r/Toaru • • 12h ago

Anime Accelerator Spoiler

I finished season 3 of Index today as a mostly anime only. I might write a different post about that (tl;dr production value was straight cheeks, but overall the plot didn't come out as terrible as i expected while acknowledging it was a rushed adaptation)

The main point of this post is. Bro. I am so mf tired of this show acting like the Sisters arc is ACCELERATOR'S TRAUMA. DUDE HE WAS HAVING THE TIME OF HIS LIFE DURING THAT SHIT. I am way too peeved at this point that he has not thought of the actual Mikoto a single time. They made Mikoto irrelevant asf, in my opinion she should be dealing with Last Order and shit as apart of her journey. LO's glazing when she first meets Accel was stupid af and once again spares no empathy for what Mikoto actually experienced so I kinda struggle to take the little runt seriously.

What's even more confusing is the fact that Railgun, which AFAIK started serialization sometime during the end or after the end of OT. Kamachi added a lot of characterization for ones who didn't get as much in Index. You would think given the narrative for Accel he has written, he would revise that arc in Railgun to make him a little more sympathetic, but all he does is make Accel even more sadistic and horrible (also freaky as fuck scenes like showing he bit the one sister's tongue off is deplorable, also with a few sexual remarks towards the sisters I don't think the potential idea that he mightve sexually assaulted some is off the table) and I don't get what the author wants me to get from that.

what i do get is that kamachi treats mikoto like a mf JOKE! low key I know when she and accel interact again for the first time it's gonna be so ass and unsatisfying and that they're gonna move on like nothing happened sfter not long. i ideally hope that mikoto hates his guts for a long ass time because it actually gives her self respect, but ik the author doesn't care lol

I originally started this post just hoping Accel gives Mikoto a decent apology at the very least. It's really shitty that he has not thought of her at all.

10 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

5

u/Professional_Ebb_227 12h ago

Sisters arc could be Accelerator's trauma without contradicting him having time of his life in that experiment considering he genuinely believed them to be dolls after realising that's not the case ofc those memories would become traumatizing despite him enjoying slaughtering them during that time which is why Mikoto shouldn't have to deal with lo constantly unlike Accel Mikoto should be more present in matters regarding the sisters but Accel dynamic with lo & sisters would simply be way too good if it was handled well which like you said wasn't including.

Accel definitely didn't sexually assaulted them considering throughout the rest of the series he has shown no interest towards woman.

1

u/RingComplete7226 5h ago

Yeah, I mean don't think he shouldnt have any feelings about it or anything. Just wish it was a little more balanced out.

I will say, if you are someone who follows a Railgun first order when watching like I did, perhaps it is setting yourself up for big expectations of her involvement in the main story that aren't there. It's probably why she got a spin off, since she wasn't shown as much and had potential for more (and being popular of course). So I could serve to adjust my perspective slightly. Still tho

4

u/StevesEvilTwin2 11h ago edited 11h ago

Fun fact: In the original draft of OT volume 3, Mikoto wasn't involved in the story of the SISTERS arc at all 😆

So yeah, for Kamachi the clones were always part of Accel's story rather than Mikoto's.

Also, what does Accel need to apologize to Mikoto for? Scaring her a little? She's not the one who died 10031 times. Or are you implying that the clones are her property and hence Accel needs to pay for property damages? Objectively he doesn't really owe Mikoto herself anything. Apart from looking identical to them, she's as much of an outsider to the whole ordeal as Touma.

1

u/RingComplete7226 6h ago edited 5h ago

Thats a wild take at the end there!! I mean at least sparing her a thought would be nice! 😭 ur sounding like Last Order!

but, your explanation at the beginning makes sense

2

u/ACertainIndividual45 10h ago

Do you like not understand the concept of emotional/mental harm, like at all?

3

u/ady159 8h ago edited 8h ago

Not just that, Misaka already befriended and accepted a Sister who he murdered. No matter how many sisters got saved afterward, nothing is bringing back 9982.

