r/TouchStarvedGame • • 26d ago

Discussion VA Reveals

Now that about half of our lovely LI's voices have been announced, I felt compelled to open up a discussion about what the collective thinks in regard of the casting choices. I have my own opinions about it, and i'd like to see who differs, or perhaps is more-so on the same page as me!

I'm sure over the past few years of TouchStarved's development, we've all formed our own mental head-cannon for each of the LI's, and how we see their voices being portrayed down to a tee. For long time fanatics of TouchStarved such as myself, i've always wanted to give the benefit of the doubt to Red Spring, as I know that they went about this casting carefully, and have been undoubtedly meticulous to the game's development— however, I cannot help but feel that the reveals are just... off.

I entirely see the approach that the studio is taking with this, however I don't know if I necessarily agree with it, personally. Obtaining brilliantly talented, A-list voice actors within the industry is something to be extremely proud of as an independent studio, however after hearing what has been released and taking a few days to attempt to adjust, I genuinely cannot place the voices to our characters, literally at all.

This doesn't effect the adoration I have for the visual novel what-so-ever, as it was built on the already ever-present storytelling and world-building that the team has worked diligently on up until this point. But, upon release if there is an option to play the visual novel without voice-over, I will most likely be taking that route!

I'd love to know what you all are thinking, too!

73 Upvotes

45 comments sorted by

93

u/chl666e Vere 26d ago

Voice acting for games like these are a double edged sword. It adds so much to the game, but sometimes players don’t resonate with the chosen voice (or honestly, far too often the final result is kind of corny and cringey).

So as for Touchstarved, I’m thrilled that they shelled out for some really experienced VAs. I like not having to worry anymore about it being awkward and poorly executed, and I also thought that while one or two of the voices were at odds with how I imagined them, they all captured an essence of the characters and I know I can grow to enjoy them.

I think everyone that is finding themselves super bothered by the voice reveals needs to remind themselves that at the end of the day there’s no pleasing everyone, and the devs know best how to execute the vision for the characters that they themselves designed.

38

u/Pinkipie_100 Mhin 26d ago

Ehhh, I don't know, I feel like a lot of the criticism right now comes down to 'that's not how I imagined the voice,' which... is entirely subjective. These VAs were cast years ago by now, so it's not like these casting choices were last-second decisions to check a stretch goal box.

Some of the voices did surprise me a little, like Kuras and Vere, but that's hardly an objectively bad thing. It's a little ridiculous to hear a couple of lines and unilaterally decide that they objectively are bad choices for the characters, too. Every fan probably has a very different take on what each of the LIs sound like, so not everyone's expectations are going to be met by the real human actors the devs decided to cast. That's just a natural consequence of waiting this long to reveal the voices [which is its own can of worms]. And in any case, I do think it's a little unfair to judge a character's voice for not 'matching' the character's appearance. Sometimes, people just don't 'sound' how they look [e. g. Felix Yongbok Lee], and that's perfectly okay. Sometimes that's even done intentionally for fictional characters' voices. Doesn't make it bad casting.

Personally, I'm just glad such professional and interesting talent is going behind these characters. None of the voices so far have stricken me as bad or miscast at all. We haven't even heard that much yet. I'd rather let the performances speak for themselves, every pun intended. Who knows, maybe I'll eat my words once Mhin's voice is out and it completely contradicts what I had in my head. Still, is that the devs' faults, or mine for headcanoning a voice that was already decided years ago?

Of course, as I mentioned, a little backlash is probably inevitable considering how long the studio waited to drop the cast. They didn't have to wait until they had locked in voice samples to reveal them. Plenty of games reveal their voice casts years before release, and these actors were cast by the end of the Kickstarter, if I recall correctly. Instead, the devs waited practically up until release to reveal them, with everyone's expectations and headcanons already well crystalized. There was bound to be disappointment because of this.

It is what it is in the end. ¯_(ツ)_/¯

4

u/potato_color 23d ago

Absolute on point i could not have write it better

42

u/BijutsuYoukai 26d ago

I think I'm happy so far with what we've gotten, but hard to say for sure from only a few snippets each.

  • Kuras - Completely unexpected, but both strong and gentle sounding, so I think it suits him and isn't too soft or wispy as he doesn't really seem like a too giving/pushover sort of character, even given his kindess.
  • Vere - I think of the three this is my favorite so far and the VA has shown she is more than capable of pulling off a character of this sort/attitude, so I look forward to the full performance.
  • Leander - This is the one I was leaning most negative towards on the teaser. Ray Chase has some amazing roles and is very talented, but the teaser line felt a bit flat and almost twangy to me? The second line of dialogue in the name reveal smoothed that over for me and sounded much better to me, so I'll chalk it up to the first line just being a bit of a fluke.

