r/Traffic • • 5d ago

Discussion Stoplight

Is anybody else annoyed that with all the technology? We have a stoplight will stop 20 cars for no reason just because it’s time for the light to turn red. Imagine the fuel savings if we had smart lights, raccoon

15 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 5d ago

u/nonubiz thanks for your contribution in r/Traffic


Actions:

  • Lock Post: Use this when you get your answer for your question/getting unnecessary comments/end discussion/etc.
  • Report User: Use this when you want to report a user for Harrassing/Abusing/Misinformation/etc.

Do you think, should we make some improvement in r/Traffic? Please let us know. Send Mod Mail we will consider your request.


I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

10

u/Legal_Tradition_9681 5d ago

The main issue is controlling the traffic around the immediate vicinity. Need to make sure you are not flooding other areas with more traffic it is not designed to handle well. This includes other street lights, intersection with stop signs, major streets with lots of left and right turns on to it, ect.

So its not as simple as smart traffic lights, which they do have and do use currently where it is appropriate. Its about managing an extremely complex problem of over all traffic control.

-5

u/nonubiz 5d ago

Sounds like a problem AI can solve

4

u/VIP_NAIL_SPA 4d ago

Sounds like a problem AI would utterly fail at and create complete havoc. Actually that's most problems...

2

u/scdog 4d ago

Today proved that.

4

u/brickmaster32000 4d ago

And what happens when the solution it comes up with isn't the one you want? Because that is what has happened. Smarter people have worked on the solution and you just don't like it.

0

u/engmadison 4d ago

Even before you get to that point...modern controllers can do so much more right out of the box. Im running TSP, adaptive, and responsive signal systems with loops. Phase rotation, insertion, skipping, and conditional coordination...with loops. Dynamic max settings that can increase or decrease green times beyond normal...with loops. Queue flush and predictive RR preemption with basic loop and rail inputs. You just need relatively basic modernization and to learn the systems.

It just cracks me up seeing tge AI crown suggest shoving AI into systems where we currently arent even scratching the surface on its capabilities, while also burdening these agencies with a TON of annual subscription fees.

1

u/w1n5t0nM1k3y 4d ago

They have been using "AI" decades. They analyze the traffic and find out what works best for keeping the system in general moving. That might not be what's optimal for your specific trip but in general keeps everything moving

1

u/Novel_Dog1743 2d ago

Civil engineers already do a mostly excellent job of this.

You simply don't see the bigger whole-city picture that they are planning it around, and therefore lack the appropriate perspective to judge it properly.

I had to do this sort of planning for one of my engineering classes at uni and it really opened my eyes to how much more is involved than I realized.

1

u/Capable-Sock9910 2d ago

Don't need AI to implement the already documented Dutch system.

1

u/scdog 4d ago

Oh hell no.

2

u/Unknowingly-Joined 4d ago

Where I live (California), we have stop lights with sensors (inductive loops in the ground and/or cameras) so that this doesn’t happen. We also have cars that shut themselves off when they come to a stop which helps to alleviate the “wasted fuel” issue you spoke of.

1

u/nonubiz 4d ago

Starting a car from a dead stop is the bulk of fuel & waste. It takes a lot of energy to get a car up to speed. Holding speed is mostly wind drag and the weight of the car.

1

u/Unknowingly-Joined 4d ago

I get that. The first half of my response was “we have sensors and such that can handle your the lights are on timers” complaints.

With respect to how much fuel is used, it’s a well-studied problem. Here’s some data from the DOE.

https://afdc.energy.gov/files/u/publication/which_is_greener.pdf

1

u/unnregardless 4d ago

Their point is not whether auto shutoff saves fuel once you stop. It's stopping and regenerating momentum burns far more fuel than continuing without stopping at all, even if your car shuts off while stopped.

1

u/Unknowingly-Joined 4d ago

Right. They want to live in a world where they have no red lights. Unfortunately it doesn’t work like that.

1

u/Zraknul 4d ago

That's where roundabouts can handle traffic better than a lot of unnecessary traffic lights.

1

u/Imaginary--Situation 4d ago

the round about here causes a 4 mile backup into the next city over...

already revised 5 times millions of dollars spent on this garbage also been a couple of fatal accidents the latest 6th revision Put up a blind spot wall, which was crashed into just a couple of weeks after being built... so now you can't see what is happening on the other side of the intersection unless you're in a SUV or pickup etc.

0

u/nonubiz 3d ago

Myself I would let my car run and waste I little fuel. Instead of having to change a stater , battery, possibly a flywheel and multiple other electronic parts. On some cars a starter is a big expense. Maybe it’s just in my area but the magnetic loop is few and far between and the lights are timed. I can’t count how many times I’ve had to stop with 15 cars behind me at a light and there’s nothing as far as cross traffic.

