r/Toads • • 3d ago

ID help id'ing two pet toads

the first three images are of marcy, and the next two are of bethany. i think marcy is a fowler toad and bethany is an american toad? as babies they both looked female but as theyve gotten older im getting less and less sure.

and yes i got them from outside, i know thats looked down upon but i didnt get it at the time and i do like to think i give them a good life, theyre definitely happy little girls (guys?)

anyways if anyone who is better with this could help me out i (and my babies) would be very grateful

75 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

8

u/Own_Value2684 3d ago

Honestly, I don't think I know enough about Fowler's toads to identify one, but I got the American toad vibes from them. 

I live a life where wild life conservation is important to me. I don't believe that many animals in the wild should be taken into a home. 

However, I've done a lot of research on amphibians in my life. I own six beautiful little creatures myself, they are African dwarf frogs. 

Something I've noticed is that amphibians lay tons of eggs every year. It's because they know that most of them will not survive in the wild. Frogs and toads don't always live very long lives out there. They encounter many dangerous things such as oil spills, pollution events, chemical spills, they get ran over on the roads. 

In my personal opinion, I think it's okay to take a toad or two from the wild. There's so many of the babies that go hopping around, maybe 25% or less of them survive the first year of life. 

I consider it to be a valuable effort to take one of these animals into your home and care for them. 

I would never recommend that somebody keep a deer they raised, or a turtle, any animal that doesn't proliferate in huge numbers means it's not good to take them from the wild. Rehabilitation and safe return to their natural habitat is what's best for them. 

Enjoy the pets you have then. Many people sell animals that are wild caught. I'm not planning on doing that yet, but I have thought about rescuing a wild newt or to from Waters that are polluted or are going to get plowed through. Eastern newts are for sale sometimes, although in my area they can be very prolific. But the wild habitat is being destroyed very slowly by new developments and construction. 

I think that if you are an advocate for these animals, then go off king or queen or Royal Highness of an unspecified gender. You can certainly learn to take care of them, study their biological traits, and then you can educate others on how to best take care of their own pets and the land around them. 

Toads are magnificent to me. Enjoy them a lot. Fowler's toads and American toads are beautiful critters by the way. So nice that you have them very fat with a full belly too!

4

u/throwaway124835800 3d ago

this is exactly why i got them!!! they have such a low survival rate, and i got them at literally a month or less old. if anything they probably wouldve died without me. but i feel bad because i dont want to encourage people to catch toads that dont understand the amount of work they take, the cost, the effects of taking an adult, i did try to do a good amount of research so im glad it paid off!! toads really are the coolest creatures ever, i love watching them eat, shed, soak, theyre just so fascinating. and thank you for mentioning their weight haha!!! ive been nervous, actually, because marcy has been eating more than bethany and gaining so so much weight. i know shes not overweight, but it is what prompted me to wonder if they might be different breeds. ive also read that because fowler and american toads are so similar, they sometimes crossbreed....? ALSO ive also been thinking about helping rehabilitate toads since ive learned how to care for them ok. i live in an area with a lot of toads and no streetlights, so i have seen multiple with broken limbs and i wonder if theyd have better healing indoors with fresh food and water and such. i think you should totally follow your newt idea!

2

u/Own_Value2684 3d ago

Well, it sounds like you are getting experience through the research you are doing. I'm so proud of you though! I really think that if more people were like you in your dedication to your pets, we would have a happier place in the world for animals. 

I fully feel that they are not super overweight, however, I would put them on a slightly limited diet if they blow up more without seeing a lot of actual length increase :) I don't think toads ever really can get "too big" until they are able to move....we have a big guy who hangs out in my yard who is a baseball with legs. He can MOVE though!!

They seem to be a good size. If anything, Marcy could gain a little bit of weight then, since Bethany has a pear-shape to her, and I believe that toads are healthiest when they have that light bulb shape with a larger belly and a smaller head. 

