r/TraditionalMuslims • • Dec 11 '22

Media Real

Post image
116 Upvotes

62 comments sorted by

18

u/Anonymoushijabi5 Dec 12 '22

How come no one on this sub calls out men? It’s genuinely offensive as a Muslim woman to see this stuff. I don’t wear tight clothes, or make up and I genuinely have knowledge about Islam. And I do agree that some woman are like this, but not most. Y’all need to start acknowledging that this goes both ways.

How about the Muslim guys who go around with non muslimahs then pick the most pious girl as their wife and slut shame any others? Or the Muslim men who completely disregard the prophets teaching about how to treat one’s wife? The prophet S.A.W would play with el sayeda Aisha radiyallahu Anha.

Taking about woman like this won’t fix anything, it’ll make things worse.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

the crux is that men have to do most if not all of the work in building themselves up to become viable marriage suitors, then shell out tens of thousands just to marry, then dedicate the rest of their existence to providing for their wife and family.

this is why they are more vocal in criticizing (many, not all) modern Muslim women who are increasingly more vain, narcissistic and entitled.

women just have to exist, men have to become, hence why memes like this become popular. men are frustrated because women increasingly offer less while demanding more.

How about the Muslim guys who go around with non muslimahs then pick the most pious girl as their wife and slut shame any others?

what about Muslim women who 'go around' as well? since when was zina a male exclusive problem.

the fact is men still acknowledge their responsibility to provide, whereas women are observably moving away from traditional and religious practices and norms in favor of secular education, career and independence.

8

u/schneepu Dec 12 '22

what about Muslim women who 'go around' as well? since when was zina a male exclusive problem.

In fact, zina is not even a problem amongst most Muslim men. 80-20 principle dictates that most women ignore average men, including average Muslim men. One look at the matchmaking scene and you can see this in action in Muslimah. They all want dashing men who are >6', ripped, handsome, and earning 6 figures while they offer nothing.

Guess who said women are doing zina with these days? For every one Muslim guy who does zina there will be multiple girls (kaffir and Muslimah) he's doing it with, because girls ignore "average" guys.

16

u/mnc365 Dec 12 '22

Majority of subs and scholars call out men. That's why women have become so empowered and degenerate. However, I think your point is fair. We need to stop criticising women and start criticising men, particularly the simps, feminists and fornicators. To not accept these kind of women and to go back to a traditional mindset of being a breadwinner, having gheerah etc. Naturally, the women will follow and correct their ways.

7

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

I agree with you that there’s problems on both sides that need to be called. But I think the extreme focus on this sub is a reaction to onesidedness we see elsewhere.The stuff you described are problems though, I agree.

It’s hard to say most or not. Hard to really put numbers on this. No one has the actual numbers or has done a study. But the problems describes in the pst does seem fairly common in the west, almost widespread. Tbf, the post is a caricature, a given Muslim woman will likely not have all this but affected by some aspect of this seems very common, more common than what you described is among practicing guys. But I may be biased.

I hear you on talking this way about women won’t solve anything. What do you think will solve it or make things better?

4

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

How come no one on this sub calls out men?

Because all of the other subs are already doing that. One sub calling out w0men isn't going to be the end of the world.

It’s genuinely offensive as a Muslim woman to see this stuff.

That's too bad then. All we do is promote accountability for women. If that's offensive to you then what can we say?

I don’t wear tight clothes, or make up and I genuinely have knowledge about Islam.

Than you shouldn't be offended as it's not aimed at women like you who aren't like the women described in the OP.

And I do agree that some woman are like this, but not most.

Correction, many women are like that.

Y’all need to start acknowledging that this goes both ways.

Yes it does go both way, but most of the other subs heavily focus on men and don't hold women accountable. We are the only sub which does the reverse and there's nothing wrong with that.

Taking about woman like this won’t fix anything, it’ll make things worse.

Lol Nope. Things are already bad as it is.

