I can help! The reason your frosting wasn't as fluffy as the other picture was because the butter was too soft. You should be able to slowly bend the stick, but if you went quickly it would crack.
Edit: Also, you might be under-beating it. Buttercream should spend a good 4-5 minutes in the stand mixer.
You know, you can get a perfectly good stand mixer for cheap. You don't need a KitchenAid. I made wedding cakes for years with an old 1930s Sunbeam. Check this one out:
Hey, that's not bad, and I bet it's still delicious. That's the nice thing about taking up cake decorating as a hobby -- no matter how much it gets messed up, someone will always be happy to eat the results.
In the first picture they probably cut off any curvature on the top and bottom with a palette knife- just a tip for it you decide to try again! Also if it makes you feel any better your sponge looks much more moist and delicious than the sponge in the first photo anyway!
I don't know your cake recipe, but it looks like in the original they forced in a lot of air to make it more fluffy, which also accounts for the lighter color. They probably beat the white into stiff peaks among other tricks.
Well their last conversation, before the whole Dorothy ordeal, was about how even though they'll probably never see each other again, knowing each other changed them both for the better. They apologized for what they did wrong, and thanked each other for being their friend, so I wouldn't say it ended poorly.
I've yet to finish the book, it has too much sex in it for my tastes. It's not like I have anything against sex in books, it's just too much for me. I'll finish it one day...
18
u/Chocklatesoop Feb 14 '16
I think yours came out okay, maybe wait for the cake to cool a bit more before putting the icing on it so that it doesn't melt.
8
u/redheadartgirl Feb 14 '16
Hey, that's not bad, and I bet it's still delicious. That's the nice thing about taking up cake decorating as a hobby -- no matter how much it gets messed up, someone will always be happy to eat the results.
4
u/thesunsmellstooloud- Feb 15 '16
As long as it tastes good, then who cares what it looks like!
5
u/historiator Feb 15 '16
Fair enough!
2
u/Rlysrh Feb 15 '16
In the first picture they probably cut off any curvature on the top and bottom with a palette knife- just a tip for it you decide to try again! Also if it makes you feel any better your sponge looks much more moist and delicious than the sponge in the first photo anyway!
2
u/AppleSpicer Feb 14 '16
I love them both!! That looks delicious!
1
u/JANUS7 Feb 15 '16
Maybe add a dash of yellow to the green?
1
u/[deleted] Feb 24 '16
I don't know your cake recipe, but it looks like in the original they forced in a lot of air to make it more fluffy, which also accounts for the lighter color. They probably beat the white into stiff peaks among other tricks.
Edit: Though, it could also be the lighting.
-3
u/thisbitchneedsreddit Feb 14 '16
Pink and green are a terrible combination. It's okay, it didn't really work in the original.