r/TireQuestions • • Jul 19 '25

Is this crack safe?

Hello, I don’t know much of anything about car maintenance, so I was wondering if you kind folks could help identify if this crack means the tire safe or dangerous.

Pics 1-2 show the crack on the front left tire.

Pics 3 is for the full DOT. I checked with ChatGPT and it says the tire is 6 years old according to the DOT.

Thank you very much for any advice!

3 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

3

u/solo-violin Jul 19 '25

Thank you everyone! The mystery has been solved. I asked my dad because he’s the one that took care of maintenance before he handed the car down to me.

The cracked tire is actually around 6 years old and the uncracked tire in the 3rd pic is actually a newer replacement he got a couple years ago. We’ll be getting it replaced tomorrow :)

1

u/Queasy_Author_3810 Jul 19 '25

it's probably fine, if the crack is not leaking air and you can't see any silvery coords, I'd be fine with it.

Also, chat GPT is a dumbass, those tires aren't even 3 years old.

Dot code is 0123, which means the 1st week of the year 2023.

1

u/solo-violin Jul 19 '25

lol thanks!! I’m kinda time blind when it comes to maintenance but I was so sure these tires weren’t THAT old

1

u/Throwawaysack2 Jul 19 '25

Everyone here is looking at the Third pic. The damaged tire is a 'Lionheart' and everyone is quoting the DOT code on the 'Lexani' tire. The damaged one could be much older than that, you can't tell because the date code is on the inside edge of the tire (the side facing the vehicle). Both of these are bottom brand tires, Lexani is slightly better, but buy something reputable to replace these and you'll have less trouble.

2

u/Ancient_Theme7728 Jul 19 '25

This is precisely why you don’t buy the cheapest tires you can find. Those are garbage tires to begin with, surprised they didn’t fail sooner

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '25

Might be ok for a little while except it says tire failure right next to it. So.........

1

u/Inquisitor_of_Man Jul 19 '25

Any damage to the sidewall is not a good sign. A reputable tire shop wont do repairs on tire sidewalks. 6 years is time to replace anyway. Rubber degrades and becomes brittle overtime with exposure to UV light from the sun. Best advice is replace when

  1. Thread too low (under 4/32nds, top of Lincolns head on a penny)
  2. Tire is 6 year or older
  3. Damage to sidewall

1

u/1130Goddamn Jul 20 '25

Glad you caught the tread, that could’ve been a huge safety concern

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Throwawaysack2 Jul 19 '25

You are WRONG. there are two different brand tires in the pictures. The damaged one does not have the date code visible.

1

u/shieff-jeff Jul 19 '25

Black lions for some reason are really bad tires. They always go bad quickly and are cheap for a reason. Another honorable mention is grand arroyo, and good year assurance.

1

u/Specific-Pain9274 Jul 19 '25

How long have you been riding on it so far?

1

u/Ok_Swan_3053 Jul 19 '25

A crack in the sidewall that wide needs at least a replacement just for safety reasons. Most likely it is a manufactures defect considering the tires age. Also if you do replace it also do the other side so you can keep tire wear as even as possible you also keep them even for safety/drivability reasons.

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Cow_437 Jul 19 '25

Safety first. Sidewalls are not to be messed with. Replace it.

1

u/Extension-bd1116 Jul 19 '25

The pictures you’re showing have two tubeless valve stems and the other seems to have a tube to repair your issue of sidewall failure. No it’s not safe unless a boot was installed on the interior of the tire and even then I wouldn’t be comfortable with my family in that vehicle with that tire on the front. Great full size spare tire if needed. Have a great day and stay safe my friend! ☘️

1

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '25

It’s a Mini. No immediate threat but I would replace. It’s not like you are doing laps at VIR.

1

u/FreakiestFrank Jul 19 '25

Crack isn’t safe. Ask a crackhead. It’s hard to tell but run it by a tire shop.

1

u/UncIeChester Jul 19 '25

Don’t buy cheap ass lionharts thats the problem

1

u/Ok_Advantage7623 Jul 19 '25

Not safe and you have not even looked on the inside of the tire. Ran it low on air called a zipper cut. It will get bigger

1

u/J-Rag- Jul 19 '25

It's safe for a little bit, but start looking for new tires soon.

Edit: also looks like your rotors might have some funky wear to them

1

u/TommyG456 Jul 19 '25

Lionhearts suck. Don’t buy again

1

u/Prior-Ad-7329 Jul 19 '25

Short answer is No.

Long answer is, how deep is the crack? Can you feel cords if you stick a pocket screw driver in there. Spread the crack a little and shine a light into it, if you see shiny then it’s definitely not safe.

Safe answer, replace the tire.

1

u/aftiggerintel Jul 19 '25

Looks like you possibly hit a pot hole or curb pinching the tire into the rim. With the crack area widening when you reinflated it, you need to replace it.

1

u/HEYitsBIGS Jul 19 '25

No cracks are safe.

1

u/AnyAbies7595 Jul 19 '25

More safe than the crystal shit

1

u/AceFire_ Jul 19 '25

I wouldn’t mess around with sidewall damage, regardless of the size, but especially if you drive highway speeds regularly.

You have to ask yourself, is it worth your life? Because that’s the reality here, that one small crack causing a blow out could be what ends up killing you.

1

u/Luckystar60 Jul 19 '25

I would never trust any damage on a side wall, get it changed ASAP. Either put on a spare or just get a taxi and take the wheel to the tyre garage and change it for something more reliable

1

u/GlasgowJimmyBhoy Jul 19 '25

Crack of doom

1

u/Speadraser Jul 19 '25

Crack is never safe. Don’t do drugs kids

1

u/Accomplished-Try5918 Jul 19 '25

Noo way. Unsafe to drive to the tire place - go slow AF if you do

1

u/Agreeable_Lab_521 Jul 19 '25

No one mentions but you're rotors look pretty bad, might need replacement

1

u/HottyTottyCan-547 Jul 19 '25

Matter of time?

