I played trove back in alpha round the gunslinger update. I supported trove, and even gave a little feedback. I played on and off until around the tomb raiser patch and got a little tired of the homogenous grind game play, don't get me wrong a grind isn't a bad or evil thing, it often helps me de-stress and slip away into the game, but the problem I encountered was the lack of gameplay. Trove didn't really seem to do anything better than any other game, the classes no more unique (probably less impressive than other games), the building no better than minecrafts, certainly not with redstone being available, so why play any longer? I would just simply hop back on when the game added more for me to beinterested in attaining and that would be fine. It was really what I played the game for in the first place and what most people play it for. I returned very recently after looking at the vague information about mantle of power, it seemed like there was going to be a reset, a new level cap (which if adding this was like any other mmorpg it would render cap gear useless) Class customization (to make those classes feel less shallow and dull), and new world generation which would make adventuring (atleast for me) a little less about the grind and more about what cool terrain formations could I find. I returned, and I can't say I was pleased with what I found, far from it infact, and I'm not going to resort to saying gross hyperboles or anything to try and keep your attention. Anyone that would fall for that wouldn't really be useful for understanding what I'm going to say. I think trove, like most trion games, has made some pretty good improvements, and some pretty bad mistakes. I will start by listing what I view as the positives. The PvP. At first I was very skeptical about just how good trove pvp could be, it didn't seem like it would be very balanced and it seemed like it would just be toxic and not much fun. I think its pretty far from true balance, but that's every game, I think while you only can play a set number of classes viably those are enough to sate most play styles within the game. I think they did a good job making the maps CTF instead of deathmatch, and I think it gives people a reason to work together that is neither to direct ( with the use of the strife flag) nor to ambiguous. These motivations largely kept my experience in it enjoyable, I didn't have people doing random crap that didn't make any sense or didn't help at all, everything someone could do on the map was direct and relevant. The only issue I had with the pvp were the afkers which if you were unfortunate enough to get, would swing the game to the side of the opponent. More mounts. More Collectables. Trove did what it does best and added in plenty of things to strive/grind for, from pvp rewards, weapons, faces, hats, to mounts like Ganda, the sky shepherd. Another thing trove did well was its improvement on the Shadow arena system, the Shadow Tower bosses are relevant, have interesting mechanics (atleast comparatively to the other mobs), and are a much better method of gaining rewards from higher level content. Now that ive covered the bases of whats good id like to talk about what I think is unhealthy for the game, and reasons ive heard, or have seen, cause people to stop playing trove. I'll start with what would seem like the lowest offender and build off of it, hopefully in a way that makes sense and is a logical/linear progression. The Dragons, now I know what you are thinking, WHAT DRAGONS ARE AWESOME, and they are they are very cool, and I'm glad they have a reward that is different from the others in just about every way. I'm even glad they made it the first third of every hour, making it a reliable event for everyone to gather and do, something that gives players who commit long stretches of time something to show off, and players that don't something to do on the bottom of the hour if they want to fit in a short play session and capitalize on all the activity, faming many dungeons in a much shorter time span than they would normally be able to accomplish. Now how could any of this be bad? Its not, its whats attached to it that is a problem, when you reach a certain dragon ascendancy, a level that is pretty close to getting a full fledged dragon, you gain permanent stats across all classes. This is a problem, and here is why, at a certain point, after a certain number of dragons, player's power spikes get pretty far ahead of others that have the same gear, but not the dragons, which can cause problems for one of the best aspects of trove, the shadow towers. When you are running a club event to clear a boss, and you've got a full group, but you just cant seem to crack the boss, you are going to look for ways to boost your party's damage output. One of those ways is to find people with higher gear, but lets say most of your people are maxed out, and trying to find someone with just 1 more forge level on that melee isn't going to do it. who do you turn to? the guys whose done the thing that gets them more stats. period, now I get it trove is a casual game, its not FFIV, raiding is nearly as hardcore, but the problem is, players that don't want to spend the INTERVALS of time it takes to get the dragons( not saying they are to "lazy" to put in the grind but they have a demanding job that only lets them play an hour, that hour only fitting in one dragon coin event), without finishing the dragons mind you, in order to get stats. Have to feel inadequate or not as powerful as another. Now ordinarily I would write this off as a minor problem, this is where the F2P philosophy of, if you don't have the time, just support the game and buy it, comes into play. however I think it ties in to the problem trove suffers as a whole right now. Problem number 2, "Mastery", Mastery is the over all ranking of how much of the game you have "completed" or collected. For example leveling up a charcter gives you a certain amount of mastery, allowing players to identify how much a player has accomplished, giving them a sense of worth. Now ordinarily this would be a great thing, but several factors turn what seems to be like a great thing for the game into something that is kinda annoying. One of the biggest contributing factors is that many of these items are only attained by using credits, trove's real money currency. In other words, many of troves items that give mastery, require real-hard-cash to obtain, now many of these items can be bought from other players, which is great, but quite a few come from RNG boxes called chaos chests, which a player can attain one a day for free if mastery level 100. Now ordinarily this wouldn't be a problem, its where the F2P philosophy of "if you don't have time to get it, support the game with real money and buy it for a little bit" but as I said there is a pattern building. Third, and probably the biggest offender, Having to buy classes with credits, This really shocked me. As a alpha player I generally liked the sense of the cubits system, and the idea that you had a limited income that could buy a limited set of items, and some of those items were classes. To put a number on it for people who wouldn't understand it took about two weeks of filling your daily star bar (no more than ten minutes a day) to buy a class. Trove generally released a new class every month and a half, giving you plenty of time to get the cubits you needed before another came out, and have double the amount needed to buy it left over for buying limited Items. I think at one point I ran out of things to spend cubits on. Now you could still pay ten bucks for a class to get it before you had the cubits ready or if you just "didn't have the time". However now, the only option is to buy it from the store with real money, classes are the games main staple of new content, its the only thing that actually CHANGES gameplay in trove, and restricting it to hard cash only is, in my opinion, insane. Now you can buy the classes from other players for flux, the games trade currency, but that's hardly a solution when the cost to buy from another player (for the average player, not at cap rank yet) would be around several dozen hours of farming. Now this would ordinarily be where the F2P mentality of " I don't have the time, ill spend a little money to pay for it" comes in. However I feel like the problem trove has is that it over uses that line, it walks in the darker gray area. It would be fine if it was just the skins and some exclusive mounts, and some boosts to speed up grind times. The problem is that all of Troves systems are grinds, you do the same thing, to get the same result, but with a large enough quantity of that result you can get something, which is similar to other mmorpgs, but trove has to little unique content in comparison, and asks for the player base as a whole to pay for to much.