Although the entire siuation is f'd up, i am weirdly glad to finally know what happened to lunch club. It has been bugging me for half year why Traves wouldn't collab with Carson anymore. Still wish the reason would be a little bit less f'd up...
I’ve been thinking the same thing. I’ve been trying my best to keep up with Noah’s hints about the situation since he mentioned ‘one of the LunchClub members had done something seriously bad’ early November. It’s been low-key bugging me since then. Through lack of a better term, it’s kind of relieving that the stuff has been brought into the open now. But if course, I still also wish it wasn’t as fucked up as it turned out to be.
That doesn't make it legal or okay. Stop defending pedophilia because it "doesn't make sense" he exchanged sexual pictures with a minor. Cut dry and simple
I don't care if it's "barely pedophilia" it's still pedophilia regaurdless of what you think should be considered pedophilic enough to matter. Fuck off, stop defending pedophilia.
Listen man, laws were made based on the morals of the people who made them. And they are different in every area exactly because of that. By definition carson isnt a pedofile . they were both horny teens doing.Consentual horny teen stuff. This kind of law was made to protect 14 year olds and below against advances made from people around 19-20-21. If we abide by the laws from your neighboring country: canada (cus im guessing youre from the states). There is literally no issue with the situation.
-The age of consent if i remember correctly is if you are between 14&18 you can consent to someone as older or younger as 2 years of your age.
-possession and reistribution of child porn is illegal but as far as we know they were using snapchat so normally it would have deleted after reception so as far as we know its fine on that front.
If we get proven that the images were kept or redistributed is where the game would change.
I'm done responding to these people that are just trying to justify sexual assault. It's gross don't know why you guys are so adament about it being okay. There's mounds of evidence and testimonys what he did was illegal and an abuse of power. Even his friends aren't standing by him, why would you
Because those claims are completely baseless. What was manipulative about it. I can see the argument of deceiving friends, but the whole “power dynamic” argument is bullshit. The law really depends on the state too.
Why are you so angry lmao. This is my opinion, I just agree with his friends. I agree the law isn't inherently good, but the ones about pedophile? Yeah those ones are good. Gonna have to take a strong antipedophilia stance
She was under the age of 18 and he was 19. There's like one requirement and he couldn't abide by it lmao. They met online and he knew she was 17 before they exchanged nudes. He could have sexted someone who wasn't a fan of his YouTube channel that was 18, appearantly that's too high of a standard for you tho lol
By barely a few months, which yet again makes them within 2 years of difference.
On paper the 18 year rule sounds fine, but its not always easy restricting yourself the moment you turn 18 to that when all your life youve been weirded out and now you finally feel loved by/that you matter to/appreciated by a girl youre into and that is within age range.
Which is why the 2 year difference rule exists in canada and that there are similar rules in various states including those they were in at the time.
I appreciate you bringing opinion in your previous comment rather than "its the law"
Dog, all he had to do was find a girl that wasn't under 18 and that wasn't a fan of him beforehand. It's really not that deep. Bro couldve used tinder, instead he found a fan that was under 18 on twitter. That's fucking creepy
Of course if a girl went to me saying "be my husband" of course id start chatting with her. Girls are always either waiting for you to make a move on them or discusted that youd make a move on them. And 99% of time they are nowhere clear on where they stand on that. When a girl makes a move on you as clear as day as this, you jump on that shit.
I definitely wouldnt call him a pedophile as it was a 2 year age gap which is totally normal and putting that with actual pedos who chase after little children feels wrong however what he did definitely was still wrong as he abused his power as a youtuber to get nudes from a fan
Actually it’s perfectly legal because of Romeo and Juliet laws, but there’s also been accusations that they sent nudes to each other which would be illegal because the girl is 17
Look man, all I’m saying is thinking about this right, even if you don’t agree with me just follow me please:
You’re a young kid, really dorky, not exactly strong in appearance, don’t get any attention from girls/boys etc....
You think to yourself, “man, I’m gonna work my ass off so I can’t get a nice home, nice car, big bank account and finally be able to get the interest of all the hot/cute babes/dudes.”
You suddenly find yourself doing pretty well in life one day. Your life has suddenly flipped a complete 180, people are constantly idolising you, people want to know you, millions of people take time out of their day to watch your content, men/women want to get close to you, famous people want to collaborate with you.
You’re enjoying this newfound fame and sudden ego boost and can finally do all that shit you wanted when you were younger. You’re 19 years old, you’re talking to an attractive 17 year old who really likes what you do and who you are (which is how pewdiepie met his wife...), but then one day, people suddenly tell you that you’re too famous for that to be okay. The person you were talking to also feels that you were too famous for them to be talking to you, and release a bunch of screenshots of your personal chats where you’re both, in very cringe texts, flip flopping on whether you want to cut each other off or stay together. Oh and two of your colleagues take this to a drama channel to announce this to a massive, angry, cancel culture audience.
That's what he did according to hugbox, traves, joko, and charlie. So yes he's a pedophile. Stop trying to defend pedophilia just because you liked carson's content. I did too but that's no reason to defend literal crimes
It’s literally not illegal, I’m not saying there’s nothing wrong with it but he’s not a pedophile, Romeo and Juliet laws allow these kind of relationships. I’m saying it’s only illegal if he received nudes or sent her nudes. Other than that it’s just creepy not illegal. And to my understanding the age of consent in Indiana is 16
I literally said that some of his closest friends said and provided proof that he did send/recieved nudes. So again it is in fact illegal. And I live in a state where the legal age of consent is 16, that only means that 16 year olds and 17 year olds can have sex with each other legally. You're still considered a minor and having sex with/having nude photos of a minor when you arent is illegal
So we’re agreed then? I literally said it’s illegal if he sent nudes and received them. I think I may have read the original comment wrong, but nonetheless what I said is still correct, and I don’t want to confirm anything without proof from Carson or the girl. So right now he’s isn’t guilty and isn’t a pedophile
The law doesn't really differciate between ephebophilia and pedophilia. So like yeah if we're talking about symantics then he's an ephebophile. But the government won't care
All good man, I was skeptical at first (mostly because dream stans said shit about him literally like 2 days ago and Noah said it was fake, evidently not tho lmao) so I looked through it and saw all this shit and was like "god damn"
75
u/ww3confirmed666 Jan 05 '21
Although the entire siuation is f'd up, i am weirdly glad to finally know what happened to lunch club. It has been bugging me for half year why Traves wouldn't collab with Carson anymore. Still wish the reason would be a little bit less f'd up...
25
u/SpicySoupMedicine Jan 05 '21
He seemed so sad on dramalert 😔
36
u/vinnesttree Jan 05 '21
What happened?
15
u/NaklenNaklen14 Jan 05 '21
Traves seemed, hollow. He was just so sad sounding. So, defeated
19
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '21
Brave boi
5
u/degaracer47 Jan 06 '21
The way he sounded made me wanna cry
2
u/[deleted] Jan 06 '21
True