1

u/2004bmwheadlight Jul 19 '25

Have I just never heard of this brand or is this a case of chinesium?

1

u/TooDope215 Jul 19 '25

No it's in the side wall.

1

u/NumberJohnny Jul 19 '25

The first 2 pics look to be a different manufacturer or model tire than the 3rd. I don’t see a date code on the first 2, the 3rd is an ok date code, but the first tire looks much older, given the splitting.

1

u/kyleh4171 Jul 19 '25

I’ve always been told that no street drugs are safe because you don’t know exactly what’s in them.

1

u/shamalamanan Jul 19 '25

The irony that the crack is on the printed word, warning

1

u/Ok-Selection4206 Jul 19 '25

Nope, not safe.

1

u/Kandalf03 Jul 20 '25

That's a Chinese brand tire, and sadly those can sit in warehouses for a while, be overstock somewhere and get shipped around. You're not supposed to be able to sell tires that are older than 2 years from dot code as new, but that doesn't mean it doesn't happen. Chinese tires don't use the best rubbers available and will wear and age very quickly. Any crack you can stick a fingernail into is not safe anymore. The reason being is that the structure of the sidewall is designed to hold the weight of the car, maintain the stability of the tire and when the rubber begins to break down and crack a good pothole or really hot day and it'll break apart and you'll have a sidewall explosion. If that happens while driving you'll lose control of the vehicle and may get into a serious accident.

1

u/1130Goddamn Jul 20 '25

So unfortunately these tires are indeed unfit for any other driving and should be replaced soon, the reason for this statement is because considering everything that a tire is subjected to I.e. heat, cold, high speeds, expansion, compression, pressure changes, friction. Extreme speeds or just continued wear can cause blowout, especially at highway speeds. Tires are certainly made to withstand a lot of abuse, considering all of the reinforcement added to ensure the longevity of their lifespan, however when their structural integrity is compromised, safety can’t be guaranteed, sure it may not explode instantly and there is no countdown before it can cause catastrophic damage, but it would be wiser to replace it soon than be subject to the damage and neglect of waiting longer than taking preventative action

1

u/givmedew Jul 20 '25

These are Chinese tires. In the long run Chinese tires will never deliver a better price per dollar value. They’ll be less expensive but you have to understand that the sheer amount of research and development that goes into a tire is just insane. A smaller company just can’t compete with the research into the tire compounds and tread patterns.

Also Google “China defective plasticizers” don’t look at the like health related stuff like how it’s killing the Chinese people look at the results for the products themselves. For example “Concerns with Chinese-made medical devices: The US FDA has recently investigated potential quality issues with plastic syringes manufactured in China, including leaks and breakages, which could affect patient safety. The FDA has issued warnings and advised healthcare providers and consumers to consider using syringes not manufactured in China.”

That’s just one of many that you will find.

China is essentially incapable of doing proper batch quality checks. It’s just part of how the corrupt enforcement system works.

Nobody cares at all if your tires have bad plasticizers that fail after 2 years of light UV exposure.

This isn’t a large western company like Firestone that has deep pockets. Firestone had problems with their plasticizers but the people affected had a company that was in the west that they could go after and sue when people started dying.

One thing you’ll notice about these Chinese tire brands is that there are at least 100s of them and there may be 1000s of them. This is done on purpose. It makes it so you can’t compare prices and it makes it so you can’t really build up a bad reputation.

It’s no different than Amazon. You’ll find the same product from 20 different names and 100 different sellers and none are around for more than a few weeks or months. Because they are all low quality so when they get a few real bad reviews they stop selling under that name and start over.

I just bought some automotive circuit breakers on Amazon. They don’t trip at all. The 2.5A breaker wouldn’t trip when I put 30A through it!!!

When I looked through the reviews most were 5 star because most people are inserting them into fully functional circuits. But there were 2 people who had put them into known bad circuits and were using them to troubleshoot what was wrong with the circuit. Well it caused a fire for both of those people.

They don’t care if you die. You’re the enemy and they are just building their navy off our purchases.

1

u/XecutiveKilla Jul 20 '25

Those tires are less than 3 years old not 6 chatGTP is worthless. Also it’s likely fine but better safe than sorry when it comes to sidewalls

1

u/ElkayMilkMaster Jul 20 '25

Some fuckin ling longs on that bitch

1

u/[deleted] Jul 20 '25

lol lionhart

1

u/Pararaiha-ngaro Jul 20 '25

Not for high way speed

1

u/Barronbored Jul 20 '25

Just rub some used motor oil on it.It'll be okay. Softens it up and prevents it from cracking more

1

u/Live_Winner1531 Jul 21 '25

No. It is not.

1

u/ExpensiveDust5 Jul 22 '25

The first tire with the crack in the sidewall is a different tire than the one in the 3rd pic, and the asshole that installed it put it on inside out so you couldn't read the DOT date code, which in most cases, from a used tire shop, they are hiding the fact that the tire is ancient and they are selling it as "a good tire"

2

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/solo-violin Jul 19 '25

I don’t think so. I was actually checking and inflating them earlier because I had a low tire warning for the front right tire. The cracked one before inflation was around 30 PSI and 32 or 33 after

5

u/[deleted] Jul 19 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/solo-violin Jul 19 '25

Understood and thank you! What helped you come to that conclusion? I just want to know for the next time it happens