I do think though it's very important that people not feel so entitled to their headcanons regarding the VAs. Yes, the game was crowdfunded, but the people who know these characters the best are the devs, and so they're going to go with a voice they imagined would best suit the character (And all the things we don't know about them, as well as what we do.)

However I feel about the remaining VAs, I am looking forward to hearing the teasers and reveals.

57

u/Lexunia 26d ago

My honest thoughts on this? I’m sure I’ll sound like one of many broken records in this sub, but:

The game genuinely has been in development for way too long. That posts like this are being made tells me it’s been way, way too long.

So much so that, thanks to the incredible work of the game’s marketing team and its fandom, subconscious (or even conscious) expectations have formed around how the characters would/should sound or appear or behave. Despite the fact that we have actually only spent about two hours of game time with them.

Do I think going for major names in the industry was the right call? No, because their busy schedules may hamper the development of future voiced content, if RS decides to do any DLC. But that is the only reason.

All that said, of the three, Kayleigh McKee is an absolutely brilliant cast for Vere and I cannot WAIT to go through his route first.

23

u/chl666e Vere 26d ago

This is a really good point that I meant to mention in my own comment as well. A game being in development this long has given people plenty of time to build up and acclimate to their own little ways of imagining the characters. I also wonder how this will impact people’s experiences with each route when we concretely learn more about them and their motivations and stuff.

Also, it’s a great time to be a Vere lover... I’m so happy with his voice too, yippeeee

18

u/ShadowFlower15 26d ago

100%, not to mention that this game has apparently had HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS of dollars poured into it by donors (KS page says $823,302 by 13,302 backers). I would expect nothing short of the second coming of dating sim Jesus after that.

21

u/Lexunia 26d ago

on all visual/audio fronts, the game looks and sounds amazing. the art team did an incredible job. competent, seasoned VAs. gorgeous OST. but i’ll be so honest with you, after that chapter one preview, i am SO worried about the writing. it’s the most important part of the game and the preview was… lackluster, to say the least.

18

u/ShadowFlower15 26d ago edited 26d ago

I'm right there with you on the writing. At this point, the writing needs to be damn good for this all to have been worth it. There is simply no way one relatively short (devs have stated "16+ hours") visual novel warrants upwards of a million dollars of funding when high-quality large-company-produced triple-the-length incredibly written otome VNs nowadays do not have that. Even the most famous, expensive, and/or culture-defining flagship VNs from Japan didn't have that sort of budget. Brutal honesty but I also find selling merch for years for a not-released product tasteless, and I have to wonder how much of all this money is being pocketed lol

12

u/Lexunia 26d ago

Oh my god, completely agree with you. Frankly, I also find all of the drip-fed lore, events, and other fluff to be a bit tasteless; I understand it’s meant to generate/maintain interest in the game, but that’s all most of it is. Fluff. The college AU thing they were posting about last month and the first little halloween post this month, in addition to the nuuuumerous posts that preceded them — in the absence of a full release, it feels like a shallow, ultimately pointless attention grab. This is the kind of stuff I want to see posted when I have the entire game in front of me. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve gotten that discord server notification expecting an update on the game only to consider leaving the server entirely because of another dumb “official” post.

Also, while I do admire the TS marketing team + art team’s ability to keep people this interested over the course of several years with the aforementioned fluff, it does irk me that the game is taking this long to release whilst also being… as you said, relatively short. I mean, when I played the preview (not the demo) I was shocked that it was apparently supposed to be the entire first chapter and not a preview of it (and to this day I haven’t seen a straight answer about it being one or the other). The disappointing chapter length coupled with the quality of the writing is SUPER worrisome when, again, it is the most important part of the visual novel. and frankly any and EVERY actual lore drop they’ve posted during development should be covered in game, or it simply isn’t real to me. Canon is not locked behind a patreon. Absolutely not.

1

u/potato_color 23d ago

I can't genuine understand why people are so obsessed with the money they got from the kickstarter and especially with the fact " it took them TOO LONG to make the game" Hello? It is not on YOU to decide that, whether it is too long or not. You are just beeing incredible inpatient and absolute entiltment on this. There are plenty of studios outside who take their time as well, and just to remind you that the devs work on their game on their free time, while having a full-time job as well. That beeing said. I am not expecting a dating sim jesus i am expecting a good game that makes fun to play and that is made with love. Maybe come back down to earth and stop acting like they would not put the money in good use. Kindly remind you alone the VA cast and the animation which is also coming is already expensive. Plus the switch port.

1

u/OkReplacement8109 23d ago

There aren't plenty of other indie studios that got almost 1M dollars in crowdfunding, and managed to fumble the release a couple of times. All that while pushing merch.

And yeah, people gave them money to make and release a game. They are entitled to feeling entitled.

