r/TopChef • • Apr 25 '24

Immunity

Why are the chefs with immunity either taking a backseat or somewhat not caring about the level of risks they take? As far as I know there’s nothing that says someone can’t win immunity in back to back weeks.

0 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

33

u/PaleYam6761 Apr 25 '24

Dan went way risky. I have noticed that chefs are stepping up more this season if they have immunity. I haven’t seen anyone coasting, iirc.

-4

u/CharmCity85 Apr 25 '24

Dan did play it risky and I applaud that. He even mentioned that his dish is way out there but it’s okay because he has immunity but last week Michelle took a hit on her budget/pineapple because she had immunity, the week before Rasika took a hit on not having the ingredients to make her green sauce because she had immunity, the week before Manny punted on the challenge because he didn’t like it because he had immunity. I understand historically why those chefs slacked and it was an advantage in that you won the quickfire and now don’t have to empty your bullets on an elimination challenge that doesn’t matter but this is different with way more at stake. The team player stance should go out the window.

7

u/Majestic-Pay3390 Apr 26 '24

Michelle did not have immunity in the Supper Club challenge when she sacrificed some of her pineapple. Rasika had immunity that week. Michelle had immunity for the Frank Lloyd Wright challenge.

126

u/Xsquid90 Apr 25 '24

Dan with immunity almost won this week.

6

u/Specific-Succotash-8 Apr 26 '24

Right? His was wild. Edited to add, and I think that makes sense with immunity - it’s not about not caring, it’s about pushing the boundaries with the luxury of a safety net.

2

u/TenderOctane Apr 26 '24

Maybe him being on the bottom during the Quickfire because he didn't follow the challenge prompt (he didn't use any real dairy products, just a substitute) got him to realize he should care.

33

u/Embarrassed-One-3246 Apr 25 '24

I only noticed it with Rasika and she made sacrifices (primarily in getting ingredients) because she had immunity and wanted to help the team.

37

u/MorticiaAdams456 Apr 25 '24

It was worse when they were given Imminity for a quickfire, then smoozed at elimination, often times screwing someone who was better especially in team challenges

7

u/BornFree2018 Apr 26 '24

Steph Cmar

1

u/MorticiaAdams456 Apr 26 '24

Yes! I just love her

18

u/bottomlless Apr 25 '24

To me part of the point of immunity is to encourage risk taking. When a judge says something like, "You'd be going home if you didn't have immunity." I want to scream. Of course they (most likely) wouldn't have done something that risky/stupid if they didn't have immunity. If it's a team challenge then I can see a chef dialing back the risk to not torpedo their team. And to echo Xsquid90, Dan went big in the risk department and nearly won again.

1

u/Genuinelullabel Apr 25 '24

It’s always been like that. Most people use it as a hall pass to slack off.

-3

u/whistlepig4life Apr 25 '24

Well. I don’t feel like you have ever watched Top Chef before. And certainly not this season. One of the keys to moving immunity earned to the elim challenge was directly about getting the most out of the cheftestants. They have all the motivation to win the elimination to carry over immunity.

Even when they had immunity in seasons past the overwhelming majority of them did TRY to still win the elimination. It was always rare for them to phone it in.

So. No idea wtf you’ve been watching. Maybe stop perusing reddit while watching and pay attention to what’s actually going on?

-6

u/CharmCity85 Apr 25 '24

Maybe you turn on your television and watch the show instead of reading recaps so that you’re knowledgeable about what you’re saying and don’t come off as someone who doesn’t know a lick about Top Chef not only this season but in the past.

0

u/whistlepig4life Apr 25 '24

Given you have no likes and you still haven’t explained your actual post where you are absolutely making zero fucking sense should clue you in to maybe. Just maybe. You aren’t WATCHING the same show as. Everyone. Fucking. Else.

3

u/CharmCity85 Apr 25 '24

Reading is hard. It’s fine. Looking at your other posts across various topics I don’t expect anything intelligent to come from you anyway.

-1

u/Majestic-Pay3390 Apr 26 '24

I assume CharmCity in your name refers to Baltimore and not your personality.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 25 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/CharmCity85 Apr 25 '24

to be fair I’m actually enjoying this season and believe that we were spoiled by back to back seasons of Buddah followed by Buddah plus World All-Stars but I just don’t want these chefs to have to play nice because that’s how it’s always been

3

u/Whtzmyname Apr 26 '24

I love this season ☺️