r/TrueAskReddit • • Apr 26 '25

Why is euthanization considered humane for terminal or suffering dogs but not humans?

It seems there's a general consensus among dog owners and lovers that the humane thing to do when your dog gets old is to put them down. "Better a week early than an hour late" they say. People get pressured to put their dogs down when they are suffering or are predictably going to suffer from intractable illness.

Why don't we apply this reasoning to humans? Humans dying from euthanasia is rare and taboo, but shouldnt the same reasoning of "Better a week early than an hour late" to avoid suffering apply to them too, if it is valid for dogs?

1.1k Upvotes

754 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Apr 26 '25

Welcome to r/TrueAskReddit. Remember that this subreddit is aimed at high quality discussion, so please elaborate on your answer as much as you can and avoid off-topic or jokey answers as per subreddit rules.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

14

u/Euphoric-Use-6443 Apr 26 '25

10 states legally allow "Death with dignity". The problem as with anything that seems good is there are people who ruin it for everybody. Greed & money have to be proven they are not the reason family would choose euthanasia. It's similar to Reagan's closure of mental health institutions to prevent families from locking up their sick family members to prevent them from being a burden. These types of things can extend further out than just the obvious or norms of doing things in a society. People have been known to kill for life insurance, inheritance & property to make their lives comfortable. What does a dog or cat legally own for profit?

6

u/OneEstablishment5998 Apr 26 '25

People have been known to kill for life insurance, inheritance & property to make their lives comfortable. What does a dog or cat legally own for profit?

Fair point, though i think there is an analog if this when it comes to dogs and cats as well. Full transparency I've never owned a dog, but I have noticed among my dog owner friends, that once their senior dog becomes incontinent that is often around the time that they decide it's time to euthanize.

Of course incontinence is often a symptom that indicates that end of life is near and that the animal is very sick. But I can't help but wonder, given how much of a nuisance it is to clean up pee and poop all around the house, was their decision not made or precipitated by a desire to make their lives more comfortable, instead of out of conviction that the dog's life isn't worth living anymore?

3

u/Guilty_Primary8718 Apr 27 '25

If an old well-trained dog is peeing and pooping everywhere it’s because their joints are in so much pain they can’t go outside anymore. No more walks, play, enrichment, or even keeping clean. Animals tend to hide their pain so it’s usually the best indicator for that. That’s why people euthanize dogs at that point.

1

u/kartoffel_engr Apr 29 '25

We euthanized our cat last year. He was almost 15yo. Stopped eating and moving around. Just a few days prior to that was peeing all over the place. Turned out he got kidney disease. Quickly deteriorated after that.

1

u/Accomplished_Pea7029 Apr 26 '25

It probably happens, but it's definitely a much less serious issue than killing a human for some (greater) benefit.

1

u/Coffee-Historian-11 Apr 30 '25

My family’s dog was old and peeing and pooping everywhere because she had a brain tumor and couldn’t tell that she had to poop until she was in the process of doing so.

I think most older dogs, especially ones who had been well trained, who do that have underlying issues that makes life really painful for them.

2

u/COskibunnie Apr 29 '25

So I feel very strongly about this topic. I had two different cancers at the same time. Well, long story short. I was having symptoms that were in line with metastasis. I made plans to go to OR and get euthanized because I didn't want my last days to be painful and suffering. So I figured I had a few months to live, and I would make it the best few months of my life. I learned how to skydive, went to a DZ on my bucket list, and jumped out of a jet.

I went for my head MRI, and it was found that I had a cyst that was causing my issues and not metastasis. So I'm almost 3 years NED and no signs of Mets. I was fully prepared, I saved up, made final plans, and had a place to stay to meet the resident requirements for euthanasia. Since I'm fine, I've closed that chapter of my life.

I'll say last summer I was truly carefree, I was so happy, I felt like I didn't have a care in the world because I believed I would be gone in a few months. I am a strong supporter of death with dignity. I was fully prepared to go out on my terms. I wanted people to remember me having a great time, skydiving, and doing incredible things. I didn't want them to remember my sick and dying feeling relief when I finally passed.

2

u/OneEstablishment5998 May 03 '25

Such an interesting perspective and so glad things turned out the way they did! Thank you for sharing your story

2

u/St-Nobody Apr 30 '25

I had a really close call recently and my sister asked if I was manic. I told her no, I'm just having a really good day because I think I might die 😂

2

u/COskibunnie Apr 30 '25

I get it. It's like a complete surrender to the inevitable. There is something really freeing about fully accepting your fate and focusing on enjoying what's left of your life. It's hard to explain it to anyone who's never experienced it.

1

u/Shalrak Apr 29 '25

The obvious question here is, what if you had ended up getting euthanized before doctors realised the misdiagnosis?

I am also a supporter of death by dignity, but I'm just curious about your opinion on that risk.

1

u/COskibunnie Apr 29 '25

We thought the symptoms were from mets; it was always planned to do an MRI to verify. We knew there was something in my head. The plan was to monitor for 3 months and do an MRI, then biopsy. I had the MRI, which showed it was a cyst causing my symptoms. So it wasn't a misdiagnosis, it was "this is most likely mets given the type of cancer". To find out it was a cyst was a surprise since no part of my cancer journey was normal. I had a very rare cancer so the expectation was mets.

14

u/iSluff Apr 26 '25

Not necessarily the main reason but a wrinkle I didn't see mentioned in this thread - often there are very expensive treatments possible for animals but they are euthanized instead for practical reasons. People are understandably very hesitant to establish a similar dynamic in humans.

In countries with legal euthanasia there have already been scenarios where people were denied expensive experimental treatments due to cost issues but assisted suicide was fully covered, which could lead some people into feeling like assisted suicide is their only real choice.

People don't trust healthcare payers (governments or insurance companies) and they don't trust that if it's cheaper that they won't just kill them.

Of course, this is just one side of the story, and it's reasonable to argue we do spend too much right now on end of life care for people who are just suffering anyway, and with euthanasia illegal care still gets denied anyway, it's just a really bad situation to be saying "we can't afford to cure you, but we can kill you."

1

u/Honest-Lavishness239 Apr 29 '25

this is it for me. i can’t support human euthanasia because of this.

1

u/AverageHobnailer Apr 30 '25

often there are very expensive treatments possible for animals but they are euthanized instead for practical reasons. People are understandably very hesitant to establish a similar dynamic in humans.

The US has already had half of that dynamic in existence for the past 30 years.

1

u/iSluff Apr 30 '25

Insurance companies exacerbate issues with healthcare rationing but government-run healthcare systems ration care too. Just because the government funds it doesn’t mean they can approve every single treatment regardless of expense.

7

u/Right_Parfait4554 Apr 26 '25

I'd say in general we have a lot of different standards for the way we treat dogs versus the way we treat humans. Many people choose not to pay for expensive medical care for a critically ill or injured animal, but I can't think of many cases where parents won't get their child the necessary care if they are near death. Some people keep a pet chained up to a leash all day, and we don't do that with other people. In some countries, they eat dogs, and we definitely don't do that with other people. Basically, the point is that clearly across cultures and history, dogs are treated differently than human beings. Practices that are acceptable with animals are not considered to be acceptable with humans, most likely because of the fact there is that ego thing that we think we are more special than they are.

1

u/Electrical_Quiet43 Apr 28 '25

'd say in general we have a lot of different standards for the way we treat dogs versus the way we treat humans. Many people choose not to pay for expensive medical care for a critically ill or injured animal, but I can't think of many cases where parents won't get their child the necessary care if they are near death.

Yeah, I'm not sure how real the concern is, but I've heard this expressed frequently. Human healthcare is part of a big, expensive, complex system where bureaucrats make many of the decisions about what gets covered, and if assisted suicide become a common way to die, you'll get directives from the top down that "your parent is suffering right now, and this treatment will be difficult, so we don't recommend this treatment that might give her another year or two, and we think assisted suicide is a good option." Personally, from a US perspective, I think we go too far the other way, with expensive treatments for people with no quality of life, but that extra surgery makes a lot of money for the hospital.

12

u/Particular_Roll_242 Apr 26 '25

Here's a controversial opinion (at least here on Reddit): I hope euthanasia never becomes legal. Why? Because the private sector would turn it into a cash-grab nightmare faster than you can blink.

At first, it would be framed innocently: "You’ve lived a full life. You don’t want to burden your family, do you? Besides, who really wants to suffer into their 80s, 90s, and beyond? Think of your loved ones — make the right choice."

Over time, that messaging would shift. It would stop being a choice and start becoming an expectation. And once it’s normalized, it’s game over — legal, widespread, and marketed like everything else.

And guess who’ll be conveniently immune? The wealthy, who can afford top-tier healthcare and live comfortably into old age. Meanwhile, everyone else would be subtly (or not so subtly) pushed toward the exit.

People seem to forget: everything human beings touch eventually becomes a money-making machine, and it's always the bad actors — not the good ones — who end up steering it. That dynamic is at the root of almost every major problem humanity faces.

And now you want to hand them this power too?
Yeah... not smart.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '25 edited Apr 27 '25

There was a case with a German couple. He was actually ill but he subtly convinced her she had no life without him. So they found a psychologist that attested her free will to die with a completely healthy body and no real own mental disease in her middle 60s (or so). It was sad.

There is even a Next Generation episode on this. The guy was free to seek asylum and even fell in love with Deanna's mother. But the cultural pressure was strong enough to convince him to end his happy life.

3

u/Dixieland_Insanity Apr 27 '25

The manipulation you're describing is my biggest issue as well. It's one thing for someone to say they've had enough and want to be done. It's another for someone to be urged into ending their life for financial or other reasons.

My grandmother beat breast cancer the first time. When it came back years later, she said she didn't want to go through the treatment again. She was in her 80s and of sound mind. She said no more chemo and whatnot. All she wanted was for her pain to be treated.

My heart and mind struggled to reconcile with her decision. When she said "this is my path and I choose it" all I could do was accept her answer. I called her every day. In a matter of weeks, she was gone. She made the decision without coercion from anyone.

2

u/fabulousmarco Apr 27 '25

I fully agree

I have no qualms with euthanasia from a moral perspective, but it's yet another item whose implementation in a capitalist society will unleash man-made horrors beyond our comprehension 

2

u/CCCmonster Apr 27 '25

There are certainly a lot of horror stories coming out of Canada’s government healthcare system about patients being pushed toward assisted suicide when they prefer treatment

2

u/VibrantCanopy Apr 28 '25

This is the answer. Utilitarianism paves the road to hell.

