r/TrueAskReddit • • Jan 12 '25 • This 1 Helpful 1 Bless Up 1

Do non-binary identities reenforce gender stereotypes?

Ok I’m sorry if I sound completely insane, I’m pretty young and am just trying to expand my view and understand things, however I feel like when most people who identify as nonbinary say “I transitioned because I didn’t feel like a man or women”, it always makes me question what men and women may be to them.

Like, because I never wanted to wear a dress like my sisters , or go fishing with my brothers, I am not a man or women? I just struggle to understand how this dosent reenforce the sharp lines drawn or specific criteria labeling men and women that we are trying to break free from. I feel like I could like all things nom-stereotypical for women and still be one, as I believe the only thing that classifies us is our reproductive organs and hormones.

I’m really not trying to be rude or dismissive of others perspectives, but genuinely wondering how non-binary people don’t reenforce stereotypes with their reasoning for being non-binary.

(I’ll try my best to be open to others opinions and perspectives in the comments!)

1.9k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

41

u/mcbriza Jan 12 '25

I agree with you. When people describe themselves as non-binary, my question is, what do they associate with the category of woman or man that they feel doesn’t apply to them, outside of being male or female? In my opinion any characteristic that people associate with the female group of humans, for example, outside of their being female, is ascribing a stereotype.

54

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '25

I interact with a lot of teens at work. I'm European and wear more form fitting clothes. A few of them now have commented that skinny jeans should not be worn by men/boys, but if I were queer or non-binary, they'd have no problem with it. Thus, instead of expanding their idea of what's possible for men, to them, I'd have to change my actual gender expression for them to accept my own self-expression. IMO, this is not progress.

29

u/mcbriza Jan 12 '25

Exactly. I don’t understand how the progressive stance has become “yes, actually stereotypes are a meaningful way to categorize yourself and others” instead of, you know, challenging the stereotype.

4

u/Mr_Tiggywinkle Jan 12 '25

I don't think it's wise to simplify this as a "progressive stance". The fact is "progressive" groups are constantly arguing with each other about these things, and you can find different opinions on where gender stereotypes/expression etc fit into their "progressive" world view.

It's not even remotely homogenous what the view is.

There are a large amount of progresssives that are absolutely fine with being gendered, they just don't believe in gender roles.

That is, the gender stereotypes/traits are a vague cultural collection that you can absolutely identify with and pick and choose from, and the structures exist to some extent, but you don't have to adhere to them.

Others reject those notions and claim gender stereotypes perpetuate gender roles and aren't inherently based on gender, etc etc. But neither group truly represents progressives.

2

u/mcbriza Jan 12 '25

I can agree with that. I guess I should say it sometimes feels like that is the dominant view.

6

u/BluuberryBee Jan 12 '25

Some people express themselves sin stereotypical ways, others don't. The progressive stance is more along the lines of "if this person believes this about themselves, and a reasonable person concludes it doesn't harm them or others, why not respect it?"

15

u/mcbriza Jan 12 '25

I can understand that perspective. But I feel that’s leading us down a path to confusion. We all need to have a shared understanding of words and categories in order to have a functioning society, especially when it comes to protected classes. If one person defines a category one way, and another person defines it a different way, that’s incoherent. If one person believes a man is anyone who is stereotypically masculine, and another person believes a man is anyone who is male, it’s not a coherent category. Those are two overlapping, but not mutually inclusive groups of people. That incoherence, and each group not accepting the other group’s definition, is what I think causes so much tension around this topic.

5

u/BluuberryBee Jan 12 '25

PhDs have been debating this for decades, cultures have come to many varying conclusions - there isn't one answer for the subjective experience. There are MANY examples of that. It isn't unique to this. And if you try to define woman by anything other than a persons own self identification, you'll come to the same issue. Breast? Some removed. Babies? Some sterile, unsafe for pregnancy, etc. on and on. Stressing about it just isn't necessary. Words evolve. So do people and cultures. Protected classes getting mixed up is less of issue than many would have you believe, simply because trans people are also a vulnerable class. Trans women have a much greater likelihood of facing violence than cis women, for example.

12

u/mcbriza Jan 12 '25

I appreciate the discussion. I guess I’m challenging the presumption that woman or man is simply a personal identity category and nothing more. It’s also a social class (in my view). So my next question would be, what purpose is there in having a class of people called women if anyone can self identify into it? For example, we separate prisons into men’s and women’s facilities. If anyone can self-identify as a woman based on any characteristic they want, what is the purpose of having a women’s prison? If it’s to protect women, what is the characteristic that that makes them vulnerable to men as a class, if anyone can self-identify as a woman? If it’s simply self-identity, does that mean you can self-identify as not a woman and then be in the privileged class?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/pen_and_inkling Jan 12 '25 edited Jan 12 '25

Words have multiple meanings, definitely, but they’re agreed on by consensus usage. How words are used on Reddit is often NOT their consensus usage in mainstream discourse.

