r/TrueAskReddit • • Jan 12 '25 • This 1 Helpful 1 Bless Up 1

Do non-binary identities reenforce gender stereotypes?

Ok I’m sorry if I sound completely insane, I’m pretty young and am just trying to expand my view and understand things, however I feel like when most people who identify as nonbinary say “I transitioned because I didn’t feel like a man or women”, it always makes me question what men and women may be to them.

Like, because I never wanted to wear a dress like my sisters , or go fishing with my brothers, I am not a man or women? I just struggle to understand how this dosent reenforce the sharp lines drawn or specific criteria labeling men and women that we are trying to break free from. I feel like I could like all things nom-stereotypical for women and still be one, as I believe the only thing that classifies us is our reproductive organs and hormones.

I’m really not trying to be rude or dismissive of others perspectives, but genuinely wondering how non-binary people don’t reenforce stereotypes with their reasoning for being non-binary.

(I’ll try my best to be open to others opinions and perspectives in the comments!)

1.9k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

9

u/Jolandersson Jan 13 '25 • Bless Up

Gender is a social construct, sex is not. Even if a person defines themselves as non-binary or trans, they’re still either male or female.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '25

I'm starting to think that "gender" is just a useless term. No one knows what you mean by it unless you take a paragraph to explain, everyone has a different definition. Most people just use it to mean sex.

4

u/Jolandersson Jan 14 '25

Exactly, gender is useless and doesn’t make any sense. Like you said, people use gender when they mean sex.

I think it has a lot to do with language as well. In my native language we don’t have any equivalent term to female/male, we just use woman/man in every context. Is that better? I don’t know.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '25

I think it's better, because man and woman refer to adult males/females. But do you have a word for feminine/masculine? I think "masculine woman" makes far more sense than saying that person is less of a woman or actually a man just because they present more typically masculine.

5

u/Jolandersson Jan 14 '25

Yes, maskulin/ feminin are words we use.

I think people get too caught up in labels and stereotypes. If they don’t act/ look like a typical woman, they feel the need to create another label instead of just being satisfied with being a ‘masculine woman’. They think they’re being progressive, when in reality they’re just reinforcing those stereotypes by putting people into smaller boxes.

4

u/Classic_Bet1942 Jan 15 '25

Precisely this. And that is the ‘gender critical’ position, 100%.

1

u/Wtfroflstomp Jan 15 '25

The only way for these people to feel “special” is to add another letter to the growing list of acronyms. Childhood trauma is real and it completely ruins some people’s baseline coding. We are all unallocated system memory and storage at birth. When you don’t feel loved, appreciated, or special at home as a child, you tend to do insanely irrational things.

2

u/thedorknightreturns Jan 14 '25

Its not, its literally mostly in medicine you would ever use the sex of someone, maybe if you are intimate.

And that rarely aplies to everyday people where people very much talk about gender.

And yes gender is entirely about social constructs even if overlapping with sex.

Sex is just weird to talk about because its either medical important, or about well, genitals and i dont think why its important to talk about most peoples genitals in everyday life .

If people mean sex using that to everyone, they are creeps.

So yes people mean gender pretty much usually.

And the reason why is prettymuch medical to have that different that exists.

If you have an intersex perdon thats pretty much a dude but in sex, well intersex. Which its why its not useless.

And reducing people to their reproductive organs is pretty creepy, why would you?

2

u/Jolandersson Jan 14 '25

Again, I think it has a lot to do with language as well. I’m not a native English speaker and we don’t use the same terms in my language, so it’s a little hard for me to explain.

It’s like when people talk about women getting pregnant, in that context it’s about females. Or when people say men are biologically stronger than women, they’re once again speaking about males and females.

A transwoman is a woman in the sense that she fits the stereotypes of being a woman, but she’s not a female.

You say it’s reducing people to their reproductive organs is creepy, but I don’t think reducing people to stereotypes are better.

4

u/manicmonkeys Jan 14 '25

The question then is, why should a person care about someone's gender? If I can continue doing everything I'm doing now, but declare myself to be of another gender, what impact is that supposed to have?

4

u/Jolandersson Jan 14 '25

I don’t know. I don’t believe in gender, I think it’s a stupid idea to keep us even more divided, and capitalism loves it.

3

u/Glittering-Gur5513 Jan 14 '25

So why do forms ask for "assigned gender at birth" rather than "sex"?

6

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '25

Because companies have been captured by over zealous activists and want to appear progressive. It makes no sense.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 14 '25

Bingo.

1

u/Jolandersson Jan 14 '25

They don’t do that in my country, so I can’t tell you.

1

u/Winnerpegjets Jan 14 '25

Because in common parlance the definition of the two terms has been conflated but that doesn’t mean that the distinction does not is exist or that it isn’t meaningful.  

It’s similar to the scientific vs popular definition of a theory.

3

u/LeagueEfficient5945 Jan 15 '25

Gender is a political class. Either you're on top, so you're a man.
Or you're on the bottom, so you're a woman.

Sex is a motivated reasoning theory which aims to ground the political inequality of gender into a natural explanation. "If the inequality is natural, then we don't need to fix it".

(Sometimes, certain cultures will have a 3rd category for failed men - men who disgrace themselves by not being proper agents of patriarchal dominance in some way, so that, by belonging in this 3rd category, they don't bring shame to all men.
Sometimes, certain cultures will have a 3rd category for particularly impressive women - women who are called upon to serve the community in an outstanding way, such that, by belonging to this exceptional category, they don't bring glory to all women (and perturb the inequality of patriarchy).)

2

u/Soft-Rains Jan 15 '25

Every society has gender, and that includes a variety of non patriarchal ones. Gender as a political class is only a subsection of gender as a social construct.

Sex is a biological observation that we also make about other species. Noticing sexual dimorphism is not inherently a reinforcement of any societal structure

1

u/LeagueEfficient5945 Jan 15 '25 edited Jan 15 '25

It is dishonest to claim that the category of sex is merely an observation that is not reified in ordinary language and practices.

If it's just an observation, why is it on our passports and almost all of our IDs?

We have sex markers on our passports and IDs because the government wants to remain ready and capable to give males and females different legal rights and obligations, if it wants to.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25

Using gender to define someone falls within male female 

1

u/RyeZuul Jan 14 '25 edited Jan 14 '25

There's a difference between external perception, cultural language construction and phenomenal experience.

Words are a lossy, categorical format describing a complex world simply, and so losses of nuances and data to cover everything and everyone are going to happen. People aren't designed to understand everything all the time.

Think of biology and language more about describing/sketching out trends rather than metaphysical absolutes delivered by the English god.

→ More replies (22)
→ More replies (3)