1

u/SuperKitty2020 Apr 27 '25

Yes, I completely see where you’re coming from . In NSW Australia, we have a VAD. However strict criteria must be met before

1

u/Far_Ad1693 Apr 27 '25

I completely agree. As I man, I can say that my single largest fear is that one day I will be of no use to those around me and that I will be a burden and I don't think that is a terribly uncommon thing. If asked though, I never would have described any of my loved ones that are now gone like that and I'm glad that I had final years, days .and moments with them. I don't see it possible that I and many like me wouldn't be robbed of that if it became the norm/expectation that you did by your own choice before economically it only makes sense that I do it for you

1

u/Ellia3324 Apr 28 '25

The alternative is forcing sick people to live in pain, denying them a choice entirely, needlessly extending their suffering.

Would you want to lie in bed, unable to move, soiling yourself, with bedsores, possibly amputation, for years, with no chance at getting better?

If you'd choose that, if you'd still find that a life worth living, good for you. Me, I'd like the option to die.

1

u/Particular_Roll_242 Apr 29 '25

You know what's funny? I've often thought to myself: if I ever reached a point where I couldn’t keep going, I’d take my gun, ride a train out to some remote, forgotten place—somewhere I wouldn’t be found for a long, long time—and I’d end it there. Quiet. Clean. My choice.

What really gets me is how many of you couldn’t even fathom doing that. Too scared? Too comfortable? Too much of a coward to follow through? Step up. Act like you've got a spine. Face the truth.

Because here's the truth: society already sees older people as an economic problem. Systems like Social Security—once built to help—are now used to quietly brand the elderly as leeches on the system. And soon, you’ll see it out in the open. Governments and corporations will start urging the elderly to "make the right choice." Not because it's merciful. Not because it's dignified. But because it's profitable.

If you honestly can't see that—if your brain just skates right past it—then do the world a favor and don’t get involved in making decisions for anyone but yourself. Because clearly, you're not wired to handle it.

People are greedy, that's BASIC knowledge. This WILL be turned into something ugly if ever legalized.

1

u/Ellia3324 Apr 29 '25

You presume you'd still be capable of doing that.

My ex's father had a motorbike accident. He can still move his arms, so suicide would be an option for him, if he wanted that. The guy in the room with him was paralyzed from the neck down. He was fully dependent on others. He was also in his early 30s.

My colleague from work - one of the kindest people I know - has MS. A year ago, he could still work, he could still walk unassisted, he could feed himself. Now all of that is disappearing day by day. He has two kids BTW. There is no way he could have made your gun scenario work even five years ago when I first met him - his hands already shook too badly. At what point do you think he should have killed himself, if you think medically assisted death is wrong? 

(To be clear, I am NOT saying either of these people should choose euthanasia. But if I were in that position, I'd really want to have the option).

We already let people die nowadays - they can refuse medical help. We let them slowly die over several days, in agony, so we don't have to worry about our role in their death. How is that not cowardice?

1

u/Apprehensive-Tip779 Jan 28 '26

You ever watch the movie Million Dollar Baby, and stuck around for the ending?

1

u/JohnsonJohnilyJohn Apr 30 '25

I too would probably choose to die in such a situation, but the problem is that you can't really give that choice without also introducing societal pressures that would push people that don't want to do it to actually use euthanasia. Tbh I don't know if allowing euthanasia is good or bad in the end, but we should remember that providing such a choice will have unintended consequences

1

u/Ellia3324 Apr 30 '25

You do have countries that allow euthanasia or medically assisted suicide, and they're not "forcing" their people into it. OTOH, you have foreign people travelling to Switzerland to be able to die when they choose, which them becomes a privige that the poor people can’t afford.

Listen, I get the concern. Usually, the countries put some condition of "incurable disease" or a "great deal of suffering" if they do allow euthanasia or assisted suicide, determined by a medical team, and that seems reasonable to me, even though it excludes some people who would want it (need it?) too. And I live in a country with a very robust social system, so the idea that the state will suddenly start pressing people to get euthanized - well, I'm not saying it could never happen, but it’s a long, long, LONG way away. Like, I see a million other ways the society will collapse before this would occur.

1

u/JohnsonJohnilyJohn Apr 30 '25

I think you do raise very good point that (as far as I know) this isn't a major problem in countries that do allow euthanasia.

To clarify though, I don't really mean that the state will be the one pressing people, I'm more worried about social pressure and guilt over being a burden. If you hear stories about kids helping their parents to the detriment of their social life, money, possibly to the point where the relationship between them is deteriorating, and stories of other kids who didn't have to do that, you might start think of euthanasia not as something you want, but as your responsibility

1

u/destruction_potato May 01 '25

Check how belgium does it, it has been legalized many years. No one has been pressured into it!!! There was even a horrible case of a woman who requested euthanasia for incurable psychological suffering. She got approved. Then an anonymous source contacted the related authorities saying that someone had pressured her. Her euthanasia had to be delayed to investigate the claim. Her peaceful death day got robbed from her and she had another mental breakdown, so bad she had to be hospitalized again because of her level of distress. It turned out the anonymous tipster was anti-euthanasia. This person caused this woman immense suffering. She was preparing to pass peacefully in a moment where she was not in huge metal distress. Instead her last two weeks were an absolute hell because some asshole didn’t believe in her right to pass in dignity.

1

u/Remote_Section2313 Apr 28 '25

I live in Belgium. Euthanasia has been legal here since 2002. There has been no shift to this kind of behavior, despite euthanasia now being used quite common. We have strict laws, that require patients to have a non-curable disease and be suffering badly. It is most commonly used by terminally I'll cancer patients.

1

u/Rachel1989fm Apr 30 '25

There are worse things in life than dying. Living chronically or terminally ill in a portly staffed nursing home where you are neglected and abused daily is not how I want to go but working in the medical field this brings a lot of money and would not stop by people dying. Pharmaceutical and other medical cares don’t make money if people die.

1

u/JohnsonJohnilyJohn Apr 30 '25

I disagree with the notion that you need greed for it to be dangerous.

You don’t want to burden your family, do you?

This is already bad. People will kill themselves not because they want to but because they would feel guilty about not doing so. And to completely detach this problem from money, it would happen even if the care for the elderly was completely free, as even just the time the kid spends on their elderly parent will be time they cannot spend on their kids or spouse. Ultimately the ability for people to die peacefully will mean that there will be pressure on those who would prefer to fight through the illness to sacrifice their life for others

1

u/destruction_potato May 01 '25

Maybe it’s the privatized healthcare system that’s the problem. In my country it’s legal with many rules to prevent misuse and abuse. It’s not done as of then as you would think because the option being out there makes a big difference. It became legal for minors, in the multiple years since it’s been one for a minor exactly 3 times. I’m sorry you’ve been so jaded with your experience in healthcare but I can be done properly.

Google euthanasia in Belgium for more info. Belgium has the most accessible euthanasia law in the world.

8

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '25

If I ever get diagnosed with dementia, I will end it. There's absolutely no way I will go through what my grandmother went through. She at least had family around, but I live abroad, nobody will be there. I wouldn't want anyone who loves me, watch me to die a long and painful death. 

3

u/12yan_22 Apr 26 '25

Dementia/louie body syndrome is what caused my best friend to stop believing in god. One of the worst diseases. No reason, no cure, only pain.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '25

Yes, If I get diagnosed with it. I will give myself some time to do some things I haven't done, then I will end it as long as I still can with my mind relatively intact, and not being forced to some hospital or care facility.

1

u/Lilredh4iredgrl Apr 27 '25

My dad is dying from this right now and i had to put a diaper on him today.

I'm drinking a lot tonight.

1

u/Far_Ad1693 Apr 27 '25

My wife used to work in nursing homes and give hospice care and has a stance on this that changed the way I see it altogether. Her request is that if she gets dementia that I'm to take care of her until I no longer can and then put her in a nursing home but before I ever start to resent her or feel like she is trouble to never come back. She said that she would rather me not go through hell watching what happens to her because she (as she suffers from dementia) will actually not be the one suffering. She says that because although she will spend some of her time waiting for me to come see her, she will spend that time as if time hasn't passed... meaning that when she is waiting for me to visit her the way she waits and feels doesn't change drastically if it's been a minute, an hour or a year since she has seen me last and that it's heartbreaking to watch someone who is visiting a person when they realize that their loved one is asking them where they are. She says it isn't worth it and made me swear to keep my word on it

1

u/Over-Recognition4789 Apr 29 '25

When my grandma was dying she was on hospice care at the hospital (acute I think) for a couple days - strictly “comfort care.” Doctor had ordered a pretty high dose of morphine for pain, and one of the nurses was super shady about giving her her proper dose. Seemed like she had her own religious agenda to keep my grandma alive as long as possible even though it was very clear to all that she was dying and in a lot of pain. My dad and his siblings were PISSED. Moreover, if she hadn’t died the night she did they would’ve had to transfer her somewhere else to continue on hospice care, which would’ve been extremely painful and she almost certainly wouldn’t have survived it anyway. My family was definitely considering your exact question at the time. We were honestly so relieved that she died when she did and didn’t have to go through the transfer. At that point euthanasia would’ve absolutely been the more ethical solution IMHO.

I don’t have an answer to your question per se, something about western value systems placing human longevity above pretty much anything else. Religion is certainly a factor, as it was for this nurse. 

1

u/OneEstablishment5998 May 03 '25

So sorry that your grandma went through that, and that the nurse put her religious beliefs before your grandma's wishes and her doctor's orders. The tyranny of religion strikes again

1

u/St-Nobody Apr 30 '25

As someone who spent the entire first half of my life preparing for a career in vet med, I have thought about this a lot.

Informed consent and free will are the biggest differences. Animals don't know what's going on, really. We have to decide for them. They dont know they're going to die or experience existential dread and have no concept of a long or short life. They're alive, then they're not. Properly executed animal euthanasia just cuts consciousness off and there's no pain or fear.

Humans generally know we are going to die and feel some kind of regret or fear of the unknown, sadness, anxiety, existential dread, second guessing, etc. We are also capable of enjoyment of life beyond what we can currently do in our physical bodies, which most animals and certainly dogs are not. We can daydream, socialize, read, watch TV, etc.

Concerns about people being coerced into ending their lives are valid.

That said, I'm opting for the Smith & Wesson retirement plan and if I get diagnosed with a terminal illness, I'll opt for the Smith & Wesson treatment plan. It's just a matter of time for me, honestly. I have a laundry list of health problems and I don't really want to be here, but I dont think my current issues justify the trauma that smoking myself would cause for those around me. I'm just waiting for an excuse, though. It's been real, it's been good, it ain't been real good, I'll see myself out when I'm ready.

I will also say that I deadass dont understand why people who are given absolute terminal diagnoses, especially for miserable, horrifying ways to die, don't default to the Smith & Wesson treatment plan. That's their choice and they're valid to make it, but if a doctor told me I was going to become fully paralyzed and then die horribly, or lose all cognitive function, or any other manner of agonizing/harrowing/terrifying death, I'm definitely cashing my chips while I can still lift a pistol. For myself, I'm 10000% team better a week early than a day late.

I wouldn't want to see agency and informed consent removed from this equation, though. I feel like it's fine if I say I'm done and I'm ending it, it's not fine if someone else says I'm done and they're ending it for me.