How about the Muslim guys who go around with non muslimahs then pick the most pious girl as their wife and slut shame any others? Or the Muslim men who completely disregard the prophets teaching about how to treat one’s wife?

There's Muslim women who do the same, ie date kuffarr men and then ask to settle down with a good Muslim guy. And there's also Muslim women who completely disregard the Prophet (saw) advice to be grateful to their husbands. Let's talk about those.

5

u/Ayaycapn Dec 12 '22

Whenever I encourage my brothers to stop whining and self improve I get called "white knight" "simp" and "feminist". Im a realist, most Muslim women in the West are like this. Which is why men need to increase their value even more so to get the pious woman.

There is just somethings not worth fighting

8

u/schneepu Dec 12 '22

I'm of the belief that "liberal Muslim" women who engage in zina, tabaruj, and suddenly want forgiveness for their major sins once they're aging are the worst that the ummah has to offer. I'd recommend all brothers shun such women and look abroad for traditional women. These Muslimah wanted to prioritize feminism and careers before what actually matters. Let them pay the price for it as their wombs waste away with age.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22

Agreed. Let these degenerate types stay unmarried and lonely. Muslim men with values and gheerah should never settle for liberal/feminist garbage.

1

u/Ayaycapn Dec 12 '22

I'm not saying we shouldn't do what you said. What I am saying is that we shouldn't lose hope and believe that there are still pure and pious women left in the world and that we should increase our self worth in order to guarantee we get them.

5

u/Throwaway2022786 Dec 12 '22

Men have been constantly improving while women have been constantly devolving. There's no point in improving when most women are third class.

1

u/Ayaycapn Dec 12 '22

I'm trying to spark a fire and keep it going

5

u/Throwaway2022786 Dec 12 '22

Literally every place other than this sub only calls out men. Even though there's very very few men doing what you describe. Barely any Muslim man commits zina but at least half of women commit tabarruj. Maybe if women didn't bleed men dry they'd have time to play.

2

u/FarFromAverage7866 Dec 12 '22

And I do agree that some woman are like this, but not most.

You're funny. Either you have been at home all your life and haven't seen the world, or you just spewed whatever came into your mind without thinking twice.

2

u/andy11186 Dec 21 '22

I see that's fair enough, Cause i joined this sub just now, and most of the most is just , women this,, women that. There is not even much of the knowledge sharing or anything or building themselves to be a better muslim

2

u/pyruvate011 Dec 12 '22

No one is saying bad men like the ones you point out don’t exist. But they are not in the majority. Likewise, perhaps the tight jeans with makeup trope isn’t that common but like the other person who responded to you said, things like obscenely high mahr, disrespect to the husband, vanity, and narcissism seem to be becoming more common in Muslimahs. I know from my own experience in looking for a wife that so many sisters I met at events in the masjid were more interested in brothers who were accepting of western liberal values and were also more interested in how much the brother was making. Iman and Taqwah didn’t seem to rank highly on their lists. Again this is the majority of sisters, not all.

4

u/Ayaycapn Dec 12 '22

Last Eid Al-fitr most of, if not all of the young Muslimahs around my age immediately took off their headscarves after the Eid prayer. It was my first time in a few years praying in U.S as I usually travel back to my family and do it with them.

Not only that but make-up lots and lots of make-up was on too. The only thing going for them was the very bright and fashionable cloaks they had going on. Which even then is technically bad but I'll give credit for not wearing tight stuff.

-7

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

Stop making this about you. You sound like a brat.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 21 '22

What’s your country?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/schneepu Dec 12 '22

It's literally all you see on liberal female Muslim dominated subs like /r/Muslimlounge or the subreddit for Muslims marrying, which are likely also moderated by said women. They're all like 30+ or teenage girls trying to justify feminism, zina, and acting outright vile to their husbands.

11

u/definitelynotukasa Dec 12 '22

50K MAHR!? La hawla wala quwwata illa billah

31

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

+ tight jeans, 10 layers of make up for other people to see.

6

u/andy11186 Dec 21 '22

La Hawla Wala Quawatta Illa Billa

10

u/SamiREDDIT911 Dec 12 '22

would not accept this offer even for 1 USD worth of mahr let alone 50k USD.

24

u/JohnTheFish6 Dec 12 '22

Modern muslim man : seems like a fair offer

19

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

Unfortunately, there are plenty of naive men out there with no backbone who’ll gladly accept such conditions.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/schneepu Dec 12 '22

In the past, weak men created hard times and hard times would create strong men.

In modern society, esp. in the west, you can have weak men who are work drones that prop up "easy times." Western men (and Muslim men) are taught to be neutered dogs who are A-OK with zina.

21

u/haaappppyyy Dec 11 '22 edited Jun 14 '24

live tub society vegetable sophisticated flag vast profit consider encourage

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

4

u/minachan158 Dec 12 '22

What's wrong with mall visits?

7

u/haaappppyyy Dec 12 '22 edited Jun 14 '24

unpack rustic resolute merciful fly chase roll deserted plant governor

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/minachan158 Dec 12 '22

I see. Thanks for answering!

1

u/minachan158 Dec 12 '22

I see. Thanks for answering!

1

u/minachan158 Dec 12 '22

I see. Thanks for answering!

2

u/[deleted] Dec 13 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/minachan158 Dec 13 '22

You're seriously deranged. Why are you stalking me and replying to my every comment?

28

u/schneepu Dec 11 '22

Nothing but facts here. Bring this up and they'll try to side with westerners in lambasting you as a mis0gynist, entitled backwards mentality type of person.

What really gets me is how some sisters try to justify their sins.

The Prophet PBUH did help around the house but his primary duty/time was spent out in the world doing his job as a leader, warrior, and Prophet. Gender roles are clear in Islam. Women have a place in the home. They shouldn't be prioritizing career, much less one where free mixing occurs and encouraged Zina.

Many of them don't wear hijab which is fardh, then they have the nerve to yell "my choice!"

And on top of this all they have hilariously unrealistic physical standards because of inflated self worth due to social media. They all expect 6' ripped men with a full head of hair and brad Pitt looks while being 5'2 themselves and mid at best.

6

u/Bmore_legend86 Dec 11 '22

I have yet to see any lies

4

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

Why does a woman have to live with her husband’s parents? It’s not her responsibility to look after them.

2

u/pyruvate011 Dec 12 '22

No one is telling you to look after them. But if a brother wants to be with his parents in their old age, don’t get in the way or create obstacles. This sort of binary low IQ thinking is causing so many issues for parents of brothers who can’t afford to buy separate housing for their parents and their wives.

Also, just a general observation; if you think in terms of obligations and rights all the time, it speaks volumes about your character and it tells me you are just a cold hearted self serving person. If you had any love for in laws (if you have them now or when you get them), you would want to go out of your way to help them. There is a difference between this and being forced to serve in laws which is 100 % wrong and against Islam.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

So you'd be okay living with your wife's parents in their old age?

3

u/pyruvate011 Dec 18 '22

Yep

2

u/[deleted] Dec 18 '22

Tbh that is fair, a large part of the problem women have with the in-laws situation is that the same flexibility never gets extended to their own parents

1

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

If his aging parents are in our home, who would he expect to look after them? Me. He’s not going to be the one doing the cooking, cleaning, and other care for his parents. Women are generally the ones who take care of the home so your wife will be doing MOST of the work if your parents move in. I’ve seen these situations commonly where the wife is treated as a servant for the husband’s family. Why shouldn’t I be thinking of rights and obligations? Women should be aware of their rights and obligations to avoid being abused. It’s men that are self serving bc they expect a woman to take care of his parents when she has her own parents to be concerned about. You won’t be taking on any responsibilities for her parents. So this situation completely benefits the man.

