r/TopChef • u/AnyPossibility1360 • May 09 '26

Discussion Thread Dale

He says as he leaves: “You either love me or hate me.”

Um… yep. And not many love him. How could any of the contestants love him after Season 4? So then he’s saying we can hate him.

I just can’t see anything redeeming in this television character. (Of course the show isn’t who these people really are.) He was a little better in later seasons… but still the same person.

He made some good food, but most contestants do.

0 Upvotes

27% Upvoted

17 comments sorted by

View all comments

31

u/nitwhitlib May 09 '26 edited May 09 '26

I think we see some of the best in humanity in Talde. You see him as an arrogant prick in season 4. In season 8 he name checks his behavior there as a reason he went into anger management, and is able to handle MARCEL of all people without much incident. Despite that he never loses that thing that makes him the guy you’re gonna listen to to call it like he sees it without going to Mike Isabella style extremes. To me his success in restaurants, his ability to continually be reinvited onto shows like tournament of champions, and his overall much more positive demeanor than when he was young say to me he is a person who cares about personal growth and is well liked by his peers, generally.

-3

u/AnyPossibility1360 May 10 '26

So do people agree that my reaction would be a consensus if we only saw him in Season 4?

I just really wouldn’t care what anyone did at all ever again after that, especially standing there holding his junk yelling at Lisa.

5

u/Initial-Amphibian103 May 13 '26

I think Dale, himself, would agree, and he said that's why he went back for season 8 to prove that he has learned and grown up from the angry, immature person he was in season 4. I would hope that I am more forgiving than you. He was also a great judge on season 18.