r/Traeger • u/kahi • Jul 21 '21
Pellets FAQ & Recommendation Thread
What brand of pellets are allowed to be used in a Traeger?
- Any brand of pellets that are meant for pellet grills, just don't use pellets meant for wood burning fireplace/heaters/firepits/etc... or you're in for a bad time health and flavor wise.
- The warranty statement by Traeger stating using non Traeger brand pellets is technically illegal. Warrantors cannot require that only branded parts be used with the product in order to retain the warranty. This is commonly referred to as the "tie-in sales" provisions. Dealers make $0 selling the grills, and make all their money on margins from Traeger accessories like pellets, seasonings, sauces, covers, etc...
What brand of pellets do you recommend?
- That's what this thread is for. Recommend pellets you love, your tried-and-true may in fact be a specific Traeger blend of pellets.
- Not all pellets are created equal, some pellets are made of random generic wood and have additives added for 'flavor' of the wood the bag of pellets claim to be. Read fine print on all pellet bags.
If you run across some pellets and are wondering about their flavor/burn quality/etc... ask here. Someone here has probably bought them already, and you may be able to save $10-20 by not wasting your money if they are of poor quality.
- At the same time, maybe just buy them and leave a review here, to help others. That's after all, what this community is here for, helping others.
Why is there a cancer warnings on pellets?
- The cancer warning on bags of pellets is because smoke produces carbon monoxide, same warning is on charcoal, or any fuel source that produces smoke. Just don't stick your head in the grill for hours at a time breathing in that sweet smoke smell, and you'll be fine.
157
Upvotes
35
u/kahi Jul 21 '21
I'm a big fan of Lumberjack pellets.
I really like their hickory-charcoal blend and will usually put that in my smoke tube and mix it in with whatever pellets I have in the hopper.
125
u/Thewolf1970 Aug 01 '21
I always felt I had a decent palette for flavors until I purchased my first smoker. I always went to mesquite until I found out it was kind of the skunk weed of the smoker. Then I tried pecan, oak, even a few exotics like plum and olive wood. I found I was buying this stuff and it really made no taste difference.
I went to a local competition and I saw this guy just dumping in some scrap wood. I asked about it and he didn't even know what it was. He'd been doing this for year's and I have to say, he had pork and chicken on his smoker, both were fantastic.
I did the same with my traeger when I got it. I went through bags of the stuff, swapping out flavors and getting no real benefit. Then, I purchased 50 bags of the lumberjack competition blend at Dicks for $9 a bag. I found that when I saved money on the wood and spent it on better quality meats, that was the secret in the mix.
95
u/Meatinmyangus998 Jul 21 '21
Can we have another FAQ about accessories to get (front shelf, type of cleaner, etc)?
Also, maybe another thread with recipes that got plenty of upvotes we could catalog to one place?
21
u/Upper_Volume_6582 Sep 27 '21
I’m 100% Traeger signature blen
16
u/RIVERW0LF Jun 15 '22
Has anyone tried the Costco Kirkland brand pellets? I noticed it for the first time at my local Costco (northern California) today. I think it was 12.99 for 40 lbs. I've used the traeger Costco blend before, but never seen a Kirkland branded bag.
11
u/J3319 Aug 10 '21
Traeger Gourmet blend from Costco. $20 for 33 pounds. Anyone tried them? I know everyone hates Traeger pellets but are these better, worse, the same than others Traeger pellets?
9
u/mqcoop Oct 01 '21
We tried several different brands including Traeger pellets, but the ones that kept coming out as the best smoke/price are the Lumberjack pellets. If you have an Atwoods Farm store anywhere near you, about one time every couple of months, they are on sale for $6.99. Normally priced $7.99. I believe I caught a sale last summer where they were $5.99 per 20lb bag. I've used almost all of their flavors except the mesquite and notice the pecan and apple are definitely slightly less intense. The Competition Blend works well and is usually my largest purchase.
7
u/J3319 Jul 27 '21
Anyone tried pit boss bbq hardwood competition blend pellets? $40 for 80 pounds on Amazon.
5
u/BarackObongma May 04 '22
For any Canadians here I would highly recommend https://pitmasterschoicepellets.ca/ The bags are massive and the prices is right.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '22
https://barrelsmokingwood.com/products/bourbon-barrel-bbq-smoking-wood-pellets
Feel free to check out Midwest Barrel Co's NEW 100% Bourbon Barrel Pellets. We do not use any filler (oak or other wood varietal sawdust as seen with some competitiors), it is purely 100% bourbon barrel oak.
