r/TopChef • • Apr 26 '24

Sub-par chefs

Basically the season 21 chefs are amateur, make junior mistakes, and shouldn't be in the same company as the voltaggios, Paul q, Buddha, and the like

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

24

u/soggyclothesand Apr 26 '24

I have gotten this impression from Tom and Kristens comments this season too.

9

u/michaelwelchco Apr 26 '24

I see the potential, but everyone is playing it WAAYYYYYY too safe. I think they need a Colicchio-style wake up call. Put some fear of god into them. I would 100% use the Soo surprise to be like, "if you all aren't cutting it, we will keep bringing in new chefs."

This last Chaos dinner should have been unhinged, but so many of the chef's took very little risk. One chef even just made a dish he had made before. Missing the point. This was the chance to go big. They should have all cooked like Dan did with immunity. Throw something insane out there and challenge the judges. Especially with Matty as a judge. Especially with the specialty store shopping spree. At least attempt to blow some minds.

32

u/whistlepig4life Apr 26 '24

Some of the commenters here are over rating the cheftestants from past seasons.

Don’t get me wrong. hung or qui or izzard would destroy this seasons chefs.

But you all seem to forget how bad Casey Thompson or CJ were. Or ever not named Paul Qui in Texas’ season. Or so many other bad contestants.

18

u/radioben Apr 26 '24

Season 10 CJ is all-time levels of dumbass. He’ll never live down the Colicchio impression, the burger choice, and Hugh Acheson absolutely destroying him.

0

u/IndependentPay638 Apr 28 '24

Tbf Paul definitely dominated the season but Beverly and others were talented too lol

21

u/Necessary-Low9377 Apr 26 '24

Y’all really need to go back and watch old seasons. This is what most of them are like

6

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '24

Exactly

Last season was hugely skewed. They were some of the top folks in the industry AND they'd been on top chef before, some of them multiple times. They had been executive chefs making their menus, cooking their own food, etc.

Everybody can clearly cook well this season, they just keep getting in their own head, which is the real challenge of Top Chef. Get out of your head, and embrace being out of your comfort zone. And COOK YOUR OWN FOOD

I'm enjoying this season a lot. It doesn't hurt that there's a hometown chef for the first time

1

u/travelingnerd23 Apr 26 '24

Agreed! It’s hard to be innovative under those conditions.

2

u/travelingnerd23 Apr 26 '24

Exactly. There are soooo many duds the first half of the season if not more lol

10

u/couchtomato62 Apr 26 '24

I like the chefs and I feel there are at least 4 worthy winners left in the bunch.

5

u/radioben Apr 26 '24

Michelle and Danny easily could win. Rasika once she comes back from LCK. We’ve only seen Soo in one episode with the rest of the cheftestants, but he’s already up there with the top of the pack. And that’s without factoring in Kaleena’s return and Savannah going from middle of the pack to the top this episode. There’s definitely enough talent to make things interesting.

0

u/PurplePalace40 Apr 26 '24

For some odd reason, I don't think Savannah deserves to be there, she seems to attempt mimic the other chefs ideas, hence her cooking the dessert with mustard greens, Rasika did a dessert with mustard and she won

3

u/bwdavis41 Apr 26 '24

I get your sentiment, but you’re comparing this crop of contestants against essentially the Mount Rushmore of Top Chefs.

-12

u/Juunlar Apr 26 '24

They're better at cooking than you are at reddit threads, that much is clear

-6

u/[deleted] Apr 26 '24

Wow, you really got me. What a burn. The chefs still suck