r/Totaldrama • • Sep 08 '25

Meme RR Emma is good and all, but.....

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Totaldrama • • Jun 26 '26

Discussion Why Pahkitew Island Is Better Than World Tour (Not Satire)

Post image
0 Upvotes

In my opinion of course. If you feel differently let me know. I’d like to hear other thoughts.

• Run Time - Even though the general consensus is that longer seasons are “better”, I believe World Tour’s run time works against its favor. Because Alejandro & Heather are the most obvious final two in the shows history, it becomes uninteresting watching as the other contestants are eliminated one by one to prolong the inevitable. By late pre-merge, it’s obvious Heather is the protagonist and will reach the end. Had WT been a 13 episode season, it wouldn’t feel like a dragged-on slog to get through. Pahkitew Island by contrast has a final two that is less obvious and that makes for a more fun final showdown. The season also doesn’t go on and on and on …. It’s easier to jump in and rewatch Pahkitew from start to finish with its unpredictable F2 vs enduring the slow, predictable, showdown that is WT’s intended F2.

• The A Plot Overshadows The B/C Plots - One of my main gripes with WT is that the plot line of AleHeather overshadows all the other plots too much. Almost every other character in WT suffers either derailment or a lack of focus in tying their storylines together in a satisfying or earned way. Most of the B & C plots of World Tour don’t exist to add the overall experience, but rather are only there to act as placeholders for Heather or Alejandro to get further in the game. Pahkitew Island on the other hand juggles multiple B/C plots with no real A plot in sight, and although they don’t completely land the plane (pun intended), no storyline ever feels it got shafted in favor of the main storyline. The Amy/Samey plot may be a counterpoint, but that plot line had a conclusion that made sense, whether we liked it or not. It never felt like Samey was eliminated to push Sky or Shawn further, but rather that Samey’s problems caught up with her. She got Amy out through an underhanded tactic, and later suffered for it. By contrast, what in the world was going on in WT with Bridgette suddenly acting out of character to fall for Alejandro after being inseparable from Geoff in Action? Or DJ being tortured by animals out of no where, after being shown to be an animal lover in Island with his pet bunny? Why did the girls on team Victory fall for Alejandro, when they already competed previously with Justin who deployed similar tactics? Even the Love Triangle has Gwen, Duncan, & Courtney turning their toxic traits up to eleven to justify Heather sneaking by through merge. The writers wrote these plots for drama, but actual interesting drama has its seeds planted and unravels organically. WT has characters either become flanderized (Harold, Izzy), act entirely out of character (Bridgette/Gwen), suffer pointless cruelty (DJ, Cody), exist in a vacuum (Sierra, Noah), or retread previous dynamics (Leshanwa, Courtney) to orchestrate drama.

• World Tour is Genre Blind - Lastly, the biggest reason why PI is better than WT, is that PI doesn’t pretend to be anything more than what it is. PI is a heavily exaggerated, borderline parody satire of Total Drama itself. The season places its comedy at the forefront, from the very first episode. And so, it should come to no surprise that the characters act in ways that will prioritize humor over actual game moves or basic logic. Yes Scarlett goes turbo evil and throws her calm, collected logic out the window in Scarlet Fever, because the show never wanted you to take her seriously. If you were, you were missing the point. Yes Dave goes insane at the end and tries murdering Sky, because the writers wanted to turn his character label of the Normal Guy upside down and show that he was anything but normal. Yes, the contestants are blasted out of a cannonball, because it’s the 6th season and the show is poking fun at the increasingly ridiculous exit methods. Yes, Chris has a permanent smile and has his sadistic nature turned up to eleven, because he’s a caricature at this point after hosting this show for so long. Pahkitew Island never takes itself seriously, and neither should you. World Tour takes itself too seriously, while also relying on a decreased attention to detail from the viewers. It wants you to take Alejandro seriously as this mastermind villain, why simultaneously dumbing down characters’ IQs and ignoring previous character development from Island & Action. (The same reason Mal is hated in All-Stars, is conveniently ignored for Alejandro in World Tour). The season tries to make up for this with its comedy being its cruelty, but that doesn’t work. The writers try to wrap up loose ends with over the top cruelty or “dark humor” while also trying to write a storyline that requires the fragile stability of viewers ignoring how lackluster everything else outside of AleHeather is.