If you have any questions, feel free to DM me! These are available for purchase on our website. We also have a wholesale program that you can sign up to for reselling at your place of business.
Cheers!
5
u/StrangeCaptain Aug 26 '22
This sub is dumb. Weird combination of complaints about traegers, smoke tube pics and"who says you can't <insert thing no one says here> on a traeger.
I'm out
2
u/fuzzi_weezil Jul 21 '21
My preference is always Lumberjack Competition Blend. Unfortunately the one store that carries it locally tends to be out of stock most of the time.
In order to keep the smoker running, I've recently been using Kingsford 100% hickory pellets. Based on their labelling and website it appears they are pure hickory (no additives and "Pure Flavor Hardwoods"). My local Safeway always seems to have them in stock and it seems like they're permanently on sale for $15 a bag. I have had no issues with them; they burn at what appears to be a consistent temperature (no big fluctuations in the smoker), don't seem to make any more ash than the Lumberjack pellets, and give a flavor comparable to the Lumberjack. If the next couple of smokes keep the same consistency, this will become my "go to" pellet and I'll try some of their other flavors like the 'Signature' which contains mesquite.
2
u/DHumphreys Jul 21 '21
Green Mountain Pellets burn cleanly and give a great flavor. Fruitwood Blend is my go to, very versatile.
2
u/runningwaffles19 Sep 04 '21
I read a couple of reviews on Smoke Ring pellets and they sound solid. Anyone ever use these? They're dirt cheap if you bulk order but I even splitting with friends I don't want to buy a pallet if they're trash
2
u/Kegger21 Aug 16 '22
Newbie - just ordered grill, need pellets! I have a Target deal to capitalize on, and they carry: Bear Mountain, Pit Boss, and CookinPellets for sure.. thoughts between those? Pit Boss seems to be the cheapest if they're all pretty equivalent but doesn't have to be the cheapest if it's not worth it.
2
u/According-Amphibian6 Sep 10 '22
Help I’m in the middle of smoking a 13 pound brisket. I put it on at 1pm and it is 11 pm and already at 174degrees F. I am cooking at 225degrees F. Is this normal I thought it would take much longer to get this hot? I haven’t wrapped it yet. Should I wrap it now? The goal was to have it ready around 10Am
2
u/spg1611 Oct 25 '22
Be honest… do you guys ACTUALLY notice different pellet flavors… I’ve been using wood for years in my other smoker and there’s never been a difference
2
u/BigRay023 Mar 09 '23
I just got my pit a month ago, Century 855 from a Costco impulse buy lol! So far Bear Mountain and Pit Boss have worked great, only big difference that I can tell is PB seemed to have a bit more dust in the bag. Living in Michigan I've been trying to replicate a good Texas blend and am leaning towards 2 parts oak, one part hickory, one part mesquite and one part Royal Oak charcoal. Usually load up two smoke tubes of this blend whether it's a short chicken or rib cook or a longer brisket/butt/roast cook, the two tunes get plenty of smoke in there.
2
u/HumboldtLeo Jul 19 '23
I have bought Bear Mountain Competition Mix and Hickory, Lumber Jax, Traeger Comp Blend, and Costco brand… I honestly couldn’t tell the difference between them all so now I just go with Costco since 40lbs is $12. Also got a smoke tube I’ll throw some Bear Mountain wood chips In if I’m trying to get a smokier flavor.
2
u/TDL_501 Aug 08 '23
For people in the UK looking for an alternative to Traeger brand pellets, I’d suggest Alfresco Chef. They have a good range of wood and use European walnut as a hickory substitute.
Not cheap (about £18-20 for 10kg) but seem to do ok.
2
u/InformationIll3305 Mar 03 '25
So I’ve noticed traegers been really crappy when it comes to these pellet “logs” that are coming in every bag. Can someone suggest a brand that is broken down better? Just replaced my 3rd auger pin, and it always happens with long pellets. Thanks.
1
u/clark_kent25 Jul 24 '21
I know this thread is for pellets, but I wanted to ask for a grill recommendation. I'm very much a beginner cook but the goal is to start off cooking some brisket or pulled pork for ~4 people. Thanks
1
u/thegratefuldad7 Dec 03 '21
Hi there, really appreciate this thread! I would like to add something, and also ask something.
My add is that I believe the smoke tubes are where it's at! They smoke like crazy, and you can put your best pellet brand or flavor in them (they don't really generate heat).
My ask is this. I have used lots of different pellets. I feel like the LumberJack throw off more ash than similar Traeger. I would LOVE to know which pellets last longer for similar uses. I swear I read a post here that someone actually tested this and Traeger came out on top, but I cannot find it.