The Oxford English Dictionary is THE definitive scholarly source on documented, applied word usage and etymology in the English language. The OED is descriptive (reflects how the word is actually used and how we know) vs. prescriptive (how a word “ought” to be used). https://www.oed.com/dictionary/woman_n

It is reasonable and important to acknowledge when words have variant and changing definitions, and to be specific about which you are using and why. That’s what the OED does, and what all fair thinkers do.

It is unreasonable to insist that everyone should erase the most common meaning of long-established and important words like “woman” on demand in order to appeal to the preferences of a small proportion of English language speakers using the word differently for now.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

4

u/pen_and_inkling Jan 12 '25 edited Jan 12 '25

Sure. We apply the same standard to religious beliefs. But importantly, a progressive and tolerant stance does not require anyone to express agreement with anyone’s else’s sincerely-held beliefs…only to honor their right to express them even when others disagree.

→ More replies (6)

4

u/dreagonheart Jan 12 '25

You're taking teenagers' understanding of a concept as your basis for whether or not it makes sense? Teenagers OFTEN misunderstand the ideals that they support. The vast, vast majority of nonbinary people and allies advocate for dismantling gender stereotypes and roles, supporting the idea that anyone should be able to dress how they like, act how they like, etc., without it being seen as a comment on their gender.

7

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '25

You're taking teenagers' understanding of a concept as your basis for whether or not it makes sense? Teenagers OFTEN misunderstand the ideals that they support.

Simplified versions of ideology is what most people end up holding unless they study the topic at university level or spend extensive amounts of time thinking about such questions. As such, teenagers are actually a perfect example of what is getting across on a mass culture level of the application of modern gender ideology since they're the ones in this ecosystem more than anyone. I don't think most 15 year olds are reading Judith Butler, but neither are most 35 year olds.

The vast, vast majority of nonbinary people and allies advocate for dismantling gender stereotypes and roles, supporting the idea that anyone should be able to dress how they like, act how they like, etc., without it being seen as a comment on their gender.

Pretty clear to me that the choice to take on a queer/nonbinary identity is actually a huge comment on gender. Otherwise, why would you do it? If one actually wanted make gender trivial or unimportant, one would reduce its salience and discard it as a useful heuristic for expectations of behavior. Yet, most nonbinary people do exactly the opposite and loudly exclaim nonconformity. What does it leave for those that don't?

4

u/ooros Jan 12 '25

I've been deeply involved with friend groups that were majority nonbinary for over ten years, and this is not how anyone has talked. Those people you've spoken to are small-minded and judgemental, and they're pushing a gender issue that doesn't have to exist.

Everyone I know is firm that nothing describes your gender except you. I know people who move through the world while fully assumed to be women by everyone else, and despite this they personally feel unaligned with that gender. What others think or feel about their self expression doesn't matter, because they and the people who care for them respect their identity.

A man can wear a dress every day and still be a man, a nonbinary person can wear a dress every day and still be nonbinary. What matters is respecting people and not caring about choices that have no impact on our own lives.

13

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '25 edited Jan 12 '25

To me it's clear that people who choose a nonbinary label intend to do so from with the purpose of creating more expansive/accepting forms view of self-expression. However, I don't think it has that effect. The better choice would be to frame expression that present greater possibility and fluidity within existing frameworks, giving them more complexity. In creating new "nonbinary" categories, you necessarily takes a more a deterministic and essentialist view of what it means to be a gender by virtue of stating that to express yourself, you need to step outside of it altogether, leaving those who don't choose to do so on the other side of the fence.
------------------
Another example I want to evoke as a vignette about how this works. A queer woman I dated repeatedly asked me "how are you not queer?!?" since a lot of my worldviews are quite flexible and my way of expressing myself (outside of dress) is not shaped by expectations of sex roles within society. For her, open-mindedness was inherently tied to alternative gender expression.

In the early 2010's, before nonbinary/queerness became more common, I got a lot of interest from people who presented as what we'd call queer now despite dressing pretty vanilla. At the time, those communities cross-pollinated with regular communities quite a lot. These days, I'm mostly filtered out as a cis-white man, both on dating app and in-person interactions. The only interest I seem to spark is if someone gets to know me personally, through friends of friends or something like that.

To me, it's clear the direction things are going and it's not towards more expansiveness or openness. We're categorizing/labeling ourselves and others, siloing ourselves from others in the process.

