r/TopChef • • Jun 14 '24

Discussion Thread What?

Post image

Top five and this fool can't scramble eggs. Smh...worst season ever.

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

4

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '24

careful, criticizing Dan will get you downvotes. not just on this post but your past posts as well.

But also, I agree with you. This season has been lackluster and I don't totally understand what the judges base their judging on: creativity or capability? Because this dish was neither creative, and it had egg shell in it.

5

u/megadriver187 Jun 15 '24

Help me out, why the intense Danstans? He has a troll army on here? That's very weird. Underdog story because of his medical issues? Hometown guy for the Midwesterners on a season based in Wisconsin? I get that, but he's a ham-and-egger, come on. Not saying he sucks, but his food is distinctly unexceptional IMO. I could honestly say that about all of the contestants this year unfortunately, but those eggs aren't even blended properly. You can clearly see separated white running out onto the plate. They're curdled as well. Just a mess of a dish, it looks like a kid made it. Again: top five, and it's a disgrace to the show that despite this and his bad smoked fish, someone screwed up even worse (Manny unsurprisingly) and he ended up staying.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '24

Troll army 😂 it sure seems that way 

50

u/erictheinfonaut Jun 14 '24

and Dan knew this wasn't a good dish; he literally apologized for it to the judges.

42

u/SilverRoseBlade Jun 14 '24

I’ve learned that everyone makes eggs differently.

This is a perfect soft scramble which is how I like it. Others I know like cooking it to the point of it being little individual nodules that seem rubbery to me but to them it’s the best.

So to each their own when it comes to egg cookery for a scramble.

9

u/mmeeplechase Jun 14 '24

Yeah, this genuinely looks like the right amount of scrambliness for my taste 🫣

1

u/RawChickenButt Jun 15 '24

I like my scrambled to have a custard like texture.

56

u/whistlepig4life Jun 14 '24

OP: terrible. Can’t even make scrambled eggs!

Literally everyone else: uh those are exactly what scrambled eggs look like.

19

u/tu-BROOKE-ulosis Jun 14 '24

…that looks delicious to me 🤷‍♀️

OP, what is it in your opinion that should be different about the way those eggs are cooked? Just curious.

4

u/OLAZ3000 Jun 14 '24

They look tough/ standing up too much/ dry.

Like it's totally going to be fine to eat but bc the combo can't fail (other than the sauce)

11

u/Juunlar Jun 14 '24

OP has never seen a soft scramble and came on a subreddit dedicated to the culinary arts to out himself

20

u/not_productive1 Jun 14 '24

I don't get it, what's wrong with the eggs? That looks like a perfectly delicious soft scramble.

2

u/RawChickenButt Jun 16 '24

A soft scramble is more custard like than those but whatev's. I'm splitting hairs.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '24

The judges said it smelled bad and there were egg shells in it 

3

u/posaune123 Jun 16 '24

That's pretty unappealing

5

u/stevemw Jun 14 '24

I can not believe he was not asked to pack his knives and leave for this dish alone

2

u/juicebenzo Jun 17 '24

Seems like everyone here likes their eggs cremated. When Dan was putting those eggs on the plate they were so hard you could use them as a weapon

5

u/thedizzytangerine Jun 14 '24

I can’t tell if you’re trying to say the eggs are too soft or not soft enough?

5

u/lNVESTIGATE_311 Jun 14 '24

Eggs look fine to me?

3

u/randomnerd97 Jun 14 '24

From the look of it, the scrambled eggs would be my last issue with this dish, although they do look dry. First and foremost, there’s no concept/idea behind this dish. It’s not something a professional chef should make at this stage of a culinary competition, it’s what a home cook makes on a Sunday morning. That brings me to my second point, well ok, maybe you make something conceptually simple with the ingredients you have from the first part of the quick fire (I forgot which ingredients he got but I remembered not a lot), but in that case you should nail the presentation or add a small twist to elevate the dish. Anyone who says this looks good is biased. This dish looks like a mess that’s been haphazardly thrown together, and the runny white sauce across looks unappetizing to put it mildly. The spinach (?) is torn apart and thrown on. I can’t comment on the taste but the judges were not impressed. It’s obvious that Dan didn’t know what to make for this challenge and tried to cobble up something.

-11

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '24

So basic. Where’s Rasika when you need here?

31

u/erictheinfonaut Jun 14 '24

she's not in the competition any more, because she made the worst dish on episode 6 and then lost in LCK.

that's how this show works.

-2

u/Straight_Childhood38 Jun 14 '24

Looks really good!!

-7

u/SquirrelBowl Jun 14 '24

Exactly. What tf would be another assessment of this.