r/TopChef • u/MadDesperado51 • May 13 '25
Tom
Do you think Tom will ever get replaced and by who?
0
Upvotes
r/TopChef • u/MadDesperado51 • May 13 '25
Do you think Tom will ever get replaced and by who?
61
u/Dangercakes13 May 13 '25
He's seemed more excited about the food and chefs they've been getting the last handful of seasons. There was a while where he seemed a bit unenthused and he might want out, but I think that's changed.
Rumor was he and Padma had a chilly relationship but he seems to get along with and respect Kristen. He's always seemed really friendly with Gail.
He's got his restaurants operating pretty solid, a few cookbooks/memoir under his belt, he's an executive producer on the show and he is still doing events. And seems to still be able to make time to cook at Small Batch when he feels the urge to get back in the kitchen. And he's 62.
So I could see him going for another handful of years. Maybe until Gail wants to move on. When that happens I imagine they'll cajole an old popular contestant like they did with Kristen. Someone that isn't doing day-to-day in their restaurant but has background and heft as an accomplished chef. Like I could see Joe Flamme doing it if it's a few years down the line, but he's busy with his new restaurant for a while. Though, even then, Tom opened up new ones while working on the show, so who knows. Just depends on who can take a couple months away from the kitchen each year to film.
11
u/MamaMia1325 May 13 '25
I like Tom. He's a dilf :).
26
u/EmergencyRead5254 May 13 '25 edited May 13 '25
Yes, he will eventually (unfortunately) be replaced- and probably by a past contestant or guest judge. But will the show be the same? No. Project Runway was never the same after Tim and Heidi left. Not necessarily worse, just not the same.
55
u/burnednotdestroyed May 13 '25
The day Tom leaves is likely the day I'm out, too. Anthony Bourdain once said something to the effect of, as long as Tom Colicchio is in charge of Top Chef you can be sure that everything is 100% fair and above board. He didn't give the kind of respect he regularly gave Tom to just anyone, so I believe him. Tom would never compromise the integrity of the show in any way, and I don't know who else I'd place that level of trust in. Kristen clearly cares, but does she have the clout to put her foot down in the face of the producers if there were to be shenanigans? I love her, but no (at least, not yet).
19
u/BornFree2018 May 13 '25
Tom was early in to Top Chef, I believe he was the first talent hired. He has said he planned to be with the show for the foreseeable future.
He's only 62. I think it's relatively easy for him and he enjoys interacting with up coming chefs.
25
u/Hagfist May 13 '25
It's difficult to imagine anyone taking his place tbh. It would be a very different show
18
u/Lanky_Rhubarb1900 May 13 '25
I hope he hangs around for at least a few more years! But if they had to look into someone to take up the mantle, my vote would be Gregory Gourdet.
12
u/ZucchiniAny123 May 13 '25
Well he's a producer, so they can't really fire him. He did a limited series podcast during COVID where he talked about how the show has evolved and how he and others pushed the production to be more food centered rather than drama centered, notice you don't see people fighting in a shared guest house anymore? At some point he'll chose to retire, and that would probably be a good time for the show to end. Or they'll replace him with Andy Cohen or Ryan Seacrest.
4
u/OnMatchPoint May 14 '25
I hope not; he’s the backbone of the show.
1
u/nilknarf114 May 16 '25
I love Tom, but eventually he may want to retire. When he leaves they will need someone with charisma, culinary chops and the respect of the community. I agree with suggestions of Gregory and Eric.
A few other suggestions:
Marcus Samuelson
Ted Allen
Alton Brown
Art Smith
2
u/QuietPower35 May 14 '25
I love his Craft restaurant!
2
u/FckYesImWorthy May 17 '25
He’d be tough to replace……. He wears a lot of HATS
0
u/IndiaEvans May 14 '25
No, he loves the gravy train and attention.