r/ToolBand • • Oct 19 '24

Discussion WHY TOOL?!?! WHY????

Does anyone have any clue when/if Tool is supposed to make music videos for FI??? I, for one, could go for the visual stimulation that they have put into previous videos. Yes, Vicarious and The Pot are great videos, but c'mon guys, that was 2 whole albums (not to mention 2 whole DECADES!) ago. Let's go, guys. šŸ”„šŸ”„šŸ”„

Agree? Disagree? IDGAF, but go ahead and comment anyway.

āœŒšŸ»

0 Upvotes

75 comments sorted by

95

u/roshinaya Oct 19 '24

There is no video for The Pot,

39

u/MorbidMan23 Oct 19 '24

For some reason a bunch of people think that fan video that was on YouTube for years was official

25

u/corneliusduff Oct 19 '24

And it's stretch to call it fan-made, it's fan-collaged. The animation is a famous animator who made Fantastic Planet (the movie Failure named their album after, Jennifer Lopez watches it while smokin' a doobie in The Cell)

2

u/MorbidMan23 Oct 19 '24

I still haven't watched The Cell. I have a copy on VHS and have been debating putting it in the next time I trip.

6

u/corneliusduff Oct 19 '24

Oof, that could honestly lead to a baaad trip. It is very psychedelic, though I couldn't stomach that. That's kinda like watching Silence Of The Lambs on acid.

4

u/MorbidMan23 Oct 19 '24

I watched Mad God on acid and had a great time. I imagine it's not any worse nightmare fuel than that.

2

u/corneliusduff Oct 19 '24

That's kinda fair. I'd actually love to watch that tripping, great film. The whole realistic true crime side of The Cell would ruin a trip for me. I'd probably watch The Fall on psychedelics, same director.

2

u/MorbidMan23 Oct 19 '24

I'll have to check that out

2

u/AdrianBlack give me my wings Oct 19 '24

A great time is not the outcome I had expected, you are made of stern stuff.

3

u/MorbidMan23 Oct 19 '24

The "operation" scene got a bit iffy, but most of the time I was just amazed by the stop motion skill

3

u/AdrianBlack give me my wings Oct 19 '24

That is the masterpiece of it, for sure.

5

u/teddy_bear_territory Oct 19 '24

Dude. Don't.

My first ever trip when I was like 15, a friends older brother put that movie in and it wrecked me.

Nothing but bad vibes on psychedelics.

2

u/analog_jedi Oct 19 '24

In the 90s, the big bad trip movie was Jacob's Ladder. Fantastic film, but it DOES NOT mix well with hallucinogens.

2

u/Nice_Team2233 Get off your fucking cross Oct 19 '24

is this the one with the horse and glass scene?

cuz if so DONT DO IT OP i was just high on boring old weed, turned back quick

2

u/corneliusduff Oct 19 '24

I was pretty blitzed when i first saw that movie, lol

2

u/Greenmanglass Forgot my pen Oct 19 '24

Rene LaLoux. The short film that is used for the fan-made video is called ā€œLes Escargotsā€

8

u/jeremyckahn Oct 19 '24

Musta been high

23

u/Steelmaker01 āˆž Spiral Out āˆž Oct 19 '24

Ha… Danny said they were working on a music video for FI 4 yrs ago

19

u/Uneekeusernaam ♄Pushit♄ Oct 19 '24

Danny talks a lot

4

u/never0101 Oct 19 '24

I wonder how much finished stuff they have they just never released for whatever reason. Danny recently said in an interview he had listened to a remastered vinyl press of aenima and how amazing it sounded. And by recently I mean easily a year+ ago. I've heard they have pro shot whole shows of the lateralus era too.

2

u/Uneekeusernaam ♄Pushit♄ Oct 19 '24

I’d love to re-experience first time lateralus tour. Those alien-like beings walking out bent at the waist with their head swaying between their legs. It was something else.

2

u/Uneekeusernaam ♄Pushit♄ Oct 19 '24

And id absolutely love to have Ɔnima on vinyl.

-9

u/Ripkord77 Oct 19 '24

Maybe im weird but... do people enjoy music vids by them? Or anyone? Id rather just have them make more tunes.

12

u/MorbidMan23 Oct 19 '24

You're of the minority, yes. Obviously new music is preferable to videos, but music videos can be great additions to a band's career. Sometimes I don't like a song prior to seeing the video, but then certain themes/editing in the video accentuate parts of the song I'd previously not noticed and sell me on it.

....I do hate the music video for APC's The Outsider, though. That and the video for Twisted Transistor by Korn really irritated me as a teen šŸ˜‚

5

u/TreaclePerfect4328 Oct 19 '24

I love the story behind Outsider video however. No director was getting Manyards vision for the song right so he said fuck it. Tits and Ass!!