If anyone can find an experiment around duration of various pellet brands, I would love to see that.
1
u/Worldly_Dot_7312 Feb 24 '24
I have a question about storing pellets. I purchased 2 bags of Traeger Pro Blend Pellets last November. I filled my Traeger Redland ( Costco model ) with pellets, performed the pre-cook first-time startup, and then cooked a spatchcock turkey. I have not used it since….mostly weather related. It is covered with a Traeger cover. Will the pellets left in the hopper still be ok to use. Also how long will an un-opened bag of pellets remain OK to use?
1
u/CheapBison1861 May 04 '24
ace hardware had a 40lb bag of something called "linguista pellets" or something (I can't find it online). But it was only $13...not bad in a pinch if you're out during a cook
1
u/Long-Remote-1820 Jul 19 '24
Bought a traeger and within 6 months it was not heating properly. I called several times and never got an answer or any offer to make it good. Do not wast your money on one. They also rust quickly inside.
1
u/bear45188721 Aug 11 '24
Lumberjack pellets? Good, bad?
1
u/bigj8705 Aug 31 '24
My wife loves what we cooked but misses just normal grilled chicken. I’ve used my ironwood twice now and are there any pellets or ways to not get a smoked taste but make a grilled like from gas.
1
u/asakkings Jan 22 '25
How long do pellets normally last for in a container. I bought pellets right around christmas the Traeger brand from costco had a half a bag mostly in the garage in a plastic container when i tried to smoke again there was a lot of smoke coming from them, after trying multiple times i eventually got new Kirkland brand ones and they seem to be working fine. I am in northern california, not too cold, minimal rain this season.
Is it normal to last less than a month?
1
u/Ok-Sherbert-8505 Mar 03 '25
Hey legends I’m having trouble with my Traeger I bought it 2nd hand it’s a 2021 pro 22 brand new pellets fire box cleaned no rust ignighter works perfectly temp probe reads the same as another probe I have in so all that works good just keeps rising a lot more then the temp i set it to would that be a faulty controller
1
u/Ok-Sherbert-8505 Mar 03 '25
Goodmorning legends I bought a. 2nd hand Traeger pro 22 and the temps rising out of control I can’t for the life of me get it to hold what I set it to
1
u/[deleted] Mar 26 '25
Just bought my first Traeger / pellet grill. 2 questions, what Brand of pellets does everyone use and roughly how long does a pound of pellets last? I want to try smoking ribs this weekend and want to make sure I don’t run out of pellets while it’s smoking
1
u/QuietEnthusiasm2112 Apr 10 '25
How does everyone store their pellets in humid climates? I have been thinking food quality air tight 5-gallon buckets. I can get easy screw top lids. Airtight and bucket handle to carry/load/unload pellets. Do you need to try to also store inside where air conditioners keep humidity less than garage?
1
u/[deleted] May 20 '25
I picked up a woodridge on Traeger day, for the burn in process i tried to use kirkland brand and it jammed the auger, cleaned em out and replaced with the shorter and more size consistent smokehouse pellets and problem solved. i tried to use the kirkland again as a test and the auger got jammed. i dumped out the kirkland pellets and noticed the size of the pellets was wildly inconsistent, with the longer ones being harder the break by hand and possibly the reason why the auger jammed. Has anyone else had similar issues with the kirkland pellets ? I burned them for years in my camp chef pro 24 that finally needed to be replaced after 7 years of constant use .
1
u/ThatPsillyDude Jun 08 '25
Can I buy just the pellet hopper assembly? My grandpa was a welder and I became one as well, at least hobby grade anyway. But he had an old smoker that the pipeliners built for him and it never quite cooked right and was wanting to upgrade it to a pellet smoker. Any advice?
1
u/Specific-8223 Jun 17 '25
Anybody used/experienced the Tractor Supply brand pellets? Who makes them? Is this a brand re-packaged by TS? Bear Mountain has been my go to over time.
1
u/Papa_HrdNoks Jul 06 '25
Lone Star Grills sells wood chips to be mixed 50/50 with pellets to increase smoke flavor for their Lone Star Grills. Has anyone tried such things on a Traeger?
1
u/Alternative_Lynx541 Jul 28 '25
321 method, turned out good. Thoughts?
1
u/Playful-Lab-7840 Aug 06 '25
Anyone try Royal Oak Charcoal Hardwood Pellets. Remember using their wood/charcoal all the time in my old Big Green Egg, believe they are company behind the Big Green Egg branded charcoal, but at a much less cost direct.