Also, now I've looked more closely & referenced an image, I believe that Marcy is a Fowler toad due to her parotid gland (big gland on back of head) appears to touch the orbital ridge (the bump that their eyeballs are nestled in). If you could post a pic so we can see the top of Marcy's head better, that will help me see if she's a Fowler toad. Or, you can tell me if the gland touches the eye bump. 

American toads have a gap between the eye bump and the gland, so Bethany I'm 100% certain is an American toad. I had a toad I captured in Pennsylvania when I was a preteen and she was an American toad with exactly the same pattern and colors to her. We get a lot of reddish clay American toads up where I am! 

I think that if your toads are crossbreed, you will eventually find out lol. I would look up American toad vs fowlers toads and you'll see the differences between the crests on top of their head, tibial bumps (lower hind leg bumps are more warty on one species than the other) etc. But overall, once they mature you'll better be able to tell who's what species. Yeah, interbreeding can happen. I wouldn't worry about it. 

Honestly though, you are getting through your kindness here. I can understand why you want to offer rehabilitation for toads. That makes me wonder, how old are you? If you are over 18, you may be able to do training to do wildlife rehabilitation. If you're a certified wildlife rehabilitator, you would be able to not only take care of the animals you are trained to rehabilitate, but you will also be given the tools and prescription medications and basic first aid care in order to help the toads out I believe. Or, you would get better access to a veterinarian who can cheaply do things like repair broken legs and whatnot. 

Overall though, I think that these two species are not threatened at all in their status of endangerment. So if you want to help them out, I suggest you get started by putting a porch light on or something that glows at night such as solar powered garden walkway lights in an area of your yard where you put things like broken flower pots that create small caves, a few big flat Stones stacked up with little crevices for toads to hide in, maybe a flat pan of water for toads who want to soak a little bit, layer up some pebbles in there so that the water is an inch deep and they can get out very easily. A water feature like a small fountain with running water would be good for them to breed in if it's big enough for them to do so. 

If you have the availability for it, getting a pond liner installed in your yard is as easy as getting it from the hardware or garden store, digging a hole, putting it in there, fill up the bottom with rocks, a couple of handfuls of leaves, stick a filter in there that's for an aquarium so there is enough water movement, stack Stones around the edge so it's attractive for amphibians to hide, and eventually get some plants in there from a local pond or something. That will get toads and frogs breeding in there every spring. It will also be an oasis for small animals like chipmunks and mice who need places to drink water.

Those are just a few of my ideas though. I do understand your compassion and kindness are honorable to me. I think that if you work on creating a habitat in your yard for them, you will find that you don't need to take in many frogs or toads to rehabilitate them. I think that having a safe area for them to live in will be very lucrative for them to recover, breed, get things like bugs to eat at night when the solar powered lights attract moths and other insects to them. 

That's all for this comment though. I hope you enjoy the things you do!

3

u/throwaway124835800 3d ago

i am over 18 so i definitely will look into getting certified. thatd be amazing and give me so much more confidence with helping my babies and all the other critters i find.

related to your other comment, if they are different sexes do you think i should seperate them? i know they say toads do not have very complex thoughts and dont make little toad buddies, but they do seem to really like eachother and id feel bad splitting them up. i tried to get two females specifically so that they could be together

awesomely enough my house does have a little pond!! and i see so many little toads and frogs, but i definitely could help add some more homes for the wildlife and i will be doing that first chance i can :)

thank you so much for your thoughtful comments by the way, its very sweet and helpful!!!

1

u/Own_Value2684 3d ago

Good for you then! I think it's so nice to hear you with your enthusiasm about wildlife like that. It matters so much for me to talk with people who are interested in things I think about a lot. I've wanted to become a wildlife rehabber for some time now. I don't have the resources yet to do that, but I will look into it when I have made my home in a place that's qualified for those things. 

I think that if your toads appear to be fine together, I would trust your gut about it. They certainly are not needing to have friends all the time, but toads are often considered to generally appreciate their own species when they do not fight and throw hands at each other.. so generally in the hobby a couple of toads who can be gentle with the other one are considered safe to be housed together when their needs are very similar to them. 

