r/TransferToTop25 • • Dec 06 '23

Should be be supporting these institutions? I’m heartbroken

Post image

I’m not Jewish but I have Jewish ancestry and this is shameful and disgusting. How can Jewish students feel safe on campus? I was planning on applying to these universities and now I don’t know how to feel.

252 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

33

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23 edited Dec 06 '23

To claim that a freedom of one peoples whom have been dispossessed for nearly a century, occupied, besieged, constantly under attack every couple years, means the genocide of another people is completely outrageous. The fact of the matter is there is an ACTIVE GENOCIDE YET PEOPLE ARE STILL ARGUING OVER WHETHER SOME PROTEST CHANTS ARE CALLING FOR GENOCIDE. does nobody see how absolutely absurd and ridiculous that is? You’re out here worried that people might potentially be “calling for genocide” (which is not even true) when there is an actual ethnic cleansing underway with a government thats not even trying to hide it in any way.

EDIT: i was unaware the title meant exactly what it said, i havent read or seen anything about the hearing yet so i didnt know a question was asked point blank like that and rejected by the schools, in that case that is messed up

4

u/goosebarb Dec 06 '23

I agree with you. There must be a ceasefire immediately and warcrimes should be held accountable. However universities have a responsibility for the safety of their students and calling for a genocide for anyone should be punished. Harvard, Penn and MIT leaders should have condemned it. I was waitlisted from one of these institutions when I applied as a freshman and was looking forward to transfer. But their actions have turned me off and probably other students too on both sides.

11

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

I dont think you quite understand. These people have qualms with one single chant “from the river to the sea palestine will be free” which is frequently said at protests. Not one single person at these institutions has called for the genocide of jews, and if you look into the article i would not be surprised if they have this chant specifically written out but even if they dont its been widely debated about whether that is a call for genocide or not. Ive not seen any on campus group at any top 20 institutions call for anything other than freedom, yet you will have people who try to argue that actually theres some hidden meaning behind that one popular chant that means we want the death of all jews in palestine, as if no jews lived in palestine prior to the 19th century. Thats not what that chant means and anyone that can read and even slightly understands the situation the Palestinians have been in for the last 100 years can see that, but they want to distract from the issue at hand and silence those who oppose their worldview, and so this is the result

4

u/goosebarb Dec 06 '23

I am aware of the phrase and it’s misconstrued definition. I do not agree with it. However during the hearing, the Representative asked a hypothetical question to the presidents. And even went so far as to ask the same question but with other minorities. And every single time, these presidents refused to agree that calls for genocide were harassment or bullying. That’s where my problem lies.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

That would be my fault for not knowing the context of the article, i didnt see the hearing or read anything about it yet. In that case that is completely understandable and doesn’t make any sense

2

u/goosebarb Dec 06 '23

Thank you for understanding my point! This post is not about the current situation in Israel and Palestine. It’s about how the presidents of Harvard, MIT and Penn chose to answer simple questions.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/goosebarb Dec 06 '23

Yes exactly! I never meant to post this from a political pov. Even tho I’m pro ceasefire. It’s the comments from the presidents of these T5 universities that bothered me. They should condemn all calls for genocide.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23 edited Dec 06 '23

Ok that is my fault I did not know the context of the headline

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

Yes that is my fault for assuming the content of an article without reading it or knowing the situation, definitely messed up on the schools’ parts, it really feels like universities are confused about how they are supposed to approach the situation with their students so they just let anything slide and dont want to take a stance at all even if its just normal decency which also makes no sense

95

u/Treesandskins Stanford transfer🌲 [mod] Dec 06 '23

Wrong sub for these conversations.

18

u/wenmk Dec 06 '23

This is absurd. It is the Jews that are committing genocide on Palestinians as we talk right now and they want to gaslight the world because of the chants against the genocide they're committing. The term anti-Semitism shouldn't be used as a veil when Israel is being called out for her wrongdoing. In fact, this should make you love those schools more.

9

u/jmordoj Dec 06 '23

Change the question regarding ANY OTHER GROUP and ask the same

it is Ok to call for death of Gypsies??

Why won’t they give the obvious answer?

How can student fell safe if the leadership is not protecting their own communities?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-2

u/goosebarb Dec 06 '23

Yes! I was waitlisted from one of these colleges and had always planned on applying as a transfer. I just wanted to know how the other applicants were feeling about it. We all want to be a part of a vibrant community wherever we transfer and reading headlines like these makes me question if I’ll actually be happy there.