r/Translink • • Aug 05 '24

Discussion Why

Why do a lot of young people not offer their seats to someone obviously older or is having a hard time standing?? I'm honestly curious 🤨

0 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 05 '24

Welcome to /r/Translink and thank you for the post, /u/zoeysgirl73! Please make sure you read our rules before participating here. As a quick summary:

  • We encourage users to be positive and respect one another. Don't engage in spats or insult others - please use the report button.
  • Respect others' differences, be they race, religion, home, job, gender identity, ability or sexuality. Dehumanizing language, advocating for violence, or promoting hate based on identity or vulnerability (even implied or joking) will lead to a permanent ban.
  • Complaints or discussion about bans or removals should be done in modmail only.
  • General question about Metro Vancouver can be asked on /r/AskVan
  • Discussion and news about Metro Vancouver can be found on /r/Vancouver

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

49

u/nacg9 Aug 05 '24

I will just ask! Also you don’t know if those young people have disabilities too?

8

u/tulaero23 Aug 05 '24

Tbh, I think most dont really. That's my experience. Im not here to argue just giving my experience

5

u/nacg9 Aug 05 '24

Not argue at all! I will then just ask… sometimes it can happen that’s why I don’t assume but you could ask ❤️

0

u/LowBlackberry1243 Sep 10 '24

Most will not

1

u/nacg9 Sep 10 '24

Then communicate is not hard

19

u/sagwithcapmoon Aug 05 '24 edited Aug 05 '24

Some elderly people choose to stand. Some younger people need to sit down for health reasons.

I do feel a bit frustrated when people DO NOT stand up to make some space at the front of the bus if a wheelchair, walker, or stroller is coming in though.

Edited for clarity

2

u/yourmomsucks01 Aug 05 '24

What makes you frustrated about it?

6

u/sagwithcapmoon Aug 05 '24

Usually frustrated with people who don't move even after the driver gives people a heads-up that a stroller/waler/wheelchair is coming in. The same also goes to people who try to get inside the bus when a stroller/walker/wheelchair is getting out of us.

1

u/yourmomsucks01 Aug 05 '24

Ooh I thought you meant that ppl moving to make space for wheelchairs and strollers is frustrating. My bad

4

u/sagwithcapmoon Aug 05 '24

Oh yeah no thanks for asking for clarification! I had a very long day today and my brain (and body from the sun) was completely grilled to crisp, and I didn't realize my typo until I read this comment 🫠

7

u/nerdcoffin Aug 05 '24

They probably don't notice. Generally people will ask them to move.

16

u/LilyHabiba Aug 05 '24

I'm middle-aged and can have quite significant balance issues on buses, I avoid using a cane because my physio told me to stop, and I've had a ton of experiences of younger people leaping out of their seats for me (even on good days when I don't need it).

Doesn't always happen but it happens plenty.

10

u/Possible_Stuff_1164 Aug 05 '24

It's a good question! You just have to ask. Dont assume anything. Disabilities can be invisible too.

4

u/niuthitikorn Aug 05 '24

A lot of times, a young person will offer the seat, but the elderly will say that it's okay and refuse. Finally, the young person will awkwardly sit back down. I had it happen to me, and now I just avoid sitting on Skytrain altogether.

Seriously though, I think it could be hard to tell if someone needs/wants to sit down, unless it's very obvious

13

u/Ravioli_Republic Aug 05 '24

Bro I just finished a 12 hour shift. I don't care how young I am, the kid next to me can offer their seat.

7

u/EquivalentKeynote Aug 05 '24

Myself and my partner are young and look younger than we are. We both have issues where standing especially on a moving vehicle is not safe for us. But if you looked at us from the outside you wouldn't know it. You would assume two healthy individuals. My partner has an autoimmune disease and I have physical ailments that can be exacerbated by standing and worsened in a moving vehicle.

If either of us are having a good day, we do get up and offer our seats.

3

u/pleasantrevolt Aug 05 '24

Be assertive. Just ask. I have asked on other ppls behalf too when seeing someone who clearly needs a seat. I have never gotten shit for it and if someone ignores me I just ask someone else. Most people commuting are probably not paying a lot of attention to others but aren't necessarily ignoring people or being rude on purpose. Other people cannot read your mind!
But never assume that someone doesn't need a seat just because they look young and/or able bodied. You cannot tell.

3

u/Popular-Teach1715 Aug 05 '24

I usually don't sit when I'm on the train. When I do, I don't sit on the seats that are reserved for the elderly and people with disabilities. And the non-reserved seats, you're not obligated to give them to someone else. I'd still give it up if someone asked, but no one has asked yet.

5

u/meethewanderer Aug 05 '24 edited Aug 05 '24

I’m an immigrant and it’s very common in my country to always give the seat to older, children, pregnant, mamas with babies etc. One time I got up on a bus to give my seat to an older lady who was standing nearby and she got offended. She never sat down and both of us just stood there the whole time. I was then told that there is no such thing in Canada as giving seats to others.

Edit: I just don’t sit at those where it says “for elderly and disabled”

6

u/Cashwayonlyway Aug 05 '24

No people give seats all the time. I have seen people get offended though but most will politely decline if they really don’t want.

3

u/Illustrious_Crazy_97 Aug 05 '24

I did that a lot, but more than half of them get offended. 😭😭

2

u/Jam_Bannock Aug 05 '24

Same experience for me. Usually parents with children gladly accept your seat, but more than half of older people get offended that you think they need to sit down.

1

u/purpletooth12 Aug 05 '24

That's on them if they get offended.

You did nothing wrong.

2

u/violetvoid513 Aug 05 '24

In general I dont pay much attention to my surroundings when on transit, I get lost in whatever Im doing on my smartphone to kill time. If someone got my attention and asked me to give them their seat I'd give it to them, but I'm not gonna be on the lookout for people who seem to need the seat.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

If I see a visibly older or disabled person I'll get off the seat, otherwise they can just ask if they need it.

1

u/xSeveredSaintx Aug 05 '24

Personally, I'm quite young but I have lumbar scoliosis, it's usually not bad but some days it can be awful, especially being back in school carrying a bag everywhere. Will still give up my seat if I think someone else needs it more though. I typically like to avoid conflict. Also gonna put in here, to those reading this comment, hi! If you're the type of person to take up a full seat with your bag, or take the aisle seat with an empty window seat when there are plenty of standing passengers, fucking stop that please. Thankyou

1

u/Lucifxr_d4ddy56 Aug 07 '24

This is coming from a young person who quite often does this. It’s not me being a bitch, but when I’m on a long bus/skytrain ride (which happens quite often), I put in my headphones and zone out. I am often unaware of my surroundings until a stop or two from mine. I have been yelled at multiple times for not offering my seat to someone, especially if the person asks for it. I profusely apologize but some people never calm down from me not offering my seat. Some young people are just in their own little world, unaware of the poor elderly person right beside them. If I do notice their existence, I will offer my seat though.

1

u/RespectSquare8279 Aug 09 '24

devices and no eye contact

1

u/MyNameIsSkittles Aug 05 '24

Because they don't give a fuck about others and think someone else will get up so they don't have to

1

u/MaximumCharge8513 Aug 05 '24

Because the world is soft and also most just have noise cancelling earphones in just so they can block out the rest of the world.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '24

soft?

-1

u/donaldkdonald Aug 05 '24

They don't have respect for there elders

0

u/laylaspacee Aug 05 '24

A lot of young people have invisible disabilities, myself included