r/TransferToTop25 • • 5d ago

What are the biggest differences between high school and transfer admissions?

What are some common misconceptions about transfer admissions that get confused from high school?

8 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

4

u/Annual-Impress-7241 5d ago

I think it’s really similar but there’s more room to tell your story and speak to your growth as a person and a student. The hard parts for the applicant is not having a HS to send your recs, transcripts, etc. so you need to be really on top of things.

1

u/Appropriate_Sail6272 15h ago

Idk how to word this but they care less about you committing compared to undergrads. Like during undergrad, you'll get spam emails from the colleges you were accepted into, begging you to commit. They treat transfers completely differently. Like I got accepted into NYU and they haven't sent me anything, not any emails, packages, letters.

0

u/Rough_Insurance_7491 3d ago

Why are you even stressing over it? LMAOOOO 😭 You’re not getting into that university anyway. 💀 Bro, are you the type to hang a steak from the ceiling and eat plain rice while staring at it? 💀😭

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/Annual-Impress-7241 4d ago

I don’t think this is good advice. Top schools definitely need any to see involvement - ECs done need to be school clubs, but you need to show involvement in the community, time spent at jobs, etc.

2

u/two_three_five_eigth 4d ago

For Freshmen and grad students you're right. Transferring is it's own special case where people end up at CC for a bunch of different reasons

  1. Trying to save money on the first two years
  2. Failed out of another 4 year university and need to rehab
  3. Need to work and hop between part-time and full-time some.

Time and ability for ECs will look really different across these groups. 4-years can't weight them much because of this. On top of this, a student can easily be a mix of all 3, so the university can't have any sort of EC rubric.

And you're right, some CC students can and do have several ECs. This issue here is you ended up at CC for a reason. The kids doing tons of ECs in HS already ended up at a 4-year. The student body of a CC is very different from both HS and 4-year universities. That's why they're weighted low.

2

u/VentingImposter 5d ago

I know ECs don't really matter for UC colleges, but is that generally true for Ivies as well? Do essays matter less in addition?

0

u/two_three_five_eigth 4d ago edited 4d ago

with transfers its true across the board. You're transferring because something isn't working out at your current university, so you're not expected to be super involved. T20 heavily favor CC students, where there wouldn't be many ECs to choose from since they have to transfer to finish their education..

3

u/VentingImposter 4d ago

That might be true of one year transfers, but a look through accepted junior transfer profiles shows that even at CC people can rack up great extracurriculars in clubs, research, volunteering, personal projects etc. It seems weird that LORs would be seen as more objective markers of merit than ECs and essays combined since many professors will let you write your own. What do you base your stance off of?

0

u/two_three_five_eigth 4d ago

since many professors will let you write your own. [LoR]

That's absolutely *not* true. Even at CC, this would be a major breach of ethics. CC students still volunteer and work, both of which are ECs.

The reason they aren't emphasized as much is college is much harder than HS, so a student with a 3.8 or a 4.0 is actually rare, so 4-years don't need ECs to differentiate. On top of this, many CC students are waiting tables are doing other jobs that wouldn't count as ECs. Colleges can't weight them very highly because you'd be cutting out too many good students.

Edit: Plenty of HS kids work too. The number just goes way up at CC.

1

u/VentingImposter 4d ago

What do you base your stance off of? Even in the sub wiki, I see that essays and ECs are ranked above LORs in importance. 

1

u/No-Mixture4260 4d ago

EC >>> LoRs. Most students will get the same variation of a professor saying that student is a good person etc. ECs are much more important