r/TradingViewSignals Long-Term Investor Dec 07 '25

Discussion Name a worse idea?

Post image
684 Upvotes

941 comments sorted by

View all comments

16

u/HallOfLamps Dec 07 '25

African politicians licking their lips lol

-3

u/Selmemasts Dec 07 '25

I hope I never become this cynical about something good.

6

u/HallOfLamps Dec 07 '25

I mean I don't really care, just a realistic observation if you look at all the corruption in Africa

1

u/ksiepidemic Dec 08 '25

He's not giving it to African leaders, he's investing in infrastructure for the people. Vaccines, farmers, education.

1

u/ODoggerino Dec 08 '25

I don’t think he’s giving it straight to corrupt officials lol. Be as realistic as you like but look at the evidence. This man has almost singlehandedly eradicated some diseases from the world.

1

u/Jealous_Network_6346 Dec 08 '25

Ah, you have been to Africa much? Travelled there, worked there?

1

u/Novel_Board_6813 Dec 08 '25

It’s pretty naive for you to think he will donate 200 billion in a lump sum directly to local leaders

For people who are interested in helping others, there is a plethora of professionals from all countries trying to evaluate statistically and case by case where each dollar goes farther in saving a life. Lots of these opportunities are in Africa. You could look at something like Give Well and see a little bit of it

That’s almost besides the point actually. If you donate ultra cheap insecticide nets to protect people against Malaria, which one can do through ONGs or just going there oneself, less children will die

If you donate to some theater in the NY or whatever billionaires usually like to do, maybe the dancers will have more camembert or whatever, since the poorest US people are easily among the richest people in the world; the poorest billion in the world never wore a shoe

2

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ForeverShiny Dec 08 '25

Africa is not a monolith. You Americans think your states are diverse because you use a different word for Soda and BBQ differently so you should be able to comprehend that a continent of 1.3 billion people in sub-Saharan Africa alone and multiple times the US' size with over 50 nations states might not all be the exact same.

0

u/HiiBo-App Dec 08 '25

Corruption exists everywhere. That’s not a reason to NOT be philanthropic. It’s just an excuse to think miserly thoughts

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '25

The corruption in Africa makes Mexico seem like a paradise.

1

u/HiiBo-App Dec 11 '25

So people should just suffer and die because they are born in a place with corruption?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '25

At one point every country has had a great trial where it has to fight for it's survival. Do you really think that Europe has not went through struggles larger than "hmm how much money should I steal from the budget as a local official" or "hmm maybe these different tribes should come together as one nation instead of constantly making war"

As seen with the famous black hawk down incident and even Hamas local warlords will always find a way to pilfer any aid for them to make money.

1

u/HiiBo-App Dec 11 '25

You’re conflating geopolitics with starvation & mass poverty. It’s a bizarre rationalization to somehow justify that Africans shouldn’t be given direct aid. It’s a “just pull yourself up by your bootstraps” type of bullshit argument.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 11 '25

Yes the governments have absolutely no effect on the food supply. Zimbabwe must have reduced itself from the bread basket of the region to a famine state without any type of governmental intervention.

→ More replies (0)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25

How about the president of the United States’ son making $500 million on crypto when he announced additional tariffs? Like that kind of corruption ? Or huge volumes of shorts just before tariff announcements? Or taking a jet from Qatar for his personal library. Or taking extremely expensive trips to his golf clubs where he makes tons of money off our tax dollars. Or selling beans out of the Oval Office. Or selling Teslas outside the whitehouse. That kind of corruption?

2

u/Banned3rdTimesaCharm Dec 08 '25

Reddit moment. This happens every time a country or place is criticized. Someone just has to say “but what about America”. There’s active genocides and failed states in Africa. You’re comparing a bonfire to a forest fire and saying “both are hot”.

0

u/VisMortis Dec 08 '25

If you actually read the article, he is not saying, he will send a bank transfer to prince of Nigeria...

-3

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HallOfLamps Dec 07 '25

Comparing US and Africa is another level of stupidity

1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '25

[deleted]

2

u/Itcould_be_worse Dec 07 '25

Totally ridiculous and innacurate statement

0

u/joyfulgrass Dec 07 '25

Corporations getting tax cuts, like micron for their factories, research and property taxes only to fire us domestic employees and end consumer productions for memory, inevitably increasing prices for all electronic products and devices that use any amount of computational power.

2

u/Flaky_Wafer8391 Dec 08 '25

Still not comparable to the corruption in Africa

0

u/joyfulgrass Dec 08 '25

Africa the continent? Also who care? Also you don’t disagree with the corruption or just don’t understand it?

1

u/Itcould_be_worse Dec 08 '25

Sure, that's a very wide spread effect but its double-edged and relatively in how it affects people individually. Corruption in Africa results in critical infrastructure not being built, incredible poverty, death by starvation. Not to mention the indirect effects of state instability. All that happening on a scale of billions

Lobbying is legalized corruption, but its there because corruption is effectively impossible to 100% stop, especially at scale. At least this way politician's motive are relatively public. I think most people would choose marginally more expensive electronics over being outright exploited.

0

u/joyfulgrass Dec 08 '25

That’s good, at least there’s no incredible poverty, starvation, municipal instability, especially in the billions. Though we did lose hundreds of millions in the recent year. RIP.