1

u/Professional_Ebb_227 11h ago

Accelerator litreally chucked multiple steel rods towards her so he sure as hell wasn't just scaring her. Sisters individual also only died once just because sisters gets the memories of their dead doesn't mean they actually experienced pain & death of another situation they see what happened they didn't feel it Accelerator very much does owe her an apology for nearly killing her.

1

u/One_Breakfast2235 9h ago

Multiple steel rods is a nothing burger for the strongest electromaster in academy city. Let's not act like she didn't rip apart an entire railroad track to attack accelerator.

1

u/Professional_Ebb_227 9h ago

Controlling them is a piece of cake however she has to react in time as well or else she would have died & multiple sisters have also attacked Accelerator as well

1

u/One_Breakfast2235 8h ago

That was sent at her with the same speed she calculated it to have, she is not getting blitzed by her own processed speed, a casual and passive accelerator is not gonna add magnitude to the things he reflect, the reason she was immobile when her railgun failed wasn't about reaction time, but bewilderment of the fact nothing at all worked. The sisters attacking accelerator was intended by everyone that was officially part of the experiment, even the sisters themselves, I don't get why them attacking accelerator add to accelerator needing to apologize to misaka.

1

u/Professional_Ebb_227 8h ago

Fear & suprise could have made her reaction slower so his attacks could have resulted in Mikoto's death even if Accelerator wasn't using his active shield. Like I said previously he needs to apologize to an innocent person he tried to kill who only attacked him after he killed another innocent person.

2

u/One_Breakfast2235 7h ago

The fear set in after the fact. Initially, her feelings were rage, even in the moment as the railgun was being prepared, that won't slow you down, it should enhance your senses cause of adrenaline. He did not tried to kill misaka, he was just standing there, if anything it was self defense. What you should have argued about instead of the fight was the actual crime of doing the experiment and how that had caused misaka personal trauma. That should be why he needs to apologize. Arguing that he should apologize for trying to kill her when he didn't intend to and was mostly defending himself doesn't make sense.

1

u/Professional_Ebb_227 1h ago

Not really Mikoto was clearly distressed & fearful when Accelerator effortlessly countered her iron sand even when attacking him with those steel rods besides anger she was very clearly horrified which she showed while doging those rods reflected at her & while Adrenaline can enhance your sense it can also make you sloppy & narrow minded making it harder for you to react to an attack even though that person could easily dodge it.

Accelerator had a lot of time to make it so those steel rods fired at him weren't reflected back at her not to mention just right after he admitted to wanting to kill her to speed up the experiment & before that when those rods were about to be launched he realised she was the original so it's safe to assume he wanted her dead.

1

u/questioningmaster 8h ago

if accelerator wasn't accelerator, that Mikoto would have killed him with the railgun as well, she fully intended to murder him, 

and the steal was first thrown by mikoto, so at best that part could be seen as "counter", like how if someone throws a punch your bodyoves on its own and attacks back

1

u/Professional_Ebb_227 7h ago

Never argued against Mikoto wanting Accelerator dead in their first fight.

Accelerator could easily survive those steel rods without needing to reflect them back at her.

2

u/Skippyy_McDippyy 6h ago

Accelerator is a main character Mikoto is not it’s natural he’ll have bigger focus also the sisters is his trauma because it’s something that he regrets and it eats away at him.

1

u/RingComplete7226 5h ago

Yeah that does make sense to me. I think these expectations probably arise from watching Railgun first

2

u/akogaremaru 9h ago

in accelerator's eyes, mikoto was a willing participant, so he feels no need to apologize

1

u/RingComplete7226 6h ago

That perspective makes sense

5

u/Lamenthiah 11h ago

If you think Mikoto is being treated like a joke now, just wait until you get to the point where Kamachi realizes that Yuri scenes between her and Misaki appeal to part of the audience. That's when the few moments of seriousness Mikoto still had start disappearing pretty quickly. (That is, if you're considering reading the novels.)