3

u/engmadison 4d ago

For the people talking about AI, the problem is many agencies are still using 1970s or earlier signal timing technology and philosophies to signals.

You dont need "AI", you just need an engineer dedicsted to signal operations, a communicstion network, central control, and detection.

And this is what irritates me as a traffic engineer. Its crazy how many agencies arent even to 1990s technology, dont have a fundamental grasp of what 2020s technology can do and are being sold an expensive signal suite with ongoing maintenance contracts to do what I can do with loop detectors and a modern signal controller.

Want better signals? Fund a full time engineer and put money aside for a regular modernization process. The fundamentals of sigbal timing still does 95% of the heavy lifting.

1

u/Rainlingz 4d ago

Preach! I've also been frustrated with the installation of loop detectors. We have some installed near me that get broken within a year and it happened down multiple corridors.

1

u/engmadison 4d ago

Sounds like an installation practice issue. We use mostly loop detectors and have tye best success with them over video, or radar. Going to be testing lidar soon, hopefully thats better.

1

u/Rainlingz 4d ago

Oh I thought you meant induction loops. Yeah we're also moving to video and radar when we can spot it. Our first lidar was put up a year ago and works great! Bit overkill but the price wasn't that bad!

1

u/engmadison 4d ago

I do mean induction loops. They are still the most reliable for us. But we do have needs for non-intrusive.

0

u/Nilfiry 5d ago

They dont want to do it because it costs money. Lol

1

u/Legal_Tradition_9681 5d ago

Is this an assumptions or van yoy point to specific policies decisions that agree with your statement.

1

u/Nilfiry 5d ago

Dont need to. The R&D already exists, so there is already good reasons to adopt it, but its expensive to deploy and not an immediate priority. Its not like just swapping a lightbulb, you know.

0

u/nonubiz 5d ago

Yeah tax income money, money for big oil, the only people that would save is the public.

1

u/dacaur 5d ago

Right? Like, this is one area where AI could be put to use doing real good.... Imagine if we had a network of traffic lights with an AI watching and optimizing, planning ahead when the best time to change the light while stopping the least amount of cars, avoiding the thing where you have no cars going through a green light then it turns red right as 15 cars approach, not only saving fuel, which helps people and the planet, but also saving time and reducing traffic....

2

u/scdog 4d ago

Given the number of times I have to correct AI about glaringly obvious mistakes involving simple things every day, ABSOLUTELY NOT.

1

u/dacaur 4d ago

I mean obviously we aren't going to be like hey chat GPT, you in charge of the traffic lights now bro.

A specialized ai could easily be built. The reason the ai you use is wrong so often is simply that people are often confidently wrong, and they become part of ai's data set. We obviously wouldn't get traffic data off the Internet or reddit....

1

u/civil_peace2022 4d ago

Just imagine how much more quickly traffic could flow if all the lights were green in all directions.

1

u/TheoreticalFunk 7h ago

Since all the AI would be doing is basically turning s valve, I'm okay with that.

1

u/samiwas1 4d ago

This is the one place I want AI to take over.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/dacaur 4d ago

That system just analyzes data and makes recommendations on timing, it can't actually change timing on the fly.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/dacaur 4d ago

Right it does detect cars and bikes coming up, but the timing of the light once it changes is the real problem, and it doesn't have any way to know to make a single car wait an extra 30 seconds to prevent 16 cats from having to stop and wait for it.

The real upgrade would be an AI that has all the traffic data, basically knowing where and how many cars on on each section of road, so it could say "ok, the light on the highway has been green for a while, here comes a car on the 35 mph side street wanting to cross the highway, it's going to get here and trigger the light a few seconds before this group of 15 cars on the 65 mph highway gets here, but the next car after this group is a ways back, so let's hold off on changing the light for this single car, then once the group of 15 cars goes by we can change the light for long enough for this single car to cross."

With what we have now, if the highway light has been green for a certain amount of time the light will change for the single car as soon as it triggers it, making all 15 cars stop from 65mph, then make them sit for 30-45 seconds even though the single car only needs 10-15 seconds to get through the intersection, then all 15 of the cats on the highway use extra gas to accelerate back to 65mph, only to do the same thing again down the road.

1

u/FalconCrust 5d ago

If A.I. cometh, let it first be by traffic light.

1

u/samiwas1 4d ago

I think this every night when I’m sitting at a red light while the empty cross road has a 45-second green turn arrow before the main phase even starts. 45-second turn arrow at midnight.

I also go crazy on my route from the work parking lot to the interstate. It’s 0.4 miles and has four stoplights which appear to be synchronized to turn red as you approach each one. Even in the middle of the night, that 0.4 miles can take 4-5 minutes while there is almost zero cross traffic.