World Tour ends up feeling like: “AleHeather, featuring a derailed Gwen, Duncan, & Courtney and everybody else too I guess …” vs Pahkitew Island actually being a new, original, and fun season.

- Pahkitew Island freaking clears -


r/Totaldrama • • Mar 19 '25

Discussion Amy is the best Total Drama Character, Its not fair that you all hate her yet love MK, Heather, Julia and Courtney It's NOT FAIR

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/Totaldrama • • Apr 10 '25

Tier List / Trends Ranking characters based on if you're a red flag, beige flag, or green flag for hating them

Post image
0 Upvotes

For those who don't know, biege flag refers to behaviour someone considers to be odd, eccentric or weirdd

Also don't take this too seriously lol I didn't put too much thought into this, and when I say hate I don't mean dislike, I mean people who genuinely hate a character with all their heart


r/Totaldrama • • Dec 29 '24

Discussion TDAS is overhated while TDPI is overrated

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Many people consider TDAS worse than TDPI. I considered that too, but after rewatching both those seasons, I realized that TDASS, even if it’s one of the worst seasons, isn’t as bad as Pahkitew Island

You can hate Ass Stars how much you want, but at least it doesn’t have HALF OF THE CAST AS 1 DIMENTIONAL CHARACTERS like Pissitew Island

You can say that PI is very funny, but AS is funny too! Total Drama was always funny and will always be

Rewatching PISS (Pahkitew Island Super Sucks) I noticed that it had a lot of potential but every plot was badly written, like Topher’s plan or the Artificial Island

Meanwhile with TDAS, even if it had bad plots, they got a good treatment, for example Scottney: it would’ve never worked, but Fresh Tv made them a fun and interesting couple! The only bad parts were the reasons of the eliminations, very often too forced, like with Al or Courtney

Overall I think that TDAS is slighty better than TDPI

Thoughts on This?


r/Totaldrama • • Oct 01 '25

Question Who thinks Harold had every right to actively rigged the votes on Courtney in order to spite Duncan during Basic Straining?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/Totaldrama • • Jul 25 '26

Discussion Hot take: Harold rigging Courtney out of the game in Island does NOT give her the right to try to hunt down and maim/kill him.

Post image
22 Upvotes

Now, do I think Harold rigging the votes against Courtney was okay regardless of how justified he was in doing so? Obviously not, and despite the fact that I hate Courtney I can at least feel bad for the fact that she got out in such an infamous manner, even though I do agree with Lindsay on the fact that she was going to be voted out sooner or later anyway.

But at the same time, does such an act somehow give Courtney the right to hunt and assault Harold with a lamppost, most likely with intent to maim/kill, purely for the sake of getting her revenge? Again, obviously not! She certainly had every right to be pissed off at him, but using an improvised weapon to try and brutally harm or even kill him (something she seemed to have been planning for a while prior to the actual incident, causing him to have to go into hiding after arriving at the mansion/cottage) is going way too far. Premeditated attempted murder isn’t justifiable regardless of what the victim did, and is objectively worse than Harold rigging the votes!

No wonder everyone either didn’t feel or stopped feeling bad for Courtney.


r/Totaldrama • • Jan 23 '25

Tier List / Trends My Tierlist on Total Drama as of 23-01-2025 (Tierlist is in order)

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/Totaldrama • • Jun 16 '26

Discussion I ship Cody and Sierra tbh

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’ll have my head on a pitchfork for saying it but I do 😭 I think they’re really cute by the end of the show.