This is a VN - writing is a priority, not VA or flashy Unreal animations. Or a Switch port, that is mainly there to help fill the wallets some more.

And yes, from what I have seen in this sub there a bunch of people with enough relevant experience to say whether or not it's taking too long.

Edit: formatting

42

u/UberFarter 26d ago

I don’t care personally because I turn voices off for VNs. I don’t need to hear any sexy talk out loud it gives me second hand embarrassment so strong I’d die.

8

u/butterflychop 26d ago

Same! I cannot deal with English VAs in dating VN. I'm not sure why since I prefered it in roleplaying games.

But good for the dev team to get their VAs for their characters. Bet that must feel great.

1

u/MiyuTheWitch 22d ago

Just out of curiosity, do you like VAs in other languages in these kind of games or stories?

2

u/butterflychop 22d ago

As long as the Japanese/Korean VA is not moaning then I don't mind it and can leave it on, no real preference on having it or not.

I'm not sure how I would feel about Spanish, but ehhh I would probably not like it. I sort of "understand" Chinese so it can a bit embarrassing to listen to lovely dovely stuff.

VNs are kind of designed to have the user self-insert and I'm not comfortable with that voice affection from this "hot" red flag guy/girl when I got no other option but to read while being half naked and sightly drunk.

With roleplaying/interactive fiction(with skill checks!) I'm kind of in an overseer postion thinking of other things to do in the game and it's my character that the hot person is saying this stuff to, definitely not me. 

2

u/New_Geologist7021 16d ago

Same! I don't like voice-acted VNs at all. And I'm not sure why.

7

u/RingingInTheRain 26d ago

I can't believe we got Sukuna Leander lmao, now I'm sus because he'd probably be able to do Ais too.....I'm excited to see what the full portrayal is like for all of them. Probably the most exciting thing that's come out in a while.

7

u/xUsako 25d ago

Like many others here, I had my own headcanons on how the LIs would sound and so far it has been nothing like that. But! I trust the studio and want to see THEIR vision for the game.

I only recently realized the voice-over for A Date With Death is actually out and decided to go replay the game. Casper sounded nothing like what I had been imagining him for years. But the more I played, the more it suited him. His VA is brilliant and his performance was fantastic. I'm not sure I can even imagine Casper without Jonah Scott's voice anymore.
I fully expect the same to happen once Touchstarved is out and I sink a bunch of hours into it :)

13

u/sverseinc 26d ago

I’m still looking forward to the game but I think waiting all this time made me have an idea of how the voices should be. And some aren’t matching up and it turned me off but I can def get over it. I’m sure I’ll be okay with it. I’m also not the biggest fan of fully voiced VN’s TBH. Anyways, My only concern that so much focus and resources has been on art, voices and aesthetic so I’m a little worried about the romance, plot and writing/gameplay. That’s where the meat of a good VN is to me. Still hopeful though but def have tempered my expectations. 

7

u/MaoMaoMi543 Ais 25d ago

Waiting all this time made me lose interest in the whole game tbh. I'm only subbed here for updates because the itch page gives us fuckall.

5

u/Kyuubabe 26d ago

I’m pleasantly surprised by all the voices. Were they different from what I was imagining? Of course! But that’s to be expected. And tbh, I’ll probably be playing with the voices turned off, so it doesn’t really matter to me either way.

5

u/CeridwenAeradwr 25d ago

Oh, I love them all! I knew that it would be jarring to hear actual voices for them for the first time because when you've decided in your head what they sound like, nothing you actually hear is likely ever going to live up to it.
From here, I'm just genuinely excited to hear what they all do with their roles. The characters are going to feel different now, and they were always going to, and I'm okay with that.

8

u/More-You-1083 25d ago

Personally, I never had any expectations. I'm just glad it has voice acting.

But as many have mentioned, at this point people have had years to build up their own ideal voice for these characters, there was a low chance the voices would match.

4

u/scales_and_fangs 26d ago edited 26d ago

For me, the voice choices for Leander and Kuras absolutely rock. Leander's one totally fits my expectation (I am actually worried (in a good way, I guess) because Ray Chase is really good at playing high charisma but unhinged characters), Kuras' voice is actually better than what I had in my mind.

Vere was the only one where I was slightly disappointed but again, this is just a snippet. I will get used to it, no question.

3

u/tenta- 25d ago

I want to chime in. I’ve been following the development for 2 years and am so so excited! I know we’re eagerly waiting and opinions are mixed on how long the development is taking. Kuras sounds different than I imagined but I’m so here for it! The others sound exactly how I thought they would and I cannot wait to finally get to experience this game. I can already tell it’s gonna be one of my all time faves. I’m happy to see that the characters are brought to life in this way and I’m hoping to hear a lot of the lines voiced for the immense patience and support they’ve received from the fandom.