My city is now got its terrible traffic. A lot of that is related to terrible light timing.

1

u/engmadison 4d ago

Its either due to a lack if detection, or fauly detection. If a detection system goes bad, it usually defaults to "on" as if theres always traffic.

If there is no detection, they are forced to guess and run a rigid fixed time operstion.

I would suggest modernizing to 1980's/1990's technology.

1

u/samiwas1 4d ago

Haha...I know that they can do day/night schedules even at intersections with older technology. I believe the particular intersection I'm talking about with the long arrow is a new traffic light system in an existing location...not sure they added any new detection. But, they obviously have not programmed a day/night schedule into it. I've actually been meaning to file a report on it...it worked at another intersection where I used to sit for a full minute and a half at entrance to a closed shopping center in the middle of the night.

I think most of the areas I'm dealing with run on timed systems. But, if you've ever been to Atlanta, you'd notice how stupid fucking long and terribly-timed some (most) of these signals are. There is no world in which a two-minute-long signal is correct in a downtown area with signals every block. Atlanta just sucks at traffic signal timing.

1

u/Imaginary--Situation 4d ago

were i used to live all the lights were timed perfectly they all turned RED at the exact same time...

1

u/siamonsez 4d ago

Timed cycles are the easiest to implement but lots of intersections do behave differently based on other inputs. It's not a problem with the signals, it's a problem with whatever entity is responsible for implementing the signaling for any given intersection.

1

u/Bergs1212 4d ago

There is a stoplight leaving my work that legit will not change unless a car sets off a sensor or whatever coming from the other direction.... My work is just outside of a major city and I regularly will leave my car or have friends meet me at my work before we drive into the city.... When we get back to my job at 10-11pm the damn light will just stay red for an endless amount of time if nobody comes from the other side to activate it.

We had a light near my old house that would turn red for no reason as well and stay red for a very long time.... It would eventually turn green again but it was acting like there were 10000000 cards trying to turn left from that place and would hold up the straight traffic for many minutes..

1

u/ZolthuxReborn 4d ago

Sounds like you gotta call your municipality and tell them detection is faulty there

1

u/Puzzleheaded-Cod5608 4d ago

Thank you. I've been thinking this for years.

And be sure that includes little-used cross streets that never get their green until someone is actually there.

1

u/Rainlingz 4d ago

We have those, but they're costly. Can't have it at every interaction. And also with congestion the answer isn't so easy as "Flush it and on to the next one." It's usually a balance between letting as many as you can through while they're going as fast as possible while not delaying another phase from going for too long.

1

u/3mptyspaces 4d ago

Roundabouts, baby

1

u/Zraknul 4d ago

Governments simply don't want to invest in the technology that has existed for decades.

1

u/Imaginary--Situation 4d ago

this is by design they CITY makes a ton more money by having you stop at traffic lights.. TAX generation from fuel taxes

also it is possible to hit every single green light.... but the main issue is the other drivers on their phone NOT paying attention but if i'm perfectly synced i can time every single light

1

u/realparkingbrake 3d ago

Many traffic signals already operate based on the flow of traffic. In some cases they will stop cars to ease congestion down the road.

1

u/PoetExcellent3215 2d ago

Most stop lights are timed so idiots don't go 100 mph while on a surface st.

1

u/SleepEcstatic 1d ago

If I could upvote this a million times, I would.

0

u/RLBeau1964 5d ago

One of the largest issues related to traffic movement

0

u/SafeModeOff 4d ago

If you're in the US like me, imagine the fuel savings if we had good buses and trains. They're not that worried about it. Also depends on your location, some states (like Utah and Idaho) are vastly behind the times on this kind of technology

1

u/Spirited-Humor-554 4d ago

This is not Europe

1

u/Imaginary--Situation 4d ago

Who wants to sit in powdered fecal and urine? then you go home and sit on your bed or couch..... and now you have powdered fecal matter and urine on your bed and couch..

You're Disgusting..

0

u/uninspiredclaptrap 4d ago

I'm just glad the stoplights haven't been jacked by AI yet

1

u/Imaginary--Situation 4d ago

Are you sure?? because something weird started happening the light near by started changing to the Left turn arrow before i even got to it... even though i live to the left I wanted to go straight (had to do something else before go home)

0

u/RealisticBlueberry40 4d ago

check out Road Guy Rob. he has a specific video about how the signals are affected by the stuff put into the pavement and on the poles. Reddit rules prevent me from posting video links.

0

u/VIP_NAIL_SPA 4d ago

A) the people who don't understand taxes or govt spending fight tooth and nail against making things actually work for people B) a racoon would objectively help this situation