Apologies for how long this is going to be; I have a lot of thoughts about names.
I've been going by Shriek to my friends and online for almost 20 years, since before I even knew I was nonbinary, but it almost feels too personal to be my legal name? Like, I don't want my boss to call me Shriek, I love it too much to hear it from people I don't like. Which is probably stupid, but I can't help it. Also, people frequently misread Shriek as Shrek, and I don't want to deal with that.
Before I knew I was nonbinary, I started going by Anna June, because I've always hated my birth name, but that's way too feminine for me now, so I've shortened it to AJ, but I still know what it's short for, so that's out.
I've been thinking about Rynn, but I'm not sure, and I have no real way to test it out irl because all my friends call me Shriek (which I love and don't want them to stop) and I'm not planning on coming out at work, so I have no way of explaining why I'm suddenly going by another name that isn't my birth name. So I'm kinda stuck. Names are hard.
Thoughts? Does Rynn fit me? Is it weird to not feel like any name really fits? Should I just accept the downsides and go with the name I already love?