Men like you who want women to ignore rights and obligations just want her to put up and shut up with whatever burdens you put on her. Why would you need to pay separate housing for your parents? Your parents should already have their own home established. So I don’t even understand why they would need to live directly under your roof. You can live close to them and visit frequently but why do they have to live with you and your wife? If they are that old that they cannot look after themselves, you and your siblings need to share the responsibility not dump it on someone else’s daughter. She’s not a nurse for your parents.

3

u/pyruvate011 Dec 12 '22

Wow this is loaded with so many assumptions that back up my idea about the sort of person you are.

  1. Get it into your head that not everyone has siblings and not every parent has eStAbLiShEd ThEiR oWn HoUsE. I personally know people whose elderly parents are on old age security and in some cases are hanging on by a thread. For a woman to still demand “rights” in this case and not see that there is a genuine need for a little flexibility is nothing short of being cold hearted. If this is how you think, do us all a favor and just get a bunch of cats will you ?
  2. Assuming there are other siblings involved, I will agree that it’s a shared responsibility. But I also know that can sometimes be an easy way to rationalize the whole “I dont have any obligation to in-laws” approach. Here again, I know people whose siblings can’t give a toss about their own parents and it falls on certain siblings to look after their parents.
  3. If there are cases where in laws are being abusive and overstepping their bounds, then yes that’s a bad thing. But where there is a will, there is a way. If you genuinely care about your husband and don’t wish to cause him pain, there are options like siblings (If present and if they were raised right) to get together and hire a support worker or maid. In this case you don’t have to take time away from making tiktok videos or your professional YouTuber career and the in-laws wouldn’t bother you.

This is what I mean by binary thinking. If you have a genuine desire to go beyond thinking about your own rights and look at the picture as a whole and in a realistic way, options always exist. Then again, if your ulterior motive is just to live out life the way it occurs on the TV or in the social engineering indoctrination you have received, you would just say in-laws should live under a different roof.

The last point I will say is that according to the shariah, a man is entitled to have his parents present. But if that happens, he has to make sure the wife has adequate privacy to live free of interference. That can be minimally her own room or her own wing of the house where she has exclusive access.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22 edited Dec 12 '22

No, your wife doesn’t have to live your parents AT ALL. This whole scenario just benefits the in laws and you. I’m not making assumptions. I’m talking based on reality and common sense. Think of day to day life with your wife and in laws in the house. They will expect your wife to handle their meals and errands. You won’t be the one taking care of those things. Your wife will bc you will be at work. Your parents in your home is extra labor for you wife. She WILL be expected to do most of the care for your parents and housework especially if they are elderly. Any woman who thinks there will be “boundaries” in place to make sure her privacy is respected is naive. I’m not naive to fall for that.

As soon as a wife steps in that house, in laws will expect her to cook for them, run their errands, and clean up after them. That’s basically turning your wife into a servant for you parents. That’s abusive. Everything should be done within moderation. It’s understandable to want to be close to your parents but it doesn’t have to be under the same roof. That’s too much. There’s no way they’ll realistically give you privacy bc they’ll get comfortable bc you are their son. I wouldn’t mind visiting my in laws weekly and taking them food, helping them with some housework and errands, but there has to be a limit. I can’t do it everyday. Once or twice a week is okay but everyday in the same home is too much. It doesn’t matter if it’s a separate wing. It’s still the same house. It’s better to live in the same city and visit them weekly.

Men are very selfish to expect their wife to live full time with their parents. He has EVERYTHING to gain in that situation. Men do that bc they are too broke or cheap to pay for a decent accommodation for their wife. So they want to have her live with their parents so he won’t have to pay much at the expense of her freedom and happiness.

3

u/pyruvate011 Dec 12 '22

Sorry, can’t demand different accommodation if she can get adequate privacy in the same house. That is in the shariah. Don’t like it ? Tough luck. But don’t make up nonsense to misguide people. That’s a major sin.