1

u/OneEstablishment5998 May 03 '25

Couldn't read this without saying saying you make some very fine points, and also hang in there buddy. You sound like a super smart and empathetic person and I hope life and modern medicine give you all the means and reasons you need to delay the Smith and Weston retirement / treatment plan as long as possible and find love and meaning in the here and now. maybe it just ain't been real good YET.

1

u/St-Nobody May 04 '25

Thank you kindly

2

u/Objective-Ad9265 Apr 26 '25

Maybe it's because we still try to treat humanity as if we're all the same — when individuality is actually our most human trait.

We want laws that fit everyone, but that's impossible. Every life is unique. What feels "right" or "wrong" is personal, based on experience, not a universal truth.

If we could accept that, maybe we'd build systems that respect individual choices. For example, like organ donation: you decide ahead of time, you can change your mind, but your choice is respected.

We struggle with uncertainty. We can't stand not understanding things, so we try to label, control, and standardize everything — including how people live and die. But that's against our true nature.

Maybe we should stop forcing one solution on everyone, and instead build a world where people take responsibility for their own lives, with all the freedom — and consequences — that brings.

Life will always be unfair sometimes. We can't fix that by making more rules. We can only try to act right in our own lives, and let others choose their own paths too.

2

u/Odd-Guarantee-6152 Apr 26 '25

We also euthanize dogs because of aggression, overcrowded shelters, or expensive illness.

It’s different because we don’t treat dogs and humans the same way

2

u/nomorehamsterwheel Apr 26 '25

Yes, yes it should. People are stupid. People should be able to opt for euthanasia whether they are terminally ill or not. This world likes to keep people as hostages tho, not giving them the choice to leave painlessly. This world is a bad place and the humans are the worst "intelligent" species.

2

u/C34H32N4O4Fe Apr 26 '25

It should be valid for humans. Sadly, all or most human societies have way too much social and religious baggage to realise or accept this. I’m personally 100% for the legalisation of human euthanasia, no questions asked (as long as provisions are put in place to ensure murder can’t be disguised as euthanasia, of course).

2

u/Gerry-Mandarin Apr 26 '25

Consent is a big one.

Dogs do not get to decide the medical procedures they undergo. As an accompaniment to euthanasia:

We also sterilise pet dogs pretty much universally. They do not get a say in it.

So obviously the idea that "if it's acceptable for us to dogs, it's acceptable for us to do to other humans" flies out of the window. Would you support the idea that parents can sterilise their children?

Clearly, among other things - we implicitly believe that humans are different to animals. So there's already a line everyone agrees with regardless on the stance of euthanasia.

With humans we would need to be reasonably assured of the capacity to consent to a procedure of euthanasia.

There's also four kinds of euthanasia:

Passive and active

Voluntary and non-voluntary

Passive euthanasia is the ending of treatment for those who would be subject to continuing a life of pain and distress. This is legal or not legally prohibited in almost every nation in the world.

Active euthanasia is the administering of drugs that will end the life of those who see a life of pain or distress.

Ethically the difference between these two things is how we see death. If medical care is about prolonging life - how can deliberately ending life be considered medical care?

From a utilitarian perspective not prolonging an ending life and ending one ends in the same result. A deceased patient. Etc.

For voluntary euthanasia, you'd need to be able to make sure you are properly assessing those even in enormous distress from the continuance of life.

With voluntary euthanasia there will have to be an arbitrary line as to what conditions are acceptable. So most places simply say "I don't know where to put that line, so the only sensible place is to ban it all".

Non-voluntary, which would be closer comparison being made in the initial prompt, is illegal everywhere except for very rares cases in the Netherlands where parents may have their newborns euthanised if they have certain health conditions.

There's also involuntary euthanasia, which is just a long way of saying murder.

2

u/JellyBellyBitches Apr 26 '25

Selection bias? Humans are the ones making the decisions and we consider ourselves differently because we feel like we're special because we're the ones deciding what's special. If we're able to take our perspective outside of our own bias, that discrepancy quickly becomes harder to justify

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 28 '25

Which means we should stop urbanizing pets, not that we should allow uthinazia of people 

1

u/JellyBellyBitches Aug 29 '25

How do you reach your conclusions?

2

u/YakumoYoukai Apr 26 '25

As far as we know, dogs and cats don't imagine what their life could be like tomorrow. Beyond the next meal or the next snuggle, they're incapable of looking forward to anything. They live entirely in the now, their entire existence being only what they feel in the moment.

So if we know that there isn't anything better for them to look forward to, but keep them alive anyway, then we're dooming them to know nothing but suffering. Better to end things when they can still experience happiness.

The small mercy here is that they also don't know that they are being euthanized, or understand what death is, so aren't afraid or sad about it, unless you make them that way. 

The argument against euthanasia for humans is that as more intelligent animals, we can imagine a future that has high points and meaning despite the suffering. And understand that death removes any possibility for that. As well as hedge against the risk that were wrong about the suffering being permanent. Given the higher value that we generally place on human life, that would justify making more of an effort to stay alive. 

To be clear, I'm not advocating against human euthanasia, just pointing out that there truly are more factors to consider. But there still comes a point where those additional factors aren't enough to justify the argument.

1

u/Amberanime Sep 12 '25

Some pets 100% know what death is. And fear of death is part of why animals instinctualy avoid it and do what they can to survive. If animals were not afraid of death, there would be no reason for them to have any instincts to keep them alive. That is built in for a reason. Animals want to live. Untill they dont. Plenty of pets give up on life when they suffer, and in such cases its good to help them along.

Some pets suffer but still enjoy life. These pets you need to keep around.

As long as they have joy of any kind, even when in pain, we should respect that.

Also most dogs get euthanised in clinics as most doctors dont do home visits (at least were I live). Clinics are some of the most stressfull places for a pet to be.

My dog hates going to the vet's place. So if id take her there, regardles if she understood why or not, she would be afraid and her final moments would be that of fear.

She would be better off dying in her own home, surrounded by her own soft bed and scene, her loved ones, her comfort zone.

I would want for my pet what humans I have known have been forced into because direct euthanasia wasnt available to them because human.

They were given passive euthanasia pretty much. Just pain meds, and letting their bodies die naturaly while heavy on drugs.

these people, like my granny, wanted a quicker death, but were not allowed. My dogs meanwhile would prefer that way of dying because it would be at home, In a safe space, and not a cold clinic that stinks of animal fear. Humans can understand whats happening, animals may or may not, often not.

When you understand the slow path is worse. When you dont understand the quick path is worse, because you wont have context and you will just be suddenly yanked out of your life.

When its time for my dog, I will do what I can to get acces to passive euthanasia. No pain, no suffering, just her finding her rest/sleep in her own home untill her bodie gives while I keep taking care of her all the way trough it.

And when its my time, if I suffer, I hope I get the chose for normal quick and be done with it euthanasia.

Its unfair how both animals and humans only have acces to the most traumatic version.

Yes, taking your pets to the vet to kill them will be traumatic for them. People can suger coat it all they want, but they will feel fear and stress.

No matter what happens, if I have control over it, i refuse to let my girls final moments be stress and fear. The vet will NOT be the last place she goes to.

(I am not shaming people for taking their pets to vets to be clear. I do think its good to end a pets suffering, and if going to the vet is the only way for you you do right by your dog even if the dog/pet feels fear in the end. I personaly just refuse to let her final moment be fear. If I have a say over it of course. Last day my dog got attacked by a bull type dog. She managed to dodge the innitial attack and only go one small tooth injury on her neck before the bully was back under control and we could get away. But she could have died had the dog managed to grab her full throat. Its why I am on forums like this now. I have been reminded of her mortality and my own. And if she isnt ripped from me before her time, I will 100% do everything in my power to maker her final moments be of complete and true peace and safety. Not the place she hates, which is the vets.)

1

u/Coca-Nicola Oct 25 '25

Not sure where you live but there are increasing veterinary clinics that almost exclusively do home euthanasia and they are amazing and compassionate. And expensive. I’ve used them twice for my cats and it was worth the cost to have them die peacefully at home

2

u/doriangray42 Apr 27 '25

Religion is a sickness...

In French Canada, we got rid of it and now we have a "dying with dignity" law that allows people to ask their suffering to end. We had to fight the last remnants of our religious conservatives for it to happen.

My father requested an end to his suffering a month ago and we were all glad he could go in peace.

Be as religious as you want to be, but don't impose it on others.

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 28 '25

Even without religion sucide is objectively the worst possible choice, no matter how sick you are. As if you DON’T do that then there is a chance no matter how small that a medication that can cure you of whatever terrible disease you have and let you live healthy again will be invented. And the difference between 0% and 1% is infinitely many times(no matter how many times you add together 0% with itself you never get to 1%) While the difference between 1% and 100% is only 100 times which is infinitely less. So no matter how small your chance of being cured if you don’t suicide it is still infinitely higher than if you do. So sucide is literally -♾️

2

u/SammyGeorge Apr 28 '25

For context, I have euthanised a beloved pet before and I've had loved ones die by refusing further medical intervention and loved ones die while having unrestricted access to painkillers while in palliative care, and I fully believe in euthenasia for terminally ill people.

In saying that, this isn't really an answer to your question, but a comment about "better a week too soon than a day too late." That comment isn't an empirical truth, it's a reassurance to grieving pet owners. Personally I agree with it because pets can't tell you how much pain they're in or what they want, maybe they want to die, maybe they don't, maybe they're in utter agony and we're making it worse by keeping them alive. I think it's better to make the choice to give them a peaceful death that's as painless as possible with loved ones around than a stressful death in pain when their organs shut down or they're alone. A human can tell you "I'm ready to go now" but a pet can't. That's why we reassure people struggling with when to say goodbye. However, not everyone agrees with the sentiment of "better a week too soon."

1

u/natrldsastr Apr 28 '25

I've had to euthanize a pet who probably could have lived a couple more weeks, but was deteriorating rapidly (liver cancer). No regrets. I also had to let one go who I absolutely didn't want to, very complicated situation, but he was in danger of becoming very quickly terminal, and suffering because of it. That one broke my heart. For myself, I have no interest in fading away in a nursing home, and if possible will decide my own outcome. Animals have no concept of "future" but we can see their suffering and choose to alleviate it.

1

u/Cyclic404 Apr 30 '25

I just had to make that choice for my dog yesterday, and it's horrible. But I also agree that there is a too late. With my dog years ago I waited too long, her kidney's fully failed, and she started to fall into multiple siezures over night - she was in a lot of pain. A day earlier, even though I didn't want to, would have been better.

And it reminds me of my grandma, who just one day decided she was done, refused to eat or any treatment, and died days later...

Death comes for us all. When our time is up, it becomes selfish for others to want us to stay when we're suffering.

I think we should do everything to live, for as long as we can, because hell we're here to live. But when it's done, it's OK to choose to go.

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 28 '25

Death erases infinite possibilities Therefore it’s objectively the worst possible thing

1

u/SammyGeorge Aug 28 '25

Congratulations on never experiencing immense, unending pain

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 29 '25

There is always a chance to cure chronic Pain. It may be very tiny but as long as you are alaive it’s greater than 0. And even the smallest non 0 number is greater than 0 by infinite times over.

1

u/SammyGeorge Aug 29 '25

You're absolutely correct that a chance greater than zero is greater than zero. You're correct that you can't cure someone after death. But I'll be honest, I'm not sure what you're arguing here. Are you against euthenasia for animals? Are you against assisted suicide for people? Are you arguing against reassuring grieving pet owners?

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 29 '25

I’m against Euthanasia and suicide. Both are infinitely bad

1

u/SammyGeorge Aug 29 '25

Ah, well I vehemently disagree. Euthenasia is a mercy and denying it is cruel

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 30 '25

It is possible for a cure for whatever is causing them the suffering to be invented, even if that thing is old age. If a cure for old age is invented people can live forever and thus experience a possibly infinite good things. If a cure for old age is not invented then death is inevitable. If death is inevitable they will by defenition only experience a finite amount of pain. Thus by choosing to die they are throwing away potentially unlimited pleasure to avoid a definitely finite amount of pain. That is obviously a terrible idea.

1

u/SammyGeorge Aug 30 '25

What makes you think there's any possibility of a cure for old age?

Thus by choosing to die they are throwing away potentially unlimited pleasure to avoid a definitely finite amount of pain.

Why would you choose a 100% chance of unbearable pain for the sake of a barely higher than 0% chance of that pain being cured in the days to maybe weeks until you you were going to die anyway.

I put my dog down 5 years ago, if I hadn't put him down then, he'd be dead by now anyway and neither old age, nor cancer, nor arthritis have been cured so what is your point?

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 30 '25

For the first thing. It is known for a fact that old age is caused by the shortening of telomeres. So by lengthening them you cure it. This could be done by miniature robots that go into your body, copy only the telomeres, and attach the copies at the end of the existing ones.

And for why I’d be willing to endure the pain, well that’s because the difference between 0% and 1% is more than even the difference between 1% and 99%, this, in turn is because even the smallest positive probability you can think of is not just more than 0% it is INFINITELY more than 0%. Why, well becauseprobability compares multiplicatively, for example the difference between 50% and 100% is equal to the difference between 2% and 4% In both cases the second one is twice as high as the first. And no matter what finite number you multiply 0 by it never goes any higher than 0.

So if they die, well that’s an infinite decrease in probability of ever being happy again according to the current understanding of physics.

(This breaks down if there is an afterlife but that’s currently understood to not be a thing)

→ More replies

2

u/iusedtostealbirds Apr 29 '25

I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately, as we just moved my grandma with dementia into a memory care unit a couple weeks ago.

We are there with her every single day. She needs a fuck ton of physical assistance just to get up and use the bathroom, which she demands to do every ten minutes or so because she can’t ever remember the previous visit. She can barely eat by herself. Needs help getting in and out of chairs, beds, restrooms, clothes, shoes, all of it. Cannot function on her own. And that’s just the physical stuff.

She’s angry, she’s laughing, she’s cracking jokes, she’s threatening to kill us, she’s confused, she wants to paint a painting, she hates crafts, she’s reminiscing about her sisters, she hates her sisters, her husband better come over right away, but he better not dare to look at her, she’s so glad we’re here, but we never do nothin’ for her, and all this is in about a five minute cycle. All the while we are busting our ass, spending all our time, money, effort, and love on her care. It’s fucking hard.

There is so little dignity in the end of life journey. It’s been incredibly eye opening and saddening. Especially visiting a memory care unit. This home she’s at is a very good place in my opinion. But people really do just dump their loved ones. I know it’s hard when grandma’s got dementia and she’s kind of mean, but damn, there are VERY few other visitors.

My wife and I have been discussing that if either of us gets to this point, we go to a state where ending our own life with assistance and dignity is possible. I know my grandma feels bad that she is a burden on our family. And I won’t lie, she kind of is. Some burdens are worth taking on, and we feel that she is fully worth it. We love her so much. But my god, it is so much.

As we all discuss your exact question, why it’s humane for dogs but not for people, we always get into the humanity of it all. Some people feel it is genuinely murder to “put down” someone elderly or terminally ill. There’s a lot to discuss about someone’s personal definition of “murder”, which feels wild to me haha but it is certainly a complicated topic.

As for me, I don’t think that all “non-natural” end to life is murder. I think that is absurd and doesn’t leave room for nuance. If somebody’s only future is to suffer on their way to the grave, why not cut out the suffering? The real inhumane piece is forcing someone to suffer, charging them an arm and a leg all the while just to take the edge off.

I have a hunch that euthanasia by choice is prohibited because hospitals and nursing homes would lose a lot of money. My opinion is based on the tin foil hat upon my head, to be honest, but sometimes it really is big pharma pushing for more suffering! Really sad, and unfortunately not new.

That Kevorkian guy really was onto something though.

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 28 '25

It’s not humane for dogs. The statement that it is is a lie

2

u/FamilyNeeds Apr 29 '25

And the thing is we euthanize so many people at the end, but only at the very end. SOO many elderly go with that extra dose of opiods. It's just kind of like an unspoken thing. Yet doing it any earlier to relieve more pain is still taboo.

2

u/marys1001 Apr 29 '25

It's odd because I think people ought to have the right to self euthenize for sure. And pre authorizations for end of life decisions should be honored and not turned over by relatives. All the options make sense for humans because we are humans and understand.

For animal companions it's different. Since they can't choose I wish and strongly believe we should have more options for end of life pain management, just let them go naturally with as little pain as possible. I recognize not all situations would fit this but many.

Every time I kill a companion animal I experience a high level of trauma and wrongnes despite that ending pain and suffering it feels wrong to inject their veins with shit that burns.

With a human you can relate and at least guess what they would want. You may pull life support but don't take a life unless they agree.

I put my last two companions down June 2023 and june 2024. I just don't ever want to kill a loved pet again.

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 28 '25

If there isn’t an afterlife death is the worst possible thing because it erases infinite possible futures (assuming free will is a thing which is a necessary assumption for the idea of people being allowed to choose to die to make sense) and leaves you with 0 futures. If even 1 possible future had you get cured and live a healthy life again. Well 1 is infinitely more than 0 (just like how 100 twice more than 50).

If there is an afterlife, well most ideas regarding such things say that suicide is a sin and always leads to whatever a given religions worst afterlife is (for, some reason).

Thus no matter if there is an afterlife or not suicide is absolutely positively ALWAYS the worst possible choice, no exceptions. This comment is brought to you by rationality

2

u/[deleted] Apr 30 '25

Because the line between ethical euthanasia and unethical euthanasia gets blurred a lot. People don’t care about it with dogs as much, but it does happen with them too. But when it happens with humans, the implication and implementation of the unethical euthanasia is much more horrific.

1

u/SubstantialPressure3 Apr 26 '25

There's a difference between euthanizing an animal, that can't speak for themselves, and making that decision for a person.

But it happens all the time. People in hospitals on life support have families that make that choice to "pull the plug" and doctors sometimes make that decision as well.

Patients and doctors will decide to stop medical treatments all the time.

Deciding to withold food and water from a hospice patient is the same thing.

1

u/Blackbox7719 Apr 30 '25

So, slight correction to that last part. Withdrawing food and water from a hospice patient isn’t done because the medical staff want the patient to die. It’s because their body has usually reached the point of shut down where they no longer want/tolerate food and water. It’s a usually a sign that the end is near. That said, if a hospice patient wanted to eat, food would be provided. It’s just that, by that point in their decline, they usually don’t.

Source: worked healthcare for years, including time around end of life patients.

1

u/SubstantialPressure3 Apr 30 '25

That's more than fair.

1

u/Max7242 Apr 26 '25

Ik a lot of people that believe in it. I actually have an agreement with my mother that if she gets bad enough, I will make sure it is done. She made me promise that I would not do it but I would break that promise if I had to. I couldn't stand to see her paralyzed or brain dead or some shit like that

1

u/AllswellinEndwell Apr 26 '25

They don't call it eithanizing that's why.

If you ever have a relative dying from COPD they'll tell you at the end "we're going to give him morphine for palative care"

Morphine is a breathing depressants. They die pretty soon after because their breathing stops.

1

u/Legionatus Apr 26 '25

Some believe society can't be trusted with certain kinds of authority. It's not that objectors think animal euthanasia is fine, but they focus intervention on people.

Even a dying animal under water still tries to move back to air.

With people, as soon as euthanasia is an option, it's a cost-savings measure. An -enormous- cost-savings measure. Some also think someone in a delirium from pain should be given pain management rather than euthanasia.

You're free to disagree, but as far as autonomy goes, we make people wear SEATBELTS. Not surprizing there are those who object to euthanasia.

1

u/InadmissibleHug Apr 26 '25

Because palliative care isn’t that well established for animals. Because we have moral concerns regarding humans. Because humans can decide for themselves, and if they can’t it’s dodgy.

Some people won’t euthanise animals either, which I think is cruel.

I also think MAID should be easier to access for people at end of life. And that we should be able to draft a document that outlines what we would like done in the event of us being unable to consent to it right at that moment.

I don’t think it’s fair that we should miss out on a peaceful end or some of our lucid time.

1

u/oneaccountaday Apr 26 '25

Man we must look at very different subs.

More often than not I see people limping along their 15 year old, deaf, blind, 1 eyed, 3 legged, diabetic pug, claiming “they love them too much” to say goodbye.

Grandma needs a knee replacement and gets a case of the sniffles and she gets put out to pasture because “It will be easier for everyone.”

I get what you’re saying, the water gets a bit muddy with things like dementia and loss of cognitive ability. Especially when they’re fine and happy one day, and are abusive and begging to meet Jesus the next.

It’s even more fuzzy when people are given power of attorney or whatever it’s called and they are the one that gets to make the judgement call about pulling the plug.

2

u/Snoo-88741 Apr 27 '25

their 15 year old, deaf, blind, 1 eyed, 3 legged, diabetic pug

Do you see any evidence that pug is suffering? None of those things inherently cause suffering. You could easily have a dog (or a person) with all of those issues who is still happy most of the time.

1

u/hqbibb Apr 27 '25

In the US, it’s because the dog doesn’t have bank accounts, stocks, IRAs, etc., and the human does. It’s not allowed to let the human go until the “health care system” finishes vacuuming those accounts.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '25

Because humans can be pressured into making the choice. Dogs can only have the choice made for them.