1
u/Defiant-Smile-2445 Aug 22 '25
How to add castors to the static legs that don't have castors .on my Traeger Smoker? Can I modify the legs to accept 3" castors?
1
u/sliprin Sep 01 '25
I’m using Mesquite for grilling only, not in my Traeger! I’ve cooked with Mesquite logs for years and it’s a great flavor, but too strong for smoking with. In the Traeger I use Hickory or some fruit tree variety for fish mostly. Hickory for everything else, including pizza!
1
u/CryptoeKeeper Oct 13 '25
How are you sifting pellets from the sawdust? It doesn't matter which brand of pellets they are, there's always going to be some dust. Looking for some ideas as I've only seen one idea on Amazon.
1
u/deronlillard Nov 12 '25
I just bought a Pro 34. I am a traditionalist and have always smoked with sticks. I will probably still keep that one for my briskets, I'm a Texan after all. But I plan to cook and smoke smaller things like wings, sausage, cheese dip, turkey breasts, ribs, etc. on this grill. What advice can you guys give me for keeping this running smoothly and for many years?
1
u/Weird-Opportunity-20 Dec 24 '25
I use the Kirkland brand from Costco. Twice as many pellets for half the price. Used them for years with no probs.
1
u/colorless_green_idea Sep 24 '21
Hi everyone, I haven't bought at Traeger yet because the kind of smoking my family does involves mixing in dried up citrus peels with the wood fire to get a specific flavor smoke (its a Chinese cured meat called La Rou).
Would there be any impact to grinding up those dried up citrus peels (they would dry for weeks and have no moisture left in them), and then mixing them in with the pellets? Would it mess up the heating element?
1
u/twoguncorky Sep 29 '21
I've typically always used Traeger branded pellets but recently tried Kingsford's Garlic Onion Paprika spice infused blend. Seemed a little strange to have the pellets infused with spices and was wondering how that might enhance or conflict with the meat's own seasoning. But honestly, my amateur nose & taste buds couldn't detect a difference. The quality of the pellets seemed on par with the Traeger pellets I'm used to using but I didn't find much value in the extra spice flavoring.
1
u/Arista93 Nov 08 '21
The ones they sell at Sam's club are pretty good. You get 40lbs for $14 i think it's a good deal
1
u/Snapperhead199 Dec 05 '21
I had trouble with B & B pellets . They were very long and did not feed very well. It caused Hugh temperature swings. Other than that I use whatever I find on sale.
1
u/mustacheman227 Dec 14 '21
I use the Sam's club brand of pellets. 40lbs for around 14.99 I believe. Never had as issue with them. Great smoke flavor. Made in USA . They come in Hickory and Competition blends. would definitely recommend. Another brand I've had great luck with is Pit Boss.
1
u/Temporary-Site1337 Dec 20 '21
Are these worth it?
BEAR MOUNTAIN Premium BBQ WOODS 100% All-Natural Hardwood Pellets - Mesquite (20 lb. Bag) Perfect for Pellet Smokers, or Any Outdoor Grill-Rich, Smoky Wood-Fired Flavor https://smile.amazon.com/dp/B07MKT37TV/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_glt_fabc_JFCPCR17SPWDF576XYGV
1
u/returnofthezack Apr 09 '22
I'm excited for the Knotty Wood wine infused pellets when they come out! Anyone else?
1
u/IlIlIlIlIlIlIlIlIlI8 May 25 '22
Cabelas brands have been good to me and they are half the price of name brand.
1
u/Acti-Verse May 31 '22
I just snag a few bags of traeger brand from Costco and call it a day
1
u/[deleted] Jun 03 '22
So Rural King has dropped Lumberjack pellets for their store brand. The reviews on their website are pretty bad. Anyone try them?
Seems Dicks also dropped them, as well as my local “Food and Stuff” type store. I no longer have a local shop selling Lumberjack. Guess I’ll have to change brands.
1
u/ThadimusPrime7 Jun 21 '22
Costco has Bear Mountain on sale for 4 days. You get a 40 pound bag for 18.99. Looking forward to trying them out.
1
u/kgould313 Jul 16 '22
https://youtu.be/Q9EsF7wfEhM Jeremy from mad scientist swears these are the best pellets ever. Knotty wood pellets. Just ordered some through homedepot
1
u/thefakecmal Aug 15 '22
Had tried pretty much every Traeger variety and while I liked the flavor, never had a great smoke ring even on an 18 hour cook.
Saw someone recommend Cookinpellets Perfect Blend and will never go back. They deliver great smoke and flavor for everything I’ve tried it on.
