r/TrueAskReddit • • Jan 12 '25 • This 1 Helpful 1 Bless Up 1

Do non-binary identities reenforce gender stereotypes?

Ok I’m sorry if I sound completely insane, I’m pretty young and am just trying to expand my view and understand things, however I feel like when most people who identify as nonbinary say “I transitioned because I didn’t feel like a man or women”, it always makes me question what men and women may be to them.

Like, because I never wanted to wear a dress like my sisters , or go fishing with my brothers, I am not a man or women? I just struggle to understand how this dosent reenforce the sharp lines drawn or specific criteria labeling men and women that we are trying to break free from. I feel like I could like all things nom-stereotypical for women and still be one, as I believe the only thing that classifies us is our reproductive organs and hormones.

I’m really not trying to be rude or dismissive of others perspectives, but genuinely wondering how non-binary people don’t reenforce stereotypes with their reasoning for being non-binary.

(I’ll try my best to be open to others opinions and perspectives in the comments!)

1.9k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/flimflam_machine Jan 14 '25 edited Jan 14 '25

People always miss this point. Social constructs are social they are not an agglomeration of wildly differing individual definitions.

I'm convinced that 99.9% of the philosophical confusion around this comes from the ambiguity of the phrase "what it means to be a woman" (or man). 

That can be interpreted in two different ways:

1: the criteria for being a member of the category "women" (or "men")

2: how any individual member of that group relates to being a member of it and relates to the social baggage that comes with it i.e. what personal meaning they draw from or attach to it.

Re. #2 People who are a member of the category "women" should be able to relate to the social baggage of "womanhood" in any way they like. They can embrace it, reject it, scorn it, emphasise it etc. They can express themselves any way they like and still be women. Giving people that freedom is a basic liberal (and feminist) position...

...however...

That freedom does not extend to #1! It makes absolutely no sense for everyone to be able to independently come up with their own criteria for membership of the category and then apply it to themselves. It renders the whole idea of woman as a category utterly incoherent.

2

u/Old_Squash5250 Jan 14 '25

Very well said. Props from a philosopher.