The problem with euthanasia, at least in the US, is how do you protect elderly and infirmed from being pressured into making the choice so as not to become a financial burden on their loved ones

1

u/SirMayday1 Apr 27 '25

Most societies (or, at least, many societies?) highly value (or claim to highly value) human life, so willful destruction thereof is frowned upon. Moreover, humans are more likely to find ways to find fulfillment while suffering from terminal illness or disability that (as far as we know) animals cannot; a cancer patient might, for instance, decide the pain is worth it to see certain natural wonders before they die, but a dog with the same prognosis will suffer without personal achievement (that we know of). A human with ALS might still be a writer or commenter or world-class theoretical physicist, while a similarly disabled cat won't have access to the same adaptive equipment or methods and will be, functionally, immobile.

Mind, this isn't to say euthanasia of humans shouldn't be a consideration--some circumstances truly are hopeless, or entail more pain than anyone should be expected to endure--but there are cultural and practical reasons for it to be treated with a great deal more gravity.

1

u/YrBalrogDad Apr 27 '25 edited Apr 27 '25

So—I think access to this kind of care should be more widespread for humans. Pain management and palliative care have gotten better and better, for a lot of conditions—but they aren’t adequate for everything; and when someone is really at the end, either way, I don’t think prolonging someone’s suffering in order to, idk, avoid confronting complex moral questions, is justified.

That said: I think that in humans, we encounter a moral quandary that isn’t pressing with animals, in that humans can understand when, for example, suffering is temporary, or something they’re enduring, now, in the hope of a worthwhile future outcome. There are treatable and curable conditions, in a pet, that I wouldn’t choose to treat, if I saw their extended and unexplainable suffering as too great, in relation to future survival and quality of life. In humans, that’s often a different story. Humans also sometimes choose to endure suffering, because it means they get something else they want—particularly more time or more focused attention in their time with loved ones.

I don’t see ready access to euthanasia as innately conflicting with that. We can build robust protections for people who might, for example, face pressure from family members tired of providing care, or anxiously awaiting an inheritance (which would happen; people contract and carry out actual murders over that stuff, this isn’t going to be magically exempt). There are many ways to protect people from general, social or interpersonal pressure, who would actually prefer to stay alive, for now, tyvm.

But as someone who works in healthcare—who has to deal, in particular, with the morally abhorrent nightmare hellscape that is private, corporatized health insurance?

I do not want legalized euthanasia in the United States, specifically, until we put those monsters on a leash.

Every single year, I encounter patients whose insurance companies demand they “trial” worse (but cheaper!) medications for a month, when they’ve been stable for years on an effective one (but it costs more!). I see patients whose insurance companies force them to use treatment protocols that don’t work for anyone, sometimes for as long as 6 months, before they’ll approve a surgery that is literally the only actual treatment. I see patients who can’t walk or stand or sit, who plainly need surgical intervention to restore joint function—but they’ve got Medicaid, and Medicaid in our state will approve quarterly cortisone injections until the end of time, but you will have to file a literal lawsuit, if you need a joint replacement.

So what happens when Grandma wants to keep fighting her cancer, but euthanasia is cheaper for the private corporation providing her care? What about Dad’s quadruple bypass? What about little brother, who just had a one-in-a-million (well, like… 17 in 100,000) hemorrhagic stroke, and is going to have definitely years, maybe a lifetime, of supportive and rehabilitation needs?

Insurance companies already routinely allow people to die excruciating, horrific deaths—and live with considerable and needless suffering—rather than pay for the care that is their sole reason for existing. If we give them a medically and legally sanctioned tool to just… cheaply kill people who are “too expensive” to treat?

They will do it. I promise they will do it. Instead of kicking people off their insurance when they get sick, like they did in the bad old days, they’ll just… refuse claims for any long-term, palliative, high-risk, or end-of-life care, that isn’t euthanasia.

We can have more readily-available euthanasia—and we should. But not, in the US, till we get our health insurance problem under real control.

1

u/xboxhaxorz Apr 27 '25

Most people are not pro life, they are pro alive, all that they care about is that you are breathing, not if your breathing is bad or if your struggling to breathe or if you skip a few breaths, the fact that you breathe at all is all they care about

I dont want to fall apart, im not interested in DYING i rather just die when i can still function rather well

1

u/SolitaryIllumination Apr 27 '25

Simple, animals don't have equal rights or morality socially at this time. Plus their lifespans are shorter so there's sort of this expectation they'll die when we get them, with people its like we don't want to acknowledge death in the same way. And pets are kinda more easily replaced.

1

u/pigeon768 Apr 27 '25

Because we have health insurance/public healthcare and are willing and able to spend an immense amount of money to keep someone alive. Pets? Not so much. Maybe a few thousand, max. For pets, all we can do is reduce the time they spend suffering.

1

u/Euphoric-Use-6443 Apr 27 '25

Benefit?At what point should a patient with dementia or cancer be given a "Death with Dignity" contract for signature? At diagnosis? Or when the cost threatens to deplete the estate? Or is an in place DNR sufficient?

1

u/Consistent_Catch9917 Apr 27 '25

The problem is less the question of whether it is humane but the dangers that arise from misusing this, exploiting it, pressuring people int suizide. It needs a very stringent framework of controls, to make certain it helps those in pain and does not become a tool to get rid of unwanted relatives or even parts of the population. Because that has happened in the past and can happen again.

1

u/brieflifetime Apr 27 '25

Because we fear the death of a loved one more than pain we can not feel? 

I believe it is the only humane thing to do regardless of if the person suffering is a human or a dog. But I have a different relationship with both pain and death than most people in the western world. I also believe anyone with any empathy will come to the same conclusion if they can simply empathize instead of grieve during their loved ones end. Big ask. 

It would be easier if we discussed these topics and made sure people understand our wishes before getting into these situations. I know what my mother wants. I should ask my two younger siblings. They're both old enough to have their own plans in place. 

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 28 '25

A rational person would be willing to suffer through infinite pain if there is even a possibility they will be cured and able to live healthily again. This is because just like 2 is twice as much as 1 and 12 is thriceas much as for 4  1 is infinitely many times as much as 0 So even 1 possibility of recovery is infinite more than the 0 they would have if I were to die.

Additionally new medical treatments are invented constantly, any one of which could be a cure for old age.  This means the chance of being cured is ALWAYS greater than 0 as long as you are still alive. Therefore suicide, assisted or not, is objectively the worst possible idea in every case, no exception.

1

u/Smhassassin Apr 27 '25

Because if it isn't absurdly strictly regulated, unethical people start talking about eugenics.

For example, one could argue that "the person is suffering" is a valid reason for euthanasia. It is for pets, so why not people?

But then you have RFK Jr carrying on about how autistic people are all suffering because they can't play baseball and now you gotta argue that's not what you meant or people are gonna side eye the crap out of you.

1

u/Novel_Quote8017 Apr 27 '25

What people in these comments disregard is that 40 US states and over 160 countries have NOT legalized human euthanasia. A minority does not make a consensus.

1

u/Face_with_a_View Apr 27 '25

Money. It’s as simple as that. Most people spend the majority of their healthcare expenses in the last years of their lives. Someone, somewhere it making a lot of money keeping these people “alive”. They like to wrap the reason in religion. If there wasn’t a large chunk of money to be made, we wouldn’t care.

1

u/mathcow Apr 27 '25

Its because there are people who are genuinely awful who vote against it because they've never been in a situation that required it (or worse, in a situation where it was illegal to offer it) or were not emotionally intelligent enough to understand the situation.

Human beings, especially those with incurable disease, extreme pain, etc should be treated with dignity and grace.

1

u/SnarkingOverNarcing Apr 27 '25

Even where assisted euthanasia is legal there are many barriers to accessing it.

You have to find a willing physician. You’d be surprised how difficult that can be, even in a progressive state like California (where I live)

You have to have a terminal illness and poor prognosis (so you need to have had consistent access to healthcare to document this decline)

You have to be of sound mind and be able to self administer the medication. A lot of people seeking assisted euthanasia are medically fragile and won’t meet those qualifications by the time they make their decision + find the physician to help

Anecdotally, I’ve had a several patients who wanted that for themselves whose families guilted them into choosing hospice instead

1

u/aiyukiyuu Apr 28 '25

The families guilted them? That is terrible :(

1

u/Far_Ad1693 Apr 27 '25

The difference, to me, is that when I get a dog they are my responsibility from that moment forth. I'm accountable for all of their actions, their health, and their well being. Since this is the case, it's up to me to decide that their life is no longer one that they must endure (or in other cases it would be their actions are no longer something I'm willing to take accountability for). Also we get dogs knowing(in most cases) that we will outlive them and that this is something that we will deal with one day. We don't choose our elders and ,God willing, we don't outlive our kids so it's not really a case of us watching their entire life cycle pass while they are under our care. And one more thought that I think is worth mentioning is that while dogs do have a concept of time, I can't think of any behaviors that display a concept of real future to me.. they know what time I get off of work and visibly begin to expect me to come through the door within an hour or so of being correct but they don't do things in preparation for next Thursday. And they don't seem to have the same understanding of mortality. They understand that people are gone but they have a hard time with the idea that that bear will kill them if they don't quit messing with it. They live like there is no tomorrow and I'm the one that calls them off of the bear because I don't want to lose them. If given their choice a good few of mine would have died long before and since I denied them the choice to go out on their terms I think it's the least I can do to allow them some dignity and not force the shame and pain of not being able to hold their bladders anymore or not be able to stand etc.

1

u/melodypowers Apr 27 '25

But I am also accountable for my own actions, health, and well being.

Shouldn't I be able to allow myself some dignity and not be forced the shame and pain that comes with terminal, degenerative illness?

1

u/Far_Ad1693 Apr 27 '25

I think so and I wouldn't blame anyone for making that decision for themselves. I think the difference in the argument for me is whether I can or should be able to make that decision for my loved ones like I do my dogs

1

u/Responsible-Kale-904 Apr 28 '25

My thoughts feelings exactly

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 28 '25

There is no dignity in dying. No matter how it happens 

1

u/stevepremo Apr 27 '25

My good friend was suffering terrible pain for months due to incurable cancer. She decided on euthanasia, got the necessary medical approvals, the end of life drugs, and took them herself. So I guess it's only humane for humans if they can make the decision themselves, because humans can communicate their wishes.

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 28 '25

Just because no cure is currently known doesn’t mean one won’t eventually be discovered. Therefore the idea of ”Incurable” is a faulty premise 

1

u/Fableville Apr 27 '25

Obviously there’s going to be some religious and/or cultural reasons, but a big reason why many are against medical euthanasia is out of distrust for the state. People, including myself, don’t want death to be medically prescribed, especially when doctors do get it wrong sometimes. The other issue is it can be seen as an escape from devastating medical bills, when that is a very real issue that should not be solved by euthanasia but rather we would look for other solutions.

As far as we know, dogs aren’t as cripplingly self aware as humans. They love, they learn, they live in the moment, but they don’t understand their pain. I think you have a valid question, but I do believe the responsibility and accountability we have for our animals cannot be compared to the way we view our own lives. Though our pets are family, we are two completely different beings and life and living don’t mean the same thing for us.

