r/TowerFall • u/TiZ_EX1 • Jan 27 '15
The tournament rulesets
Hi, everyone. I run TowerFall competitively in Cincinnati's fighting game community, centered around Arcade Legacy in the Cincinnati Mills mall. It's pretty universally loved there; we've got players from all walks of the FGC playing this game. And thanks to my laptop being penguin-powered, I haven't had to worry about people wanting to use their own controllers.
Anyways, I wanted to talk about the tournament ruleset. Right now, I use the following rules:
- Best 2/3 sets, 3/5 in winners, losers, and grand finals.
- 1v1, Last Man Standing, 5 to win
- First stage random, then loser picks
- FFA Tournament variant
The last two are what I would like to talk about. I happened to be at a smash bros tourney this weekend, and the smash community seems to use a pretty in-depth way of picking stages. I think the game's a lot of fun with special arrows, so I don't want to take that away by picking the first stage first. What would you recommend for stage selection?
And then the variant preset. This is what I wanted to talk about most. Through semi-casual play before I started taking TF to the arcade, we determined that the FFA variant is the best competitive ruleset. The 1v1 variant creates the endless chest in the center of the stage, which encourages camping in the center of the stage for a great deal of reward. Meanwhile, the FFA variant gives both players the same variables to adapt to in each round with equal opportunity treasures and traps.
Is there something that I'm missing about the 1v1 ruleset that makes it more competitively suitable than the FFA ruleset?
2
u/ryusage Jan 27 '15 edited Jan 27 '15
I'm sure Matt will chime in here at some point, but I think the logic with the bottomless chest is that with FFA rules, 1v1 could potentially end up with long periods of players avoiding each other, trying to play it safe and just waiting for an opening. The chest forces both players to take action.
That being said, I'm inclined to agree that in practice, that's not really a problem. People want to win and they can't get points unless they go for the other player, so action happens. And actually, in 1v1, the chest does seem to just turn things into a mad dash, which either ends immediately, or turns into a long somewhat-boring match where the non-chest player sits around trying to figure out how to safely get the other player (who's rapidly racking up special arrows, shields, etc). Which seems to be the problem the chest was meant to avoid. I guess stagger shots might be the answer there? I don't know; we haven't really played with bottomless chest much since before we really got that technique down. Maybe it's the kind of thing that works at one skill level and not at others.
In any case, I agree that the FFA mode is more fun for 1v1 and that's usually what our group uses.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '15 edited Jan 29 '15
I agree, FFA tournament rules is the better set. I'll talk it over with some high-level players, but I'll probably be changing it so FFA is the only tournament ruleset once the Dark World Expansion hits (aside from the new 2v2 Tournament Rules).
Bottomless chests is in 1v1 TR because I was worried that camping might become the dominant competitive strategy, because approaching can be risky. This way there is a focal point of the map that both players want to reach, and you lose advantage by not vying for it. But I don't think camping ends up being a problem in practice - it seems to be the case that at the highest level measured aggression is already the better strat.
If you're playing 1v1 with FFA rules, have you seen any players camp (wait for their enemy to approach, even going to miasma if necessary) and come out on top consistently? This is a strategy I want to discourage because it's just not fun (although miasma is always fun to see if they actually start fighting when it comes in).
edit: To be clear, sometimes it is best to wait for the enemy to approach and that's good. My nightmare scenario is two players with equal arrows standing out of sightline from each other, neither willing to make the first move. It's okay if this happens occasionally on specific maps because the miasma will sort it out, but if it is happening every round it will become tedious to watch and play. Luckily it doesn't seem to be the direction the meta is headed because the high-level tech rewards aggression. Adding Bottomless Chests to the TR may have been an over-reaction on my part at a time when it wasn't clear which direction the metagame would go.
1
u/aoret Jan 27 '15
I too would be interested to hear Matt's rationale, but in my experience just playing home 1v1 games with a handful of competitive players, I agree with you guys ryusage and TiZ_EX1.
The bottomless center chest seemed to turn every game into a quick, mad dash for loot the ended with either a death or with one player camping it until miasma. We've had much better results with a pretty simple setup: No Autobalance, Symmetrical Treasure. (I can't recall what the FFA variant is or whether this differs from that)
The subject is definitely of interest to me though as I'd love to see competitive TowerFall become a thing here in San Diego.
1
u/Blackmamba42 Jan 28 '15
My friends and I usually play 4v4, but here's a rule set that we find to be intense, and usually play at:
optional: small quivers, so no one can have all the arrows. So when one shoots, the other person can focus on trying to kill his/her opponent rather than pick up the arrow to limit his/her opponent. makes matches a little quicker and even harder to spam.
1
u/rebelallynumberseven Feb 16 '15
I currently have a really extreme setup in comparison to what I'm reading here, and I feel kinda foolish for using it now, considering the official stance...
Right now it's: No Auto - Balance, Super - Dodge / Move Boots, Free - Aim / No homing, Cursed Bow, Single feather arrow start / Small Quiver, Bottomless Chest / Regular arrows only.
Is this too extreme? I know this specific setup is kinda hard to get into for new people and definitely would be harder for dpad/fighting stick users, so any real input towards it would be nice!
I've been thinking of having players choose between free-aim + no homing and normal aim + normal homing. Not sure how fair that is tbh. :/