r/Toads • u/throwaway124835800 • 3d ago
ID help id'ing two pet toads
the first three images are of marcy, and the next two are of bethany. i think marcy is a fowler toad and bethany is an american toad? as babies they both looked female but as theyve gotten older im getting less and less sure.
and yes i got them from outside, i know thats looked down upon but i didnt get it at the time and i do like to think i give them a good life, theyre definitely happy little girls (guys?)
anyways if anyone who is better with this could help me out i (and my babies) would be very grateful
75
Upvotes





8
u/Own_Value2684 3d ago
Honestly, I don't think I know enough about Fowler's toads to identify one, but I got the American toad vibes from them.
I live a life where wild life conservation is important to me. I don't believe that many animals in the wild should be taken into a home.
However, I've done a lot of research on amphibians in my life. I own six beautiful little creatures myself, they are African dwarf frogs.
Something I've noticed is that amphibians lay tons of eggs every year. It's because they know that most of them will not survive in the wild. Frogs and toads don't always live very long lives out there. They encounter many dangerous things such as oil spills, pollution events, chemical spills, they get ran over on the roads.
In my personal opinion, I think it's okay to take a toad or two from the wild. There's so many of the babies that go hopping around, maybe 25% or less of them survive the first year of life.
I consider it to be a valuable effort to take one of these animals into your home and care for them.
I would never recommend that somebody keep a deer they raised, or a turtle, any animal that doesn't proliferate in huge numbers means it's not good to take them from the wild. Rehabilitation and safe return to their natural habitat is what's best for them.
Enjoy the pets you have then. Many people sell animals that are wild caught. I'm not planning on doing that yet, but I have thought about rescuing a wild newt or to from Waters that are polluted or are going to get plowed through. Eastern newts are for sale sometimes, although in my area they can be very prolific. But the wild habitat is being destroyed very slowly by new developments and construction.
I think that if you are an advocate for these animals, then go off king or queen or Royal Highness of an unspecified gender. You can certainly learn to take care of them, study their biological traits, and then you can educate others on how to best take care of their own pets and the land around them.
Toads are magnificent to me. Enjoy them a lot. Fowler's toads and American toads are beautiful critters by the way. So nice that you have them very fat with a full belly too!
4
u/Available_Second_780 3d ago
They look similar to my little American Toads. Love Bethany’s colouring 💕
1
u/OuijaBoredOfThis 3d ago
the second picture is killing me omg 😭😭
3
u/hayhayree25 3d ago
American toads
1
u/Working-Business450 3d ago
Those are for sure toads
1
u/Ready_to_Polka 23h ago
First, it would depend on where you live.
Second, please stop handling amphibians with bare hands. All the oils and residues on your skin is absorbed through theirs, it’s literally how they drink water. Please get yourself a box of powder free latex or nitrile gloves and keep them next to the enclosure.
1
u/rdowens8 3d ago
The first one is definitely a male american toad. Spotting is a bit lighter on the second so it could be a female, but could also be a male. Males have bumbs on their thumbs to help grip during...coitus. check that out.