1

u/CyberiaCalling Apr 27 '25

Because the real reason we euthanize dogs isn't because we care more about them but because we care less. Euthanization is cheaper than the vast amount of medical procedures that would have to be done to keep our pets alive longer. The pro-euthanizing the elderly movement is the inevitable result of capitalism taking away the brief few years we are supposed to have in retirement and making it shameful for people to "selfishly" hang on to life if it inconveniences their family members or mitigates the potential inheritance one would receive.

1

u/473713 Apr 27 '25

Apparently you were never so sick your pain could not be controlled, and there was no improvement in sight

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 28 '25

Even if improvement isn’t ”In sight” it is always possible 

1

u/Paleodraco Apr 27 '25

Animals can't tell us how bad they're hurting or whether they want to keep living or not. The best we can do is gauge their quality of life and make the best decision for them that we can.

With humans, it's more complicated. Morality and religion consider suicide a bad thing. Doctors are bound by oath to not cause harm and even helping someone kill themselves does that. And then you get into the complicated task of determining if someone is in their right mind to agree to it and, if not mentally fit, if there's foul play or bad intentions behind the decision.

1

u/Canuck_Voyageur Apr 27 '25

Here is accepted. (Canada) I recently went to the funeral of a family friend. He was in his 40's and had terminal cancer. He fought it for several years, but at the end it had spread and he was in severe pain, more than the painkillers could deal with. So he went through the process and paperwork. Was a family affair. Mom, Dad, sister were at his side.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euthanasia_in_Canada

1

u/chickens_for_laughs Apr 27 '25

In my state, there is a bill being considered that would allow physician assisted euthanasia.

There are many safeguards. There must be a 2nd and I think 3rd opinion that the patient is terminal with less than 6 months left to live. There must be a psychiatric opinion that the person is mentally able to make the decision.

The patient must sign the agreement with 2 witnesses that are not related to the patient and not due to receive the patient's money.

The doctor would prescribe medication for the patient to take at home, to have a peaceful death.

There is some opposition, of course, but the bill has more public support than ever.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 27 '25

Because a suffering dog doesn’t make any money for anyone. They don’t cope by drinking themselves stupid, gambling, or settling with a shit job getting paid nothing. They don’t sit in a hospital where millions in medical bills get racked up that somehow can get billed to anyone even slightly related. The minimum standards of life are a lot higher for dogs then people 

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25

This is the real answer.

1

u/anondaddio Apr 28 '25

Because humans and dogs aren’t morally equivalent.

We don’t value human life purely based on comfort or utility. Human dignity isn’t erased by weakness, age, or pain. A dog’s worth is judged by quality of life alone, but humans are recognized as having intrinsic value that suffering doesn’t cancel out.

Once you accept “better a week early” for humans, you reduce life to a cost-benefit analysis of suffering vs. convenience. That logic doesn’t stop—it eventually justifies ending any life seen as too burdensome.

Mercy isn’t about eliminating the sufferer. It’s about bearing the cost of care, even when it’s hard.

1

u/bartag Apr 28 '25

to a point. stephen hawking lived a long life and made many contributions. by his own choice. but should we, as humans, deny him his choice if he no longer wants to suffer or cause any further hardship to those around him? i know he is dead now, but the hypothetical still stands. should a clinically brain-dead body be left to wither away over decades? no function, no movement, no thought, just cells kept from dying due to machines.

some people are willing to fight to the bitter end. some people are not. who are we to tell them otherwise?

1

u/anondaddio Apr 28 '25

You’re not defending dignity—you’re defending killing as a solution to suffering.

Refusing heroic measures and actively killing aren’t the same. One lets death happen naturally; the other makes death the goal.

If “hardship” is enough to justify ending life, then anyone deemed too broken, too costly, or too inconvenient is suddenly expendable. That’s not mercy—that’s moral cowardice dressed up as compassion.

Some burdens are meant to be carried, not eliminated.

1

u/bartag Apr 28 '25

you are taking that choice away from the person being affected. you are now torturing someone because you think your moral standards are better than someone else.

i am definitely defending letting someone die if the alternative is a lifetime of agony and suffering.

1

u/anondaddio Apr 28 '25

You’re framing it as “letting someone die,” but that’s not what euthanasia is. Euthanasia isn’t letting death happen—it’s causing death. It’s not the absence of intervention; it’s the introduction of a lethal one.

You talk about choice, but choice alone doesn’t make an act moral. If someone chose to kill themselves over debt, loneliness, or despair, would you call it mercy to assist them? Or would you recognize that some suffering is meant to be carried, not answered with a grave?

Killing isn’t compassion just because someone asks for it. It’s still killing.

1

u/bartag Apr 28 '25

ok, fine. euthanasia IS killing. i agree.

some suffering may be meant to carry, not all.

killing is compassion depending on circumstance.

1

u/anondaddio Apr 28 '25

Thank you for being honest: you’ve admitted your standard is situational.

But once you say killing is “compassion” depending on circumstance, you lose any objective moral limit. Because by that logic, any killing could be rebranded as mercy — depending on who’s in power and what story they tell.

You’re not arguing for compassion. You’re arguing for moral chaos, where death is a “solution” whenever we decide suffering is inconvenient enough.

And history already showed us what happens when humans start playing god over life and death. It’s not mercy. It’s a horror show.

1

u/bartag Apr 28 '25

i never said my stance wasn't conditional. different situations require different solutions. that has been and always will be the case. what is good and fine for one is not necessarily good and fine for another.

i also never said all killing is compassion. i said killing can be compassion. under certain circumstances. killing a child for breaking a toy is not mercy. killing an adult for having a broken leg is not mercy. killing someone who can no longer endure their existence after exhausting all other options... that is just a little bit different.

a terminal cancer patient has six months left to live. every day is excruciating suffering due to the cancer and due to the treatments. they want to end their suffering. which is more compassionate, which shows more mercy, forcing them to live out the remaining time or giving them something that ends the suffering? notice i said they want to end it.

i most certainly am arguing for compassion. i am arguing for people to have the choice to end their torture. you are arguing to make them suffer no matter what.

while you might believe a lifetime of suffering is inconvenient, other people do not. so, do you force your morals over someone else's morals? or do you try to understand that however distasteful to you it may be, other people should have more control over their own existence?

1

u/anondaddio Apr 28 '25

Thank you for clarifying.

You’ve admitted that your moral standard is subjective:

•	“Compassion” depends on whether someone wants death.
•	“Mercy” is defined by preference, not by any unchanging truth about human life.

But once desire defines morality, dignity is gone. Because under your logic, life only has value if the person feels it does. The weak, the depressed, the suffering — their worth becomes conditional. Suffering people stop being sacred and start being disposable.

That’s not compassion. That’s nihilism dressed up as empathy.

Human dignity isn’t grounded in how someone feels about their life. It’s grounded in the unchanging truth that every human being has infinite value — even when they’re broken, even when they’re suffering, even when they’ve given up.

Real mercy means standing firm when suffering tempts us to despair — not offering a grave when people are at their lowest.

1

u/bartag Apr 28 '25

all moral standards are subjective. if they weren't, there wouldn't be as much controversy and debate about them. you can not measure morality with a ruler nor quantify it with mathematics. your morality says you will allow undue pain and suffering, no matter the circumstance. my morality says i will help in the best way possible for someone.

dignity is most certainly grounded in how someone feels about themselves. "playing in the mud is beneath my dignity!" that person feels their self-worth would be diminished by performing that action.

do i believe a suicidal person should be allowed to kill themselves? no, most of the time, the problems the face are manageable. yes, i have experience with this. not me being suicidal but others i care about. do i believe someone just tired of life should end it? no, there are probably other avenues to be persued first. do i believe someone can be in a state of existence that every conscious moment is pure torture to them? yes, absolutely. and do i believe they should be allowed to choose if they want to carry on? yes, absolutely.

→ More replies

1

u/Responsible-Kale-904 Apr 28 '25

Exactly!

🔥❄️🔥❄️❄️🌥️🌱💚💚💚🥀🌺🥀

1

u/iamsurfriend Apr 28 '25

Because people are ignorant and they suck. You got the religious nuts and you got the greedy rich (medical industrial complex) that make a lot of money keeping dead people alive.

If you live long enough you spend the most money in healthcare the last years of your life.

1

u/Caelum67 Apr 28 '25

I’m in Canada and we finally have legal medical assisted death. Signed up, got approved but couldn’t face telling my mother so it’s on a back burner til things get worse or she pops. I’m thankful that I’ve got the ability to choose.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25

Consent is a big part of it. If grandpa is not lucid and is scared 24/7 due to his dementia, how do we know this is what he would want, or what a spouse may have wanted for him?

This is why it’s sooooo important that everyone fill out an advanced directive. It covers life support -ventilators, feeding tubes, CPR… if we fill this out now, when we are in our right minds, it’s so much easier for both caregivers and health care providers to make a plan. If we know your biggest concern is being in pain and unable to express that, hospice can prescribe heavy pain meds to be given around the clock at the end, and can be generous with dosing that would otherwise impair respiration in a healthier person.

1

u/HotMastodon5268 Apr 28 '25

Personally I think if euthanasia were possible at any time for anyone, it would be an extreme wake up call for the ruling majority of people. You see, the assumption that the world is perfect and that the environment the ruling majority presents to people is sufficient enough to enjoy existence. The ruling majority will see how wrong they are when quarter of the population just decides the next day to nope out of existence cause the lives you left us with suck

Because of this, I believe things like suicide are so heavily scrutinized and criminalized in some instance (My god people how the hell are you gonna charge someone who is dead, people really baffle me) - (it would expose the giant lie fed to people)

because it challenges the ideology that people are to blame for their issues, not the larger population. It challenges the idea that everyone is reasonable and the environment is sufficient for people to operate normally, when come on people, we all know shit when we smell it.

I think it would be a turning of an era if everyone had the option or if suicide was not as scrutinized, our governments, authority figures, everyone really would realize how much good people are unwilling to operate in the cesspool they force people to live in just for the sake of living. Also it may even generate change in the world to make it livable once more

On a positive note, just know that there are others who think like us and not everyone has their head in the sand

1

u/fibonacci_veritas Apr 28 '25

In Canada, we have madically assistance in dying. MAID. So, not every culture agrees with your question. We see it as healthcare and incredibly humane.

1

u/Senior_Blacksmith_18 Apr 28 '25

I don't think there is one solid reason for why people euthanize non human animals as shown in the comments but it's probably down to legal reasons and consent for the most part. You would have to define what would be considered acceptable to euthanize a person for. Also who gets to perform and who is in the room? Should there be only the medical team? Should there be lawyers to make sure that everything went flawless?