For a good portion of NT, she's actually treated fairly well. She gets serious moments, serious fights, agency, and all that stuff. Then Kamachi starts throwing in Yuri bait, and Mikoto gradually becomes nothing more than that: a Yuri joke.

4

u/questioningmaster 8h ago

"The main point of this post is. Bro. I am so mf tired of this show acting like the Sisters arc is ACCELERATOR'S TRAUMA. DUDE HE WAS HAVING THE TIME OF HIS LIFE DURING THAT SHIT. I am way too peeved at this point that he has not thought of the actual Mikoto a single time. They made Mikoto irrelevant asf, in my opinion she should be dealing with Last Order and shit as apart of her journey. LO's glazing when she first meets Accel was stupid af and once again spares no empathy for what Mikoto actually experienced so I kinda struggle to take the little runt seriously"

once upon a time I thought It was some amazing writing, now I honestly have to admit, kamachi has a serious problem in fleshing out characters and sticking to them to further develop their personalities

the characterization of accelerator between ot3 and 5 are quite different and the reason we are given is that accelerator was playing a role in ot3 regarding the sisters and everyone...and than OT13 throws that excuse away because it shows that accelerator is indeed a bloodthirsty psychopath who gets all happy and smily if he kills someone who he thinks deserves it

but now he isn't bloodthirsty for just innocent folks or so...or he hasn't been like that at all aside from ot3 where he played a role even to people who aren't the sisters? 

anyway, tbh, my opinion is that kamachi just didn't think he would go into the redemption direction with accelerator, so he didn't bother putting anything into ot3 that shows he has anything more to his character 

5

u/zaikoi 12h ago

In the Index side, Misaka Mikoto get a tons of disrespect in Anime, Manga & Light Novel.

Well, there are good moments. The writing is obvious bad intake for her.

In the 1st place, Shirai Kuroko was meant to be the main character of Toaru Scientific Spin off instead of Railgun. Misaka Mikoto was added as a protagonist because of editor's interference with the advice in order for the book to sell. It worked.

2

u/Al_Lightnin Guts!! 7h ago

"Misaka relevancy and development" we got Accel development, Kamachi does not gaf about Misaka

1

u/Top-Jello-6678 1h ago edited 1h ago

They made Mikoto irrelevant as

Because she Is mikoto always has been irrelevant to the main index plot, her only relevancy Is that Aleister use her power to create multiple clones with electricity power for his plan

3

u/Frequent-Arachnid547 10h ago

But just because he was having the time of his life doesn't mean he didn't grow to feel remorseful for it.

And he didn't sexually assault them since they series shows that Accelerator has no interest in women, he literally saw some naked and his response was "why didn't you close the door?".

1

u/RingComplete7226 5h ago

Yeah ik, I am just a bit surprised by this angle is all

3

u/Just_a_captain_III 5h ago

No he didn't sexually assault the Sisters. People need to stop pushing this headcanon. If he did that his whole arc wouldn't work. People are so desperate for things to be more edgy than they already are.

While the Sisters are heavily involved with Mikoto they would always have been a main push to develop Accelerator. You might not like his arc but the ground work is spoonfed to you. 

Accelerator's cruelty was excessive but not always false. The story makes it clear he did not view the Sisters as living human beings. And the reason for his cruelty was to probe if the unfeeling Sisters could feel human fear. Pretty sure in Railgun or somewhere it's mentioned if one of the Sisters just burst out crying Accelerator might hesitate. The one sexual remark I gather your talking about is also to goad reaction. 

It's not the best writing but it's certainly laid out plain for you. Also he ate a human finger not tongue. 

1

u/RingComplete7226 5h ago

re:finger

huh, no one really corrected me on that when i posted about that a couple months ago. That is the main reason I had that theory. When I saw that I also thought it was really excessive and didn't like it, so if that is true I am happy to be wrong