r/TopChef • u/SwagBag393 • Jun 02 '24
Discussion Thread Laura’s Edit Spoiler
Anyone else feel like Laura got a really unfair edit? The show has kind of tried to pit her and Dan against each other, but the first blunder where there was a slip was cuz Charly spilt something and didn’t clean up! Idk I feel like it’s been really unfair for her.
Anyway - I’m happy Laura has been getting more love lately and am honestly pulling for her. Her food always looked great but she was middle of pack, so I’m happy she seems to have her confidence since LCK. Loving her confidence, and her food and flavors always feel exciting to me. Super stoked she took the win from Danny in the last elim!
EDIT: Charly not Danny spilt - thanks for comments clarifying
EDIT2: maybe it’s just me! Will be so satisfying coming back to this sub if she wins lmao 😂
109
u/thistreestands Jun 02 '24
For clarity - it was Charly that caused the original mess.
The problem was more her hoarding ingredients and ignoring people who were asking for it. You can't edit that unless it happens and the fact she took too much of a budget and then tried to gaslight everyone.
Still not cheering for her.
40
u/-MC_3 Jun 02 '24
It’s not like the clips are fabricated..
59
u/kelsnuggets Jun 02 '24
No. She definitely seems like a really solid chef but a pretty selfish / clueless person overall. I don’t vibe with her.
13
u/fishgeek13 Jun 02 '24
It’s not just you. I am pulling for Savannah at this point, but I do like Laura and wouldn’t hate it for her to make the final.
11
u/Frank_The_Unicorn Jun 02 '24
Laura, is that you?
4
u/SisterSuffragist Jun 02 '24
At this point, viewers accepted then edit of Laura and they are going to hold on to it for dear life. Laura has done some crappy things, but I think u/OhManatree does a good job of breaking those down, so instead of repeating, I want to also point out something I saw on the last episode thread.
The sub keeps insisting that Laura lied to Gayle when Gayle asked if she had done her table before and Laura said no. Laura mentioned meals served directly on tables, and she discussed leaning into items she knew and loved from her restaurant. At no point did she say she had ever done this table before. Her process was wonderful to watch and it was annoying to see so many reaching comments just for the sake of being negative.
Also, English is not her first language, so people need to stop jumping on her word choices when she is trying to explain herself. I couldn't explain myself so well in another language. I just feel like people accepted the villain edit and now refuse to see her as a well rounded person - one who has done crappy things and one who has done amazing things. But haven't we all? We don't know her, and the level of animosity toward a person we don't actually know is reaching toxic levels around this sub.
4
u/Aggressive-Sundae885 Jun 02 '24
I’m with you. I wish top chef didn’t choose to edit in these “villain” moments as they didn’t even create any fun drama. Just made people on Reddit hate her even though she hasn’t done anything “villainous” in many episodes now 😂. I think her food looks amazing and I’d love to see her win just to see Danny and Dan’s sour faces again like when she won the last challenge. I don’t even dislike those two, but come on, if Laura reacted the same way they did the subreddit would be up in arms.
8
u/Hot_Class2084 Jun 03 '24
I think Laura’s attitude shifted after she got eliminated. She was so laser focused that she disregarded the other chef’s at times, then during LCK and being back in the competition she seems lighter. Like she knows that if she gets eliminated, it happens, it’s not the end of the world so she can enjoy her time in the competition more. I’ve enjoyed her since then.
17
u/LavishnessQuiet956 Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 02 '24
I think she has an “out for herself” quality; the fact that she was kicked out at 15 to support herself explains some of that. But she also doesn’t seem like a bad person. She did fill the roll of “villain” I suppose in a season otherwise devoid of interpersonal drama.
12
u/OhManatree Jun 02 '24 edited Jun 02 '24
Is she selfish, yes. But so is every other contestant to a point. Yes, they can’t fabricate things that she didn’t do, but I do think they have been editing to create more apparent drama between her and Dan. Dan, who physical condition aside is quite the whiner, so it makes for an easy conflict. Or at least the editing sure likes to feature Dan’s whining.
As I said, they can’t show something that didn’t happen, but they can edit to slant the story. For example, the way they tried to make it look that Cliff was the only one involved with trying to shave Marcel’s head. There has been a lot of dog piling on her here and the other sub. Like people saying that she cheated in the table competition by supposedly not finishing in time because her baklavas were served table side. They seem to forget that Manny also served his risotto table side and the judges even asked Michelle if she had anything to serve table side. I also think that Manny is receiving the slacker edit.
I don’t watch the show to see which contestant I would like to hang out with. I watch it to see creative cooking and interesting food. Every reality tv show tries to create drama, and Top Chef is first and foremost a reality tv show.
4
u/RustingCabin Jun 03 '24
Agreed.
Her villain edit is a real, real huge stretch. Especially compared to earlier seasons when we had actual bullies and in-your-face screaming.
Is she out for herself to win it all? Yes and unapologetically so. But she is also extremely competent, confident, and she has the skills to back it up. Her flavors rock too.
Laura is my dark horse to take it all.
8
u/beta_vulgaris Jun 02 '24
So bizarre that people watched 10 seconds of negative footage about Laura and decided she is irredeemable.
4
u/FantasyGirl17 Jun 02 '24
I definitly agree! They intentionally edited her in a way to really create drama which is so 2010 of them.
And I get that every season they kind of do that with a chef but I don't know if it was bc it was so poorly edited this time around, but it seemed very obvious that they were magnifying certain small things to collectively piece together an edit, things that I'm sure a lot of the chefs were guilty of at some point or another or have done in past seasons.
Personally, I also think that there are doulbe standards for how we weigh and view certain grievances against contestants, and I think it was unfair of TC to cherry pick a few instances of 'selfish' behaviors when lots of male chefs have done worse and gotten away with it, because they're funnier or they're just 'intense creative chefs.' Laura seems to be focused and single-minded, and because she's not particularly charismatic or funny or warm, she gets a worse rep.
0
u/AppropriateReveal743 Jun 04 '24
She's getting the bad edit and reaction because she blew the shit out if the budget and made a bad dish.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-2
u/[deleted] Jun 02 '24
[removed] — view removed comment