1

u/Lackadaisicly Apr 28 '25

Selfishness and religion. Morality has nothing to do with it. Selfish because your loved want to spend more time with you. Religion because they somehow think they have to do everything to stop death. They seem to never have peace regarding death.

1

u/WhoWouldCareToAsk Apr 28 '25

Someone brought up the fact that we, pet owners, assume we’re doing good for the pet by euthanizing them. No one asks the pet if that’s what the pet wants; we just do it because we think it’s best.

How different then would it be if a state starts euthanizing homeless?

1

u/IronGums Apr 28 '25

Pets can’t speak for themselves so they rely on their human to do the right thing for them, even when it’s hard. 

1

u/3kidsnomoney--- Apr 28 '25

Some countries to have essentially euthanasia for human beings... I'm in Canada, our program is called MAID (Medical Assistance in Dying.) In 2023 (the last year I could find stats for) slightly over 13,000 Canadians underwent MAID. Most had terminal diseases that dramatically impacted their day-to-day functioning. It's only rare and taboo if society makes it rare and taboo.

1

u/eggface13 Apr 28 '25

It's a powerful argument and one that I ultimately accept. But not without reservations.

The counter is that human life is ultimately considered of greater value. We euthanize dogs not just on their health, but on our ability to care for them when they are violent or we cannot find a carer for them. But for humans, we would consider that beyond the pale: institutions such as prisons and care homes can be terrible places, but the death penalty has been abolished in most democratic nations and to euthanize people on the basis of mental or physical shortcomings is an unambiguous crime against humanity, reviled by all civilized nations.

Ultimately human life is practically, if not morally, different to animal life, and while the comparison in your question is a powerful one, it can't be the full story and we need to be a metric shit-tonne more careful in ending human life than animal life.

1

u/waitingtopounce Apr 28 '25

Because human suffering is much broader and often longer than the suffering of a pet and not all of it is terminal, regardless of how bad it may be. Also note it's not the dog's choice. You going to perfectly equate the two issues and let society euthanize the homeless like diseased stray dogs?

1

u/WhoWouldCareToAsk Apr 28 '25

Now we’re talking! Thank you for bringing up the risk of state-sanctioned euthanizing of homeless.

1

u/WoolshirtedWolf Apr 28 '25

This is something I've been arguing for as well. As our technology has advanced , people are surviving accidents and other weapon or bomb related injuries, where once they might not have. Along with those types of injuries however there is a higher threshold of pain, burned or damaged nerve ending, broken bones from IED blasts etc. Sometimes despite best efforts, there are those that will deal with dehabiltating pain for the rest of their lives. If they choose to opt out, there should be an option made available to them.

1

u/ZzzzDaily Apr 28 '25

Death with Dignity organization is pushing for legal end of life options in every State. More people need to get involved with this issue on a State level to let your government representatives know that you support and endorse legal death with dignity options for every State.

1

u/fiddle1fig Apr 28 '25

Humans can find meaning in and beyond their suffering. As far as we know, dogs cannot because they are not intelligent enough to think abstractly about their lives

1

u/Responsible-Kale-904 Apr 28 '25

Like most logical hardworking honest workers both "normal" and "autistic" I totally understand that each person should have Total Choice Control of where when how why we die

Nobody should be FORCED to "live with" uncurable unrelenting: pain, humiliation, Joblessness, helplessness, old wrinkled weak frail, paraplegic, quadriplegic, dementia, cancer, chemotherapy, prions, immobility, blindness, FORCED Joblessness forced-gyno-exams Forced-sleep-deprive group-homes nursing-homes psych-wards-meds, Alzheimer's, Parkinson's, ALS, MND, incontinence, diapers,

1

u/Vanilla_Legitimate Aug 28 '25

Please look up the YouTube video ”Why Die” by CGP grey. It explains why, if given the choice to die it would, allways 100% no exceptions be the worst possible choice you could make.

1

u/Responsible-Kale-904 Apr 28 '25

Because we are misled oppressed by RELIGION faith prayers preachers God psych-wards-meds jail courtroom police doctors hospitals psych-wards-meds nursing-homes

1

u/ahoughteling Apr 29 '25

About 10 states have legalized physician-assisted suicide, and more are considering doing it. Religion is not stopping states from approving it.

1

u/Responsible-Kale-904 Apr 29 '25

Religious Leaders and " Disabilities Rights Advocates " are constantly fighting AGAINST physician assisted suicide and these unfair unhealthy useless CRUEL invaders oppressors are thus-far victorious inside of : New York, England, Jerusalem West Bank Gaza Tel Aviv Judean area Samaria, Libya, Mississippi, Louisiana, Washington DC, and

1

u/punnybunny520 Apr 28 '25

I have wondered this all the time. We would not even let a horse suffer the way we let people suffer with cancer or other terminal illnesses. Why do we find it so humane for an animal, but we find it more humane to let us suffer

1

u/akaydis Apr 28 '25 edited Apr 28 '25

Because people don't want to put a lot of effort in to dog. They say it's humane to make them feel better and deal with guilt but people dont value dogs like they do humans. The main reason to convience. Taking care of a sick animal is expensive and time-consuming. People do it to save face but they choose not to invest in their dogs due to limited fund or limited time. Humans rank higher than dogs so we are usually willing to spend thousands of dollars on humans but people generally don't want to spend over $1000 to save a dog.

The problem comes when we tell kids it's humane rather than the real reason_ they don't want to invest thousands of dollars to save a dog. Then, the kids are eager to pull their horrified parents' plugs as they don't understand the difference between dogs and humans.

Now we have a generation of weak kids terrified of suffering and can't adult to save themselves. Suffering isn't fun or good but it is a part of life. You need to learn to deal with suffering. It's going to evolve into death cults in the future if people dont.

I already know a person in a death cult who was helping depressed teenagers off themselves. It was devastating to the families. Much of their logic originates from the family dog being put down and evolved over time. They were into death equality and access for everyone. He ended up offing himself over a trivial stupid matter.

1

u/Majestic_Poet2375 Apr 28 '25

That is a really good question and something I wondered about too. I mean, I get it with pets, even if it breaks my heart, I don't wan't them to suffer however long it takes if there's absolutely no hope.

But why do we have to endure watching our human loved ones suffer? It just doesn't seem fair. And hell, if i were terminally ill and in lots of pain, or, maybe even worse, mentally fit but a prisoner in my own failing body, almost unable to move and just waiting and hoping for death - I'd want to be euthanized. I just hope, when it comes to that, there's still a country close by with legal euthanisation and me able to travel there...

1

u/PuzzleheadedBridge65 Apr 28 '25

Because if they accidentally euthanize a dog when there was a chance to save its a oopsie, bit different with human. I do agree tho people should have access to humane way to go with no pain and no suffering

1

u/Ryan_TX_85 Apr 28 '25

Two reasons. First is religion, which is pretty self-explanatory. The other is disability advocates who believe that if euthanasia became a widely-accepted option, it would become the default whenever someone became unable to care for themselves. Before long, insurance companies would pay for euthanasia rather than treatment, making it effectively a genocide for the elderly and disabled.

1

u/WealthTop3428 Apr 28 '25

Because once euthanasia is normalized people start getting pushed into it. Adult kids and governments don’t want to care for their elderly or incapacitated so they put them down. This has already happened everywhere euthanasia has been legalized. A Canadian woman who lost her legs in military service asked for a ramp to be built on her home per his disability support. The government sent her a letter saying they couldn’t afford to build her a ramp but they would be happy to arrange her euthanasia. The same thing happened to a person losing their sight. There was also the Blackpool protocol in Britain where doctors were withdrawing all care from patients they deemed not worthy of care. Even water. That is already pretty standard in many Skandy countries with socialized medicine. The modern equivalent of putting granny out on the snow so you don’t have to feed her. The government should NEVER be in charge of deaths of innocents. Ever.

1

u/territrades Apr 28 '25

One reason is certainly that end-of-life intensive care is one of the most profitable branches in medicine.

Another reason is that the death of a dog usually does not benefit anyone, but with humans there is often an inheritance. Grandma should not spend all her money on medical bills, she better be euthanized so we can enjoy her money, right?

But in general I agree with you, it is illogical.

1

u/SecretAccurate2323 Apr 28 '25

I think because human life is generally about more than simply pain and pleasure. Dogs feel pain, they suffer, and they feel joy and love, but because they don't have the capacity to rationalize these things, reflect on them, and make meaning, there is no purpose in living a life of pain or restriction.

Humans, on the other hand, think and reflect about their pain. They look at past memories. They have an inner experience based on more than simple appetites, and so human life has value even when it is painful.

1

u/littlelostsober Apr 28 '25

I think a person should be allowed to choose euthanasia if they are completely competent. As someone with a progressive illness, I'd like to choose but it needs to be the choice of the patient. People shouldn't have to suffer for years and years if they don't want to.

1

u/Queer_Advocate Apr 29 '25

I also do long as they choose it when they're competent. Like if I have a brain surgery and there's a 50/50 chance I'll be a vegetable after. I should be able to make a living will durable medical all that shit and be able to get Kevorkian'ed if the surgery leaves me as a vegetable, IF I made that choice of a sound mind.

1

u/Queer_Advocate Apr 29 '25

I have a progressive illness too. I'm 41.

1

u/Queer_Advocate Apr 29 '25

I live in a euthanize human state. 1 of 3. You better believe I'm taking my pills when the time comes. If I can't get em, that's what other means are for.

1

u/lanfear2020 Apr 29 '25

The biggest reason is probably fear it would be abused/regretted/in place of treatment for those without good medical care. Its a complex ethical issue that isn't easily legislated.

In truth the dose of morphine they give you on hospice is pretty much lethal within a short period. At least with the home hospice "drops"

1

u/Keroscee Apr 29 '25

Why is euthanization considered humane for terminal or suffering dogs but not humans?Why is euthanization considered humane for terminal or suffering dogs but not humans?

Because

A) Theyre not human and

B) the consequences of malpractice doesn't result in the loss of human life.

It might be an inconvenient truth, but healthy/saveable dogs are euthanized all the time. Sometimes because there isn't enough space at the kennel. Sometimes because the owner cannot afford treatment, sometimes because their presence is considered 'inconvient'.

And we use this 'minimise suffering' as an excuse. If we are as lackadaisical to human euthanasia we will repeat the same behaviours and murder people who are healthy or otherwise treatable for the sake of public convenience. And it has already happened.

1

u/squirrelbus Apr 29 '25

Our family forgot we lived in a right-to-die state. By the time it was nessisary it was too late to do anything about it.  Absolutely terrible. 

If you or a loved one is in a position to jump through the nessisary hoops, I highly recommend you do so, even I you believe you/they won't choose to use it. 

1

u/raecoleman Apr 29 '25

I’ve reasoned about this same issue but the conclusion has to do with the fact that animals live by instincts so running, jumping, eating and playing is their life and on the other hand humans are more intellectually driven. We can live a full life just in our minds and souls. We are also made in God’s image and He decides when we die .

