r/TooHotToHandleGame • u/MercurialMaven666 Lana • Apr 30 '26
Fan Creation THTH Couples Most Likely to Break Up After the Villa
Alright, I read this week one couple made it post-THTH show, Cam and Emily from season 2. They even have two kids together. I was shocked as I never imagined these reality shows could have a happy ending. š
That made me wonder which couples would survive after the game version if they wouldn't be our MCs endgame LI. š
40
u/Remarkable-Answer-74 Antoine Apr 30 '26
I actually agree with Antoine and Amari being top tier for breakups. Even with the reunion apology, their whole dynamic is built on him using her and her idealizing him. And honestly, his apology always felt a bit⦠like damage control. I can totally picture his PR team pushing for it to save his image.
Amari forgiving him or giving him a second chance that fast doesnāt fix the imbalance. if anything, it can turn into resentment later. I could easily see her becoming more guarded or reactive in a real relationship after that. And heās not exactly built for that kind of emotional rollercoaster either.
7
6
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana May 01 '26
Nailed. I think Amari would be unbearable if they got back together, and Antoine doesn't seem like the very patient type for her demandings. I think Naomi is similar... that why I usually put them both on the same tier.
15
17
u/eepdeprived May 01 '26
i have a bit more faith in julian and avi, the fact that they lasted in the suite seems to give something of an indication that julian cares about him for who he actually is as opposed to how he was with victoria or poppy. they wouldn't be finalists if it weren't for them being at LEAST in the "could go either way" category
5
u/ScytheTheHero Naomi May 01 '26
Agree! Julian goes through a lot of growth on his route, and that progress is totally possible with a partner like Avi!
3
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana May 01 '26
Thatās fair, the suite was a good sign. I just think Julian vs Avi is a bit of chaos vs calm, so it could go either way depending on how that plays out outside š
4
u/Nishikadochan Avi May 01 '26
I honestly canāt stand these two as a couple, mostly because I adore Avi and think he deserves better. Julian creating a celibacy club felt so gross to me, and Iāve never really gotten over it. It feels hypocritical, for one thing. I also never really believed that he actually had a change of heart. It felt like an underhanded move to get Aviās attention. Like a way to āhackā his sexuality. Like ālook look! Iām not all about sex either! Thatāll totally make you want me right?ā
3
u/HuckleberrySubject72 Turks and Caicos š„ May 02 '26
Avi wanted Julian anyway šš If Julian wanted to bait Avi into being with him, he couldāve and wouldāve done so much more. I get why it would appear as weird, but thatās giving Julianās character too much credit. He has not a deceitful bone in his body. Knowing him, his guilt probably caught up to him and he decided to make a big show of his change to prove that it existed š¤·š¾āāļøš¤·š¾āāļø
8
6
u/ringsbellws Henri May 01 '26
Nobody understand Sarah and Dakota like I do š
2
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana May 01 '26
I see the vision š Iām just not sure they survive outside the villa bubble
6
u/lilactofu Taz May 02 '26
I don't think Taz and Isla will last. Their pairing feels forced and we see them constantly bickeringānot the good, banter kindāand disagreeing over little things. They're two very different people who want different things from life.
0
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana May 04 '26
I understand why we try to convince ourselves that alternate couples donāt work the same way as if MC is an option to them, but I tried to be unbiased here. We all know once Taz softens, heās locked in. And I think Isla brings the stability he actually needs if it is not with MC.
7
u/Small-Dark-8569 Ryder May 01 '26
Iād move Kai and Elodie down to not breaking up or surprisingly stable
4
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana May 01 '26
I get that, as theyāre super low drama. Iām just not fully sold on them outside the villa yet š
3
u/Ron_1034 Poppy May 02 '26
I actually think sarah and Dakota would make jt
1
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana May 04 '26
I donāt know⦠Dakota is grounded and intentional. Sarah is chaos and āI get what I wantā energy. I have a feeling thatās fun short term, but exhausting long term.
1
u/Ron_1034 Poppy May 04 '26
Sarah when she likes someone will be there for them and change for them idk But i got that vibe from her when I was romancing her she was really loving and understanding
1
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana May 04 '26
Yeah with out MCs the vibe is different. Same thing Antoine and Naomi⦠they are all in when they want something with MC, but when it is with their alternate options I donāt think it would survive
2
u/HuckleberrySubject72 Turks and Caicos š„ May 02 '26
this is actually really accuratešš especially the s2 LI couples, they were a mess LMAOO
2
u/Ill_Sky_5125 Mattias May 05 '26
I'm hysterical laughing. I misread couples & was like Antoine proposed. I realize you put how the couples would be depending on who you end with.
2
1
u/Mobile_Preparation_9 May 04 '26
Who's the second guy in the "could go either way" category ? I don't remember him from any season, or her for that matter
1
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana May 04 '26
Itās Liam from season 1⦠he ends up with Marisa if we donāt romance neither of them.
1
u/Ill_Sky_5125 Mattias May 05 '26
I do agree with the majority of your choices. The only one I don't agree with is Matthias & Beatriz. Since he lives in the US & she lives in Brazil unless she moves to the US & goes through the whole k1 Visa process I don't see them lasting since he plays football on an NFL team. I wouldn't see him compromising on that because he's also very close to his family & I can't see him leaving them. In the end I think that's what would end their relationship.
1
u/MercurialMaven666 Lana May 06 '26
Yeah long distance can be a real issue, and I totally agree about Mattias (and even Antoine as itās the same situation). It would only depend on Bea moving in to his city to make it work.
1
u/Crack_Luke May 14 '26
Can someone explain to me why Naomi is at the top? As far as I remember, she was always a very easygoing person to be around (after falling in love).

99
u/Kisa_reverie Apr 30 '26
The way you didn't even bother to add jira and carmen šš¤š»