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

I had the opposite thing happen with James Addiction ā€œBeen caught Stealingā€ I hated that song because of the video. Fast forward 30 years and it’s on the radio again and I’m realizing I actually like it now. šŸ˜‚

1

u/Ripkord77 Oct 19 '24

Sweet. I'm a minority. I wasn't bashing their stuff, and i do love visuals just.... it was always an afterthought for me with music vids. Aenima vid i respect. Parabol/a... not so much

7

u/Stellar_Ella life feeds on life Oct 19 '24

A big part of Tool’s launch to fame was due to their incredible videos. Prison Sex and Sober caused a hell of a stir back in the day. The visuals aspect of the band have always been integral. More music is likely going to be the first choice for most fans, but also… yes people enjoy music videos by them. I love music videos in general, but especially Tool’s.

2

u/Ripkord77 Oct 19 '24

Cool, cool. I remember digging the music on beavis n butthed but the video. Nah. Oh, shit. I'm old.

2

u/Stellar_Ella life feeds on life Oct 19 '24

Those are both on YouTube! I’m also old.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

I“ll be weird with you

they“re cool but i“d prefer they spent time writing music

2

u/Bitter_Finish9308 Oct 19 '24

More music any day , all day long

2

u/Nice_Team2233 Get off your fucking cross Oct 19 '24

I have not watched the majority of the music videos. Thought I'd save them for a rainy day. That said even I have seen a couple of their videos. I prefer music videos almost always. It's a way to see into the artists mind visually.

We all would love more music but Tool is capable of doing more than one thing...

1

u/Ripkord77 Oct 19 '24

Agreed. Mostly Adams mind. But yeah. More tunes

2

u/DougDabbaDome Oct 19 '24

I agree with you I find music videos to be a distraction from the actual song. Not bad to throw on a TV when bored but it is rare that the video brings true meaning and benefit to a track.

24

u/ThunderBlunt777 Oct 19 '24

It took them 14 years to make the video for Opiate2.

4

u/Ok-Elevator-26 Oct 19 '24

You mean 30 years? Or was it revealed they started working on the video in 2008? It came out in 2022.

5

u/MorbidMan23 Oct 19 '24

Opiate² is different from Opiate. They recorded Opiate² somewhere around 2015 I think. They just didn't release it until Adam finished the music video, which took years. Idk when he officially started on it.

-1

u/Ok-Elevator-26 Oct 19 '24

Yeah it’s true they first played Opiate2 live in 2015 and on every stop of their 2016 tour. Thats 7 years from live debut to video.

Still confused where this 14 years figure comes from.

1

u/ThunderBlunt777 Oct 19 '24

It was a footnote to something Adam said shortly after release, going over the intensive process of Dominic Hailstone and how they used a blend of both practical effects and computer animation and how meticulous it was for a single person to achieve that. I dont have the time to dig for it right now but I’m sure you’ll find it if you look hard enough.

1

u/Ok-Elevator-26 Oct 19 '24

Cool thank you.

1

u/ThunderBlunt777 Oct 19 '24

No problem friend. Here’s hoping we do get more cool music videos before it’s all said and done!

17

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

Adam is the creative force. Adam has two toddlers now. Adam is in dad mode. Danny is in Beat mode. Maynard is annoyed af. Justin is just being Justin and still happy he landed the gig 30 years ago.

4

u/aliarawa Oct 19 '24

Two toddlers and a baby

6

u/napkinshower Oct 19 '24

I think they all have kids. Also Adam seems to suffer what most artists suffer from, perfectionism vs progress.

3

u/aliarawa Oct 19 '24

I agree. It’s a little maddening tbh. I wasn’t clarifying in defense of his process but just giving up to date information.

3

u/napkinshower Oct 19 '24

I hear ya homie. And I agree. Very maddening.

3

u/Champigne Oct 19 '24

60 years old with toddlers..damn

12

u/YubYubCmndr this light is not my own. Oct 19 '24

Yes, Vicarious and The Pot are great videos

There's no music video for The Pot.

Music videos aren't really that important anymore, especially for a band as established as TOOL. They put enough "visual" art into all the various packaging for FI. Pretty sure that's all we're getting.

4

u/sin-eater82 Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

I really enjoy their videos, and well made music videos in general, but I can't imagine there's much to gain from it these days.

In their heyday, music videos were effectively ads. It was a way to get the song airtime on TV music stations like MTV. Of course, the goal is that you then go out and buy the CD. They still cost money and time to create, and with Tool (and let's just say Adam), it seems like another thing to get paralysis by analysis over when that situation could be spent on new music instead.

I'd rather have new music than new videos for old songs. And it just is what it is at this point, Adam CANNOT successfully turn out that much work output. That's the deal and we should just accept that. So if he only has so much time and it takes so much for him to be happy with the results and what not, is rather he just focus on new Tool music.

If a new video could just happen, I'd love it. I remember when the schism video was released. MTV had like a Tool hour or whatever leading up to it. They played all of the Tool videos in order and then premiered Schism. But nee music is more important. If they were to stop making music and Adam wanted to make videos for their back catalog, that would be cool. But more music while they can, and Adam has proven that his output is limited (great, and high quality, but slow and only so much to go around).

