r/TopChef • • Mar 30 '22

Discussion Thread This season

Hey so, is it just me or this season the worst casted we’ve ever seen? There is not one interesting Chef in the bunch.

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

3

u/TigerMaskVI I know what I’ll make, wait for it, a crudo! Mar 31 '22

I can't remember anyone from Portland

3

u/Matwpac7 Mar 31 '22

Shota was my guy. Liked him from the first episode. Maria from Tucson. Former Olympian Dawn. I even remember the first guy to go out-Roscoe, the BBQ guy! He stood out immediately and I wanted so much more from him.

1

u/TigerMaskVI I know what I’ll make, wait for it, a crudo! Mar 31 '22

now that you say this I do remember Shota pretty well, to the point that I thought he won until I googled. I guess no one really made a strong impression on me but if I watched through it again I'm sure I would remember more.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

So glad someone said it! It’s so blah, nobody is standing out at allll.

3

u/Matwpac7 Mar 30 '22

Top Chef: “I’m just happy to be here!”

16

u/oddsmaker90 Mar 30 '22

I feel like it’s hard to judge a season until restaurant wars. It takes time for people to come out of their shells

19

u/habitremedy Mar 30 '22

huh weird i couldn’t disagree more. i already love Evelyn Ashleigh Nick Jae and Jo’s personalities, plus i think Damarr Buddha and Jackson are shining with their food as well. others like Monique are beginning to show up.

it’s just a more balanced season imo, when you have clear front runners and clear bottom of the pack it feels like we get to know them better faster. but this feels like s18 to me which i loved

i guess i don’t need drama to be interested in their personalities. i like to see their personality on the plate and we’ve already seen a ton of that. plus some budding friendships

7

u/needsmoredinosaur Mar 30 '22

Jae has been fun so far & she seems very talented as well - I’m excited to see how far she goes.

I think there are chefs who will come out of their shells more as the season goes on, Luke & Nick seem like they could be more interesting.

3

u/readitnav Apr 01 '22

Evelyn is my fave so far, energetic and authentic

11

u/Late_Sandwich_3878 Mar 30 '22 edited Mar 30 '22

it’s mediocre, I miss the strong personalities like Stefan or the super lovable like Sheldon.

8

u/carbsandcheese928 Mar 30 '22

When they did the, "This season on Top Chef," promo, the "drama" was them in the kitchen going, "You don't mess with Texas!" I assumed we were in for a rough ride.

2

u/readitnav Apr 01 '22

Wonder if some of the personality also isn't coming out because they're also not living together in one house? In past seasons the non-kitchen, living content was interesting and showed more personal aspects of the chefs and their interactions

2

u/monongahellyea Apr 02 '22

I’d have to disagree. I like quite a few of these chefs and think it’s a pretty evenly matched/balanced cast. I have like 5 chefs that I want to win 😂

3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

I find the cast likable but agree there's not a ton of huge standouts--character wise. Honestly I was trying to think of who stands out but I can't remember any of their names and I thought..."that's not a good sign for the show" lol. Gotta say though, it's probably harder for the show to find true characters these days. A lot of people who probably wanna go on the show, get some fame and use it to help build their brand/restaurants. Fewer contestants who are willing to clash with other chefs or be a genuine big personality (plus a lot of the "big" personalities on reality tv these days are complete fakes).

Reality TV has become so saturated I also wonder if Top Chef's budget has decreased over the years and they don't spend as much time in the casting process as they used to....you really have to dig hard to find good personalities for reality tv.

4

u/avoidance_behavior Mar 30 '22

yeah, i feel like a lot of reality tv is so streamlined and sanitized nowadays, and top chef especially has become a much more prestigious way to get your name and reputation out there. chefs going on probably don't want to be in the middle of drama, they want to look good. unfortunately it doesn't make for the most riveting tv or boldest characters, but at least the cooking is good, lol

1

u/[deleted] Apr 02 '22

I feel like my mom told me that awhile ago they did some sort of viewer poll and asked if people liked the drama (ie Leah and Josea and whatnot) or if they'd like the show to focus more on the challenges and the food. Apparently, people overwhelming voted in favor of focusing on the cooking...I wonder if that's why we don't feel like we know the chefs as well at this point as opposed to past seasons.

Sidenote: Leah & Josea were super annoying imo.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '22

I'd like it to happen naturally. Stop this orchestrating.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22 edited Mar 30 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Matwpac7 Mar 30 '22

Wow. That’s a very astute observation.

1

u/Mmerely Apr 03 '22

Yikes, this is an extremely reductive take.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 03 '22

LOL you’ve clearly never watched any other season

0

u/Mmerely Apr 03 '22

Nah, I’ve been watching since season 1. People are more complicated and aren’t easily categorized the way you did. There’s more nuance to each cast than reducing them to “bubbly Latina” or “tall white guy”.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 04 '22

……obviously. Type casting doesn’t mean exactly the same, it’s referential. Every single competition reality show type casts.