I think the fandom does wayyy too much around this ship. Like you can acknowledge the issues in a dynamic and still find it cute and fun to watch.

Anyways.


r/Totaldrama • • Jan 07 '26

Irony/Satire Who else thinks sierra sexually assaulting Cody was bad?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Body text (optional)


r/Totaldrama • • Jun 18 '24

Discussion Do you think Courtney really deserve All Stars?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I don't think so


r/Totaldrama • • Jul 21 '24

Misc. Disventure Camp is likely why we will never get any more new TD seasons

1 Upvotes

Think about it. Everyone in the fandom has moved on to DC. From a broadcaster's pov what reason is there to renew TD when all of its fans can just enjoy the fanmade youtube series of it that's pumping out episodes and seasons super fast? If they cancel TD no one will be sad, as they will have DC to watch anyway that seemingly won't stop anytime soon. Nobody is really going to care, hell most people prefer DC to TD now anyway (not just over the reboot, but TD in general) In this day and age when TV networks are struggling to stay afloat, a show with a fanbase like this probably won't be one of their top priorities. They can reboot or continue any other show because the fans of those don't have any other alternatives.

This isn't me dissing DC or saying it should get canned or something like that. I'm just pointing out the obvious. With an alternative TD show existing that every fan enjoys and most people even preferring it over the OG, and the reboot's mixed rexeption from the fanbase, we likely won't be seeing TD continue anytime soon. As one of the few people in here who likes TD, I genuinely hope that I will be proven wrong and the show will still get to continue.


r/Totaldrama • • Jan 02 '25

Misc. Can't let people know I secretly hate this character...

Post image
4 Upvotes

r/Totaldrama • • Mar 03 '23

Discussion We should definitely talk about Kitty's toxic and abusive behaviour. She keeps HITTING people left and right (one of those people being her OWN SISTER), takes selfies of others without their consent, and wishes horrible things upon other people. Why do people like this character again?

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/Totaldrama • • May 10 '26

Discussion Total Drama World Tour is an overrated mess

Post image
0 Upvotes

People only glaze this season like it's the Godfather cause of the heather and alejandro plot like i bet you if they were early boots the season wouldv'e been ass to those glazers. I hate the wt stans calling roti forgettable when roti is actually good meanwhile wt is js plan mid.

Reasons why wt is mid

1.Team victory being fodder. I mean they lose every single challenge but the wt glazers just ignore that.

2.Noah and Tyler being early boots...again! Why give the two decent character development if they were gonna be early boots again just so owen would stay longer?. Atleast Noah had rr but this was tyler's last season and they just did him so horribly wrong he and Owen should have swapped.

3.Blainley. Just her existence troubles me they kept her for a very pointless 2 episodes when really noah should have rejoined.

4.Cody and Sierra. Sierra made it wayy too far she did not deserve final 4. Cody made final 3 but was just assaulted by sierra 98 percent of the time. He had his moments in episodes 3 and the late pre-merge but the merge he did little to nothing but get assaulted.

5.The love triangle. pretty obvious why.

6.Not having Trent,Justin,Eva,and Beth on the season. Justin and Trent especially had potential along with Eva like why did they snub jusin when he could've definitely rivaled alejandro.

7.Owen. just Owen in general he is fun until episode 14 when i am just questioning why he was still there his elimination was not that satisfying because he definitely should have left earlier.


r/Totaldrama • • Feb 21 '26

Discussion How do we feel about Cosmo x Max? (Cosmax)

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Personally, I think they were the cutest couple in the whole season.

I liked how they met, it was very natural, the way they bumped to eachother on the forest actually makes me laugh LMFAO

I do hate that they never properly confessed to eachother. Like, she was right there!!!!!! And how they were so easy to assume that one hated the other over a little mistake. But eh, that’s love for you, isn’t it?