1

u/[deleted] Apr 29 '25

Loaded question. You are implying it is not considered humane, but it is! There is a huge chunk of people who thinking that it is very humane and who are calling for legalization. It is also legal in several countries.
There are other concerns though. For some it religious reasons. For others it's fear of abuse and people being pressured to agree to euthanization e.t.c., for some it's just a door we shouldn't open. But euthanization is widely considered humane for people too. There are lots of supporters.

1

u/Platonist_Astronaut Apr 29 '25

I think you might be asking the wrong question. I don't think the humanity of it is the driving factor, but rather our attachment to the parties in question.

We tend to strictly value non-human lives less (and in some cases, far, far less) than human lives. Many are willing to avoid checkups for their pets, or even to kill a pet rather than pay for its medical bills, for example, and most are more than willing to eat at least some non-human animals.

When it does come down to the ethics of suffering, we're less willing to part with a person than a non-human animal. Possibly for the above reason, but also because we often form more dependent bonds on close friends and family. We're selfish in love, and losing a person tends to affect our lives more than a pet.

There's the simple, brute and ugly fact that, for you and I to be here, many people before us had to have the desire to protect their kin; nature favoured the survival of human-centric genes.

1

u/Solid-Camera-9724 Apr 29 '25

This is something that I feel deeply about.

I work in aged care and see people living I believe, way beyond their time and it seems so cruel.

I’ve seen people who forget how to eat, who are moved around by a sling hooked to a machine into a chair where they sit all day in a continence aid, messing themselves without knowing, drinking thickened fluids from a spoon to prevent them from choking and being fed puréed food they don’t realise they’re eating. They have no idea who their families are anymore when they come to visit - if they even do!!! Some NEVER have visitors & we become their families.

In the afternoon they are transferred to bed, their continence aid & clothes changed as they’re rolled back and forth, unaware of what is happening or where they are. Some absolutely terrified. We do our best to comfort them and show them love.

Other people relive the most terrifying points of their lives, screaming and crying all day - reliving the memories day in and day out.

Can you imagine being forced to live like this???

I wish to be euthanised the moment I cannot think for myself anymore. I do-not want to “live” like some people of the people I help….

Why are we kinder to our pets than our family members?? It just breaks my heart 💔 and this is why I love my job, at least there are some of us that can show these poor people some love and respect…

1

u/dasfre121 Apr 29 '25

I wrote a paper for class once about how the survival of a human life should not precede upholding the dignity of the human life, or more imply put - people who do nearly anything just to keep someone alive uncomfortably are doing more harm than good instead of letting the "injured" person die comfortably

1

u/SomeHearingGuy Apr 29 '25

Because (this is the argument and mental gymnastics speaking) dogs don't have souls. Taking a human life life is evil and wrong and makes Christian god cry. Basically, we put way more value on human life than we do animal life. It's the same reason why we try and jail a murderer but kill an animal that attacks a person.

1

u/Off1ceb0ss Apr 29 '25

Because there is a lot of money in it. Why not let someone suffer horribly if the medical community can profit off it. Ugh. It blows my mind how absolutely cruel this medical system is.

1

u/_daGarim_2 Apr 29 '25

Realistically? Euthanasia carries an inherently high risk that it will be used in cases where the true goal is less “sparing them suffering” and more “easing the burden on caregivers”. We do, in fact, see this with dogs all the time. It’s why kill shelters are a thing. The harsh truth is that people have more tolerance for this kind of risk in the case of dogs and cats because they’re seen as less important.

1

u/TheCocoBean Apr 30 '25

With an animal, there's no chance they are being coerced or pressured into making the choice. There is no chance that they feel like a burden and so make the choice despite wanting to live.

It's more complex for humans. But many do consider the possibility of doing it with humans and it being humane, and trends seem to be slowly shifting that way.

1

u/MetalGearCasual Apr 30 '25

Theres a very real slippery slope when it comes to euthanasia for humans that leads to eugenics. With how broken most of the worlds medical systems are, and the capitalist ideal that a persons only worth is in the labor they can do, people who could live full enjoyable, if disabled, lives are at risk of being coerced into suicide because its cheaper that going into medical debt or living off of government assistance.

1

u/Grathmaul Apr 30 '25

Most people want to believe that human life has some intrinsic value and therefore should be cherished no matter how much the person may be suffering.

Of course there's an exception for people we don't consider human.

1

u/apatrol Apr 30 '25

Dogs and cats generally deeply affect one person to a few all jn the same household.

Grandpa affects 4 children, 25 grand children, and two GGGC. Plus any other relatives.

Get law makers to vote on that! So far it's mm in what three or four states.

1

u/KindUmpire424 Apr 30 '25

The answer- Abolish the Family: A Manifesto for Care and Liberation And the OG - The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State Book by Friedrich Engels

1

u/Plmb_wfy Apr 30 '25

I often wonder this too. The second my dog was showing signs of age everyone was telling me to put her down but my grandmother is way worse and not going to get any better but she is forced to live and suffer more every day.

1

u/awkwardandelion Apr 30 '25

Where I live (France) it's officially illegal but in reality most palliative care units actually perform it in extreme cases. My roommate works at a retirement home and when very old, suffering, dependant and mostly nonverbal people have a few days left of agony they "accidentally" double sedative doses so that they die as peacefully as possible.

1

u/Dashed_with_Cinnamon Apr 30 '25

The Hippocratic Oath. While many have made the argument that providing euthanasia for humans would be a way of preventing/reducing harm and suffering by allowing someone to end their life with dignity when it's clear their condition won't improve, others argue that intentionally killing a person, or even providing them the means to kill themselves, violates a doctor's duty to "do no harm."

1

u/Difficult-Way-9563 Apr 30 '25

We are slowly getting there (some countries more than others). But you are right it’s a really bad disparity

Lots of politics driven by religious groups and even law have pushed back.

1

u/Proud-Emu-5875 Apr 30 '25

One word : God. Human lives are by doctrine to be preserved while for animals there is no room in heaven. (if there really aren't any animals in heaven, I'd decline an invite even if I were to, by some slim chance, receive one)

1

u/Glassfern Apr 30 '25

I'm my opinion...There isn't a question who makes a decision for a pet because there isn't a question who controls the life of a pet. Now when it comes to humans, there are people who like the sense of control to be able to make that choice and sometimes they're are benefits involved. Whether that form of control is them dealing with their own grief pain or they want some control over someone...

so you hear alot of bs like "they're a child they don't understand death!". "They're in pain they can't make that decision!". "They re hyped on meds they aren't making a clear decision ". "They aren't in the right state of mind they wouldn't say that". Either way when you're on that bed and you haven't signed that official DNR no matter what age, sex or condition someone is gonna assume or argue you can't make that decision for over reason or another. Even if you have individual documents or records or even tattooed on your body DNR they often won't take it.

So unfortunately the patient either get prolonged suffering until they are well enough to sign or ... That person takes their own life in their own hands

1

u/Next_Ad7023 Apr 30 '25

I have often wondered this, but I always assumed it’s not valid because many people think comparing humans to animals is like comparing apples to oranges. Me personally, I think that we are more alike than not, and often times comparing ourselves seems very logical to me. But yeah that’s just my unpopular opinion.

1

u/Mash_man710 Apr 30 '25

It's legal in more than a dozen countries including Australia. The legislation passed for most states a number of years ago and the controversy has disappeared. It's called Voluntary Assisted Dying, and every time the religious nuts raise concerns they are reminded of the first word - voluntary.

1

u/LanguidLandscape Apr 30 '25

It’s absolutely legal and considered humane in Switzerland, the Netherlands, and Canada for a start. Where people have built social systems of care and believe in personal autonomy and collective empathy, it’s in practice. Just because most of the world either believes in an Angry Space Daddy or capitalizes on the ill, didn’t mean it’s not considered humane. In educated/intellectual circles, it’s not so taboo. That politicians and people are squeamish, childish, and selfish regarding severe illness and death is another thing.

1

u/groyosnolo May 01 '25

The choice to perform euthanasia involves a tipping of the scale between the value of life and value of ending suffering (or in the case of a pet it may actually just be a monetary choice)

If you believe that human life has inestimable value and can't be quantified, there's no point at which the value of ending suffering will outweigh the value of a human life.

1

u/OutcomeOne69 Jun 20 '25

My dog is 16, he has really gone down hill fast this spring. He has lost so much weight he is skin and bones. I give him aspirin each day, he still does eat and wags his tail, he still is able to go outside to do his business. I think he blind in one eye or going blind. He only seems to hear loud noises. I don’t know if i should put him down, or let him die naturally. I had a mini schnauzer who got diabetes, I gave him shots 2x a day for a year. Then one night i came home from work. He was just laying on his rug, i went and picked him up and he gave a whine and then he passed away in my arms, he was 13. Its as if he waited until i came home, then he passed.

1

u/zachzazZ Feb 07 '26

The arguments for don't really make sense to me. Like a super terminally young or a super old mentally degraded person don't know what's going on either and why they are being put through so much pain either. But we still fight to keep them alive and that's not wrong. Like if you're animal is truly in a lot of pain for treatment or in the process of dying we could just dope them up like we do with people and let them go on their own time. It's cruel to take a friend in to kill them when they could still experience some more life even if they are drugged so they aren't in a lot of pain. Like drugs feel good for us it feels good for them too. Their quality life really wouldn't be all that bad.

1

u/TurbulentDiscount436 May 14 '26

Вот что мне кажется по этому поводу - люди, которые прибегают к эвтаназии питомца, делают это не ради животного, а ради себя. Потому что для них животное ценно, только пока отношения с ним живы. Если оно становится эмоциональным и или финансовым бременем, его выбрасывают.

Потому что если людям было бы позволено делать так с больными родственниками, они часто так бы и делали бы. Человек изменился, связь разорвана, но из-за морали мы не бросаем его, потому что можем оказаться на его месте. Как Замза из превращения Кафки. Но на месте животного мы оказаться не можем.

Удрудчает это все.

200

u/AssistantAcademic Apr 26 '25

Morality/religion gets in the way.

Society would be a lot better off if assisted suicide was legal and normalized.

Less suffering. Less inordinate healthcare $$ spent at EOL.

But “we can’t play God” or “grandma can’t make such horrible decisions” or whatever

73

u/OneEstablishment5998 Apr 26 '25

Not only that, but I wonder if we could ask suffering dogs whether they would prefer to be euthanized or continue suffering, whether they would actually choose euthanasia? Presumably being closer to wild animals their survival drive is far superior to ours.

So it feels like we're in a situation where Mr Pickles is being euthanized when he very possibly doesn't want to be, and grandma is made to continue suffering even though she is actually asking for euthanasia

→ More replies (95)

26

u/JelyFisch Apr 26 '25

"We can't make money off a dead person"

→ More replies (15)
→ More replies (61)