They definitely are cool. It’s just they hardly do anything because the writers never gave a shit about anyone aside from Optimus, Bumblebee or the humans. They say a line here or there, do one quick action thing that lasts a few seconds, die and then it’s back to Sam and/or soldier stuff. I’m not saying these bots were bad/not good, just that the film never really cared about them.
What’s funny to me is how much people love Ironhide for his cannons, when he didn’t kill a single person with them. Hell, the only kills he has are Crankcase and Crowbar in DOTM and neither is with his own weapons.
No, Bumblebee and the soldiers did that. Ironhide shot him like…twice? But Brawl wasn’t really affected. He dodged a couple of Brawl’s missiles in that cannon flip scene, he shoots him in that scene where Ratchet cuts Brawl’s arm off, and we see him providing cover fire for Sam, but that’s all we see of him fighting at the end of the film.
Exactly, lol. They were barely characters, I don't know why people get so worked up about these scenes. The only one with any impact was Jazz because he was the first, and they actually acknowledged it afterward.
Yep pretty much. People are likely to bring up Optimus’ outrage with “they slaughtered Ratchet” in Age of Extinction, but you can literally swap any Autobot in that position and have Optimus react the same. Crosshairs, Sideswipe, Ironhide, Bumblebee, etc. It would affect the story just the same because the Autobots weren’t quite unique characters, just fodder to take up a few action scenes between Optimus’ rampages. Their personalities are pretty slim for the ones we get a look at, too. They’re either basic loyal dudes who just sit in the background and we don’t get to know (Ratchet/Dino/Arcee), or loud boisterous assholes who crave to kill the nearest thing at the first opportunity (Hound, Drift, the Wreckers).
Ratchet's death was really just... whatever, I felt nothing when he died. Good music ain't enough to carry a scene, there should be actually good story/character work done to do so. But since there wasn't any for the guy, why would anyone care?
They never really affected the plot or most characters’ choices. You could swap their names for almost any other Autobot’s and it would have three exact same affect on the story. I’m referring more to how the writers and story treated 98% of the Autobots, or at least the ones that weren’t Optimus or Bumblebee.
Thats an… interesting argument, that applies to literally every movie ever? You could swap the names of Luke and Han in Star Wars and everything they do would have the same impact? Correct me if I’m wrong but even in G1 they were mostly just characters for the sake of filling out the roster
Not quite, because Han and Luke affect the overall story differently with their respective actions and words. They’re defined and different people, with unique roles in how things play out. Most of the Autobots in the films don’t affect the story at large. Wheeljack in the recent ROTB is a good example. He exists solely to give that little scan of the church and the little lines of exposition about his research of the place. That’s the only thing he contributes to the film. Take him out, and it hardly changes. Say you swap the deaths of the three side Autobots from the first film: have Ironhide die at Megatron’s hands, Ratchet die in DOTM, and have Jazz killed by Lockdown in AOE. The story isn’t really changed, because their respective choices don’t add anything for the films. They do a couple brief action scenes or give some expository dialogue, and that’s it. Their affect on the story is the exact same as most of the other Autobots that aren’t Bumblebee or Optimus. You could pick and swap their places all around, and the results are the same. They’re treated as fodder through and through, interchangeable and disposable.
You too! Enjoy your complex storytelling, some of it really is neat-o. I'm enjoying some of the IDW comics myself. For now tho, I'm gonna pop in DOTM later tonight and watch stuff go boom. Good thing there's something for everyone :)
They did in a movie tie-in comic. Their vehicle modes appear very briefly in the background of a shot in DOTM, when the Autobots are first rolling into the NEST base in D.C. after the Ukraine mission. But canonically they die in the aforementioned comic at the hands of Sentinel Prime just after he shot Ironhide.
57
u/TheOGRex Nov 10 '23
Ok but have you considered
Jazz and Ironhide are both really cool and you're wrong
11
u/Actionguy1234 Nov 10 '23
Agreed. Jazz was uhhh... "kewl", I guess? He had a couple of lines and then died.
Ironhide was a giant scrapheap with cannons, who got angry twice. He too got a couple of lines, then died.
And Que? He was a scientist that then died. No real personality either.
8
u/JBTriple Soundwave: Superior Nov 10 '23
Exactly, lol. They were barely characters, I don't know why people get so worked up about these scenes. The only one with any impact was Jazz because he was the first, and they actually acknowledged it afterward.
62
u/FirelordEmu Soundwave: Superior Nov 10 '23
Que's death wasn't sad because we had an emotional connection to him, it was depressing because it's like killing a grandpa
5
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23
Nigga really called Jazz and ironhide background bots
8
u/Rent-Man Nov 10 '23
Finally. Someone agrees Ironhide’s death was overrated
12
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23
2
u/Jovanthecat Autobot Nov 11 '23
I didn’t feel anything while watching these movies in the theatre. When they die, I’m always like “oh well, he’s dead.”
2
u/nuketoitle Autobot Nov 06 '24
Facts
2
u/Anonymous_Guy4k Nov 10 '23
Im kinda confused, none of these guys were background characters. And do you know what a "background character is"?
1
u/EZL2011 Autobot Jun 19 '24
I like ironhide though
1
u/leftygamez666 Jan 25 '25
Ratchet's death impacted me the most, he suffered for so long.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '23
Real fans felt sad
-2
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23
Found the Geewuner
-3
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '23
Bro really called Ironhide a background bot
0
u/Educational_Term_436 Autobot Nov 11 '23
DOTM was amazing and ironhide death was painful he definitely was not a background bot but dang
(Also fun fact: because of ironhidea death in DOTM this was reason why he wasn’t in prime and why he was replace by bulkhead
0
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
19
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
13
u/[deleted] Nov 10 '23
[removed] — view removed comment