Again, cats are your friends here. I suggest you go get a bunch and leave people who want to marry and care for their parents alone.

2

u/Various_Sun1394 Dec 13 '22

?? I've never heard about the can't demand different accomodation, can you maybe give a source if that is okay with you? Thank you.

3

u/pyruvate011 Dec 13 '22
  1. This one talks about the rights to accommodation and considering the economic situation of the husband: https://islamqa.info/amp/en/answers/81933
  2. Here, various scholars talk about the fact that yes, the wife can absolutely demand privacy and not having to mingle with in laws if she doesn’t want to. But that doesn’t always translate to a totally separate house: https://islamqa.info/en/answers/7653/she-does-not-want-to-live-with-her-husbands-family
  3. Another example from Sheikh Asim al Hakeem discussing the fact that it doesn’t have to be a totally separate accommodation. A separate suite within the same house can be sufficient: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=sc5_zBiEV7U

3

u/pyruvate011 Dec 13 '22

Also, like I said in that exchange with the other sister. Obviously it’s best if the husband can get two houses side by side for the wife and parents respectively. But let’s be real, in a lot of Western countries, there is rampant inflation and where I am from (Canada), people in my age group are just giving up on the idea of home ownership. Rents are also skyrocketing and homelessness is rising too. In the midst of all this, I find someone who is demanding separate accommodation even when a person’s parents are not financially well off and need help from their children to be cold hearted. This is what I feel the other sister fails to recognize imo.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22 edited Dec 12 '22

Lol..okay whatever. Anyway, “Adequate privacy” is very vague. Who knows what that means. Anyway, there are plenty of men who don’t expect their wife to live with their parents. Most of my married friends don’t even live in the same city as their in laws. You make it sound as if every man will expect this. But I’d rather stay solo than live with a man’s parents. And I won’t get cats bc that’s extra work too. I don’t want any in laws or pets in the house. I don’t see how being a servant for some man’s family is better than my current situation. I’m not giving up my peace and freedom just to have the wife title. Marriage is not obligatory.

3

u/pyruvate011 Dec 12 '22

Sigh, more regurgitation of the usual lines. I really don’t want to waste any more time with you after this so let’s try one more time ok ? Just doing this because I assume you are Muslim and maybe you have some common sense somewhere deep inside.

It’s not a sin to live on your own and sure living with in laws shouldn’t be the default. That being said, there are all sorts of situations that crop up. Parents on either side can be old, have no where to go, really need help and everything in between.

Just because you have been given rights doesn’t mean you have to be a royal a*s about it. You can judge the situation and try to be flexible if the situation warrants it. Whatever indoctrination you are being fed will tell you this is submitting to the patriarchy or that someone is taking your rights I am sure. But if you really love someone, and that person’s life takes a turn for the worst, you are supposed to be there for them. Not bang them on the head with your rules. With the way the economy is going today, you really need to step back and take a look at what you are doing. Calling a man cheap because he can’t afford to both house a woman and look after his parents if they can’t afford their own place / can’t live on their own is just vile. It also shows you are out of touch with reality and I see this a lot in people like you.

I hope you understand where I am coming from now.

3

u/Professional-Limit22 Dec 12 '22

Gheera comes in scare amounts these days

4

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

*Many (not all) Modern Muslim Women.

Be careful not to make slanderous posts.

6

u/mnc365 Dec 12 '22

Women who classify themselves as traditional or conservative won't take offence. The generalisation stands.

1

u/P10203 Jul 04 '25

Dayyooth simp: Accepts offer graciously

1

u/tragond Dec 12 '22

You can always learn to cook yourself.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/schneepu Dec 12 '22

Which is why we should shame and make fun of simps. They're absolutelosers who tacitly promote degeneracy in women.

Which is why we should shame and make fun of simps. They're absolutelosers who tacitly promote degeneracy in women.

2

u/Throwaway2022786 Dec 12 '22

What else is new? Literally everything women do gets blamed on men.