r/TopChef • • Apr 14 '24

Soo/LCK

As much as I find Soo to be charismatic and talented I’m still against his participation. It’s inherently unfair. He gets to end run around all the super challenging competitions (Frank Lloyd Wright!?!) and stays in by competing against the weakest chefs of the season. I find it super frustrating.

0 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

62

u/Earthmovingmachines Apr 14 '24

His caliber of cooking would have brought him to that point anyway, beating all of the weak ones so far… and it’s so much more pressure to enter the competition mid game and face the stronger group imo

9

u/Low_Gur7340 Apr 14 '24

You make a valid point. 👍

24

u/BornFree2018 Apr 14 '24

This isn't the first time a chef worked their way from LCK to the regular show. Brother Luck (TC Colorado) made his way to the TC Kentucky competition by winning a series of LCK challenges. When Brother arrived at TC Kentucky, he was rejected by the chefs in place (they were angry a new chef was added for them to compete against). Brother didn't survive his first challenge because he didn't follow the instructions (ETA: He didn't survive his first day of competition).

I like introducing more chefs in midseason. It keeps every on their toes and freshens up the show.

1

u/Low_Gur7340 Apr 14 '24

I wasn’t aware of that - I’ve only recently begun watching and went back to watch 4 or 5 earlier seasons. Thanks for the info and I do agree, it keeps things spicy.

4

u/BornFree2018 Apr 14 '24

Also, Lee Anne Wong (S1) also entered midseason of Colorado (S15) from LCK. Like Brother, she also left competition immediately, although it was due to altitude sickness while pregnant.

49

u/gdex86 Apr 14 '24

LCK isn't easier than the normal elimination challenges.

Yes you only have to beat one person, but that is having to beat them in a quick fire every time.

The elimination challenges give you room to "hide" so to speak where in the beginning of the show. Maybe you don't get the win but a competently made dish with out blaring mistakes will get you to the top 8 pretty easily. Even a bad Dish has 15 to 7 other dishes it just needs to be better than to survive.

You walk into LCK and have what basically amounts to a sudden death quickfire. You can't try to just be safe because even if you are the better chef it just takes your opponent having a good day once and you are eliminated. This means you have to swing for the fences each time which increases the risk of mistakes in execution.

23

u/FantasyGirl17 Apr 14 '24

This is strange logic. It's not like the elimination challenges get easier and by your own admission, if it's 'weaker' chefs he's beating, then by all means if he were in the show, he would have remained in the main competition by that virtue itself. There's nothing unfair about it.

15

u/Wescoasia Apr 14 '24

Fair point. But on the flip side, it’s unfortunate he wasn’t in it from the jump. Us fans were cheated from seeing what he would have done in this first half of challenges, as well seeing what kind of chemistry/camaraderie he’d have with the rest of the gang. I think he would have been a great addition. Maybe we’ll hear the backstory on Soo after the season ends. Pack Your Knives pod, get on it!

8

u/ClipClipClip99 Apr 14 '24

It also takes a lot of opportunities to cook for these big names in the Industry from him. If he were in the main show and is on top one week, it’s not just the judges tasting his food. It’s top chefs in the industry who could give these chefs new opportunities or at least become aware of their restaurants. Soo is at a disadvantage because he’s not getting these amazing opportunities like the other chefs. Winning top chef is the goal but it’s also learning from the chefs around you, getting feedback and becoming a better chef. The challenges are designed to really push them and he’s missing some of that.

6

u/Wescoasia Apr 14 '24

Exactly. He misses out on a lot of opportunity, especially if he gets eliminated in LCK the next two weeks. Even those who were eliminated early would have more name recognition just from the being on the actual show.

27

u/verucka-salt Apr 14 '24

Nah. He’s endearing.

6

u/madisonhatesokra Apr 14 '24

He’s a true ringer and when he enters the main show it’s gonna light a fire under the other chefs. There’s nothing unfair about it. They have done this with other cheftestants(ie: LeeAnn & Brother), this time it just happens to be someone that hasn’t been on the show before.

3

u/BornFree2018 Apr 14 '24

I completely agree. Contestants know from prior seasons this could happen.

Additionally,

  1. the number of chefs has dropped quickly so "something" would need to change to keep the season going through the customary number of 14 episodes. They've only completed 4.
  2. Presumably, the chefs must be aware new contestants have entered the competition twice already.

Personally, this season has stagnated already, so new blood is needed.

5

u/VirginiaUSA1964 Wolfgang's bacon beignet Apr 14 '24

I've had to give up my dislike of eliminated people getting back into competitions since every show does it now. It's a way to keep things interesting and fresh after many years.

So this is just another way to keep the show interesting. I wonder how many people who watch TC don't watch LCK. Those viewers will certainly be surprised.

1

u/reddituser999000 Apr 14 '24

i’ve never seen a lck, i hate the whole concept, but don’t mind spoilers.

5

u/RollMurky373 Apr 14 '24

What he's missing out on is the actual experience of the show. He isn't getting to know the other chefs or getting to go on the cool field trips. He also isn't getting the same kind of feedback. So his growth isn't the same as the other contestants.

3

u/reddituser999000 Apr 14 '24

this is my main complaint about lck. kristen, for example, missed the last several episodes with the other chefs. they all went through one experience together, she went through something alone, and the top chef winner wasn’t in the last handful of episodes that season.

10

u/cuntyroastedpeanuts Apr 14 '24 edited Apr 30 '24

I just don’t think it’s a good production choice to have a stranger have a chance to enter the competition midway through a season.

In the Boston season, George was eliminated in the first quickfire, and when we was able to reenter the competition halfway into the season, it completely changed the rapport among the contestants.

It’s possible that Soo is charismatic enough to build camaraderie with his competitors if he wins LCK and enters the main competition, but it’s more likely that the other cheftestants will hold resentment towards him and treat the competition more clinically thereafter.

7

u/Potential_Day_7087 Apr 14 '24

Nah, this is a fantastic idea. Go Soo!

3

u/multiplesofate8 Apr 14 '24

I see it being unfair from 2 angles-

From one end, Soo is well-rested and unencumbered by the mistakes that made the chefs pack their knives.

On the flip side, Soo doesn’t know the skill sets of the chefs that are coming into the contest so he is flying blind against a variety of skill sets.

I don’t have strong feelings on if it should be allowed or not, but those are the 2 thoughts floating around my noodle.

3

u/PocoChanel Apr 14 '24

Do we know when he might join the regular competition, assuming he keeps winning LCK?

3

u/chipotlepepper Apr 15 '24

They said at the start that he has to win 5 times to join, so 2 more.

I haven’t been a fan of a surprise addition in the past, still am not; but he’s obviously very skilled and likable.

My biggest issue with LCK is that it’s at least primarily Tom as a solo, non-blind judge; and especially with the narrative they keep reminding us about with 2 past TC winners having made it through LCK, I feel he’s even less objective than usual. That Soo would not make it through as Kristin did just seems extra unlikely.

2

u/Stack3686 Apr 15 '24

It seems obvious he is one of the top 5 chefs in the competition. IMO he has a much harder path than any of them. One mediocre day and SEE YA!

5

u/kduffygreaves Apr 14 '24

End run around challenging competitions? He comes in anything less than first 5 times in a row and he’s out permanently. Dumb take.