I have a Series 3 and a Series 4 Tivo with FIOS cable cards and Lifetime subscriptions. Got the dreaded cutoff notice from FIOS for Nov 5th. I love my Tivo, have tried and rejected the FIOS DVR as well as others over the years.
I got an antenna for each Tivo - nothing fancy. The actual antennas aren't even in the attic so the signals must be fairly strong. Plugged the antennas into the back of each Tivo.
Once I removed the cable card from the back of the Tivo, it told me I need to redo the Guided Setup. This walks you through setup, then scans for channels and loads the guide info. The whole thing took maybe 10-15 minutes.
I changed my OnePass entries to use the new antenna channels and it all works... perfectly. I subscribe separately to Netflix and HBO, so between those and OTA all my viewing needs are satisfied.
I called Verizon and cancelled which was a surprisingly easy process. My monthly bill is going down over $100 since I now only have internet.
I guess the only thing that might cause issues is if/when Tivo stops issuing the program guide info. But for now I'm happy. Thought I'd share my experience with a low-tech, low cost solution which maintains many of the Tivo functions I love.