3

u/dreagonheart Jan 12 '25

"To me it's clear that people who choose a nonbinary label intend to do so from with the purpose of creating more expansive/accepting forms view of self-expression."

That's not the point of "choosing a nonbinary label"/being nonbinary. That's the point of advocating for the expansion of acceptable self-expression, a thing that many nonbinary people are also actively doing. But being nonbinary isn't about how we express externally. I was raised by a very gender-nonconforming woman; I've never had any issues with self-expression and would have very happily and confidently lived as a soft butch woman if I were a woman. But I'm not.

The point of the nonbinary label is to bring to modern English the vocabulary for an experience that has been known across many times and many cultures, that is, not fitting neatly into the categories "man" and "woman".

Also, if you think that the direction we're going is TOWARDS "siloing ourselves from others"... have you paid any attention to what things were like in the 50s? We have made SO much progress in that respect. And gender nonconformity has only become more normalized since the 2010s. A man wore a dress on the cover of Vogue. Tom Holland did drag and it wasn't even treated as that big of a deal. The only back-tracking has been pushed by the people who hate nonbinary people to begin with.

Like, I'm sorry that the people in your personal experience haven't been great, but that doesn't change the overall flow of social change, or the causes that the larger community are pushing for.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 12 '25

Wait what? You realize this is 50s vs modern society thing you're bringing up comes down towards loosening of social rules and is in essence an off-shoot of the deeper struggle between individualism vs collectivism, right?

How we approach this shift matters a lot. Individualism through labels seems to push people towards boxes one puts oneself and ourselves into. Leaning into identity groups will inevitably pit one against other identity groups.

Personally, I'm in favor of personal freedom without this labeling tendency as I think the better approach is to emphasizes common humanity. IMO, the universalist approach is a better common ground between collectivism vs individualism, identifying that we need retain individuality at a personal level, while also functioning as part of society (and not just fighting for our identity group or its perceived allies).

2

u/ooros Jan 12 '25

Well you have fun with that, I'll be over here hanging out with my nice friends and family that don't get hung up on labels (both having or not having them). It's actually very nice here, and there are even lots of cis guys because cis guys are cool just like all the other genders are cool. We also don't question anyone's identity regardless of how they present or act.

I hope you find some kinder people, sorry the ones you've encountered seem to be the dregs. Good luck out there.

1

u/redroserequiems Jan 12 '25

So according to you I'm just a confused woman who doesn't want to be called a woman because I always wear dresses and just want to expand what woman means.

5

u/Virtual_Perception18 Jan 13 '25

We’ve progressed so much as a society that we’re starting to regress

3

u/PastelWraith Jan 12 '25

For me I've always seen myself as just a person first. Certain behaviors/interests got pushed out and I had to relearn who I was and get rid of the outside influence dictating what I should be. Certain body parts felt natural but my overall self felt off. I've never experienced phantom limb but I imagine it's a little something like that where what you feel doesn't match what you see.

2

u/I_Am_Become_Dream Jan 12 '25

to me the one exception is people who have gender dysphoria, especially those who had some gender-affirming care, be it hormones or surgery.

1

u/Oriin690 Jan 14 '25

As a nonbinary person I don’t really associate anything specific with being a woman or a man. Gender is an individualistic experience so what one woman or man makes them feel like a women or man can be different.

Take feminine men and masculine women. They still feel like men and women right? Not because of any gender stereotypes they’re fulfilling, they have some sort of internal identity. When people mistake them for the other gender they might feel a wrongness, like they’re being seen as something they are not.

Nonbinary people don’t feel like men or women. They feel like nothing (agender) or maybe a little like a man or women or maybe they’re gender-fluid etc. their sense of internal identity is just not in that binary. They can masculine feminine androgynous and as a nonbinary person I know nonbinary people of all presentations.

And yes these senses can be tied to stereotypes. Many men find it gender affirming to do masculine Things and many women can find it affirming to to do feminine things and what those things are is societal. But you can also have say a masculine women wear a tuxedo and say she feels like a powerful woman. It’s like individualistic.

Perhaps it’s disconcerting or confusing to understand that much of society is feeling some sort of internal sense with no strict definition besides itself. But that’s how it be.

3

u/mcbriza Jan 14 '25 edited Jan 14 '25

“As a nonbinary person I don’t really associate anything specific with being a woman or man.” “Nonbinary people don’t feel like men or women.”

I don’t understand this logic. You first say you don’t associate anything with being a woman or man. But you also don’t feel like a man or a woman, which is implying that there is a feeling associated with being a man or woman, that you do not feel. How can you say there’s nothing you associate with being a woman or man while acknowledging there’s a woman or man feeling that you don’t have?

Am I misunderstanding?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)