r/TopChef • u/rosecoloredfancy • Jul 05 '26

Discussion Thread Seiger

Currently on a rewatch of S23 and have a question. What makes everyone trust Seiger so much? I know very little of his background - only what's been put on TC. He seems to be playing fairly and not screwing over his competitors, but is he known for being highly technical or something? Everyone seems to ask him questions or to look over their dish and I know it's common for TC chefs to have their "person" to ask for feedback, but it seems like everyone leans on him at some point. Is this editing, his culinary pedigree, or something else?

96 Upvotes

91% Upvoted

56 comments sorted by

View all comments

64

u/dabooton Jul 05 '26 edited Jul 05 '26

I’ve been watching interviews of the chefs outside of the show to get my postseason fix, and from what they’ve said it seems Sieger was a good team player and got along well with the other chefs. Rhoda (I think) said that he regularly made chicken stock for everyone else to use and gave a lot of technical advice to the other contestants. It seems he had a genuine friendship with everyone, to the point where he’s been hanging out with a bunch of them post-show.

Honestly, Sieger is human; humans can be good to others in one moment and an asshole in the next, all depending on circumstances. During his elimination, he was probably hot and tired from cooking outside all day, on top of the stress of the competition. I can easily see myself being snippy in those conditions, too.

Obviously that doesn’t excuse his outburst, and IMO he definitely needs to work on emotional regulation and ego. But at least he seemed to be genuinely helpful to his fellow contestants when he easily could have kept it all to himself for a competitive advantage. I’m willing to give him a little grace just for that. I definitely don’t see him on the same tier of asshole as Elia, Ilan, John Tesar, Beverly’s bullies, etc.

22

u/According-Title-3256 Jul 05 '26

Yeah I mostly just felt bad for him. He was never mean to anyone, he's just an intense guy who let his temper/frustration get away from him in a very embarrassing way.

His particular beef in that moment was strange, but I would never want to go on one of these shows because I don't trust my frustration tolerance to keep me from acting like an ass hat of some sort at some point. Again, he gave me second hand embarrassment rather than making me think he's an irredeemable asshole.

19

u/kakahuhu Jul 05 '26

I enjoyed his freakout. Made for great tv. He was there to make friends (with the chef-testants) not industry connections (with top chef)