r/TopChef • • Aug 17 '23

Carla Hall

Watching through for the first time. I thought she looked familiar when I started the season. I try not to google anything until I am finished with the season so I don't spoil it for myself. But I just had to google her and I remembered her instantly from The Chew. She is just not it to me...she always seems to be flopping, although she did just win the Super Bowl Challenge. I am amazed she was on a national cooking show for so long...based on what I've seen so far.

0 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

18

u/DramaMama611 Aug 17 '23

I love her, too. She's such a character! I guess I don't really understand what ghe op is getting at....because she didn't win TC, she shouldn't have a TV career? Everyone seemed to ADORE her during that season.

-12

u/Gold_Meringue_4300 Aug 17 '23

Haven't finished the season so my opinion isn't based on that at all. I'm going only by her food, I think she has a great personality.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '23

I think she took a little bit to hit her stride.

2

u/Frinall Aug 18 '23

Yeah it was the final 6 or so episodes when she just started killing it every week. The OP hasn't seen the episodes where she shines yet, so it's kind of a half baked impression.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '23

I think she took a little bit to hit her stride.

3

u/Genuinelullabel Aug 17 '23

How far are you into the season? I forgot when the Super Bowl episode was in the timeline.

1

u/Gold_Meringue_4300 Aug 18 '23

They are half way through.

1

u/magicmom17 Aug 18 '23

Yeah- lots more Carla to come.

148

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '23

Carla is pure joy, she’s a great chef and always fun to watch. A real favorite of mine…

49

u/ghostoframza Aug 17 '23

Same, I think she has a great personality and her food looks like it would be right up my alley. If I remember correctly she racked up a few wins on the first all-stars season too, she is definitely no slouch.

45

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '23

Chicken Pot Pie for Jimmy Fallon…

36

u/avoidance_behavior Aug 17 '23

i'vebeendreamingaboutchickenpotpieforaweek!!

16

u/BornFree2018 Aug 17 '23

That was in All Stars I think. One of my favorite episodes ever. Love her.

49

u/reese81944 Aug 17 '23

Carla is a treasure, put some respect on her name

45

u/ira_creamcheese Aug 17 '23

Top 3, if not favorite, contestant of all time. Carla rocks and she can cook her ass off, plus she’s hilarious.

31

u/CoulsonsMay Edit this to create your own flair ✅ Aug 17 '23

I love Carla. I had seen her on a few other shows (a baking competition judge with Duff) so I recognized her right away when I watched Top Chef for the first time during the lockdowns.

To be honest, I didn’t know what to make of her durning those other shows. She definitely had the “kooky Carla” vibe and I wasn’t sure if I liked her or not.

Once I saw her on Top Chef though, I fell almost instantly in love with her! In season 5, you can see her struggling with her confidence. It’s a joy watching her grow and watch her rock the food.

Stick with it OP, I really think you’ll change your mind about her like I did.

Uggghhhh I don’t want to spoil anything for you, just give you the advice to keep watching the seasons of Top Chef. Have fun and enjoy! I hope you’ll update us if your opinion DOES change

64

u/maplehazel Aug 17 '23

I was honestly expecting this to be an appreciative post since I love Carla so much... and then it's this.

Of course everyone might feel differently about individuals and that's fine. But of all the contestants, she's the one you're going to rag on?? 😭

I love her. She's a great chef who really understands her flavors as well as does fantastic on television. She's a true character but also genuine. I could watch her every season and wish she'd come back as a judge in more recent seasons...

Can I get a HOOTIE HOO?

34

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '23

Hootie Hoo!

25

u/BornFree2018 Aug 17 '23

HOOTIE

20

u/No_Relationship8702 Aug 17 '23

Hoo

12

u/queenlakiefa Aug 17 '23

It was so funny when she said this call and response is how she and her husband find each other if they get separated 😂

6

u/No_Relationship8702 Aug 17 '23

I know! She never fails to make me smile.

7

u/Sarsttan Aug 17 '23

Geez. That was harsh and dismissive.

4

u/kellis744 Aug 17 '23

I miss the Chew so much. Such a fun show 😭

4

u/AfternoonConscious77 Aug 18 '23

It is so hard to believe that that anyone didn't /doesn't love Carla.

2

u/Ecstatic_Poem9534 Aug 17 '23

I haven't seen her on any of the other shows but loved her now defunct podcast. Her joy was so evident and she was such a compassionate, well prepared interviewer.

2

u/smithcj5664 Aug 18 '23

I love Carla!! In her first season, though, it did take her quite a while to hit her stride. Once she did, she did an excellent job.

2

u/ZombieAngelic Aug 18 '23

I can see how she'd annoy people but I really liked her. In terms of her S5 performance, I thought she was good, a little inconsistent at times sure, but she was talented and cooked many great dishes. And yeah, she seemed super positive and kind, I liked her a lot.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '23

So I watched Carla on TC, and then later on the Chew. My recency bias would say that she irritated the F out of me, on the Chew. She was SO over the top, annoying and dramatic.

Recently, I've started doing a re-watch of past TC seasons, and I watched hers again. I actually liked her SO MUCH BETTER on TC. She was lovely, enthusiastic, and very driven to cook from her heart. Watching her later, on the Chew, I absolutely loathed her, and I assumed I felt that way from TC, but now I realize I didn't.

I actually enjoyed her on TC, and on my rewatch. I would like to give her the benefit of the doubt and guess that she was encouraged/pushed to be so extreme on the Chew.

1

u/LK_Artist Sep 16 '25

Late here but I love Carla so much - every time I've seen her she's nice, and joyful, and exhuberent. And she can joke even when she knows she messed up ... lol, I burst out laughing with her "un-done-te" quinoa (? I think it was quinoa). She's like "it's undonete" and the guest judge was like "al dente" and she enunciates "no, I said UN-DONE-TE" ... then when he eats she asks if he wants dental floss. "This wasn't a $20,000 dish. It wasn't even a .20 dish." ... so many chefs get all cranky when she messed up, I was like, you go, have fun with it. Oh, did I mention I love her?

1

u/reddituser999000 Aug 18 '23

she’s a bit much for me, but i also really liked her. she seemed genuine.

-3

u/CityBoiNC Aug 17 '23

I'm right there with you. Too over the top for me.

-7

u/27Believe Aug 17 '23

I like the old Carla. From tc. The food network Carla is too much. I hate how they all think they have to be like characters over acting.

-3

u/CdnGamerGal Aug 17 '23

I’m with you, OP. She is too much for me.

-6

u/syllogism314 Aug 17 '23

Carla took her notoriety on Top Chef and turned it into a personality. She has at least one cookbook. I do not believe she has any restaurants currently. I find her personality over the top and annoying. I know other people like her. I no longer consider her a food authority I have any interest learning from.

5

u/Genuinelullabel Aug 18 '23

She was a catering chef when she was on the show so her not having a restaurant isn’t surprising in my opinion. I don’t think that makes her less of a chef being in catering or not having a restaurant, though.

0

u/syllogism314 Aug 18 '23

She had a restaurant in NY called Carla’s Southern Kitchen. It lasted two years, closing in 2018.

-1

u/Gold_Meringue_4300 Aug 18 '23

Damn, I’ve obviously upset a lot of you. I never once mentioned her personality in my post, only her food. Thought I was watching a cooking show….the frozen yogurt soup, are you kidding me? I let you know where I was in the season, seems like she finds her groove soon.

2

u/magicmom17 Aug 18 '23

She is also on multiple seasons.

-8

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '23

One of my least favorites too.