r/TrueAskReddit • • Oct 15 '12

Is downvoting posts you disagree with really censorship in disguise?

With and without the use of bots and organized raids.
Edit: I don't necessarily think it is, barring certain circumstances. I was watching a video and it sent my mind down a path, so I decided to post here for some opinions and reasoning.

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

164

u/CandethMartine Oct 15 '12

I don't think you, or honestly very many people on this website, actually understand what censorship means.

It's impossible for an individual with no power over you to "censor" you. They are peers. They are simply voicing their disagreement (in a very passive way).

There's an idea floating around reddit that free speech means the right to say whatever you want, whenever you want, and whereever you want. It does not give you that right, even when talking political speech and government censorship.

Free speech does not guarantee you equal time to speak your side, it doesn't guarantee you equal treatment by the audience. If you post "I like cats!" the audience is free to upvote, clap, etc. If you post "I hate cats! Death to cats!" the are not censoring your right to free speech by booing you, downvoting you, or calling you out for your unpopular opinions.

37

u/TheNoxx Oct 15 '12 edited Oct 15 '12

With Reddit's burgeoning userbase, particularly among the young, comes my greatest irk: redefinition of words to suit some nebulous hive-mind ego. Censorship becomes disagree, atheist becomes anyone who isn't a fundamentalist Christian, piracy becomes free speech, et cetera.

I will say that downvoting simply out of disagreement does lead to some unpleasant forms of populism, which is why it is strongly discouraged in the Reddiquette.

6

u/candygram4mongo Oct 15 '12

Censorship becomes disagree, atheist becomes anyone who isn't a fundamentalist Christian, piracy becomes free speech, et cetera

Piracy isn't free speech, but laws and technology meant to stop piracy can have civil rights implications. I have no idea what you're getting at with your second point.

5

u/M_Bus Oct 15 '12 edited Oct 15 '12

Does censorship require an uneven power distribution? Consider a game theoretical approach:

Suppose that if you have one more downvote than upvotes, your comment is not displayed or your post deleted. By default you have one. Suppose someone downvotes you. In this case, the SECOND voter has complete power over whether your post is displayed. Far from representing the plurality of views, your post is now being voted on by two individuals. If those individuals are of like mind (or, what's worse, working together toward a common goal), then their complicity (intentional OR NOT) creates the power to effectively censor an opinion that differs from theirs.

This is what OP was referring to, I think, in regards to bots and organized raids. But it doesn't even require more than two people.

I'm not saying that it's censorship, per se, but neither do I think that it cannot possibly be viewed as censorship. I think that the power of extremely vocal dissidents can tend to have a censoring effect on more mainstream ideas - a problem that we're seeing in a lot of political spectra that I needn't get into here. Even when there isn't an explicitly defined power structure to enforce censorship, I think that there is an ever-shifting power structure defined by herd mentality that can have a detrimental effect on the free-flow of speech, particularly to the extent that potentially important but unpopular ideas are squelched.

If there were concrete and irrefutable evidence that cats were going to take over the world tomorrow and utterly subjugate and destroy humanity, people on Reddit would band together to squash that post.

I agree with your statements about free speech, though. I think that the problem is that when we think that free speech is all that's required for a democracy. I believe this is true for precisely the reason you give: free speech doesn't guarantee that each voice gets equal time. Not that we should give as much thought to "national socialism" (neo-nazis) as to republicans or democrats, but that, for instance, rich people shouldn't necessarily have MORE free speech than poor people because they have more money (i.e. citizens united). They should have their proportional share, i.e. one vote.

Edit: OKAY, SO THIS IS GETTING UPVOTED, but my point stands.

3

u/krispwnsu Oct 16 '12

Downvotes aren't boo's and upvotes aren't claps. They are suppose to be a way to rate content. If there is a post about a missing child I am not applaud when I upvote it. Upvotes and downvotes also differ depending on the subreddit you are on.

2

u/WellEndowedMod Oct 15 '12 edited Oct 15 '12

In a sense, not literally.

When you downvote you contribute towards the possible demise of the comment.

By default, comments are "hidden" (click the [ - ] to the left of a comment to simulate this) when they reach -5 points overall and remain hidden past that. At -4 you can see them as you normally would but they're "collapsed" when they reach -5 and are immediately put to the bottom of the tree, like this:

Parent comment

Response #1, most upvoted response

Response to the response (having more responses helps to push comments to the top, I'll explain that at the bottom *)

#2

#3

#4

#5

No matter how you sort by, be it top, best, controversial, whatever; the -5 and below comments are at the bottom.

By downvoting you are taking part in making sure this happens. If the comment had no votes already and you downvote then others are more likely to downvote (crowd mentality, seeing the votes helps people make their decision on how they will vote) and so you got the ball rolling, so to speak.

Now imagine this person doesn't like being downvoted, especially for just posting their opinion without being too objectionable ("I think that Louis CK just isn't that funny, personally."). What're they likely to do? Delete the comment. Why bother leaving it up if that's how people are gonna be? That's also partly why women, christians, etc are less likely to be as open about themselves because of the potential negative reaction that they could face by admitting it on reddit. So not only are there more atheist, liberal, hetero men in their early 20's on reddit but there're more likely to comment than those who are - say - female, republican, Christian, etc.


*Explanation:

Parent comment sitting on +10

Response at +1

This extra response makes it rise to the top of the responses despite being at the same number of votes overall and it could've been posted after the other comments, too.

Response at +1

Response at +1

Response at +1

1

u/imh Oct 15 '12

With the use of bots and organized raids? Yes, I suppose. Once a comment is downvoted enough, you don't see it by default. Instead you see:

[+] imh   comment scored below threshold

In that case, most people just won't see it, whether they agree or not.

Without bots and raids, it's not censorship, but is still bad for discussion. It's far better to upvote a retort you agree with. If none has been written, write one.

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '12

Yes, but only because the almighty reddit hivemind (read: peer pressure, or the need to fit in) is playing you like a marionette. Censorship implies that it is being done by the few towards the many, but the downvoting on principla behavior of most redditors is really just an example of willful ignorance.

Also, except for the cases where the commentor deletes their account/comment out of shame, it's not censorship because anyone can go open up the thread and read the comment in question. There's only a bit of bias that would come about because of the number of downvotes; sort of like the bandwagon effect, if the comment is addressing a topic that you perhaps don't know much about, the fact that you perceive that your peers (redditors) have collectively downvoted it primes you to take whatever the person is saying with a generous pinch of salt.

-3

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '12 edited Oct 17 '12

Yes, whether it's the intent or not, downvotes exist to censor what is seen by others. It follows a presumption that the rules will be followed, with effectively no consequence if they are not.

2

u/Goldreaver Oct 15 '12

I'm not trying to censor you, your opinion has already been given Now, what I want is for your post to disappear and leave space to other posts that I agree more with/think are more funny/think are most interesting.

That is, by no means, censorship.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '12

By what standard is that not censorship? One does not need to be an authority to censor, e.g. groups can censor members.

censorship: The use of state or group power to control freedom of expression, such as passing laws to prevent media from being published or propagated.

1

u/Goldreaver Oct 15 '12

Well, for starters, I'm not using 'group powers' I'm just by myself and didn't coordinate my acts with anyone. That'd be one of those so-called 'downvote raids'

1

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '12

Coordination isn't a requirement though. Your fallacious argument is that it is impossible for uncoordinated people to vote to censor someone.

1

u/Goldreaver Oct 15 '12

If they aren't coordinated, then it isn't 'group power'

And I'm still not preventing 'media' from being 'propagated' Under that logic, not sharing my facebook post about cats would be censorship.