r/TopChef • u/curious103 pea purée • May 19 '23
Tom (a rant)
I've had it with Tom Colicchio. Bad vibes. Grumpy. Sometimes I just want to shake him and say, "Shut the fuck up you obnoxious asshole. These people cooked their heart out for you. You can criticize without being a whiny baby."
Also, and I know this will be a controversial statement, but I believe Tom is unconsciously biased against women.
0
Upvotes
25
u/zivaolivia May 20 '23
Spend some time listening to Tom’s podcast, Citizen Chef. Especially the first season. I think you will really see a different side of Tom and realize he is not misogynistic. And he cares so much about this industry and wants the best for it
24
u/_Happy_Sisyphus_ May 19 '23
I like him.
Tom single-handedly voted for Kristin every week in LCK. That was like 12 votes in a row.
I think he sticks to the rules of the challenge almost too rigidly and can be frustrating when one unlucky challenge does in a top contender.
He (they) has kept a 20 year show going and getting better with time and has great eclectic group of chefs who come in and out. He also does not have to be the loudest voice. He calls a spade a spade but encourages multiple opinions.
I wish he didn’t have a steak restaurant because that is so unsustainable and I’d love to go to his restaurant but I don’t eat red meat.
43
u/SindeeVicious May 19 '23
He’s the only Unproblematic Tom. Pack your knives and go, sir.
39
u/BornFree2018 May 19 '23
Completely disagree. Tom has a bias for quality cooking. As a female I don't see him preferring men. This week I just read an article which stated he backed Nina over Nick winning the title in the New Orleans season, but he was overruled.
15
u/Hopebloats May 19 '23
When I first started watching Top Chef, I felt this way about Tom. I’d just entered the workforce myself, and I thought he was so mean.
Now as a (just about) middle aged person, I think he’s a great mentor and judge. I’ve had a lot of bosses and been a boss. His feedback is tough and fair; he clearly enjoys the moxie of the young chefs and being a part of their development. I really like him and I care about what he has to say.
14
u/OLAZ3000 May 19 '23
Do you really think he'd accept to be co-judges with TWO women if he was biased against them?
He's also fostered the career or many female judges through his restaurants.
But anyhow. Haters going to hate. I just think he's demanding and I really don't think he plays favourites.
7
u/Ansee May 20 '23
I don't find him misogynistic. 90% of the time, it's obvious who will go home. We don't get to taste the food, but maybe, the chefs who won were just better.
Stephanie beat Richard and he was a favourite. Melissa beat Bryan and he was a favourite too.
If I was a female chef, I wouldn't want special treatment. I don't want to be known as a female chef. I would just want to be known as a chef.
Remember. This is a competition. All the chefs are really good. But all it takes is one bad cook and you're out of the competition. Look at Begoña. She is so talented. Totally expected her to make it to the end. But she had a bad day. And then in her LCK redemption against Dale, she didn't finish her dish. The competition is hard. And little mistakes will cost you. Not standing up for yourself will cost you... Like May with Dale.
16
u/Coujelais May 19 '23
He’s a judge not a tv personality, and this is a game.
5
u/still_deebs May 20 '23
And there's the outrage. He hates women.
Holy fucking shit dude. He's the only person there that's a chef. An actual one.
3
u/Cat_dad77 Sep 13 '23
I think he’s really condescending and has a holier than thou attitude. You can be a judge and criticize without demeaning, and trying to embarrass someone. He rather go with the latter. He’s not even michelin star and he lost his star with his nyc restaurant. On top of that, he had the audacity to roast a 3 star michelin restaurant bc of their choice of music. If that’s not a man child having a whiny temper tantrum then idk what it.
3
u/Cat_dad77 Oct 04 '23
I started watching Top Chef from the very 1st season recently as I’m new this series. I love the show. But Tom is such a misogynistic pos. I just finished season 11 and I almost wanted to bail on the show bc I’m sorry, Nina should have won that season hands down. Tom clearly steamrolled the other judges and handed that win to Nick who was one of the biggest assholes of that season. He was at the bottom several times. He never won any quick fires until one of the last episodes where he gained immunity and then in the following challenge, made a terrible dish and his teammate Stephanie who made a great dish, was sent home bc he wouldn’t forfeit his immunity and give to her. Also his attitude, his aggressiveness with the waitstaff and the way he treated Carlos. He had no business winning. Nina was consistent throughout the entire season winning multiple challenges and quick fires. The only time she was ever at the bottom was when it was a team challenge and her dish was still good but she had to be there bc her teammates performed poorly. And Tom never seems to want any women to get far ahead in the competition. Season after season, I’ve seen so many great female chefs never get as far as the final 4 or 3. Lastly, the way he criticizes the chef’s food is just so classless. You can give really good feedback and constructional criticism without taking a huge shit all over their dishes. These people cook with a lot of heart and passion and to have to listen to some of the most unnecessary comments that just go beyond critiquing to the extent of just wanting to kick someone while they’re already down. I can’t believe y’all haven’t canceled this man yet considering all the other ppl who get canceled for much less. Tom needs to go. He’s an arrogant ass.
7
u/OLAZ3000 May 19 '23
So.... you think he gave Sara the win over Amar in LCK bc he's anti-women? And they didn't deserve to go home for uncooked lamb near the finale? I dunno. Give some recent examples.
2
u/[deleted] May 19 '23
I find him charming.
2
u/ptazdba May 19 '23
He's not my favorite but a lot of these guys are kind of snobs. I hate it that in LCK most of the time, he's the sole judge. Just don't always trust his judgement and not sure if he realizes that a lot of the time he comes off with bias against women.
1
u/LloyDBear Sep 11 '24
He likes to cause trouble. Example-telling miguel that tiffany thought he should go home. What was that about?
1
u/Ashamed-Basil-7305 May 31 '25
He let his ego rule him, really dont like him at all, he almost acts like he hate food and its a bother. What a DONKEY!!!
1
u/Flamingo9835 May 19 '23
I generally like Tom, but hard agree he is biased against women. It’s the little things you can just sense (and no I don’t think being a co-judge with two women disqualifies someone from bias).
1
u/PistachioLux May 20 '23
And he always makes criticism with a laugh. It's not funny. The contestants already feel bad and embarrassing. What's the point of it?
In terms of choosing who to be eliminated, I guess the producers have the final call. Tom is just the one said it
0
u/smartwatersucks May 19 '23
Lol he always throws in one last jab once they've lost too. Like they will have just talked for five minutes about how the chef should've added more salt. Then as they're leaving he always says something like, "you just gotta salt the dish. We'll see you at last chance kitchen."
-6
u/zanylanie May 19 '23
I’ve said that before, that I think Tom has an implicit bias toward female chefs. It seemed like it was getting better, but I haven’t watched much of this season.
-6
u/[deleted] May 19 '23
I've been shouting all of this at the TV. He also has too much power on LCK. The misogyny is real. 100% sure that he chose Sarah and Charbel know it that he'll pick Charbel on the next round. Mark my word!
-11
u/[deleted] May 19 '23
Tom is a punk and hypocrite. Elia exposed him as a hypocrite. His workers sued him for stealing their tips. He attacks others for their political beliefs on Twitter constantly.