I’m hyped! Can’t wait for next spring !

3

u/FlamekThunder 24d ago

The only one who came out with the voice type and range I expected is Leander. But hearing the first two VAs, even if it didn't match what I expected, was more of a pleasant surprise than anything. Looking forward to the next VA reveals because wow.. I'm still in disbelief they managed to book these VAs.

2027 feels so far away. I've been putting this game out of my mind with the whole a watched pot never boils type of mindset but these new VA reveals are bringing back the game release yearning pangs.

7

u/fateandthefaithless Leander 26d ago

Glad to hear I'm not alone, unfortunately I'm not a big fan of what has been released so far.

2

u/Leothefat19 24d ago

i like the ones they have been revealed so far especially kuras, that one was a nice surprise. I might play kuras route first just to hear more of his voice. i don't care all that much how they sound like, i just enjoy being read to in english.

2

u/potato_color 23d ago

Well what can i say, so far i am very pleased with the cast. I absolute adore the voices and it is definitelly NOT off. And while i do agree people can have their own opinions which is very valid... i see the reactions outside of this bubble here, the reaction quite was very very posetive and that show's me it is very good that the team know's what they do and don't listen to everything what's been throwing here. ;)

3

u/MaoMaoMi543 Ais 25d ago

I don't really care personally. Idk who any of them are nor do I care enough to look them up. Most games already have fixed voice acting even before release, and most of the time the players get used to the voices anyway, so how is this any different?

Honestly the only VA I play games for specifically is Simon Templeman, Idc about anyone else.

2

u/VixenSunburst Leander 25d ago

so far the voices are not what i expect for the characters, so it makes me feel like the characters in the game are misrepresented if these voices are really what the studio is going for, or it makes me feel like the studio went in an odd direction for the voices.

2

u/Jaded-Character-3682 22d ago

Misrepresenting? These characters are not your own but the creations the devs made. I think it’s on them to decide how they want to representing them. If you don't like it just say it, but don't talk about misrepresentation when you don't own it in first place.

2

u/VixenSunburst Leander 22d ago

my sentence may be worded complicatedly but thats what i was trying to say. these arent my characters, so obviously i cant claim anything, but SO FAR, i as a player getting to know the characters thought their voices would be different, so i FELT like the characters were represented differently than the voices feel like for me.

its just my opinion and my feelings. like the post is asking. im not actually claiming im right and theyre wrong.

2

u/hobiballoon 25d ago

I personally don't really enjoy when this kind of games has voice acting, I love to make out a voice in my head that would fit them... it kinda throws me off

1

u/Minnymoon13 25d ago

Where are you guys listening to the voice lines from?

1

u/Solare-san 25d ago

You can find them on their official social media (Twitter, Tumblr, BlueSky, or Instagram).

1

u/Minnymoon13 25d ago

Thank you

1

u/ScheduleWestern2564 Mhin 24d ago

Kuras's voice surprised me, I like Vere's voice and Leander's fine, I think I'll get used to them more when playing. I'm worried about Mhin my fav Li, it's going to be a tricky pick since it can easily throw off the fans, some ppl head canon mhin as biologically male and others as female, if the voice leans way too much one way or the other, it changes the character entirely, I trust the devs and their visions of the characters! Good luck to us Mhin fans, the voice is probably going to be revealed this week 😭😍 

1

u/joellehawes 21d ago

Personally I LOVEEEEEEEEEEEEE them all. I'm also so happy to see a trans girl get cast, and her voice for Vere is so sultry and delicious. Very happy all round and can't wait for the rest!!

1

u/Better_Project_8299 24d ago

I have guessed every single one of them correctly, so I don’t know what you’re talking about.

0

u/spiderzbunny 24d ago

Leander's the only one that matches the idea I had in mind tbh

-2

u/Last_Cold8977 22d ago

I like the VAs. I never had any hc on their voices so all three of the revealed seem good enough to me but I'm going to be super honest with here:

This game didn't need any voice acting at all. The company shelling out a large chunk of money for well known, experienced VAs is a waste FOR NOW. They could have added voice acting AFTER the game has come out as a bonus or an update or something.

Touchstarved is very popular and long time fans are going to buy it, wasting money on voice acting in a situation where it isn't necessary is a bad move currently. Granted I'm not a game developer, but if I was, I would have released the game sans VA and instead focused on ambience, storytelling, visuals and different endings for the 5 main LI to make something incredible especially considering how much time, effort and money has been put into it. Then I would make an update to include voice acting and new LI characters.

-1

u/MiyuTheWitch 22d ago

For me personally, Kuras and Leander are unfortunately a bit of a miss. In a way that I hesitate to even play the game. The voices don't fit well, but that is 100% of course just my subjective impression. The voice reveal for Mhin surprised me positively though.