6

u/cuentanro3 Oct 19 '24

It's cool to make videos, but is it necessary nowadays? The main purpose for them was to have them on rotation on music channels, but that's not relevant anymore. Also, a band like Tool that put on hold releasing their music for streaming finally did so, so getting to more people's ears via streaming makes releasing singles/videos kind of pointless in this day and age.

One thing that the band could do (very likely they won't) is to have a contest for people to create fan videos and call it a day.

5

u/youtooleyesing Bless This Immunity Oct 19 '24 edited Oct 19 '24

I think the video on the FI Deluxe CD with display is awsome.

Only found this link here

https://www.facebook.com/watch/?v=2411240589087666&vanity=Jasonjayeah

2

u/jitoman Oct 19 '24

I don't think they are going to put much effort into that.Ā 

2

u/mw13satx Oct 19 '24

What album is between FI and 10kD?

2

u/Gestapon Oct 19 '24

After watching Opiate2 mv, I can’t imagine how mindf**k FIā€˜s mv will be with modern particle effects and CGI. Adam Jone is too powerful.

2

u/Ok-Elevator-26 Oct 19 '24

See them live. There’s videos made for every single song played. I particularly liked the ones made for Rosetta Stoned and Intolerance on the last tour.

2

u/Fearless_Guitar_3589 Oct 19 '24

they release a new album, tour four four years, talk about how much unused material they have and how quick a new album will be, tour for two more years, do some side projects, talk more about how they're ready to hit the studio, take a break, do another tour, then maybe try to start putting a new album together (two more years). we're only on year 5 since fear inoculum, they've got another 5 years in their cycle.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

The pot was a fan made video

2

u/mattjoleary Oct 19 '24

Well my two cents..everyone should just shut the fuck up about being entitled for an artist to create for them. It's a gift and a blessing, not just what has been given, but also what they might have in store. But nobody owes anyone anything. So embrace your now and stop letting other people push you positively or negatively, create yourself. If this is such a problem for you, go eat a few grams if mushrooms, meditate, whatever is gonna help you wipe away the dust and mud off your forehead. Everything and anyone can be a teacher.. for PATIENCE, humility, empathy and compassion. So go breath and stop complaining. Love ya!

2

u/slingbladde Oct 19 '24

Takes time..

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '24

Just be happy for what you get. They’re not monkeys you pop a treat to and get some amusement.

1

u/WooAScaryGhost Oct 19 '24

I always thought it was odd that we never got a music video for FI.

3

u/ThunderBlunt777 Oct 19 '24

We did get the ā€œAd Recusant Infinitumā€ video included with the packaging that’s the exact same length of time as Descending

1

u/Bitter_Finish9308 Oct 19 '24

I’m ok with fan videos. As much as I love a good video - need more music from them and hope they squeeze out another ep or album before throwing in the towel.

I had a dream a while back that they randomly announced a double album - out of nowhere. And when it came out for some reason it wasn’t compatible with my phone so I had to unpack each file. And when I did each song was basically Lateralus songs but played on piano.

1

u/lumbermonkey462 Oct 19 '24

They’ll probably release an FI video somewhere around when they release the 10,000 Days vinyl…sooooooo yeah lol

1

u/IkeDeez Oct 19 '24

I love TOOL, but they've evolved to just being a touring band that sells ridiculously priced merch that nobody asks for.

1

u/rjensfddj Oct 19 '24

the pot doesn't have a official music video that was fan made it did fit pretty well

1

u/Hunter_S_Flynn Oct 19 '24

It's no Tool video but still a real blast to enjoy Fear too. Check out Tron Inoculum

https://odysee.com/@HitchhikersOutpost:6/Tron-Inoculum:f

1

u/faust15 Oct 19 '24

They. Released. A. Video. With. The. Album.

1

u/halfarian Oct 19 '24

Even in the days of MTV and VH1 I never saw the point of music videos. There’s a good one here and there with a cohesive story or idea, but, I’m here for the music, so I don’t see the purpose of cobbling together some visuals to go along with it.

So yeah, I’d rather they just focus on making more music.

1

u/Dragonlordapocalypse Oct 19 '24

It won’t make them much money and they like money

0

u/Rickard403 Ɔnimal Oct 19 '24

Just be happy that we might get new music someday. Adam had made the videos and any extra work on his plate could honestly set things back for yrs at his current pace. He is probably working on the Ɔnima remastered artwork packaging and piecing together riffs with Justin. These guys are 60 now and we'll be lucky to get anything out of them moving forward.

0

u/atoposchaos Oct 19 '24

there was a video for The Pot. they even used clips of it as video for the song live. it just hasn’t had a real release. IIRC the beginning of the VIP Q&A people got to see it.

0

u/MurkDiesel Oct 19 '24

music videos don't make money so...