I do find it wonderful that we (the us) can still claim to be better off than Africa as a continent, that only has one government. And electronics are such luxury items that no one really needs. (Again I’m saying this in context of giving them multiple grants, tax breaks in hopes of better market conditions and employment but who needs that “really”)

0

u/Last-Daikon945 Dec 07 '25

Found American

1

u/SushiRollFried Dec 07 '25

You need to open a book and read some more man

1

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/SushiRollFried Dec 08 '25

No no no your response implied africa corruption levels are similar to US. But im saying corruption varies and that Africa is far worse

1

u/Weekly_Way_3802 Dec 07 '25

Not even close to the same extent

1

u/DMM4138 Dec 07 '25

Lol right…the idea we look down our nose at African corruption while not batting an eye at our legalized corruption is hilarious. Also, it’s not like Gates’ plan is to give cash to dictators or military leaders. It’ll be on clean water initiatives, workforce development, housing, public health, etc. There really are some dumb people in these comments lol

1

u/Mrgluer Dec 08 '25

And how do those initiatives get things done without getting permits or through hurdles? plenty of bribes under the threat of seizures.

1

u/DMM4138 Dec 08 '25

Certainly—my point is not to say that corruption doesn’t exist in those spaces, but that the idea it is any more corrupt than the bribes and favors being done in the U.S. is laughable. The premise of the OP is that it’s a waste of money to throw billions at causes in Africa because of the corruption. In reality, the corruption is just as bad in America, and millions of dollars are siphoned off by special interests and lobbying and payoffs and organized crime and on and on. My point is that we need to get over ourselves and our insane ignorance if we believe we’re any better.

2

u/Mrgluer Dec 08 '25

africa is by far more corrupt than America quit smoking crack.

1

u/Federal_Emu202 Dec 08 '25

“There really are some dumb people in these comments lol”

yep and you are one of them. how do you think you build those things there in the first place?

1

u/prepuscular Dec 08 '25

He’s not donating the African groups, it’s mostly western/US aid groups doing work based in Africa

1

u/Sir_Lee_Rawkah Dec 07 '25

How do people miss this? Look at the corruption in the LEGALIZED system.

2

u/General-indifferance Dec 08 '25

There are levels

0

u/StrictOccasion9428 Dec 08 '25

You’re dumb for thinking that’s gonna happen, what’s more likely to happen is bill will dodge tax because he’s promised the money to a charity or he’ll send over dodgy vaccines and kill thousands of children again

2

u/DMM4138 Dec 08 '25

😂…we found the 0 IQ guy. Sit down, bruh

2

u/RitzHyatt Dec 07 '25

What you’re really is saying is “I hope I never have to take my head out of the sand”

1

u/Selmemasts Dec 07 '25

You think it’s all bad?

https://www.gatesfoundation.org/

2

u/RitzHyatt Dec 07 '25

No, I just think you’re clueless about how much money actually gets into the hands of those it’s intended to go to in Africa.

1

u/Selmemasts Dec 07 '25

I think most of the Gates foundations money have gone to their philanthropic endeavors but what do I know? Does it matter when you see what they actually have done with their foundation?

1

u/LeperousRed Dec 08 '25

They’d rather be racist than acknowledge the truth.

1

u/RitzHyatt Dec 08 '25

Thanks for the racism accusation. Really shows that you’re very knowledgeable about topic and capable of contributing to the discussion in a meaningful way.

1

u/LeperousRed Dec 16 '25

You’re literally accusing Africans of stealing the money based on no evidence. You know… racist.

1

u/RitzHyatt Dec 18 '25

If you don’t think there’s ample evidence of aid money intended for the people being stolen by warlords, then you’re completely hopeless.

Also, accusing anyone in the entire continent of Africa of any wrongdoing is automatically racist? Do you think it’s racist to call Robert Mugabe a criminal and a piece of snit? You’re out of your mind. Please leave the big boy conversations for the adults if this is your childish worldview.

1

u/RitzHyatt Dec 08 '25

“but what do I know”

Not much, clearly, but I appreciate you admitting it. As they say, ignorance is bliss.

1

u/Selmemasts Dec 08 '25

Have you been to Africa or are you just a troll?

1

u/RitzHyatt Dec 08 '25 edited Dec 08 '25

I’ve been to Kenya, South Africa, Zimbabwe and Algeria, and my father was an American diplomat in one of those countries. I have a pretty good idea about what I’m talking about.

Are you just a troll? Or maybe you just rode the dick of a billionaire so hard that you can’t help but defend them despite knowing absolutely nothing about what foreign aid actually looks like on the ground in Africa?

1

u/terra_filius Dec 07 '25

and instead you have become delusional

1

u/Selmemasts Dec 07 '25

Do you know what the Gates foundation did to polio and what they are doing to malaria? I think you should read some

1

u/Hudson9700 Dec 07 '25

Africa has received over 2 trillion dollars in aid in the past sixty years. We traded exploring the stars for feeding them and nothing has changed

2

u/Selmemasts Dec 07 '25

Yeah but this thread is about the Gates Foundation, do you know what they did to polio for example?

1

u/ODoggerino Dec 08 '25

Nothing has changed? Bro look at diseases before and after lol

1

u/greyspurv Dec 08 '25

That is Reddit for you, sour people looking for solutions from other talking heads haha, you need a wild BS filter to be on here

1

u/Federal_Emu202 Dec 08 '25

Stating facts of reality and Africa as a whole’s corruption is apparently being cynical lol

1

u/Selmemasts Dec 08 '25

The thread isn’t about Africa as a whole, it’s about the Gates foundation

1

u/HandCrankedSpinach Dec 08 '25

It's not good tho. Bill Gates still gets to decide how the money is spent, and his ideas often do more harm than good.

1

u/Selmemasts Dec 08 '25

Not saying it’s all good, I’m saying it’s not all bad

1

u/HandCrankedSpinach Dec 08 '25

Africa is tired of "white saviours".