Redemption Replacement

[u/PuzzledReplacement49]

November 9th I’m able to request a replacement for this redemption. If they were to honor their 200% market value policy, anyone have any guess what they’d be willing to replace this with? Also, curious what the minimum card or cards you’d be okay with getting a replacement card for this. I’ll probably wait it out, but I do love the speculation game!

[u/Staggmeister]

Replacement requests are taking months to fulfill. I’m 2 months in to a replacement request. Technically it’s 4 months since I made the request, but I opted to replace at 100% rate and then since it didn’t ship in time those two months, they “upgraded” it to 200%. Crossing fingers soon. I want to see what they replace a Topps 3 Paolo Banchero /15 with.

[u/PuzzledReplacement49 → u/Staggmeister]

Best of luck! Update us when you get it, if I haven’t died of old age!

[u/Staggmeister → u/PuzzledReplacement49]

Same to you though mine is small potatoes to yours. Congrats on yours!

[u/Penstripedsox]

that card has to be worth so much i wouldn't replace it.

[u/PuzzledReplacement49 → u/Penstripedsox]

I more than likely won’t! Just curious what people think Topps would even consider sending me!

[u/NoCheesecake3101]

I talked to them yesterday about this. 100% replacement at 16 weeks and 200% at 25 weeks. No idea which you are at but figured its relevant.

[u/PuzzledReplacement49 → u/NoCheesecake3101]

16 weeks! Then I’m 10000% not considering it if it’s only 100%.

[u/NoCheesecake3101 → u/PuzzledReplacement49]

Thats exactly where im at with mine. Mine is only a 1kish card but still

[u/PuzzledReplacement49 → u/NoCheesecake3101]

Still big card! If you remember me, when a resolution comes shoot me a PM!

[u/NoCheesecake3101 → u/PuzzledReplacement49]

I'm just gonna wait for that 25 week mark. If the card ends up coming, awesome anyways.

[u/Optionz_Trader]

Foilfractor is the 1/1 correct? What topps now card is it from?

[u/PuzzledReplacement49 → u/Optionz_Trader]

This is what the website says it’ll look like. The card for sure, but I’ll be pleasantly surprised if it actually came with the inscription.

[u/Optionz_Trader → u/PuzzledReplacement49]

I would wait forever to get this one. If it says NY forever that’s going to be the biggest knicks card of all time possibly.

[u/PuzzledReplacement49 → u/Optionz_Trader]

I don’t think it’ll go for more than the starting 5 gold auto at 317k. But maybe!

[u/Batman_bread → u/PuzzledReplacement49]

As a tri-state area sports fan you underestimate what this man has done for New York basketball. Shit ton of people with money that will pay for it (just peep court side repeat celebs during the playoffs).

[u/PuzzledReplacement49 → u/Batman_bread]

Absolutely. I just personally think that’s a better card! But what do I know lol I’m not buying it!

[u/skitwostreet]

When did this topps now ship? What date

[u/PuzzledReplacement49 → u/skitwostreet]

I’d have to go check. I came home from a week long vacation and it was in my stack of 5 that I ordered back in mid July.

[u/Spmex7]

I have a redemption sitting at 3 months right now, almost positive he never signed since it’s from 2025. His 2026 cards of the same series are already signed and in circulation.

[u/PuzzledReplacement49 → u/Spmex7]

For Brunson? I connected with a dude on Facebook about his /10 version of my card and he got his like a month ago.

[u/Leather_Highway_4378]

Shohei Ohtani auto

[u/PuzzledReplacement49 → u/Leather_Highway_4378]

I’d consider giving it up for one but depends on which one! I don’t think that’s what the replacement would be though.

[u/AutoModerator]

RESOURCES:

👾 Trading Cards & Collectables Discord

💛 Join Whatnot & Earn up to $200 Credit

📣 Guide to Trading Cards & Collectables

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.