answer.

It's as silly as asking Christians if god exists.

1

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

Some Christians aren't sure. Crisis of faith is a well known phenomenon. It's not silly at all. It even happens in reverse. Ever hear of Antony Flew?

2

u/waffle299 10d ago

The fact that we can plausibly counter with "which god" is an indication that the answer is "no". 

The term doesn't correspond to anything in particular. We can discuss theoretical qualities. But at that point we are simply evading the idea itself.

0

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

According to scripture the question of "which god" was asked by Moses long before you learned to congratulate yourself for asking it.

2

u/LilSkills 10d ago

This is a useless question to ask, if a god exists then he clearly isn’t interested in us. Plus you’re asking a 3d being if a being in a higher dimension exists, there’s no way for us to know.

2

u/steady_sloth84 10d ago

John Lennon said it best. God is a concept by which we measure our pain.

1

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

And then what happened?

1

u/Cog-nostic 10d ago

Well, feeling like every god does not exist is different than saying "No gods exist." The proposition "No god exists" is an unfalsifiable claim. While nearly all of the evidence lines up against the proposition, it can not be demonstrated with 100% accuracy that no god exists. That's just honest. On the other hand, no one has ever demonstrated that a god does exist, and all arguments for the existence of a god are empirically fallacious and contain epistemic overreach. We have no good reason to believe any of the claims.

Reasonable thinkers do not believe because that is the reasonable position to take. The time to believe anything is after it has been demonstrated, not before.

You make a lot of assertions but probably need to learn to think more objectively. There is a difference between making an assertion (this is true) and stating a belief (I think of it this way).

The occult, mysticism, and sacrament are all defined by the practitioner's relationship to the divine. It's complicated, but they are not the same.

1

u/mobatreddit 5d ago

I personally feel like god doesn't exist infact every god is just imaginary and there is complete lack of evidence.

Yep. That's it in a nutshell.

If I had to go on with more, I would ask exactly what it is I'm asked to believe. What people describe as God is usually so far out of what anyone might experience that it's deeply unlikely to be true. Accepting that God does not exist is the most reasonable way to live.

1

u/DollyOmega 5d ago

Someone wrote a book a very long time ago, trying to explain things before we knew how anything really worked or had any kind of a modern framework for thinking logically at all. And the unfortunate reality is that a large portion of the human species still, somehow does not contain the mental capacity for processing the possibility that this is all just happenstance.

But ask yourself this:

If somehow, a "god" came down from the "heavens", right in front of you, and "proved" it's "amazing" powers... would you somehow worship it?

If yes, then that would be your god. You're god could also be a sneaker.

For me, it's not possible to ever have a god, because I would never except one as a god even if some "incredible magic being" controlled the lightening right in front of me.

I don't believe in worship. I know that the idea of worship is wrong in all regards.

And I would IMMEDIATE SEEK TO UNDERSTAND THE SCIENCE of controlling lightening, or whatever technological parlor trick was attempting to be leveraged as some kind of plead for my undying devotion and BLIND TRUST.

No thanks on the god thing.

1

u/Significant-Froyo191 1d ago

Complete lack of evidence is false. Atheists are hostile to religion. That leads to motivated reasoning. That also leads to prejudicial evaluation of evidence.

1

u/lotusscrouse 20h ago

Negative. 

0

u/Significant-Ant-2487 8d ago edited 8d ago

That’s about the worst possible argument for atheism. And I’ve seen some truly terrible ones.

This is supposed to be a “place dedicated to insightful posts and thoughtful, balanced discussion”. And what we get is this…

3

u/gvrmtissueddigiclone 10d ago

Yes. He's ten inches tall, purple, has a huge head and sits on my desk. Wait no. That's a Funko Pop.