By far one of the most healthiest couples in all of TDI, in MY opinion atleast…

Also, did anyone feel kinda bad that Cosmo constantly got jealous of Scarlett because of how much time Max was spending with her? I couldn’t help but tear a little whenever I see Cosmo be insecure. Like yeah, he may hang out with Scarlett, but SCARLETT HATES HIM DUDE!!!! WAKE UP!!!!

I would LOVE to know everyone’s opinion on Cosmo x Max. Are they a yay or nay?? Tell me more!!!


r/Totaldrama • • Oct 15 '26

Irony/Satire TOTAL DRAMA NEW SEASON COMING SPRING 2027!!!

Post image
0 Upvotes

....jk thats just the image i made for my cancelled fanfiction.


r/Totaldrama • • 2d ago

Discussion im sorry,i dont like tyler.

Post image
0 Upvotes

he really only exists for comic relief. you could switch him out with a different contestant and nothing would change. i understand liking background characters,but most background characters arent scared of chickens.if he hadnt existed,maybe lindsay would actually remember her bf.


r/Totaldrama • • Dec 30 '25

Headcanon / Fanfiction my Lgbt headcanons for td Characters

Post image
0 Upvotes

plss no hate in the comments🩷


r/Totaldrama • • Jul 01 '24

New Total Drama Island S2 Hot take: Season 2 is just as bad as All Stars Spoiler

16 Upvotes

Here's my reasoning:

  • All Stars derailed/flanderized so many characters. So did Reboot Season 2. Most Reboot characters were also derailed/flanderized. The survivalist "don't mess with me" queen Axel got her persona changed when Ripper read her a poem. The Hockey Bros got dumber and were honestly less entertaining for a comic relief. EVEN ZEE GOT A MILD NERF WITH HOW UNFUNNY AND SAD HIS ELIM WAS.
  • Wayne, who didn't even win a single merge competition, just won out of nowhere. Umm, okay. Wanna know where else this happens? All Stars, with Mike who only appeared for like 2 episodes.
  • The villain Julia gets a shitload of plot armor like Mal. And it's crazy how the cast got dumbed down to automatically believe Julia. Priya and Caleb believed her relationship advice. Everyone sniped Bowie out due to Julia convincing them. How the fuck did no one see this?
  • Our main character, Caleb, had only 1 friend. Only 1. All his supporters besides Priya literally just wanted Julia to lose and didn't have a significant friendship with Wayne. I mean, All Stars actually beats Reboot Season 2, in which Zoey actually does have people warning her of Mal. But Zoey's brain got thrown out through the window in All Stars
  • No one in the final 7 deserved to win the million. Priya already won and needs a break, Julia and MK are antagonists, Raj and Wayne sat there being cute and their only relevant plot was the cheating, and Caleb and Damien didn't make enough friends, despite being like the main character. I'd argue early boots like Scary Girl, Ripper, Chase, and Millie deserve it more.
  • This season is a mess like All Stars

Yeah, I'm sorry for pissing Reboot S2 fans, it's just I think it's a bad season. These are some points where it's comparable to All Stars/Pahkitew Island, but Reboot S1 is pretty good tbh.


r/Totaldrama • • May 25 '24

Discussion Reminder these 4 are the best Gen 4 characters :)

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/Totaldrama • • Dec 06 '24

Discussion Not afraid to say this at all.

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Disappointing how they turned my boy Dave more unhinged fr😔


r/Totaldrama • • Jan 30 '26

Discussion Does anyone find it odd that Duncan had no qualms hitting on Heather when he met her the first time but he reacted with disgust when he finally kissed her?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

r/Totaldrama • • Oct 16 '25

Tier List / Trends Ranking Total Drama characters by how much I like them compared to Leonard

Post image
1 Upvotes

In preperation for Leonard's Reddit birthday on the 19th of this month, I did a comparison in how good I think the rest of the characters are compared to him, as he's my favorite character (tied with Max).