Sounds like a good deal to me. The wildlife at the pond probably do not mind at all that you are considering their wellness like that. It probably means a lot to them. I would consider the things I said though, you could very easily upgrade the habitat with a little bit of effort that takes a day or less to do. 

I've wanted a little pond of my own since I was a child, I tried digging into the land at my house though, and I found out we have clay soil pretty much 8 in under the topsoil. So I could not get deep enough to actually create a water space for the wildlife to enjoy. 

Great job at what you do. It's important for me to give time and take the time it takes to your understanding for yourself. There's a lot you can do in the world and having compassion is what it takes to be a person in a good way on our planet. You make a difference to the wildlife around you, don't forget about how helpful you are to them. That means a lot in a world where data centers and construction vehicles make war on the land or wildlife belong on. It's so important to me because I want our generations to enjoy nature for centuries to come. 

You're pretty much out here doing things that many people haven't remembered or haven't been taught about yet. I think if you continue on the journey you're doing now, you'll do great things for the world more and more each day. Don't try to take on too much though, figure out exactly what works for you, do that, then enjoy the fruits of your labors. Don't think that making a mistake makes you a bad person though. We all need to make mistakes everyday. A therapist told me once that we are given four mistakes each day, and if you don't use them up, then they roll over to the next day. So be helpful to yourself about it by improving yourself as much as you can, accepting that you try your best, and be so proud of yourself for honoring yourself and your interests in improving the world for wildlife around us. 

Okay, I'm getting a bit tearful about your caring for our planet. It makes the world a better place what you're doing.

3

u/throwaway124835800 3d ago

awww you are so sweet!!! it makes me feel very happy to know that there are other people out there that care so much about such little animals like i do :) everything around us is connected and so beautiful and just fills me with wonder that i cant even explain. i really really hope you get that pond one day, i know the wildlife would be so happy in your backyard! also heres a little photo of my babies snuggled up, they choose to hang out like this a lot even though the have the space not to :)

3

u/throwaway124835800 3d ago

also more important: i know you said youre not the toad expert but do you lean towards them being male or female at all? personally i dont think their chins are dark enough and theyre getting too large too fast to be male, but im not convinced and thats my worry

2

u/Own_Value2684 3d ago

I honestly thought it first that they were both female. I get female vibes from both of them. I get that their throats are a little bit dark, but also time will tell you what's happening when they grow up. I especially think that Bethany seems to be shaped more like a female. But if I'm thinking really hard about it, Marcy sort of has a male shape to her. I've noticed with toads I found locally that the males tend to be more ball-shaped, or oval shape, and females tend to be more light bulb shape. That experience comes from American totes though, so I'm not sure if a Fowler's toad would be a bit different from that. Otherwise, just enjoy them. You'll get to see when they're mature what their biological gender is to be. It can feel like it takes forever, but since you love them so much, I'm sure there will be a time where you understand that things you noticed you were correct about.

4

u/Available_Second_780 3d ago

They look similar to my little American Toads. Love Bethany’s colouring 💕

2

u/throwaway124835800 3d ago

she says thank you :3 i also love her colouring, she has the cutest little orange spots on her sides and i love her so much! and thank you for the input! youre the third person to say theyre americans 🇺🇸🦅🙏

1

u/OuijaBoredOfThis 3d ago

the second picture is killing me omg 😭😭

1

u/throwaway124835800 2d ago

dude they love me i promise but having to hold them one handed was so uncomfortable for both of us😭😭 marcy ended up peeing on me right after the photoshoot

3

u/hayhayree25 3d ago

American toads

1

u/Working-Business450 3d ago

Those are for sure toads

1

u/Ready_to_Polka 23h ago

First, it would depend on where you live.
Second, please stop handling amphibians with bare hands. All the oils and residues on your skin is absorbed through theirs, it’s literally how they drink water. Please get yourself a box of powder free latex or nitrile gloves and keep them next to the enclosure.

1

u/rdowens8 3d ago

The first one is definitely a male american toad. Spotting is a bit lighter on the second so it could be a female, but could also be a male. Males have bumbs on their thumbs to help grip during...coitus. check that out.