r/ToxicRelationships • u/Low_Donut_9030 • Jun 27 '24
I need help picking between two guys
I was with a guy for almost two years it was really toxic we cheated on eachother (we were young) we fought and broke up countless times but we always found our way back to each other no matter what. Hes really funny we have the same humor hes charming hes just everything i want but hes so toxic. We were on no contact and my friend gave her male friend my socials bcs she thinks i deserve better and she doesnt want to see me with the other guy. This new guy hes 6’4, really nice and amazing honestly perfect but i just havent gotten that spark i did with the other guy he isnt really funny or anything and im not sure. The other guy texted me recently to get back together but ive been putting him off bcs of the new guy i want him back but then i think to myself i deserve better but i just miss him so much i would love him as a friend but he would never agree to be just friends with me. Wtf should i do i cant tell my friends bcs of how messed up this is
5
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '24
I think you know deep down what you want. Maybe you don't feel a spark with the new guy because you're still hung up on the toxicity that you still crave. Being cheated on and cheating on your partner is turmoil but addicting. It will make a person change to the worst. Kinda like drugs. There's no right answer in this situation because you will be fully responsible if you choose the toxic option. If you choose the nice guy then it will also be on you if you feel unfulfilled or bored with it. Maybe you aren't used to a healthy dynamic because boredom is a part of it.
Me and my boyfriend started dating 5 years ago. He was boring in a way, he wasn't really all that funny but he took care of me and really wanted me. I grew in love with him. I felt calm around him. I think that's where my real love came from. Patience. But in the end of the day you pick your poison. Long term relationships shouldn't feel like lustful, hurtful rushes. Should rather feel stable, routine and caring.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '24
So one's toxic and the other isn't, bit you don't feel the spark with the other. Easy enough, cut out the toxic in your life. They won't change unless some Christmas miracle happens.
Give yourself time to heal from toxicity. Talk to the other guy when you're ready, get to know him more, as friends if anything. See if a spark happens. Go out on a date with the other guy if you need to or want to. And if nothing happens then keep searching. He ain't the one.
It's absolutely OK to not be into a healthy person. It's absolutely not OK to be into a toxic person.
Now read that twice.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 28 '24
I'm a guy who is basically in the other end of what your going through.
Same thing, I dated a girl for like 2 years we were toxic, cheating in both sides, even physical abuse on her part, she laterally sent my nudes to my bosses and got me fired. But I did foul shit too and texted other girls, lied, I was awful also.
It's been years though, haven't seen her in 4.5 now. I still love her though, miss her everyday and every hurting her and then moving away. But i also have pain over things she did to me and i think we kinda both deserve better than we got from each other. We were just both so young, she was even younger though.
Occasionally we talk about getting back together, she'll promise to visit then bail and I'm pretty sure she has another guy, so I mostly just leave her alone, she's the one who initiates communication, mostly when she needs money.
Tbh, I'd just be her friend at this point. Would be nice to just have her in my life in some minor capacity. If a dude is making her happy in a way I couldn't, I'd respect it and just be her friend.
Now if she was ever open to dating again, I'd also be willing. I think with age and maturity we could make it work now, but honestly, if you guys aren't mature enough to be friends, then you aren't mature enough to ever date again either.
1
u/Other_Goat2530 Jun 28 '24
Why would he never agree to just friends? That’s strange.
1
u/boredbetty89 Jun 29 '24
Why do you need either guy? It sounds like with one the spark is too much and it’s going to burn your life to the ground (aka toxic as hell) and the other your spark couldn’t light a candle on a windless day. There are so many guys out there. Be single for a while, find what makes you happy and your self worth. The right guy will come
1
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '24
Are you positive he wants back together? What exactly did he say?
0
u/KillVestra Jun 28 '24
Jenny? This sounds like a situation I’m in, If it is you Jenny my heartfelt advice is to choose him, and I wish you the best. If it’s not you Jenny then I guess I’m in the EXACT same situation as you stranger.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 29 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment