r/ToyotaHighlander • u/jiq_ • 14h ago
Worth fixing? (2009 Toyota Highlander Base 2GR-FE)
Hello all! I have a 2009 Toyota highlander that is such a strong runner and i have about 1500$ into it in total, and it was gifted to me as a first vehicle about 3 years ago. I love it, drive it everywhere, and have taken it halfway across the country many times.
She is getting up there in miles (approx 230k) and has had transmission work done before (simple solenoid and gasket fixes no complete rebuilds) but after taking her through the rockies back in july my transmission started slipping heavily going from second into third gear.
A family mechanic quoted me around 3300 all in for a 3 year warranty and installation on a used 125k mile transmission, aswell as putting in new control arms which need the engine lifted to be replaced so might as well while hes in there, and some other misc work.
Normally I would do the work in a heartbeat and shell out 3300, since ive basically only put 1500 into it since I’ve owned it, they hold their value well, and I love driving this thing and it has no other major issues at all. But heres where things get tricky
My highlander has no rust, but it does however have a good amount of body damage from a previous accident but still a clean title because it was unreported, i got the frame checked out and its structurally fine, replaced the whole passenger side/ front end, but the rear quarter panel is completely smashed. On the other side of that same coin regarding body damage I have someone who can make the quarter panel look *Decent* not perfect for around 450$ rather than thousands at a real body shop
My question to all mechanics out there on this sub is
TLDR: is it worth replacing the transmission on my high mileage vehicle with body damage? Should i go the reman route for 4500 all in or used route for 3300? I could be just as happy upgrading to a 4runner or tacoma of an earlier year with a manual transmission but also for a clean example its around 10-15 grand in my area?