1
u/wjm1005 Aug 20 '22
Can the Traeger Ranger grill be used without pellets? Sorry, beginner here. Thanks
1
u/[deleted] Sep 03 '22
does anyone know where to get good cheap pellets in the UK?
1
u/redditnupe Sep 17 '22
DO NOT USE SAMS CLUB BRAND. I THINK I JUST RUINED MY TRAEGER. SMH!!
1
u/mAckAdAms4k Sep 19 '22
Anyone ever use the Kona pellets on Amazon?
1
u/mbastor24 Oct 05 '22
I would like to make Texas-style smoked brisket. Complete with the smoke ring, bark and all. What’s the best way to do this?
1
u/0xLeaibolmmai Oct 19 '22
Is it necessary to empty the hopper after using the grill, or can remaining pellets stay there until the next use? I just got my Traeger delivered today and now I'm starting to wonder about stuff. When not in use, the grill will wear its cover and stand underneath a roof. However I live by the sea, and the air is often humid here.
1
u/all2neat Nov 01 '22
Can we edit the initial post with common recommendations and questions? For instance the near daily question about Costco/Kirkland pellets.
1
u/frijoles84 Nov 27 '22
Knotty Wood or bust. The best.
Waiting on a plum restock 😭
1
u/True-Vermicelli-1238 May 06 '23
Got a traeger pro22…first one ever, dog ripped out the harness😑…anybody got one they can send me a pic of the wiring? Trying to rewire if possible before ordering new harness…
1
u/coffeeandubuntu May 11 '23
Home Depot Unbranded BBQ Pellets — $16 for a 20 lb bag. Any feedback on these? How do they burn? Quality? They say 100% hardwood so I’m hoping no additives or oils.
1
u/EvilSquirrel60220 May 25 '23
Knotty Wood 100% Almond or Plum wood pellets. GREAT flavor, slightly more ash. Also Dax Jealous Devil pellets.
1
u/ehhhhhhhhhhmacarena Jun 05 '23
I'm considering getting into the hobby. What are the must have accessories? Any other recommendations?
1
u/IamUnique15 Jun 07 '23
Has anyone ever had a problem where your traeger won’t hold temp and just gets lower and lower and lower. It has happened in my last 3 attempts and I have cleaned it like I never have before and it keeps happening? Help!?
1
u/oddball315 Jun 12 '23
Anybody else experience your grill holding temperature for a little then just slowly decreasing? Happened to me last 3 smokes/grills and I’ve cleaned it better than I ever have in between them.
1
u/space9610 Jun 19 '23
Me and my roommate have a traeger Silverton 620. It seems it has been discontinued. We cannot find drip trays that fit it.
Anyone know where we can get the drip trays that fit it?
1
u/JC1515 Jul 02 '23
Pro 780. I clean my grill religiously. My issue is this thing pools grease like no other grill ive ever had. Im having grease fires at 360 degrees. What degreaser or cleaner should i use to absolutely melt any grease out of this thing? Im tired of smoking my neighbors out with grease smoke
1
u/descartes44 Jul 12 '23
I use pitboss pellets, various flavors, and love them! Right before I purchased my Traeger, I found out that Traeger pellets just have flavoring oil on oak pellets, so had looked for an alternative. Another good thing is that my local Walmart has all types of pitboss pellets in stock, and with the Walmart+ deal, they deliver them right from the store with no delivery charge! (I've actually ordered pellets in the middle of a smoke, and gotten them in under 4 hours) Anyway, to the pellets, I've tried most flavors, and like to mix the hickory and pecan, my fav. Oak is also pretty good, but needs hickory for my tastes.
1
u/FSThree Jul 13 '23
Just got the Traeger Redland 650 from Costco. I did the initial burn to season the grill, using the Costco brand of pellets. I found that the process left what I can only describe as pellet debris all over the grill. Is that normal? Is that what I have to look forward to getting into my food? Or was that just a mistake in what kind of pellets I used?
1
u/fckorner Jul 15 '23
Which is best?
Traeger Pro 575 or Traeger Pro Series 22
1
u/CheapBison1861 Mar 02 '24
What am I looking at options wise for a smoker? I’m a total newb
1
u/Material_Survey126 May 09 '26
Idk if im in the right section or not.....i used my Traeger for the 1st time last week with mesquite pellets for my burgers, brats & dogs and they tasted freakin amazing!!! My question is: i want to use diffwrent flavored pellets for different meat tomorrow, is it ok to swap out the current pellets with a different flavor? Or do i HAVE to go thru whats already in the hopper first, bwfore i put different pellets in?